How I Got My Revenge

Chapter 7

It Begins

We spent the next several weeks refining Carl’s plan, buying, and putting together what we needed to carry it out. There were some difficult tasks, including obtaining a few things through some questionable sources.  Then there was the embarrassing trip to the adult store. The final step was to send out the invitations and gamble that they would keep it a secret and actually show up. We added a line at the bottom which read, ‘Don’t tell a soul, even your best friend. Last year we almost got in trouble because someone told the wrong people. Anyone caught telling anyone else about it will be disinvited.’

Elijah read the strange invitation he received and wondered how many of his old teammates would show up. He was curious about the trouble someone got in. He figured it may have been the alcohol and decided heed the warning. He sent a text to the strange number listed that he would be accepting the invitation.

Josh opened the invitation and read through it and thought about calling his old buddy Elijah to see if he was going, but after reading the warning, decided against it. He surely received an invitation as well and would definitely accept an invitation to a teem reunion the week before the class reunion. Josh then thought about Jeremy and whether or not he’d show up. He regretted what he and Elijah had done to him that night. It started out to be just a prank, but they took it way too far. He hoped Jeremy had forgotten all about it and besides, Jeremy had no idea who had done it to him.

Weeks later on Friday afternoon, Elijah pulled up and parked. He was surprised to see that there was only one other car parked in the area. He was early though. After parking back out of sight of the road, he got his sleeping bag and a few other things and then headed up the somewhat concealed path to the secret campsite, anxious to see who else had arrived. As he rounded a bend and emerged between some trees and a rock formation, he heard someone yell from up ahead on the hill. They were wearing a football helmet that resembled their team’s school helmet. They were waving to him. He couldn’t wave back since his hands were full. Suddenly, someone reached from behind him and covered his mouth and nose with a cloth. He gasped in surprise and then wondered, ‘What was that smell?’

Two hours later, Josh pulled in and found only two other cars parked. One he thought looked like the one Elijah had last year. He was hoping he was right. He parked next to the car he thought might be Elijah’s and noticed the other car was still warm and must have arrived just before he did. He pulled his backpack out of the car and a few other things he thought he’d want to have with him and began the trek up the path. He grinned when he saw the guy on the hill waving to him was wearing a football helmet. Was it Elijah? Suddenly he found himself struggling to pull someone’s cloth covered hand from his face. What the fuck? Everything grew dark.

Josh awoke with a headache. He was blindfolded and he couldn’t move his arms. They seemed to be bound by his forearms on either side of him. His chest was resting on a padded surface and his legs were flat on a hard surface, spread apart. He found he couldn’t move them either. He realized he was naked. He called out, “What the fuck? Is this some kind of joke? Guys, come on. Set me free. Hello! Elijah, you here somewhere?” Only silence greeted him. He struggled against the restraints to no avail. He cried for help until his voice was to horse to continue, then he wept in silence.

