Page 78, Gay First Time Stories

Summer vacation with my friend's dad

By Bi Latino 323 13 Sep 2017

Young inexperienced curious bot gets seduced by his best friend's dad one summer when they unexpectedly spend a lot of time alone.

8.5 (95) 13115 8 Min Comments

Educating Ricky

By Grant 11 Sep 2017

Ricky gets an education before going away to college.

8.9 (180) 10160 40 Min Comments

A Big Hairy Daddy Deflowers His Son's Best Friend

By Naughty Eric 27 Aug 2017

Big Daddy and his wife Antoinette host a joint 18th birthday party for their son Mario and his best friend Cody. After booze had big daddy horny as hell, he gave Cody a special birthday gift by deflowering the innocent 18-year-old's virgin ass.

8.0 (439) 55115 9 Min Comments

A Different Path

By Habu 27 Aug 2017

A widower colonial lawyer finds reason to remain on America's early Virginia frontier.

9.1 (116) 6069 21 Min Comments

First Gay and Speedo Experience for 18yo

By Aussie "Speedo" Guy 25 Aug 2017

Meeting two amazingly hot guys at the local pool, this curious 18yo wears a speedo for the first time which is just the start of his first gay experience.

8.4 (103) 8772 6 Min Comments

white twink loses virginity to bbc

By whiteslutforbbc 22 Aug 2017

white fem twink with long dark hair takes a 9in big black cock for the first time

8.6 (112) 13862 2 Min Comments

Bait and Switch

By sikticireloaded 10 Aug 2017

It's his first time!

7.9 (78) 8423 5 Min Comments

A delicious beat down

By naaru 19 Jul 2017

A muscular teen, three bad boys, one gym and lots of hormones. What could possibly go wrong?

8.2 (74) 15132 11 Min Comments

Turning the tables (ch. 5)

By naaru 13 Jul 2017

Czem fucked Karim's sister and ruined her reputation. Karim will not accept that and get his revenge.

8.6 (49) 3092 13 Min Comments

Best Friends Finally Fuck

By Aussie "Speedo" Guy 7 Jul 2017

After 28 years of friendship, it took a weekend camping in our speedos for Stephen and I to finally reveal that we wanted each other and boy did we fuck each others brains out.

8.3 (102) 10870 4 Min Comments

Turning the tables (ch. 4)

By naaru 4 Jul 2017

There is always a next time you see someone, but who knows what will happen

7.7 (17) 1707 9 Min Comments

First Time

How I seduced My Shy Straight Virgin College Roommate

By Naughty Eric 30 Jun 2017

Cory, a 21-year-old promiscuous gay college student, begins his junior year with a new roommate Jai, a 21-year-old innocent virgin straight guy who has never had a sexual encounter. This is the story of Cory's devious plan to seduce his straight roommate for wild gay sex.

8.5 (213) 25001 12 Min Comments

The First Blow Job

By Aiden 27 Jun 2017

A lonely Sam finds himself attracted to a man in a grocery store check out line. A connection he never expected to make leads to an adventure he never expected to have.

8.8 (109) 6191 15 Min Comments

First Time

The Crack Demon

By man with Pipe 18 Jun 2017

A monster from hell is unleashed on a group of young men, seducing and fucking them in grisly ways...

7.2 (30) 7227 8 Min Comments

How it all started for me

By Slutty Texas Btm 15 Jun 2017

From seeing my first big cock to taking them up my ass

8.7 (196) 14339 10 Min Comments

Sizzling Hot Bus Boy Flirts with Lone Dinning Dude

By Naughty Eric 8 Jun 2017

Devin, a handsome 40-year-old college coach, is dinning alone having a late 1:30 PM lunch when a very sizzling hot 18-year-old bus boy deliberately continues to make trip after trip by the Coaches' table with a dustpan and broom flashing a big smile at the Coach as the young guy keeps sweeping the floor over and over. The flirt leads to a night of awesome breeding of the young twink bus boy's virgin ass.

8.8 (148) 7506 10 Min Comments

The First Time

By Aiden 3 Jun 2017

Feeling like he is losing his will, Troy takes a ride that changes his life.

9.0 (131) 9971 23 Min Comments

First Time

Str8 Bait

By Aiden 2 Jun 2017

I was sittin at work and decided to write a poem - It's a fun little ditty about something i think is pretty popular among us

8.4 (45) 4439 2 Min Comments

First Time

I want you

By naaru 30 May 2017

Why would you want water when your boyfriend is mouth watering?

8.1 (32) 4585 16 Min Comments

The Virgin Servant

By Kyle Falls 30 May 2017

Desperation can make a straight college do just about anything in this erotica story. First story in my Servant mini-series. Enjoy

8.7 (99) 5426 14 Min Comments

Political Intrigue: Hot Daddy & Sexy Twink Have Sex at Political Conference

By Naughty Eric 29 May 2017

Tate, a handsome 50-year-old very experienced political operative & active gay man, meets Jay, a 21-year-old sexy hot twink and young political activist, at a three day political conference. Tate rooms with Jay, an innocent virgin, until their first night together in the hotel room.

8.5 (52) 4692 10 Min Comments

First time tasting cock (ch. 2)

By SammyBoy 22 May 2017

I had now tasted Jareds perfect cock and his warm cum! I needed more, I had to have it!

8.3 (49) 4577 8 Min Comments

Ty's Adventures (ch. 2)

By Aiden 15 May 2017

After discovering a Pagan Ritual, an after orgy and being scared off, Ty gets home and remembers the night for one last orgasm before showering and falling asleep.

8.9 (30) 1552 3 Min Comments

Ty's Adventures

By Aiden 14 May 2017

Contemplating what to do with his life after graduation, Ty finds himself on the edge of what he would eventually find out was a Pagan Sabbat Ritual that turned into an orgy. Ty had no idea what would change after this night.

8.5 (38) 2488 8 Min Comments

Forbidden Love

By Aiden 12 May 2017

Starting to undress as he awaited word that his bath was ready, he stared at himself in an oval mirror encased in mahogany wood. Looking deep into his own eyes he allowed himself to again drift back to the simple life of childhood.

8.6 (101) 6878 9 Min Comments