How I Got My Revenge

Chapter 33

Love Hurts

I walked to the front door and looked out through the peephole but didn’t see anyone. I thought maybe it was just a prank, so I opened the door to look around. “Sorry, I thought I’d retrieve my bag’, I heard a familiar voice say. Then Elijah appeared from around the corner of the house. I asked, “What are you doing here? You weren’t going to be here until tomorrow morning.” Elijah gave me a curious look and asked, “Didn’t Carl tell you?” Just then, Carl said from behind me, “Surprise!” I turned to look at Carl with a smile on my face, “So, you planned this?” Carl said, “When I found out you were getting off work Wednesday night, I got Elijah’s number from your phone and called him. This way, you’ll have the whole day tomorrow to catch up.” I grabbed Carl in a hug and said, “Thanks. I thought I’d give you a night of peace and quiet, so I thought tomorrow morning would have been better, but I guess you don’t mind.” I released Carl from my hug and then hugged Elijah, “Great to see you, Elijah.” Elijah replied, “It’s great to see you too, Jeremy.” We went back into the living room and Carl said, “Well, I have to work tomorrow, so I’m going to bed. We’ll catch up more tomorrow, Elijah. I made you a drink. It’s on the table.” They then hugged and Carl and I hugged, and we kissed, saying goodnight. So much for Carl sleeping in my bed tonight, I thought.

Carl headed into his bedroom. Elijah and I sat down on the sofa. Elijah said, “I hope my surprise arrival tonight isn’t an imposition. I thought about calling you, but Carl wanted it to be a surprise.” I replied, “It was definitely a surprise. I was wondering who would be stopping by this time of night. It also explains why Carl was carrying in two more drinks when I thought we were going to bed. As far as you being an imposition, not at all, just a very pleasant surprise. How was the drive?” Elijah replied, “It was pretty uneventful. Not much traffic on the road at this time of night. I was planning to arrive sooner and be here when you got home from work, but a classmate stopped by and wanted to go over some of the pre-semester required reading. So much for being last minute.” I asked Elijah, “Have you talked to Josh recently?” Elijah smiled and said, “As a matter of fact, I talked to him this morning. He spent most of the weekend hanging out with a guy from some of his classes. He said at first it was under the guise of studying but that the guy eventually asked about going out to dinner. He said after dinner, the guy asked if he minded if they went on a drive. They ended up parking on a logging road and the guy asked if he was into guys. Josh was so excited when he was telling me this. He said the guy is really cute, but more of a nerdy kind of cute. He said he’s got a nice body, but more of a swimmer’s build than like ours. He said they made out that night and ended up sucking each other’s cocks. He said the following night he fucked the guy and took his cherry. I’m really happy for him.” I smiled and said, “Good for Josh. It’s good he found someone nearby he can hang out with now that you’re a hundred miles away.” Elijah’s expression changed a bit to a more serious one as he said, “Yeah, Josh and I are best friends and became best friends with benefits, but we never could have been more than that. I’m glad he’s found someone he might be able to be more intimate with.” The atmosphere seemed to change to be more somber. There was suddenly that three-hundred-pound gorilla in the room. I wasn’t sure what to say at that moment. Fortunately, Elijah suddenly smiled and asked, “What have you been up to? Are you still playing basketball on Saturdays?” I smiled, relieved he had changed the subject, “Yeah, we are. I guess we’ll keep playing until it gets too cold out. I don’t know what the guys usually do during the winter. If I remember, I’ll ask them on Saturday. Do you remember Chris, I mean Baker and Chuck, the guy from New York? Elijah said, “I remember Baker, the younger guy. Chuck was the guy with the New York slash Philly accent, right?” I grinned, “Yeah, most people think it’s just a New York accent, but living as close to Philly as we did, we can pick up on that accent. Anyway, they’ve been hanging out sometimes on weekends. Chuck is an amazing cook and..” Elijah interrupted me, “Do you mess around with them?” I grinned and said, “Uh, yeah, somewhat.” Elijah grinned back and asked, “What’s that supposed to mean?” I explained, “Well, Chuck doesn’t know that Chris, er Baker is gay. We promised him that we wouldn’t out him to anyone. Chris is Baker’s first name by the way. He saw Chuck naked in Carl’s bed one night