Elijah awoke in similar circumstances, naked except for a blindfold, and his forearms bound beside him. His chest was on a padded surface with his legs spread apart and anchored to the floor. He was bent over with his bare ass spread open for anyone who was there to see. He called out, “What the fuck! What’s the idea?” A voice behind him suddenly said, “We know what you did.” A hand then slapped him hard on his bare ass cheek. Elijah yelped, “Ahhh!” Another hard slap on the other butt cheek, “Oww! Fuck!” Another, “Ahh! Fuck! Stop! Please!” Elijah writhed around in a futile attempt to avoid the stinging blows that rained down upon his bare, vulnerable buns which were now a bright crimson. He screamed in pain. Suddenly the hand stopped on his left butt cheek giving Elijah a chance to catch his breath. Tears rolled down Elijah’s cheeks as he tried to comprehend what was happening to him. Strangely, the hand remained on his butt cheek, seemingly cupping it. Then the voice behind him repeated, “We know what you did.” Then the stinging blows resumed on his still sore, crimson butt. “Ahhh! Fuck! Stop! Please! What do you want? Ahh! Owww! Fuck! Please! Stop! I’m Sorry! I’m sorry for whatever it was I did! Please! Stop!” The hand stopped again, on the other cheek this time and then squeezed it, and rubbed it a little. Then the voice, “We know what you did”, and the spanking resumed. Elijah’s cheeks were on fire and he screamed out with each blow, “I’m sorry! I really am, for whatever I did. Just please! Please, stop hitting me!” This time the voice repeated it again, “We know what you did”, but the spanking went on this time. Elijah was just sobbing continuously now, yelling out in pain with each strike to his bare cheeks. Then the hand stopped once more, again on the left cheek. Elijah was trying to recall anything that he’d done to one of his teammates and then suddenly he asked, “Jeremy?”  The voice asked, “Was that his name?” Then the spanking resumed and Elijah thought, ‘Shit! Someone saw us that night!’ In between screams of pain, Elijah yelled out, “It was just supposed to be a prank! Fuck! We got carried away! Owww! I’m sorry! Ahh!” Suddenly, the hand stopped, again cupping the right cheek. Elijah’s sobbing continued and when the hand was removed from his butt cheek, he prepared for the spanking to resume. Instead, he was startled as a cool gel was applied to his sore butt cheeks and was massaged across them, soothing the inflamed skin. Elijah couldn’t help but elicit a moan of pleasure as the hand massaged in the cool gel and fondled his bare cheeks. As the hand rubbed in the gel, suddenly a soft brush began stroking his balls and the base of his cock, tickling them and arousing his cock to grow hard. Elijah groaned in embarrassment and tried to will his cock to behave, but the soft brushing of his balls and the soothing hand applying the gel, playing with his buns couldn’t be ignored and his cock was soon fully rigid. “Oh fuck”, Elijah groaned as he realized the fingers massaging the gel onto his cheeks were getting closer to his exposed hole. Panicked, Elijah pleaded, “No! No! Please! Please, no!” as a finger slowly pushed in past the tight ring and then began working in and out. Elijah continued to plead, “Oh fuck. No! Please stop!” Another finger was joined the first as the soft brush continued to tickle his balls and periodically stroked Elijah’s throbbing shaft. Elijah continued to plead, “Oh fuck! Please stop. Oh, please. Ohhh fuuuck. Please. Ohhh fuuuck.” Elijah soon stopped uttering the words no and stop, and that didn’t go unnoticed. Then the fingers were withdrawn, though the delicate brushing of Elijah’s cock and balls continued. Elijah then felt something else pushing at the entrance to his anal canal. Frightened, Elijah resumed his pleas, “No! Please don’t! I’m sorry! I’m sorry! Please don’t do this to me!” The small dildo was slowly inserted into Elijah, regardless. Once it was inserted, Elijah found that it wasn’t as painful as he’d expected. Seconds later, the dildo was being moved in and out, fucking him. Elijah was embarrassed. His cock was rock hard and he found it was turning him on. Precum began leaking from his rigid cock. He was a little disappointed when the dildo was slowly withdrawn from his ass. As another, larger dildo was inserted into Elijah, his captors smiled at each other as Elijah arched his back slightly, accepting the invasion. Elijah’s cock was throbbing painfully now, but the brush was no longer stroking it, just periodically tickling his nut sack. At this point, Elijah’s embarrassment and humiliation were giving way to sexual frustration. The stimulation of his prostate was overwhelming and his cock was aching so much. He just wanted to cum. He began pushing his ass back and forth onto the dildo that was being used to fuck him, causing his rigid cock to bob up and down with a string of precum hanging from the tip. The dildo was slowly pulled back, and Elijah was frantically thrusting back in an attempt to get it back in him. He began pleading, “Please. Please!” Carl had a huge grin on his face, and I mouthed the words, “Holy fuck!” We were both amazed at the change in Elijah going from panicked and embarrassed to suddenly wanting his ass filled. I nodded to Carl, and he retrieved another ‘toy’. It was a butt plug with an elongated handle. We had attached a plastic band, and attached to the band was a weighted rubber ball. After lubing it up, Carl began to insert it into Elijah. Elijah arched his back and pushed back onto it and was somewhat surprised when his sphincter closed around the narrow end. Elijah soon realized this was not a dildo to fuck him with nor could he thrust back and forth on it himself, but he tried anyway, bucking his hips. This caused the weighted ball to bounced on the elastic band resulting in a similar sensation on Elijah’s prostate, “Ohhh. Uuhhh”, he moaned as Carl and I looked on in amusement. I stepped in front of Elijah, who’s mouth was open as he rocked his hips back and forth. I took that opportunity to shove a small dildo into his mouth and strapped it around his head so he couldn’t spit it out. He moaned his displeasure on it as we quietly left.

