Fred Sugar

15 Mar 2024 Score 67 / 100 Mobile friendly

  • Videos 4 stars
  • Pictures 4 stars
  • Unique 4 stars
  • Size 4 stars
Review score 67
  • 4 stars Cost
  • 0 stars Updates
  • 3 stars Usability
  • 4 stars Claims
FredSugar tour page Click here to visit Fred Sugar

Introduction to

Fred Sugar is a porn talent scout who films mostly amateur straight guys wanting to break into the adult business or simply to get paid to blow their loads on camera. The guys strip and wank their dicks or get handjobs. There are a handful of hardcore action scenes among the 265 videos to download, stream, and watch on your mobiles. Lots of first-time masturbation.

Skip to full review

Since Last Review

  • Site has 237 less videos
  • Videos now only available in 1 download size
  • Videos no longer auto-play
  • Site appears to be re-adding previous videos as updates

FredSugar Topics

Video info

Videos offered for download and streaming

265 exclusive videos. Downloads sized at 1080x720 at average to decent quality. Streaming, mobile-compatible versions also available.

Picture info

Each video has a picture set. Pics range in size from 1067x1600 to 6000x4000 at decent to good amateur quality. No zip files or slideshows. Pictures can be individually downloaded. 12 to 20+ pics per set.

Site issues

This site no longer updates!

Membership cost of Fred Sugar

  • Monthly: $18.95 (recurring every 30 days)
  • Monthly: $24.95 (30 days, non-recurring)

Fred Sugar Review

Fred Sugar started out as a talent scout auditioning guys who wanted to break into the porn business or who just wanted to earn some cash getting off for the camera. These are amateurs and unknowns who can be handsome, cute, average, or not very good looking. You'll find jocks alongside truckers and rednecks, as well as some guys who look like they might have done some hard time. There are clean-cut guys, geeks, twinks, daddies, skaters, and a host of others. You'll find physiques ranging from slim to athletic, some guys are more muscular while others are chubby. And with such a mix of men, you'll find both clean-shaven and bearded faces, a mix of smooth and hairy bodies, and some tattooed while others are not. Most of the guys are Caucasian, but I saw a few men of color in the ranks, too. Ages range, too, from college age to men in their late thirties or early forties, some even older than that.

Fred doesn't focus on a particular type of man, but features all kinds of guys who want to become porn performers or just get paid to get a massage or a handjob. Wyatt Coxxx is a beefy man, a straight construction worker in his thirties and he snickers when he says his name. He wears a goatee, has a furry patch on his chest and he strokes his uncut cock in his video. Brian Saxonic has long hair and a beard, a sexy low voice, an average body with a furry bush and pits who shows off his hairy ass and jacks off for Fred and the camera. And hann "The Bunny" is a stocky guy, a bit scruffy but with boy-next-door cute factor, too. He has a piercing on his balls, and he chats with Fred before shooting his load.

Fred Sugar talks to the guys at the beginning of their scenes, but not for long. He has them introduce themselves, give basic stats, and he may ask about their sexual orientation or if they've done this before. Most have no porn experience, but a few have made some straight videos, and I recognized a couple from gay porn. Some guys return after their first video to get groped or receive a handjob. Some of them stroke their cocks while watching porn, others don't need the external stimulation. Fred generally tries to get the men on their hands and knees showing off their asses; some go further and dry hump the bed or pillows. 

There are a fair amount of handjob videos, but most of the guys here take care of themselves. There are some side by side jerk-off sessions where a couple of men stroke off together, and sometimes they blow their jizz on each other. A recent video, called "Justin Fresh gets fucked by John Stahl" has a cute twink getting fucked, and this ends with a side-by-side jerkoff; I found a few more anal sex sessions including a bareback fuck.

Keep in mind that many of these are basically audition reels of mostly amateurs who have never been naked in front of a camera, so the results aren't always ideal. A couple of guys shoot their wads quickly, and one poor guy tried for 13 minutes to get an erection before he apologizes and packs it in. But the majority have no trouble getting hard and pumping out a load, or having another guy pump it out for them.