after we returned from a concert. He didn’t actually know at the time it was Chuck, but then he saw Chuck in the kitchen the next morning with Carl and knew. Carl covered for Chris by asking if my floor was comfortable the night before so Chuck would assume Chris had slept on my bedroom floor instead of my bed.” Elijah took it all in and then said, “If Chris wants to stay in the closet and limits those he has sex with, why did you tell me?” I smiled and said, “Well, he might come by and if he’s into it and you are as well, maybe the three or four of us can have a little fun together. Maybe even with Chuck, but of course that would be without Chris.” Elijah then asked, “I know you’ve been using prep and so do I, but what about these other guys? I mean Chuck comes across as gangsta material.” I laughed and said, “Chuck’s actually a pretty good guy. His reputation and accent cause people to form opinions about him that from what I’ve seen are nothing like who he really is. We do wear condoms though when we have sex with others with a few exceptions. Carl and I of course, and then you and Josh, although that may change now that he’s having sex with others. Other than that, the only other person I haven’t worn a condom while having sex is with Chris.” Elijah asked, “So you’re pretty sure Chris is clean?” I laughed and said, “I’m pretty sure. I’m the one who took his cherry and the only guy he’s ever had sex with without wearing a condom and then it was only one other guy, Carl.” Elijah said, “So you and Carl have unprotected sex and you and Chris have unprotected sex, but when Chris and Carl had sex, it was with condoms?” I grinned and said, “Yeah, well there was a reason for that. There was spit roasting involved and each of us had our turn. We agreed to wear condoms to keep things extra clean throughout.” Elijah’s mouth was open the whole time until I finished, then he said, “You had several three-ways in one night and I wasn’t there!” I laughed and then asked Elijah, “Speaking of which. What have you been up to at your campus?” Elijah shrugged his shoulders and said, “Not much. As far as anyone up there knows, I’m a jock straight boy. I am as far as I still like girls and have gone on a few dates, but it never went as far as me fucking them. To tell you the truth, the only time I’ve thought about sex since my last visit here has been thinking about our time together during that visit.” Shit! I was afraid that the three-hundred-pound gorilla would come back. I wanted to kiss him and tell him that we would always be together, but I couldn’t lie to him. My heart sank and it felt like I had Elijah, Chris, and Carl in the same room, and I had to choose one of them. Fuck! Elijah then said, “I’m sorry, Jeremy. I shouldn’t have said it that way. I know what you told me before I left.” I took a deep breath and said, “It’s ok Elijah. I have deep feelings for you, but I also have deep feelings for Carl.” Elijah interrupted me by saying, “And Baker or Chris. I could tell by the way that you talked about him. It’s ok. I only wish I lived closer by so I could at least compete for your time. I just never felt the urge to find anyone else. I just want you to know that if you do decide to settle down with either of them or even someone else, I’ll try to move on. In the meantime, I’m going to hold out hope, but understand right now we’re just going to have fun until then.” I could see there was hurt in his eyes, and I think he saw the hurt in mine. I wished I could wipe out that hurt in an instant because it was also part of why I hurt. Suddenly, our lips met, and we kissed. I hadn’t even realized we had slowly been leaning closer together until our lips met. We kissed passionately as tears rolled down both our cheeks, and then our arms wrapped around each other as we held tightly and continued kissing. As we broke our kiss, we both began laughing as we wiped each other’s tears from our cheeks. I said, “This wasn’t supposed to be how your arrival was supposed to go. I’m sorry.” Elijah got a serious look on his face, and said, “Look, I’m glad we got this out of the way. I’m fine with the way things are right now. I just want you to understand how I feel, and hope things turn out well for me. If not, I still want to be in your life, but I’ll be ok. I just want you to be happy and instead I guess I just put more pressure on you.” I smiled and said, “I’m getting used to it and you and Carl seem to be saying the same things but in slightly different ways. No matter what, Elijah, I wish I had been more relatable back in high school. You, Josh, and I could have been great friends and I guess I missed that chance. Now, I feel we are