As Carl and I walked toward the house, I commented, “I almost felt bad for Elijah at first. You were spanking that ass so hard it turned an almost bloody red. Now it seems he’s getting into it.” Carl laughed and said, “Yeah, at first I thought maybe I was being a little too aggressive, but I kept thinking of what they did to you. After the spanking was over though, he was getting into it. I almost felt like helping him to get off, but that would have been taking it too easy on him. The little fuck does have a nice butt though, you have to admit that.” I grinned and said, “Yeah, he does, but yours is better.”

We opened the outer basement door and quietly descended the concrete stairs, closing the doors behind us. As we reached the inside door at the bottom of the stairs, we heard a ragged voice calling out, “Help! Help me! Get me out of here!” We quietly entered the basement where Josh was snugly strapped to another contraption Carl had put together. “Ahhh!”, Josh screamed from the startling pain as Carl’s hand smacked down on his bare left butt cheek. Carl said in a low voice, “We know what you did.” The spanking then rained down on Josh’s bare cheeks as he yelled in pain, “Ahhh! Fuck! Stop! I don’t know what you mean! Please stop! Tell me what I did!” The spanking continued for several minutes as tears rolled down Josh’s cheeks as he sobbed. Suddenly, the spanking stopped and a hand began massaging Josh’s sore, red butt cheeks. Josh at first was happy the spanking had stopped but was then embarrassed by someone massaging his butt and he said, “Get the fuck off my butt. If you let me up now, I’m going to kick the shit out of you!” Big mistake. Carl said coldly, “We know what you did”, then the spanking rained down on Josh relentlessly as he screamed in pain until his voice was too horse to hear what he was saying. His body just shuddered from the pain and the sobs. Josh realized his outburst only made things worse and he began pleading for mercy again in a horse voice, “Fuck! I’m sorry I threatened you. I won’t hurt you. Please, just let me go! Tell me what I did! Please, just stop hitting me! I beg you!”  The cold voice repeated, “We know what you did.” The spanking continued and it seemed Josh began having trouble catching his breath. The spanking stopped and the hand began slowly rubbing and squeezing Josh’s sore, crimson red butt cheeks. A sudden shock went through Josh as a cold liquid was poured onto his butt. The hand slowly worked the cool, soothing liquid into Josh’s burning buns. Josh sighed deeply as the cool, soothing liquid relieved the pain in his sore buns. As the massaging continued and more cool liquid was poured onto his butt cheeks, Josh realized the lubricated middle finger of the hand massaging his butt was diving deeper into the crack between his firm buns and probing at his anal ring. Josh yelped, “Ohh, shit!”, as the finger penetrated him. As the finger began working its way in and out of Josh’s hole, Josh suddenly cried out, “Jeremy!” The cold voice asked, “Was that his name?” Josh replied, “Yes! I’m sorry! It was Elijah’s idea! I’m sorry! It was just supposed to be a joke and it got out of control! Please, I’m so sorry!” By now, several fingers were probing Josh and there was a feather-like brush tickling his balls. Josh began to think how Jeremy may have felt as he had worked his fingers inside him and used that feather to tickle his balls while Elijah had forced his cock down Jeremy’s throat. The thought caused Josh’s own cock to stir as he recalled the feel of pumping his own cock in and out of Jeremy’s mouth. The fingers were suddenly withdrawn and replaced by a small dildo, though it didn’t seem small to Josh’s virgin butt. He groaned, “Ohh, fuuuck”, as it slowly slid into his rectum. This wasn’t something they had done to Jeremy. Josh’s cock immediately began to wilt from the pain. As the pain faded though, and the soft brushing of his balls continued, his cock stirred back to life, much to his embarrassment. He groaned, “Uhhh! Ohhh, fuck.”,as the dildo worked in and out of his hole, massaging his prostate. His cock jumped as the brush slipped up the length of his rigid cock. Josh felt both humiliated and turned on by the ministrations his body was receiving. Then suddenly, the dildo was slowly removed, leaving Josh with an almost empty feeling. It didn’t last long though as a slightly larger and longer one replaced it. Josh soon became amazed at the waves of sexual pleasure his prostate was sending him. Precum was oozing from his throbbing cock. Noting this, the dildo was slowly removed and replaced by the same type of Butt plug Elijah now had in him. Another dildo was forced into his mouth and strapped fast. Then he heard footsteps walking away from him and doors being closed. He moaned against the dildo in his mouth and struggled once more against his restraints. He was frustrated, but his struggles did reveal that something had the butt plug moving and stimulating his prostate somewhat. As long as he moved periodically, something kept the butt plug moving.

