Gay Amateur Site Reviews

GayDemon's Reviews: In this category you can find in-depth, honest reviews of gay porn sites with male amateurs & straight guys.


Gemini Men

Reviewed 27 May 2019

Gemini Men features 100% exclusive and anally-oriented homemade videos of straight guys jacking off and exploring their butts with fingers and dildos plus some gay sex and lots of helping hand action. Nearly 1,000 videos to download, stream and watch on your mobile, and a new video is added weekly. Real amateurs, lots of ass play.


Island Studs

Reviewed 11 May 2023

Island Studs offers solo amateurs, including plenty of surfers, skaters, jocks, average guys, and a few daddies in outdoor nudity and masturbation sessions. 567 exclusive videos filmed in Hawaii and Oregon to download, stream, and watch on your mobiles, each comes with pics. Updates every two weeks. Lots of straight guys, some with hairy pubes or armpits.


Maverick Men

Reviewed 26 Apr 2021

Cole and Hunter are the Maverick Men, a real-life mature couple who like sharing their amateur sexploits, which usually involves threesomes with tag-teaming younger guys in their twenties. They take turns holding the camera and servicing these guys' mouths and asses. Site has lots of personality, tons of horny anal sex fun, 268 streaming videos.


Red Hot Straight Boys

Reviewed 23 Sep 2023

All-American amateur straight guys are interviewed, paid to strip, and jerk off, and these days they get handjobs, blowjobs, or even a little butt play. 248 exclusive videos to download, stream, and watch on mobiles, and the site updates twice a month. Some of the guys go further, so we can watch their first experiences with a man on video.


Fred Sugar

Reviewed 15 May 2023

Fred Sugar is a porn talent scout who films mostly amateur straight guys wanting to break into the adult business or simply to get paid to blow their loads on camera. The guys strip and wank their dicks or get handjobs. There are a handful of hardcore action scenes among the 503 videos to download, stream, and watch on your mobiles with weekly updates. Lots of first-time masturbation.


See My BF

Reviewed 10 Dec 2021

The content at See My BF features real amateur guys jacking off or sucking cock at home, shooting selfies, showing their bulges or hanging out. Over 4,000 videos to download, stream, and watch on your mobiles, and frequent updates keep things fresh. While vids aren't always great quality, this is real homemade content.


International Wanker

Reviewed 15 May 2021

International Wanker offers recorded webcam sessions of all kinds featuring amateur guys who love showing off their cocks and shooting their loads in the privacy of their own homes. With more than 5,500 amateur quality videos to download and stream on your desktop and mobiles, the site offers lots of hot amateur dick. Middle Eastern, military men, and more.


Aussies Do It

Reviewed 1 Jun 2023

Australian amateurs suck and fuck in duos, threeways, and a few group sex scenes, plus solo guys jerking off. All kinds of men from 20 to 40 ranging from smooth to hairy with plenty of uncut cocks. 485 video updates to download, stream, and watch on your mobiles. Lots of Aussie amateurs with oral and anal sex.


English Lads

Reviewed 19 Aug 2022

British jocks, hunks, twinks, and amateur straight guys, most with slender to athletic bodies, get off in solo, stripping, duo, and hardcore sex action. There are 1,921 exclusive streaming videos for desktops and mobiles, good quality photos, and weekly updates. Heaps of horny English guys with uncut cocks.


Amateur Straight Guys

Reviewed 10 Sep 2020

Amateur Straight Guys offers horny straight guys, and some who are bi-curious or gay, many in their first-time gay sex experiences. Hot college-age guys with slim, athletic, or muscled bodies jacking their cocks, sucking dick and taking it up the ass. Mostly duos, but quite a few threeways and solos. 622 exclusive videos to download, stream, and watch on your mobiles.


Watch Dudes

Reviewed 8 May 2022

Watch Dudes offers all kinds of amateur guys in homemade content from twinks to hunks in solo masturbation, plus some sucking and fucking. Lots of selfies, guys at home showing off their asses and cocks, some dildo action, and naked posing. 3,570 video clips to download, stream, and watch on your mobile, plus plenty of pics and lots of handy categories to help you find what you want.


Joe Schmoe Videos

Reviewed 24 Aug 2019

Joe Schmoe Videos delivers straight trailer trash boys and amateurs, some covered in tats and horny as hell. There is a mix of solo masturbation, blowjobs and hardcore action in 508 exclusive videos to download, stream and watch on your mobiles. Updates are recycled, but it's a great site if you're looking for real amateur rednecks and average guys.