great friends and more. I’m just not sure yet how much more. Please be patient with me and at the least you’ll always be in my life I hope, but in the meantime, let’s have as much fun as we can as we get through our college years.” Elijah said, “Ok, now that we have the heavy stuff out of the way…” Elijah then moved closer, and we kissed once more as he began undressing me. I began undressing Elijah as well and soon we were naked on the sofa making out. Elijah dropped to his knees between my legs and looked up into my eyes before bending down and licking at my hard shaft and balls. I suddenly realized I hadn’t showered after work yet and said, “Elijah, I should get in the shower first. I didn’t have time to after work yet.” Elijah stopped for a moment and looked up at me, “I like the taste of you, sweat and all.” Then he licked my balls before taking the head of my cock in his mouth. He swirled his tongue around the head of my cock for a little, then plunged down onto my cock. God, he looked so hot! I heard movement and noticed Carl headed into the bathroom. He gave me a thumbs up. I smiled at him just as Elijah looked up at me. Elijah pulled off my cock and turned to see Carl standing there watching us, and asked, “Wanna join us?” Carl grinned and said, “I’d love to, but I have to go to work in the morning. You two have fun. By the way, nice butt.” Then Carl went into the bathroom. Elijah turned back to me. He had a huge grin on his face and a twinkle in his eyes. Then he went right back down on my cock. Elijah didn’t even flinch when Carl emerged from the bathroom and went back into his bedroom. He grinned at me as he did. After several more minutes, I pulled Elijah up and said, “My turn.” I got up and had Elijah sit down. I went down to my knees between his legs and took his cock in my left hand and held it while I lapped at his nut sack. I took each of his balls in my mouth and tongued them, feeling each ball rolling around inside the sack while hearing Elijah moan in pleasure. After working on each of his large balls, I moved to licking the bottom of his cock from base to precum-leaking head. Each time my tongue touched the base of his cock, it jumped with excitement. Eventually, I began licking his entire cock, swirling my tongue around it, especially the head, licking up the sweet nectar that was his precum. Elijah began running his fingers through my hair as he said, “I’ve missed this so much. Can we get into a sixty-nine so that I can suck you too?” I pulled off him and jokingly shook my head and said, “Nope. I’m greedy and want your seed first.” Elijah grinned and said, “That might happen anyway the way you’re working on my cock.” I stood up and took his hand as I pulled him from the sofa, “You haven’t felt anything yet. Let’s take this into my bedroom.”

As we got into my bedroom, I pushed Elijah back onto my bed and then climbed over him in a sixty-nine position. Once I was in position, I took his cock and immediately took him down to the root, burying my nose in his pubes. Elijah yelled out, “Holy fuck!” I remained in place with my nose buried in his pubes as I inhaled Elijah’s scent. It was intoxicating, but I couldn’t get a full nose full because of his cock blocking my airway, so I eventually pulled upward. Elijah was in awe, “Where did you learn how to do that? That was so fucking hot. You almost made me cum from that!” I pulled off his cock long enough to say, “It took some practice, but once you overcome the gag reflex, it’s not so hard.” I then buried my nose in his pubes and inhaled more of his scent. I heard Elijah moan on my cock as it released a flood of precum into his mouth from the euphoria his scent caused. I then went back to work on his cock, periodically taking his entire length. He was working my cock as well, and every now and then, he would choke. He was trying to deep throat my cock. He needed more practice. Suddenly, I felt him tense. His balls tightened up and his cock swelled. He moaned loudly on my cock and then his cock began pumping his seed into my mouth. I savored his sweet cream as his baby makers danced on my tongue. His hands were squeezing my buns tightly as he spasmed beneath me. The excitement and amount of the cum flooding my mouth triggered my own release. My own cum surged up from my balls and suddenly ropes of my own cum were firing from my cock into Elijah’s mouth. I heard the same sound from him that I was making on his cock, “MMMmmm! MMMmmm! MMMmmm!” As we slowly finished depositing our seed in each other’s mouths, I pulled off his cock and flipped around to face Elijah. He had a huge grin on his face. I bent down as he raised his head and our lips met in