As we made our way back to the wine cellar, we were amazed and amused to find Elijah still thrusting his hips around and moaning in pleasure on the dildo in his mouth. A clear trail of precum went from the tip of his cock down to the floor. Elijah hadn’t heard us return since he was too busy trying to stimulate himself to cum and was startled when Carl said, “We know what you did.” Elijah froze, realizing we had returned and witnessed his debauchery. When he felt someone removing the butt plug, he instinctively tried to keep it in him, but to no avail. Someone then removed the dildo from his mouth and inserted a water bottle to his mouth so he could drink. After drinking some water, the bottle was removed, and Elijah said, “Please, please let me go.” Carl repeated, “We know what you did.” Elijah then confessed, “Yes! Yes! I admit it! We sexually assaulted Jeremy! It wasn’t supposed to happen but somehow we got out of hand. Maybe from the alcohol, but we did it. I’m so sorry! Please, believe me.” Tears were once again rolling down Elijah’s face as he continued, “We made him suck our cocks. I’ll do what you want. I deserve to be punished. I’ll do whatever you want. I’ll suck your cock. Fuck my ass, but please let me cum.” We looked at each other, surprised by how quickly Elijah had surrendered to us. Carl asked him, “You want us to fuck you?” Elijah quickly replied, “Yes! I mean, no. I don’t know. I just want this over.” Carl then said, “So you think by apologizing we’ll just forget all about what you did?” Elijah replied, “No. I deserve some punishment. Like I said, I’ll suck your cock. You can even fuck my ass again with that dildo if that’s what you want, but please, at least let me cum.” Carl grinned and said, “No. It’s not going to be that easy. Your going to have to beg for it.” Elijah said, “Ok. Please let me cum.”  Carl grew irritated and said coldly, “Not that.”, and then slapped Elijah hard on his right butt cheek. Elijah yelped, “Ahhh!”, then he realized what Carl had meant and asked in almost a whisper, “Please, fuck my ass.” Carl said, “Did you say something?” This time, Elijah said it loudly, “Please! Would you fuck my ass?” I looked at Carl knowingly as he undressed as he said, “Well, since you asked so nicely.” He slid on a condom and squirted some lube on it. Elijah heard movement around him and wondered what was happening. Elijah then felt an arm reach around his waist. He had been expecting another dildo to be shoved into him but suddenly realized he was about to get the real thing this time. As the head of Carl’s cock penetrated him, Elijah gasped, “Ohh! Fuuuck!”, and as he gasped, a cock was suddenly shoved into his mouth. He began choking as it entered his throat. As he coughed, the cock was slapping him in the face, getting his cheeks wet with saliva and Jeremy’s precum. Elijah finally stopped choking and whimpered, “Oh, fuck.” Just that fast the cock was shoved back into his mouth, and he began moaning on it as Carl’s cock slowly burrowed into his ass. It felt different than the dildo, softer and yet bigger around and maybe longer. Elijah soon gave in totally to the dual assault. He began eagerly gobbling on Jeremy’s cock as Carl rammed him from behind. I smiled at Carl and he grinned back at me as our cocks slid in and out of Elijah’s holes. Elijah moaned and hummed on Jeremy’s cock, delirious with the amazingly good feelings the dual cocking was giving him. Then a hand wrapped around his cock and began stroking it in rhythm to the fucking he was receiving. The cum that was building in his balls for what seemed like an eternity shot out like bullets in long ropes. It struck Elijah’s chest and chin as well as Jeremy’s balls as they swung under Elijah’s chin. Jeremy’s legs also wore some of Elijah’s thick, creamy seed. I felt Elijah’s cum hit me as Elijah’s moans grew louder and Carl felt his hole spasming around his cock as well as Elijah’s cock spasming in his hand. Carl and I almost simultaneously unloaded into Elijah. Elijah’s voice went an octave higher as my cum filled his mouth. He began trying to swallow it but some ran down from the corners of his mouth. Carl filled his condom and Elijah felt it ballooning inside him. Satisfied with our work, we pulled our cocks from Elijah. Elijah was obviously both emotionally and sexually exhausted and just hung limply, supported by his arms and the padded board his chest was resting on. We released his hands and legs from their restraints, assured he didn’t have the strength to resist us and led him to a bunkbed where we laid him and chained him fast. He said, “Thanks for letting me cum”, before he was soon fast asleep.

