How I Got My Revenge

Chapter 21

Coming Clean

When I got home on Monday after classes, I told Carl about my lunch with Chris. Carl asked, “Who is Chris?” I realized I’d used his first name, “Chris Baker. Chris is Baker’s actual first name. Sorry, I should have just said Baker, which is what most people call him.” Carl grinned and said, “So, you’re on a personal first-name level with him suddenly?” I smiled and said, “I guess so. I told him I’d still call him Baker during our basketball games, but he’d rather me call him Chris at school.” Carl asked, “So, is lunch together going to be a regular thing now?” I replied, “Yes, Mondays and Thursdays for now because of our schedule. Since it’s a summer semester, I only have classes Monday, Tuesday, and Thursday, but it will help me graduate sooner by taking the summer courses.” Then I sensed where Carl was going with this and said,” It’s only lunch, Carl and not like he could drop and suck my cock in the middle of the restaurant or cafeteria. Carl grinned and said, “Was I turning green again?” I grinned back and said, “Maybe just a shade.”  Carl then retorted, “I might like to see him drop and suck your cock.” I laughed and said, “I could see a three-way between us.” Carl then said, “You’re making me horny. Too bad we don’t have time. We need to eat and then I have an appointment at the bank. I agreed, “Yeah, I have to study and get a paper ready for tomorrow.”

The week flew by, and I was again sitting across from Chris Baker at a popular pizza shop called Tony’s for lunch on Thursday. As we sat down waiting for our pizza, Chris asked, “Are you looking forward to seeing your friends tomorrow? I’m hoping you bring them on Saturday. Do you think they’ll come?” I replied, “I am looking forward to seeing them again, and I’m sure they’ll be happy to see each other as well, since they’re about a hundred miles apart. I happen to be pretty much in the middle. As far as Saturday, it will depend on how things go Friday night.” Chris asked, “Is something wrong? I’m sorry, you don’t need to answer that. That was rude of me to ask.” I gave him a forgiving smile and said, “No problem, but it’s something personal that we need to discuss.” He smiled and said, “Like I said, I shouldn’t have asked. I was just trying to make conversation. I didn’t mean to get personal. I’m just trying to get to know you better.” I smiled and said, “Well, I’m twenty-one and about to start my junior year here. I live in a two-bedroom house with my ex’s brother who works nearby, and I usually work evenings after classes to help pay my tuition. I turned down a football scholarship for an academic scholarship because I knew I was never going to be NFL material and they had the program here I liked.” Chris laughed and said, “So, you’re a nerd jock or is it a jock nerd? You really turned down a football scholarship?” I smiled and said, “It wasn’t easy, but I weighed the pluses and minuses, and realizing I was too short to ever make it to the NFL as a corner or wide receiver, decided to focus on academics.” Chris grinned and said, “Yeah, jock nerd fits better.”  I knew he was teasing me, but asked, “Why is that?” He replied, “Well, the way I see it, you used your head to figure out what you wanted to do rather than letting the glamor of a football scholarship cloud your thinking. I’d say that’s a smart move.” I looked at Chris, questioningly and asked, “So, I’m assuming you’re eighteen, nineteen going on eighty?” Chris’s eyes opened wide as he yelled, “Eighty!” People looked over at us and I laughed, “Yeah, eighty. You just sounded like an old wise man.” Chris grinned and said, “You’re the one that made the wise decision. I just complemented you for it.” All I could do was smile as our banter went back and forth. I felt comfortable around Chris. He was quick-witted, funny, and passionate. He was also boyishly handsome. His smile was contagious, with his cute dimples. I really liked hanging out with him. I avoided any embarrassing questions, like Carl’s insistence that Baker (Chris) was intentionally backing his bubble-butt into my crotch, etc... I decided that kind of thing would find its own time. I decided to just enjoy our lunch together and I did, we did. We walked back to the campus and then separated, headed to our next class, my last of the day. I found myself turning back to look at him one last time, only to find him doing the same. We both grinned with embarrassment before turning back and heading to our classes.

Friday afternoon arrived and I was a bundle of nerves. Would Elijah and Josh take the news well or would they freak out about it? I had no idea. I heard the door open, and Carl entered, carrying two bags of groceries, “I thought they’d both be hungry when they got here after their long drive. I picked up some steaks and sides to throw on the grill for dinner.” I said, “Good thinking, though I’m not sure I’ll be too hungry. My stomach is in knots right now.” Carl gave me a serious look and said, “Look, there’s not much you can do about how they’ll react to the news when we tell them. It won’t help to get all worked up about it. They’ll either take it well or they’ll get pissed off and leave. Either way, we need to tell them. It’s what you insisted on and it’s the right thing to do.” I sighed and realized he was correct. No matter how worked up I got myself worrying about it, it would all come down to how they took it, and that would depend to some degree on how we explained it to them. I nodded, “You’re right, I’m just hoping they take it well. After getting to really know them better, I’d like to continue the relationship I’ve begun with them since the reunion. After years of playing football with them and just recently finding out about how they felt, I feel I missed out on getting to know them personally. We need to tell them in a way that’s sincere and not a shock.” Carl just grinned as he put the groceries away, “Look, I understand what you’re saying, but you have to calm down and not drive yourself crazy with worrying about it.”