a cum-sharing kiss. It took several minutes of snowballing back and forth before we had consumed our combined cum. As we broke our kiss, Elijah said, “Oh my god! That was the best ever! You were so fuckin’ awesome, Jeremy.” I laughed and said, “Elijah, there were two of us involved. We were awesome.” I kissed his lips and then moved my mouth to the nape of his neck and then did something I don’t normally do. I took his left arm and lifted it up above his head and then buried my nose in his arm pit, inhaling deeply. Elijah giggled and asked, “What are you doing? That tickles!” I began licking his pit and didn’t stop until I had covered every square inch. He didn’t have a lot of hair under his arms. He began giggling again as I moved to the other one, first inhaling his soapy, musky, sweaty scent, then licking it until I had covered all of it. Then I looked at Elijah and smiled. He gave me a puzzled look and asked, “Why did you do that? I almost smashed your nose into my pit. Your tongue tickled at first.” I said, “Don’t laugh, but when I was blowing you, I was smelling your pubes and your scent was turning me on, so when I was kissing your neck, I got a whiff of your pit, and it was a similar scent, and I couldn’t help myself. Your scent seems to turn me on a lot.” Elijah laughed and said, “I can tell by what you just did and the fact that the rod between your legs is making my abs wet.” I grinned at him and said, “I guess I should get in the shower now. We should get to bed soon.” Elijah grinned and said, “Oh, no you don’t.” He caught me by surprise and rolled us over, so I was now on my back and he was on top. He looked down at me and smiled before pushing my right arm up, and then he pushed his face into my pit. After several seconds, he pulled back and looked at me and said, “You’re right. It makes me lightheaded and makes my cock rock hard.” I said, “I smell that bad, huh?” He pushed his face back in my pit and then began grinding his hips, rubbing our steely hard cocks together. Our abs were already slickened up by my precum and now his cock was also producing quite a bit. It was feeling really great. Suddenly, Elijah scooted up on my abs with his knees on either side of me and my cock wedged between his butt cheeks. His cock was now dribbling its precum between my pecs. He continued grinding, but instead of grinding our cocks together, he was grinding his butt on my throbbing cock. He pulled his head up from my pit and smiled down at me. He had a glazed-over look in his eyes as he asked, “Can I ride you?” I said, “There’s a condom and lube behind that door in the headboard.” As Elijah reached for the door, he said, “If you don’t mind, I don’t want you to use a condom. Like I said, I haven’t had sex with anyone since I was here, just left, and right palm and I know you’re clean.” I smiled and said, “I’m ok with that.” Elijah said, “I want to feel your skin on mine, and I want you to breed me with your baby makers.” He lubed up my cock and used the excess to lube himself up. After wiping his hand off with tissues, he lifted himself up and brought my cock to his tight ring. Then he slowly lowered himself down onto my cock. He still had that glazed over look in his eyes and now his mouth hung open as he sank down onto my cock. He soon had my entire length inside him. Elijah began riding my cock, “Ahhh. Aaahh! Ohhh, fuuuck yeahhh! Oohhhh yeahhh. Fuck, your cock feels so good inside me. Aahhh. Ahhhh. Fuck, yessss.” He began moving up and down faster and I started pushing up into his downward movements. The slapping sound of his firm, muscular buns colliding with my lap, and his moans of pleasure filled the room. For a brief second, I hoped we wouldn’t wake Carl, then it was forgotten as I was focused on our fuck as his cock slapped down between my pecs each time our bodies collided, spattering precum across my chest. I asked Elijah, “Ready?” He stopped with my cock imbedded inside him, “Ready for what?” No sooner had Elijah gotten that out of his mouth, I sat up and wrapped my arms around his upper and lower back and rolled him backward, putting us in a missionary position. Elijah grinned up at me and said, “Give me that cock! Fuck me, Jeremy!” I began thrusting in and out of him at a pace similar to what we had when he was riding me and slamming into him just as hard. I knew I was getting close and was trying to hold off as long as I could. Elijah’s cock was still leaking precum on his abs in surprising amounts as his stiff rod bounced around as I pistoned in and out of him. I said, “I’m getting close.” Elijah said, “Yeah. Gimme that load. Breed me, Jeremy! Fuck yeah!” I was seconds away, so I began rapidly