Carl and I cleaned up a bit before heading down to the basement through the outside door. Josh heard us enter, so stopped what he’d been doing before we came in. Unfortunately, the ball was still bouncing when we arrived. As we approached, I pulled down on the ball, stretching the elastic band and then let it go, causing it to spring up and down violently, resulting in higher stimulation of Josh’s prostate from the attached butt plug inside him. Josh groaned from both the prostate stimulation and the humiliation. The realization was now sinking in that he was now paying a price for what he and Elijah had done to Jeremy. What of Elijah? Would he suffer the same fate? Maybe once he was out of this situation he could warn him, unless of course he had already met the same fate. If so, why hadn’t he warned him. Suddenly, Josh felt the butt plug stop vibrating and then it was being removed. He wasn’t sure if that was a good or a bad thing. Without the butt plug, Josh strangely felt empty. The strap around his head holding the dildo in his mouth was removed and then the dildo was also removed. Josh was hoping that his ordeal was over and they might be letting him go. “AHhhhh!”, Josh screamed out in pain as a hand slapped his right butt cheek. Then the cold voice, now in front of him said, “We know what you did.” The hand that slapped him remained on his butt. Josh said, “I told you already that we did it. I admit to it. Now, please, let me go!” The hand slapped his butt hard once more and was immediately removed, revealing and bright red hand print. Josh began apologizing once again, “I’m sorry! I’ll apologize to Jeremy if I ever see him again. I swear it! I’ll admit what we did to him. Please, I swear I’ll do it!” Josh then felt something pushing into his butt crack once again. Another dildo? An arm then wrapped around his waist. Josh suddenly realized this was a real cock that was about to enter him this time. He pleaded, “Fuck, no! Please don’t!” His plea went unheeded as he felt the head of the cock enter him. I pushed in slowly, not wanting to hurt Josh, but to teach him a lesson. Josh resigned himself to what was happening and though he hated to admit it, he wanted to feel that awesome feeling as his prostate was stimulated. Josh’s head drew back, and he inhaled deeply as Jeremy’s cock slowly sank into him. Then suddenly, a cock was being forced into his mouth and a pair of hands grabbed the back of his head, “Suck my cock”, the voice commanded. Realizing he had no choice, Josh complied, trying not to choke on it. As he adjusted to the cock in his mouth, Josh felt Jeremy slide his cock in the remaining few inches, “Uhhmmm.” Josh groaned in both pain and pleasure as it seemed the cock in his rectum seemed to have gone deeper than any of the dildos and had found a new button.  As Carl began fucking Josh’s mouth and throat, I began long, slow strokes fucking Josh’s ass. Josh was hanging on for the ride. His hard cock was bouncing in rhythm to the fucking he was receiving from both ends. Josh was amazed at the feeling of a real cock stroking inside him, massaging his prostate, filling him with new sensations and causing a stream of precum to leak from his hard, throbbing cock. He was even enjoying the feel of the groin and balls slapping into him as the hard cock thrusted deeply into him. I nodded to Carl, and he nodded back, then I reached around Josh’s waist with my other hand and grasped his precum-soaked, rigid cock and began stroking it in rhythm to the thrusting of my cock. Josh’s grunts and moans grew louder as he became overwhelmed with the sexual stimulation. Carl continued to face-fuck Josh as he enjoyed watching me fucking him. Carl mouthed the words, “This is fucking hot!” I nodded in agreement, loving the feel of Josh’s full, firm butt as I slammed into it and seeing Josh’s head bobbing on Carl’s cock. Then Carl said, “Oh fuck! I’m about to cum.”  Josh knew he couldn’t avoid what was about to happen. He felt the cock in his mouth grow harder and swell and then his mouth was being flooded with wads of thick creamy, salty seed. He instinctively began swallowing it, noting its taste was not unpleasant to him. As Carl’s semen flow began to slow, the thought of swallowing this guys cum brought Josh over the edge and I felt Josh’s cock erupt in my hand as it showered the floor beneath him. I began thrusting into Josh faster and harder and then I had to muffle my cries as I unloaded into the condom inside Josh. Once I had drained my balls, I slowly withdrew from Josh’s hole. I smiled at Carl and he smiled back, happy with our day’s work. Josh’s chest was still heaving from the ordeal. After disposing of the condom, we unstrapped Josh’s calves from the floor, but left the bar strapped to his calves. We then unstrapped his forearms and reconnected them together behind him. We then led him to a small cot where we secured him so he couldn’t get more than two feet from the area and then placed a blanket over him. We then left him to rest for the night.

End of Chapter 7