I helped Carl prepare the food. While Carl prebaked the potatoes for twice-baked-potatoes, I seasoned and dry-rubbed the steaks. While the potatoes were getting done, Carl threw together a fantastic salad with lettuce, spinach, carrots, broccoli, grape tomatoes, cucumber, cauliflower, and red onions.

When we heard the doorbell, we had just finished getting the potatoes ready, filling the empty potato shells with a mixture of the mashed potato, cheddar cheese, chopped bacon, and onion. I opened it and found Elijah standing there, smiling. I gave him a hug, which caught him off guard, and then asked him, “Where’s your bags?” He said, “I left them in the car in case I was at the wrong house.” I laughed, “I’ll help you get them, then I’ll introduce you to Carl and show you the house.” He didn’t need any help as he only had two bags, but I took one anyway. As we walked into the house, Carl was wrapping the potatoes in aluminum foil. I introduced them, “Elijah, this is Carl.” Carl wiped his hands and then stepped over to us and reached out his hand, “Glad to meet you, Elijah.” As they shook hands, Elijah replied, “Glad to meet you too, Carl.” We then left Carl to finish wrapping the potatoes while I showed Elijah around the house, minus the attic and basement areas. Elijah was smiling and said, “Thanks for the tour, Jeremy. I’m glad you invited us for the weekend.” I smiled and for the first time all day, felt relaxed, “It just made sense. I live almost right in between you and Josh.” As we arrived back at the kitchen, the doorbell rang again. Elijah joined me as we opened the door to find Josh standing there with two bags. I said, “Well, at least you were confident you were at the right house.”, while taking a quick glance at Elijah, who grinned. Then I said, “Please, come in, Josh. Glad to see you.” I gave him a hug and he dropped his bags and said, “Hey Jeremy, thanks for inviting us.’ Then he looked at Elijah and said, “I see you’re here already.” Elijah hugged Josh as soon as I backed away and then we went in, and I introduced Josh to Carl. After their pleasantries, I grabbed us each a beer and we went into the living room and sat down, Elijah and Josh on the sofa, and Carl and I in the two chairs on the other side of the coffee table. I then explained, “Carl and I are going to sleep in my room so that one or both of you can sleep in Carl’s room. The sofa is available as well if you don’t want to share a bed.” Elijah and Josh looked to each other and both shrugged. I said, “You can decide later if you want. I just wanted to leave your options open.’

After discussing the sleeping arrangements, which were still undecided for Elijah and Josh, we grabbed some more beers and moved out back to grill the food. We talked as we waited on the grill and Carl asked Elijah and Josh questions about them and answered their questions. At one point, Josh asked, “So you’re Jeremy’s ex’s brother? I would have thought that would make things a little uncomfortable.” Carl froze at first, but then said, “No, not really, I got to know Jeremy for a while before Kayla and Jeremy split up. She we over to England to study to help her career. Jeremy was open to it and their split was pretty much inevitable at that point. Right, Jeremy?” I hadn’t expected that subject to come up. I replied, “Yeah. I wasn’t thinking it at the time, but long distant relationships don’t usually last, so I should have known.” I noticed Elijah and Josh glance at each other. Then Carl announced that the food was ready, and we all sat at the table on the patio and gorged ourselves on tender steak, potatoes, and salad.

After we had stuffed ourselves, we cleaned up and then sat out back for a while drinking and talking. We had changed to mixed drinks, so we wouldn’t be running to drain our bladders every few minutes. As the sun was setting, Carl gave me a knowing look, and we moved inside.