drilling him. His eyes opened wide as his mouth hung open in surprise at how fast I was drilling his hole, “Ahhhh, Fuuuuuck! Oh shit!” He reached for his cock, but it exploded before his hand reached it, sending his cum flying all over his face chest and abs. Some even hit my chin and dripped down on my chest. Then I groaned loudly as my cock began pumping my seed inside him. I slammed in to the hilt as my cock continued pumping. It felt so good. Elijah was actually pulling me in tighter with his heels on my lower back. I smiled down at Elijah as he looked up at me with shock still written on his face. He finally said, “Oh my God. That was the hottest sex I’ve ever had! I think you just destroyed my prostate.” I laughed and said, “It was fantastic for me too.” Then I leaned down and licked the cum from his chin. As I pulled back, he stopped me and leaned up and licked the cum from my chin. I lowered my body down onto his and we kissed some more. Eventually, my softening cock slipped from him, and we lay there embracing and periodically kissing. After a while, Elijah said, “Thanks, Jeremy.” I looked at him, a little confused, “For what?” Elijah grinned and said, “For not wearing a condom. You see, I’ve been off birth control for months now, so I think it will be a boy.” I started laughing and then gave him a serious look (Fake of course), “You know you’re on the bottom. I could fix that.” I then began tickling him. He screamed and squirmed beneath me and begged me to stop. I eventually did, and as we both caught our breath again, Elijah said, “Seriously though, thank you. I wanted you inside me, without plastic or rubber between us. It feels more personal to me.” I fought back tears as I looked at him. He was serious now. How do I deserve these guys. Three guys I’m sure I love. Only one of them has given me an out, if I want it, or if he decides he wants someone else. Either way, we’ve agreed we’ll always be brothers, but Elijah and Chris are a different story. They’re not giving me an out. Elijah tried in a half-serious way, but I saw through it. Would I want it if they provided me with a way out? I wasn’t sure. I recalled what Carl had said to me and decided to follow his advice. I stayed in the moment and smiled down at Elijah and said, “I’m glad you asked me, and I’m glad we did this without condoms, Elijah. I’m not sure how I deserve your affections, but I do appreciate them. I wish I had been more attentive to having real friends when I was in high school. I was too invested in trying to be the best physical person I could be, the best in sports I could be, as well as academically. I didn’t even date many girls in high school. I guess I was too self-absorbed. Now I find myself on the rebound from a relationship that I expected to be the one to give me a family and kids. A normal, heterosexual life. It all came crashing down around me and in my own desire to make Kayla’s life better. I don’t blame anyone for what happened, but it still hurt. Then these great guys came in and began picking up the pieces, helping me through it all. I discovered I like having sex with guys as much as girls and maybe even more.” Elijah interrupted, “I found out the same thing thanks to you and Carl. You guys tried to teach us a lesson and we learned at lot more than intended, so thank you for that.” I replied, “I regret what we did to you and Josh regardless of what you guys did. Two wrongs don’t make a right.” Elijah took my hand and said, “In that case, I think it did. Both Josh and I came out better for it. I was able to admit my true feelings, and I just had sex again with my high school crush.” I couldn’t help but laugh, and said, “I guess you have a point there.” Elijah squeezed my hand and said, “How about telling me more about Chris. I’d like to get to know my opponent, just kidding. I really would like to meet him. If he’s anything like you describe, maybe we could form a friendship.” I smiled and said, “He’s a great guy, kind of a dark-haired version of you in build. He’s also very thoughtful. He’d give you the shirt off his back if you needed it.” Elijah said, “Pretty much like you, Jeremy.” I laughed at his ribbing, at least I took it that way. Then I suggested, “Hey, since you arrived early and we’ve been catching up, would you want me to invite him along for lunch tomorrow?” Elijah looked over at me and said, “That’s a great idea!” I took that as a good sign but that comment he had made about Chris being his opponent had me a little concerned. I hope they get along great and become friends. I looked to Elijah and said, “Let’s grab a shower.” Elijah continued holding my hand, and said, “Yep. Now I’m ready.” 