There are 265 exclusive videos at Fred Sugar. The downloads I checked were only available to download in one size (1080x720). They're average to good amateur quality with decent sound and lighting, although a few were a bit on the dim side; they download quickly and play well. You can also stream the videos in two or three resolutions, and the highest size gives the best results when enlarged to full screen. The videos played on my Android phone and tablet, so you shouldn't have any trouble with them on your mobile device.

Each video comes with a picture set. Many of the sets offer pretty good amateur quality digital stills available in a variety of sizes, depending on the set. Some are as large as 3872x2592 or even 6000x4000, which showed the guy larger than life-size when expanded, while others are sized at 1067x1600 or 2440x3622. While many pics seem to be good amateur quality digital stills, some seem to be average screencaps. There are no slideshows or downloadable zip files, however you can save the pics individually, and you can navigate from picture to picture in the viewer.

Let's talk about updates and changes. On our last visit, FredSugar had 503 exclusive videos, the newer sized at 1920x1080 and the older at 1080x720, while on this visit, there are 265 videos, which is 227 less, and all the downloads I checked are sized at 1080x720. The oldest video - and most of the other videos say they were added "1 Month Ago", yet there were just over 500 videos ten months ago. The eight latest videos say they were added in the last hour - a ninth was added while I'm typing this. There's a new design, which looks more old school and amateur, which might fit the theme of the site better. So it appears that FredSugar did a reset and started over again with just the older videos, and will probably be adding back the missing newer videos over time. None of this will matter to you if you're a new member, but if you were a member six months ago, you may have to wait for your favorite videos to be re-added.

There are a couple things I want to mention. First, the good news is that the site has fixed the issues we had on our last visit. The model profiles aren't filled in - where the info should be, it just says N/A for each category. The site categories are only "Manhandled" and "Hairy Guys", and while each video has tags, sometimes this is more useful than other times. Some videos are missing some obvious tags, and on one bareback video, I clicked the "fucking" tag, only to find it was the only video lsited. Since there are other fucking videos, it would be nice if the site would stick to tags that describe the core subjects and use the same ones for the acts/type of men.

I enjoyed my visit at Fred Sugar mostly because the guys are real amateurs including hairy guys, a few chubs, some muscle hunks, twinks and lots of regular guys. I did recognize a couple of gay performers and a few guys have done a straight porno or two, but most are getting naked in front of the camera for the first time. There's a wide variety guys ranging from their twenties to nearly forty, and there's a mix of body types from average to athletic and well built to chubby. Some of the men are quick cummers, others put on quite a show in the 265 exclusive videos. Some of the vids include a massage or a handjob, and there's the occasional suck and fuck action, but for the most part these amateurs show their asses and stroke their cocks. While the site has removed half their videos, they added two videos while I was doing this review, and they apparently added nine today. One thing is for sure, Fred Sugar delivers hot action and plenty of real amateur cock.

Things we disliked

  • Site seems to be recycling udpates
  • Only 2 categories, not too useful
  • Tags aren't always very helpful

Click here to visit Fred Sugar

FredSugar Screenshots

About Reviews

Online since 1999, GayDemon is a trusted guide to gay porn sites. On this page you can find a in-depth, detailed review of Fred Sugar with our honest opinion about this site. The review outline what you can expect to find as a member if you subscribe to Fred Sugar. The review was as accurate as possible when it was written on the 15 Mar 2024, but sites constantly change. GayDemon cannot guarantee that you will find the exact same content or features when you visit. Please contact me or leave a comment if you have any questions.

Legal stuff

GayDemon only write reviews of gay porn sites that are legal and safe to visit. This review contain our honest options, however GayDemon receive commission from a membership sale if you decide to join this site. We can only continue to write reviews with your support through your purchases. (96937)