Carl went into the kitchen to refresh our drinks as Elijah and Josh sat on the sofa and I sat on one of the chairs. Elijah and Josh were still laughing at something I had said until they noticed I was no longer laughing and had a serious look on my face. Elijah noticed and asked, “What’s up, Jeremy?” I said, “There was an ulterior motive in inviting you two over this weekend. We have something we’d like to tell you.” Josh joked, “What, you and Carl are getting married?” Just then Carl walked up behind the sofa, bent down between them, and said in the voice he had used before, “We know what you did!” Josh jumped to the floor and spun to look at Carl in shock while Elijah just froze in place looking at me wide-eyed. My stomach went into a knot again as I wondered what the fuck Carl had just done. Josh then said in astonishment, “It was you?” The room went silent as Josh looked at us in turn with horror on his face. Elijah’s expression changed from shock to that of bewilderment. I looked at Carl with what I was sure was anger on my face and fire in my eyes for how he had done this. Carl then said, “Yes, it was us. It was my idea. I hope…” Before he finished, Elijah looked at me and said, "It was you! You must have seen us that night! Oh my god!” He was grinning. I was confused by this. So was Josh, who asked Elijah, “What’s so fucking funny, dude. They kidnapped us and did those things to us!” Carl said, “And I’m sorry, we’re sorry for what we did.”, but both Elijah and Josh seemed to ignore him as Elijah said to Josh, “Dude! Don’t you see? It was revenge for what we did to Jeremy! We deserved it, and I might add, we both ended up enjoying it and don’t pretend you didn’t. I was there, and to top it off, I no longer have to worry about getting any STD from it! We also don’t have to worry about any of our other football teammates one day exposing us, do we?” Josh lowered his eyes and said, “I guess you’re right. We did deserve it.” Then he looked at me and asked, “Why would you admit this to us? You could have not said anything, and we’d never have known.” I looked to Elijah and then to Josh and said, “True. We could have kept it as our secret, and you would have never learned the truth. I would have known though or rather we would have known, and it was wrong of us to do it no matter what you had done to me, and no, Elijah, I didn’t tell anyone else.” Carl then interrupted and said, “Like I was saying, it was my idea. When Jeremy broke down one day and confessed to me what had happened, I was furious and wanted you to pay for it.” Elijah looked to Josh and then back to me and asked, “You broke down? We hurt you that bad? I’m so sorry, Jeremy.” I looked at him and smiled, “Look, I meant what I said. I’ve forgiven you and in so doing, I think it healed any hurt inside as a result. I’m also happy that we rekindled our friendship, hell, actually have a real friendship which I hope wasn’t damaged here tonight by our confession.” Suddenly, Elijah pounced on me and embraced me in a hug, “If anything, Jeremy, I for one think it made our friendship stronger.” I soon felt another weight on us as Josh had piled on, “I agree with Elijah. Friends forever.” Elijah then looked over at Carl, who was still holding some drinks, and said to him, “Come on, Carl! Join us!” Carl smiled, and put the drinks down, then piled on as well. The force of him landing on us sent the chair careening over backwards, leaving us rolling onto the floor in a pile, laughing. In between the laughter, I yelled out, “You guys are crushing me!” More laughter, but they began rolling off me. There was only Elijah still on top of me. He was smiling down at me and then suddenly brought his mouth to mine and kissed me before climbing off. It didn’t go unnoticed, but it also didn’t seem to change the mood in the room. In fact, there seemed to be more than one growing bulge occurring. We all still had smiles on our faces. We up righted the chair and returned to our seats, then I said, “Well, now that that’s over, what do we want to do now?” Elijah got this mischievous grin on his face as he asked, “Did you guys keep all that stuff?” Carl asked, “What stuff?” Elijah said, “The thing you had me strapped into and Josh.” I couldn’t help but smile. Carl said, “Yeah, we had to bring it back here. It’s in the back of the basement, but we can’t drag it out tonight if that’s where you’re going with this.” Elijah looked disappointed, “Too bad.” Josh grinned and said to Elijah, “You pervert!” We all laughed, and Elijah said, “Takes one to know one.” Josh turned pink and said, “Yeah, you might be right. I must admit, it was pretty fucking hot after the shock of it wore off.” Carl then asked both Elijah and Josh, “Have either of you had any sex since the weekend after your reunion?” Josh shook his head and Elijah replied, “Not since the weekend with these two.”, indicating me and Josh. Carl then looked to me and said, “Can I talk to you for a moment in private?” I got up and Carl and I went into the kitchen to talk. Once we were in the kitchen, Carl said, “Look, I know we agreed to only have condomless sex with each other, but these guys have been clean and if you’re willing, I’m up for some bareback, group sex with them.” I grinned as I saw the hard bulge in Carl’s shorts. My own cock was straining at the fabric of my briefs as I nodded my consent.