I turned on the water and when the temperature was right, I motioned for Elijah to enter first. He yelped as I slapped his right butt cheek. It was as firm as ever. We washed each other’s hair and then soaped each other’s bodies up. Elijah took a long time as he massaged the soap into my skin. It felt really good as he pressed his thumbs into my muscles and then made circular motions relieving the stress from my muscles and my body, “That feels so good, Elijah. Where’d you learn how to do that?” Elijah replied, “My roommate, Kevin, is taking sports medicine. He showed me some tricks.” I said, “Some tricks, eh. Are you sure he’s not trying to trick you into his bed? Owww!” Elijah had given me a slap on my butt. Being wet, it stung a lot! Elijah said, “I think his girlfriend, Jesse, would have a problem with that. She spends almost as much time in our room as he does. She was there when Kevin was showing me this.” I grinned and replied, “If you say so. Oww! That stung too!” Elijah said, “You deserved it. Now you have a red handprint on each of those hard buns.” I turned to face him with a grin, and he looked down and said, “You pervert! Those slaps just turned you on!” I laughed and then watched as Elijah lowered himself down and took my hard cock in his mouth. He cupped my buns while he worked on my cock. A few times he tried to take it all. He choked but was getting better. Then I felt a finger working into my hole. My cock throbbed and Elijah moaned, “MMmm Hmmm.”, as a surge of precum flooded his mouth. He soon had three fingers in me, and I was approaching the point of no return. I guess Elijah sensed this and suddenly got up and said, “Turn around. I wanna fuck you.” I raised my eyebrows as if to ask, “Do you now?’, but my cock gave my eagerness away by jumping around. I grinned and turned off the water before turning around to lean against the shower wall. Elijah asked, “Why did you turn the water off?” I replied, “So we still have hot water left when we’re done.” He began rubbing the head of his precum-lubed cock against my hole for a bit. He then pulled back and applied some lube that I keep in the shower, before slowly entering me. “Fuuuck.”, I groaned as he slowly penetrated me until I felt his pubes pressed firmly against my buns. Elijah said in my ear, “God, I love the feel of those hard, muscular buns of yours.” Elijah remained pressed against me for a while before he began to withdraw. He withdrew until only the head of his cock remained inside me and then plunged back in. His strokes were slow at first, gliding across my prostate and then he slowly sped up. As he did, he said, “I missed this a lot!” In between grunts I asked, “Huhh. Huuh, I thought, Huhh, you liked, Huuhh, bottoming more, Uhhh.” Elijah replied, “I do but I really love fucking this ass.” I hadn’t touched my cock, but I felt like I would explode at any time. Elijah’s cock was hitting my prostate on every tug and push. I was loving every second, “Huhh, Uhhh, Oh fuck! Ohhh! Huhh. Fuck me! Fuck me, Elijah! Uhhh! Fuck!” Elijah’s strokes began getting more ragged and he said, “I’m getting close! Can I breed you?” I hadn’t expected that question and wasn’t sure how to respond. I was too lost in sexual bliss to think, “Uhh! Ohh! Yesss! Ohhh, fuck me! Fuck!” Elijah suddenly slammed inside me as he yelled, “FUCK! I’m cumming!” Elijah’s hand wrapped around my cock, and it instantly exploded, sending my cum splattering against the shower wall. I felt Elijah’s cum pumping inside me at the same time. I was grunting with every spurt and Elijah was grunting in my ear at the same time. As I finished cumming and began catching my breath, I leaned on the shower wall for support and Elijah leaned on me. His cock was still inside me, but it was losing its hardness and eventually withdrew from my hole. Elijah’s breathing slowed and he started kissing my left ear and neck. He was no longer leaning on me for support, just pressed against me intimately. I straightened up and turned toward him and we kissed. When we broke the kiss I asked him, “Did you call me an ass?” He giggled, knowing what I had meant then yelped, “Owww!”, as I slapped his right butt cheek. I laughed and then stepped back slightly and turned the water back on knowing what was next. Elijah screamed, “Fuck! That’s cold!” I laughed and then moved back under the shower once the temperature had adjusted again. He grinned at me and said, “You did that on purpose.” I laughed and said, “Maybe.” We finished showering, stepped out, and dried each other off. We then crawled into bed and cuddled.

Elijah rested his head on my chest and said, “I missed this. I want you to know that I understand that you don’t want to make any commitments right now, especially to a long-distance relationship, but I don’t plan on going anywhere. I hope Chris and I become good friends, but I’m holding out hope that in the end, you’ll choose me.” A tear rolled down my cheek. I didn’t respond. I couldn’t respond. I was too choked up. The last thing I remember as I was falling asleep was Elijah asking me in a whisper, “Jeremy, are you asleep? Ok, goodnight. I love you.” I felt him kiss me and then his head was back on my chest.

 

End of Chapter 33