See Him Solo

Reviewed 3 Jul 2022

See Him Solo offers horny straight guys from slim and smooth to athletic or muscular men, all jerking off, showing their asses and shooting their loads. Most guys are porn stars from the straight side of the street. 112 exclusive videos to download, stream, and watch on your mobiles. Some really big dicks here.


Young Straight Boys

Reviewed 31 Oct 2021

YoungStraightBoys offers amateur straight guys in solo teasing, masturbation, handjob, and some hardcore scenes. Mostly Latinos, Black, and Middle Eastern guys with some Caucasians ranging from 18 to their mid-20s. 107 exclusive full scenes broken into 541 updates to download or stream on your mobiles. Site updates daily, usually with a part of a full scene.



Reviewed 12 Mar 2023

AlternaDudes features punks, goths, emos, skinheads, rockers, skaters and regular guys in hardcore and jack-off action; many guys have plenty of tattoos and piercings. 453 exclusive videos to download, stream, and watch on your mobiles. Some very hot amateur alt guys plus a few mature dudes and porn stars.



Reviewed 23 Aug 2023

Amateur homemade and studio porn featuring guys in solo masturbation (some with sex toys) and hardcore suck and fuck action, including some barebacking. A mix of sexy amateur guys and regular porn performers with athletic to muscular bodies. 386 videos to download, stream, and watch on your mobiles plus familiar faces from the early days at Chaos Men.


Men Bucket

Reviewed 1 Mar 2022

Men Bucket brings you real amateurs, a mix of mature daddies, bears, and regular guys in homemade jack-off, blowjob, and hardcore sex videos. With 1,930 short and sleazy videos to download, stream, and watch on your mobiles, plus over 4,559 galleries of dirty pics, and members can have fun searching through all the amateur action.


Eric Deman

Reviewed 7 Jul 2019

Truckers pissing in the bushes, athletes in the locker room and showers, and lots of public nudity - that's what you'll find at Eric Deman. Approximately 34,000 downloadable video clips and the site currently adds 50 or more clips per week or more. Navigation can be challenging, but lots of hidden treasures at this huge site.


You Love Jack

Reviewed 10 Jun 2016

You Love Jack features horny amateur twinks, jocks, and regular guys who get naked solo in their own home videos. 239 exclusive videos to download, stream or watch on your mobile, each with pics. This clean, easy-to-navigate site no longer updates, but the videos are hot with lots of assplay, masturbation, dildos and some big cocks.



Reviewed 25 Dec 2021

Horny 20-something dude TattTwink is slim, scruffy, heavily tattooed, and he loves to suck dick, get fucked, or sometimes do the fucking. Lots of hookups with a variety of guys, some kink, including foot play and sexy solos. 243 streaming videos for your desktop and mobiles. Love his smooth, tattooed body, and red facial hair!

Live Sex Cams on GayDemon!

Want more gay amateur porn?

Have you read our in-depth reviews of amateurs sites, and you are now hungry for more? You will find an impressive collection of gay porn videos, maintained and curated by our team. Or, if you like to read about straight guys experimenting with an alternative lifestyle, head over to the gay erotic stories area, where you can find out more about hot gay encounters with strangers. A lot of gay porn blogs will provide you with information on the latest studio releases and other fun stuff. For more visual titillation, the gay porn pics organized by categories are readily available so that you can browse them to your heart's content.

About our gay amateur reviews

An online source of gay porn since 1999, GayDemon Reviews represents the best free guide to the highest-rated amateur sites. In this section, you will discover a complete collection of gay porn reviews. Our honest and objective reviews include gay amateur membership sites, paysites, VOD streaming, and pay-per-view sites. These reviews represent our critical opinion on these sites dedicated to male amateurs, and we guarantee that we are a trusted source of information on the topic, based on more than 20 years of enjoying and working in this industry. The type of information you can learn from the reviews in our gay male tube refers to the amount of content, its quality, frequency of updates, and pricing. We will always provide you with practical information on what kind of experience you can expect should you decide to become a member. You can sort the reviews in the amateur section by score, so that the most recommended, based on ratings, appear on top. For questions and suggestions, please feel free to use the available contact form.

We take amateur gay reviews seriously!

On GayDemon, you will only find reviews of gay porn amateurs sites that are legal and safe to visit. You can rest assured that we always give our objective opinion, but GayDemon does receive a commission whenever you subscribe to a paysite from the ones reviewed. We can only continue our work of reviewing such sites with your support when you purchase memberships. Please keep in mind that the amateurs site reviews we publish are accurate at the date of publication; however, sites can change all the time. As a result, GayDemon cannot offer guarantees about finding the same content and features when you visit them.