We arrived back in the living room with wide grins on our faces and large tents in our shorts. Elijah and Josh were both looking at us with huge grins. I said, “So, you guys wanna have some fun?” Elijah jumped up to face us with an obviously hard shaft under his jeans and said, “I’m up for it.”, indicating his hardness. Josh got up smiling, and revealed his own hardness beneath his cargo pants, first looking at Elijah and saying, “Pervert”, and then to us, “Let’s do this!” Carl said, “Let’s make this interesting.” He went to a drawer in one of the cabinets and pulled out a deck of cards, “We’ll shuffle the cards and then each draw one. Whoever gets the highest card gets to take a piece of clothing off whoever gets the lowest card. We first have to make sure we each have the same amount of clothing.” We checked and agreed on counting shoes and socks each as one. We each had on only t-shirts, underwear and either pants or shorts. Josh and Elijah each had on belts but we agreed they would not count so everyone would have five pieces of clothing. Josh then asked, “What if there’s a tie?” Carl asked you mean if two people each have the same card?” Josh said, “Yeah, or three of us. Two twos or three jacks…” Carl said, “We go by suits then. Spades are highest followed by diamonds, then clubs, and lastly hearts. Those are Hoyle’s rules. At the end of the game, whoever is naked first gets fucked by the winner. The next guy naked gets fucked by whoever ends up second. Agreed?” Josh nodded and said, “That’s pretty straight forward.” Elijah then asked, “Could we get a shower and get cleaned up first?” I nodded and said, “I think that would be a good idea. There’s a private shower in my bedroom that Carl and I will use. I showed you (indicating Elijah) where the bathroom is down here. You and Josh can take turns using it, just don’t use too much hot water. Carl, you can go first if you want.” As Elijah and Carl were taking their turns, Josh and I were alone. Josh asked me, “So, how did you know it was us?” I said, “Well, it made sense since you were plying me with beer all night and who knows what you were putting in it. Then there was the part where the blindfold slipped down a little and I saw the two of you walking away.” He grinned and said, “Oh. Why didn’t you say anything when we untied you the next morning?” I shrugged, “I felt embarrassed and wasn’t sure what you might do if I said anything. Afterward, I just wanted to forget about it and leave it behind me. I thought I had until the invitation arrived for the reunion, then it all seemed to flood back.” Josh nodded and said, “I’m really sorry. I know you said you forgive us, but I still feel bad about it.” I said, “I did forgive you and hope you will forgive me for exacting revenge the way we did. That’s why we wanted to tell you what we did. We felt badly as well.” Josh nodded and said, “You don’t need our forgiveness. If we hadn’t done that to you, you never would have felt the need for revenge, but you have my complete forgiveness if you feel you need it. I’m sure I’m speaking for Elijah too.” We then got up and hugged, tightly. Suddenly, someone said, “Get a room.” It was Carl, grinning as he entered. We both laughed and I then went to get cleaned up.

As Carl and Josh sat there, Josh said, “So, you were pretty pissed at us for doing that to Jeremy. I’m sorry. I really regret what we did and hold no grudge against you for taking revenge on us.” Carl smiled and said, “Nevertheless, I thought I needed to apologize for it.” They both got up and shook hands before laughing and moving into a hug that lasted until Elijah cleared his throat behind Carl. They broke the embrace and Josh gave Elijah a smile before heading into the bathroom. Elijah smiled at Carl and said, “So, you and Josh all good now?” Carl smiled and said, “Yeah, I guess we are. How about us? We good?” Elijah nodded and said, “Of course we are. I’m actually glad that you felt the need to seek revenge for what we did to him. It shows that you care for Jeremy.” Carl responded, “As do you.” Elijah’s face went red as he nodded. Carl said, “Look, right now, Jeremy and I have an understanding. I don’t want to smother him. I want to give him the freedom to explore, but safely. This weekend is different, because we know you and Josh are clean and you can be assured we are as well. We’ve both been tested recently and use prep.” Elijah looked at Carl and realized the conflict in his voice. He knew Carl was into Jeremy almost as much as he was.

I returned to the living room and noticed a little tension, and asked, “Everything ok?” Carl and Elijah replied in unison, “Yeah!” I chalked it up to sexual tension. We made small talk as we waited on Josh.

Josh finally returned and we sat around the coffee table as Carl shuffled the cards. Josh cut the deck and set it in the middle of the table. Since I was to Carl’s left, I turned over the first card. It was the jack of hearts. Elijah turned over a six of diamonds, then asked, “Do aces count as ones or aces?” Carl said, “Glad you asked now before someone overturns an ace. Aces are the highest card.” Josh flipped over the queen of clubs. Carl drew his card and looked at it before putting it down with a smile. It was the three of spades. Josh asked, “Do I get to choose what to take off of him?” I grinned and Carl said, “I can’t decide this one since I am the one losing something.” I looked to Elijah, who said, “I think we should make it interesting. Instead of having a group of guys sitting around naked except for their shoes and socks, lets agree to make it shoes first, followed by socks, then t-shirts. Lastly, pants and then underwear.” We all nodded in agreement and Carl lifted his feet up so Josh could remove his sneakers. To be funny, Josh held his nose while he removed the last one. Carl laughed and said, “I just took a shower, dick.” We all laughed then, and I went in and made us all another drink. When I returned, we resumed the game, this time, Elijah drawing the first card. He drew a four of clubs and said, “Fuck!” Josh drew a seven of spades. Carl again looked at his card before turning it over. It was a ten of diamonds. I pulled my card off the pile and flipped it over revealing a king of clubs. Elijah lifted his feet onto my lap, and I slid off his sneakers. He squealed as I tickled his feet and quickly pulled them away from me. We weren’t just sexually aroused but were having fun as well. The knot in my stomach was completely forgotten as I was now feeling completely relaxed. I could tell all of us, including Carl, were having a great time. Before long, I was the only one with my socks still on. Carl and Elijah were shirtless, and Josh was barefoot. The next hand had Carl removing my socks. He grinned before kissing the bottom of my foot. When the last card of the deck was drawn, Elijah had his jeans removed by Josh. The deck was reshuffled, and we were all down to our pants and underwear, except for Elijah, who was down to a light blue pair of CK briefs. I lost the next round and Elijah removed my shorts, putting his mouth over my rigid cock through my black Jockey briefs for a moment, to applause from Josh and Carl, before we resumed play. I turned over a nine of clubs, and Elijah drew a jack of spades. Josh turned over a three of hearts and knew he’d lose. Carl flipped over an ace of hearts, got up and stepped in front of Josh who had stood up in front of the sofa. Carl opened his pants and slowly slid them down to his ankles revealing his orange with black eagles American Eagle boxer briefs with a telltale wet spot where the tip of his stiff cock strained for release. It was Elijah’s turn, and he drew a seven of spades. Josh flipped over a nine of hearts, and Carl, a queen of diamonds. I was the last to turn over a card and was nervous as I slowly flipped over the king of spades and smiled. Elijah stood up. He had lost but smiled at me as I noticed the half-dollar sized precum dark blue wet spot in those light blue CK’s. I dropped to my knees to slide them down. Once on my knees, I noticed the clear, almost gelatinous precum that had seeped through his briefs and smiled before I leaned in and put my mouth over it and licked up as much as I could with my tongue. His precum tasted sweet, a touch salty and with a slight taste of vanilla. I pulled back and looked up at him. He was grinning down at me with that twinkle in his eyes that was trying to melt my heart. I grabbed the front of his briefs in my teeth and pulled them down around his ankles. His cock popped out, hitting me in my right eye as I did. I heard Carl and Josh laugh. I didn’t care, we were having fun. As Elijah and I took our seats, I noticed Carl and Josh grinning at me. I asked, “What?” Josh said, “I think Elijah left you a present on your right temple.” I reached up and felt a wet spot on my temple and wiped it with my fingers and then looked to find more of Elijah’s precum. I licked my fingers clean and said, “Ok, who’s turn is it?” Everyone was grinning as Josh leaned over to take his turn. Josh flipped over a four of clubs and said, “Fuck!”, realizing he would probably lose this round and end up the second loser. Carl drew his card and looked at it before laying down a ten of hearts. I drew a jack of hearts and began getting up, but Elijah protested, “Don’t I get a turn? I know I already lost, but I might get the high card or what if I get a lower one? Would that give Josh a pass?” Josh quickly said, “My vote is to let Elijah draw a card and if he’s low card, then I don’t lose this round.” Carl and I looked to each other, both shrugging, then Carl said, “Go ahead and draw a card, Elijah. It keeps things interesting.” Elijah flipped over the Ace of diamonds and jumped up, “Yes!” Josh said, “Fuck!”, and stood up to let Elijah remove his boxer briefs. Elijah stepped over in front of Josh, kneeled, and slowly lowered the boxer briefs down, avoiding the same smack in the face I received. That left Carl in his cargo shorts and underwear and me in my black Jockey briefs. Carl turned over a five of spades and got an eight of clubs. Elijah drew an eight of spades and Josh flipped over a queen of spades. Josh stood up, smiling, and Carl got up to allow him to remove his cargo shorts. Josh got down on his knees and pulled down the zipper, then unbuckled Carl’s belt before unbuttoning the shorts, allowing them to fall around Carl’s ankles. He stepped out of them and stood there in his red 2Xist briefs with his stiff rod stretching at the fabric. After they both sat back down, I drew the next card. It was the queen of hearts. Elijah picked a seven of hearts, and Josh flipped over a four of diamonds. We waited as Carl picked up a card and looked at it before setting down a six of spades. Neither of us had lost and I said, “That sucks! I’d have won.” Elijah then drew an eight of hearts. Josh flipped over a king of diamonds. Carl picked a card and said, “Fuck!”, before setting down a four of hearts. He was certain to lose. I drew the final card and turned over a two of spades, “Mother fucker!”, I had lost the hand to a four of hearts. Josh stood up and stepped over in front of me, grinning. I shrugged and then smiled as I stood up facing him. Josh dropped to his knees and eyed the waistband of my briefs and the gap caused by my hard cock. He then moved in and took the waistband of my briefs in his teeth and pulled them down around my ankles. He was now wearing a streak of my precum across the bridge of his nose and grinning because of it. Elijah suddenly got up and stepped over and said, “Let me get that for you.”, bent down and licked my precum from Josh’s nose. Everyone’s cock throbbed as we watched his tongue lick it up. Carl then asked, “So, am I supposed to keep these on?” The three of us grinned as Elijah, Josh and I surrounded Carl and each grabbed part of the waistband of his briefs in our teeth and slowly pulled them down.

We pulled the chairs back out of the way, then the coffee table, making room in front of the sofa. Once the area was clear, Josh asked, “Do you want us to kneel on the sofa or lay on our backs?” Carl replied, “Slow down. Why don’t we warm up a bit with some oral action first.” Elijah asked, “Sure, what do you have in mind?” Carl said, “I’ll lay on the sofa. Elijah, climb on top of me in a sixty-nine. Jeremy, you and Josh do the same on the floor. We can get their holes ready for our cocks at the same time.” Josh asked, “Why do you guys get the sofa?” Carl grinned and said, “Because I won the game.” Josh grinned and nodded, “Fair enough.”

We got into position and went to work on each other’s cocks. Carl and I also began working our fingers into our partner’s tight holes. The sounds of mouths full of cock moaning filled the room. The loudest were coming from Elijah and Josh who also were getting their holes fingered. I felt Josh’s cock swelling a bit and his nuts began to tighten and I pulled off his cock and removed my fingers from his hole and tugged on his nuts. Josh said, “Fuck, I was so close to filling your mouth. When did you learn how to take my whole cock in your throat?” I laughed and said, “I noticed, which is why I stopped. I’m sure you’ll empty your nuts a few times tonight, just not yet. I just recently learned how to do that. It takes practice.”

I noticed Elijah and Carl getting up as well, and Carl positioned Elijah at one end of the sofa on his knees facing the back of the sofa. His arms resting on the back. I looked at Josh and he smiled and climbed next to Elijah in the same position. Carl and I looked at each other smiling as we lubed up our cocks. We then simultaneously began entering our partners. Elijah inhaled sharply, but arched his back more, exposing his hole and moving back toward Carl’s cock. Josh groaned, “Fuuuck.”, as I penetrated his hole with the head of my cock and slowly sank inside him. Soon, Carl and I were planted deeply inside our partners with our hips pressed tightly against their firm, muscular buns. Then I watched as Carl slowly withdrew until he was almost completely out of Elijah’s hole and then plunged just as slowly back inside. I then began slowly fucking Josh as well. They were both in slight pain and pleasure which soon became obvious pleasure as I noticed Elijah start moving back into Carl’s forward thrusts. Then I heard Josh in almost a whisper say, “Oh fuck. Fuck me. Oh fuck, your cock feels so good inside me.” I leaned forward against his back and kissed his neck and then asked next to his right ear, “You like my cock inside you, don’t you? Don’t you, Josh.” Josh nodded his head while he continued to moan as I slid in and out. I said in his ear, “I didn’t hear that, Josh. You want my cock?” This time he responded, again in almost a whisper, “Yes. Yes, please. Fuck me. Oh, fuck yes. Please.” I pulled back and began speeding up a little and entering him harder, slapping my groin into his hard buns.

I heard Elijah begging Carl, “Fuck! Fuck me! Harder! Please, slam my hole! Fuck! Yes! Yes! Give me that cock!” I looked over to see Carl smiling while drilling him as he said, “Yeah, your ass is tight and hot, boy! I’m gonna slam your hole! I love this fuckin’ ass!”

I started fucking Josh even harder and soon he was loudly begging for more, “Fuck yeah! Fuck me! Harder! Your cock feels so good! Yeah! That’s it! That’s the spot! Fuck! Oh! Oh! Fuck yeah! Wreck my hole! Please! Harder! Oh, fuck yes! Oh my god, I’m gonna cum soon.” I looked and realized both of Josh’s hands were on the back of the sofa. He was going to cum hands free. I suddenly pulled out of him. He looked back at me confused. I told him, “Turn onto your back. I want to see your face as you cum.” Josh quickly flipped around onto his back with his head pushed against the back of the sofa and lifted his legs. I took his ankles and put them on my shoulders and then slid back inside him.  He yelped as I slid in fully in one move and then resumed fucking him.

Elijah and Carl had worked up a rhythm and were moving together in opposite directions, pulling away from and then back into each other with a loud slapping of abdomen into butt. Elijah was encouraging Carl, “Fuck my ass, Carl! Yeah! Slam my hole! Fuck yeah!” Carl saw me have Josh change positions and decided to have Elijah do the same, saying, “I want to see your face as I fuck the hell out of you.” Elijah complied happily, and soon his legs were on Carl’s shoulders and Carl’s cock was once more drilling him.

I continued slamming into Josh and he was now just spouting gibberish until suddenly, he cried out, “Oh, fuck! Oh, fuck!” I felt his hole spasm around my cock and then a blast of cum shot out of his cock and spattered across his face and another, stronger landed on his forehead and into his hair. The remaining shots landed on his chest and abdomen as he heaved his breathing in and out. I could hear a similar thing going on next to us but was too transfixed by what was happening in front of me. Suddenly, I felt myself going over the edge, “I’m gonna cum! You want me to breed you?’ Josh said, “No, please. Shoot it in my mouth!” I quickly pulled out of Josh and let his legs drop down on either side of me. He sat up quickly and opened his mouth. I grabbed my cock and it let go, firing wad after wad of my cum. Some of it hit its target and some splashed across his face joining his own seed. Some dribbled down onto his chest. As I caught my breath, I heard a similar commotion next to me and saw an equally cum-covered face on Elijah. Carl started leaning down toward Elijah and I said, “Wait!”, then I instructed Josh to slide over next to him and once he did, I said to Carl, “Why don’t we gobble this up and share it?” Carl grinned at me and said, “You sick fucker. Let’s do it!” We began taking turns licking our way up both Elijah’s and Josh’s torso’s, periodically swapping and mixing the cum in our mouths. Elijah and Josh were licking the cum from each other’s faces and as we worked our way up, we ended up in a four-way kiss and cum swap, a mixture of cum from all four of us. We eventually collapsed into a pile on the sofa.

As we all caught our breath, Josh suddenly broke into laughter. Carl asked, “What’s so funny?” Josh said, “I was just trying to imagine what I looked like with all that cum on my face. If it was anything like how Elijah looked.” Before he finished, I said, “You both looked pretty hot with all that cum on your faces.” Elijah added, “It was also hot watching you two licking the cum off us, and our four-way cum swap was fire.” Carl leaned over and kissed me before saying, “This whole evening has been pretty hot. I’m glad we did this, but the night’s not over yet. Josh said, “Yeah, we should get a chance to fuck you two next.” Carl said, “We won the game. Why would you get to fuck us?” I said, “Because maybe we’d enjoy it as much as they obviously did.” Carl gave me a sharp look which quickly became a grin and said, “Let’s have another drink first.” As Carl and I made the drinks, Elijah and Josh picked up the cloths off the floor and folded them. Though he tried to be discreet, Josh noticed Elijah sniff the crotch of my briefs before folding them.

Carl and I brought the drinks in and we sat down sipping them. I finished my drink first and decided to initiate things. I got up from the chair I was sitting in and walked over in front of Josh. He looked up at me smiling. I smiled and then climbed onto his bare lap and kissed him. Carl looked on and Elijah asked, “Where’s mine?” I looked over at him and smiled, then climbed off Josh’s lap revealing his fully rigid cock sticking up. I then stepped in front of Elijah and climbed onto his naked lap and leaned down and kissed him. I soon felt his rigid cock spring up between my buns behind me. Taking my queue, Carl got up and took my place on Josh’s lap. They kissed as Josh’s cock throbbed between his cheeks. I soon felt Elijah slowly working his hips up and down slightly, sliding his precum-oozing cock between my cheeks. I groaned my approval into his mouth as our tongues dueled for domination over each other’s mouths. Soon, Elijah’s cock was smoothly sliding between my buns, having lubed both his cock and the area between my cheeks with his precum. Elijah broke our kiss and looked into my eyes and asked, “May I fuck you?” I smiled and without answering I moved up and reached behind me. I grasped his slickened cock and guided it to my hole and slowly lowered myself down. I gasped as the head of his cock broke through my sphincter and waited for my hole to adjust. Once the pain faded, I slowly sank down on his shaft until I was seated on his pubic bush and balls. After a minute of more kissing, I felt Elijah’s impatience as he began thrusting his hips up into me. I groaned in his mouth and then began moving up and down on his shaft as I rode his cock. We broke our kiss momentarily to look over and see Carl climbing on Josh’s cock. We looked at each other and smiled our approval and then we resumed our fuck. Elijah was now moving his hips up to meet my downward movements. I looked down at his and said, “Your cock feel so good inside me Elijah. Fuck me.” Elijah replied, “It feels so good sliding my cock in your hole.” After a few minutes, Elijah asked, “Can I do you doggy for a while?” I smiled down at him and nodded. I slowly slid up, extracting his hard shaft from my hole and then we switched places as I got on my knees on the sofa and waited for him to reenter me. As I waited, I looked over and watched Carl bouncing up and down on Josh’s shaft, moaning in pleasure. I suddenly gasped as Elijah entered me and slid in fully in one movement, “Oh, fuck!” “Sorry.”, I heard Elijah say behind me. I glanced back and said, “It’s ok, I’m good.” Elijah leaned forward and I bent upward as his chest pressed against my back and we kissed as Elijah resumed fucking me. I moaned into his lips as his cock rubbed against my prostate sending shockwaves through my body. I broke the kiss as I told him, “Fuck me, Elijah! Harder! That’s the spot! Yes! Fuck my ass!” Elijah responded by saying, “Fucking hot, Jeremy!” as he began slamming into me, trying to go deeper. Elijah was slamming my ass and I was was whimpering in pleasure, “Oh fuck. Oh fuck, yes. Fuck me. So deep. Yes. Fuck.” Suddenly, Elijah pulled out of me. I felt suddenly empty. Elijah said, Turn around. I want to see you as I fuck you and I want you to look into my eyes.” I smiled and wanted that as well as I got up and spun around to face him, then pulled my legs up. I turned to see Carl and Josh changing positions. Josh was about to take Carl doggy style. Then I felt Elijah entering me once more. He pushed my legs up until my knees were at my arm pits and his abdomen was pressed against my throbbing cock. We kissed again as he began moving in and out of me. He broke the kiss and moved to my neck and began kissing me just below my ear, driving me wild. I groaned, “Fuuuuck yessss.” Elijah pulled up from me and smiled as he began fucking me harder. I met his eyes and said, “Fuck yes, Elijah! Pound my ass!” Sweat was running down his temples and forehead as he was slamming into me. The counter sounds of skin slapping skin echoed around the living room as our duel fucking was a split second apart. Elijah leaned back down on top of me once more and the rubbing of his abdomen coupled with his cock massaging my prostate brought me over the edge as I cried, “Fuck! I’m cumming!” Elijah pulled up and looked toward my cock just as it shot out its first wad of cum striking him in the chin and lower lip. The next hit his chest and some landed on my own chin. The remainder shot onto my chest and abdomen as Elijah stood back up to look on and resume fucking me. Elijah looked down at me grinning as a drop of cum hung from his chin and said, “That was so fucking fire!” I said, “Keep fuckin’ me!” as my cock continued to throb out cum until it throbbed a few more times discharging nothing. Elijah slammed into me one more time before announcing, “ Fuck! I’m gonna cum too!” I looked into his eyes and said, “Cum on me!” Elijah pulled out and I began to sit up, but before my face was level with his cock, it exploded into my hair and across my forehead. I opened my mouth and caught some, and the rest went across my cheeks and on my chest. As the last of Elijah’s cum dribbled out of his cock and onto my crotch, Elijah stood there with his chest heaving and a huge smile on his face, as he said, “Now I know what I looked like earlier. He then collapsed down onto me as we kissed, sandwiching the cum that was on my chest between us. When we broke the kiss, we hungrily devoured the cum from each other’s bodies and then shared the mixture in another kiss.

Meanwhile, Carl and Josh had shifted positions putting Carl on his back while Josh rammed him missionary. Elijah and I then looked over and watched them fucking, periodically turning to each other and giving momentary kisses. Suddenly, Carl was cumming, shooting on his chest and abs which took Josh over the edge. He pulled his cock from Carl’s hole and stepped between Carl’s legs as Carl sat up and took a facial full of Josh’s seed. I said, “That is so fucking hot!” simultaneously as Elijah saying, “That is so fire!” Once he caught his breath, Josh bent down and began licking Carl’s cum from his abs and then moved up to his chest. They then kissed, sharing Carl’s cum before Josh licked Carl’s face clean. They then shared Josh’s cum. We moved over and joined in, making it another four-way kiss and cum-swap. We collapsed together in a heap on the sofa, giggling and discussing what a great night we had. Strangely, we paired off to shower, Elijah and I in my shower and Carl and Josh in the main bathroom.

I turned on the water and after it was hot, we entered. I lathered up Elijah’s hair with shampoo and gently massaged it in and after he rinsed it out, he shampooed mine. We then lathered each other up with soap, making sure no part was left unclean. Elijah was only the third person, other than my mother, to do this and his touch was gentle and extremely sensual. By the time we were through, we were both hard again, but finished and dried each other off before throwing towels around our waists.

We stepped out into the Livingroom where Carl and Josh were sitting on the sofa wearing running shorts. Carl said, “We’re going to go out back and have another drink and maybe throw some wood on the fire pit. Why don’t you put some clothes on and join us?” I looked to Elijah questioningly and he said, “I only brought one pair of shorts. I could throw on the jeans I wore tonight.” Josh said, “Sorry, dude, one of us somehow got cum on them. Carl put them with the dirty laundry.” We all laughed except for Elijah. I said, “I have a pair you can wear. Let’s go and change.” We went into my bedroom, and I retrieved a pair of briefs for each of us and a pair of shorts. We then each made a drink and joined Carl and Josh out back and found them kissing. I turned to Elijah and we kissed as well before moving over next to Carl and Josh. Once they realized we were there, they broke their kiss, and we sat down around the fire pit and made a fire. As the fire was burning down, I noticed Josh had fallen asleep with his head resting on Carl’s shoulder. I smiled and glanced at Elijah who was also smiling at them. Elijah the leaned in and kissed me before nuzzling his head on my shoulder against my neck. I looked over at Carl who was smiling at me.

Once the fire had gone out, we woke Josh and went into bed. Carl and Josh in Carl’s room and Elijah and I in mine.

 

End of Chapter 21