How I Got My Revenge

Chapter 15 

Forgiveness

Elijah and Josh stared at each other, relieved at what I had just said. Finally, Elijah broke the silence, turned to me and asked, “What can we do to make it up to you, Jeremy?”

I sat back and grinned, then said, “You could start by sucking my cock.” Neither Elijah nor Josh had expected anything like this and just stared at me, dumbfounded. I broke them out of their shock, “Well?” Josh then grinned and said, “You’re joking, right?” I gave them my poker face. Elijah then said, “I think he’s serious, dude.” Josh then dropped in front of me on his knees and Elijah was soon next to him. They fumbled with my belt and zipper before pulling my pants down around my ankles, revealing my stiff cock beneath the pale blue fabric of my Jockey briefs. Josh reached for the waistband of my briefs, but I pushed his hand away, stood up, and said, “No, do it with your mouths.” Josh looked up at me astonished, but Elijah grinned, leaned in and grabbed the waistband of my briefs with his teeth and began tugging at them. He began making some progress, but suddenly stopped and released them from his mouth. I was puzzled at first but he suddenly put his mouth over my cotton-sheathed cock and began nibbling and sucking on it. My cock grew completely hard immediately, “Fuck, Elijah. That feels so good.” Josh soon joined Elijah and began sucking at my balls through the fabric. I grinned down at them, “Fuck yeah!” After a while, they each used their teeth to grab onto the waistband of my briefs and pulled them down to my ankles. My hard cock sprang out and slapped hard against my abs. Elijah the playfully began pulling my cock down and then released it to spring back up against my abs again. Josh removed his shirt before kneeling back down in front of me next to Elijah. This time, when Elijah pulled my cock down, he held it there and looked to Josh. Josh grinned, then leaned in and put his mouth over the head of my cock. As Elijah removed his hand, Josh slid his mouth over as much of my cock as he could handle which was several inches. He then began sliding his lips back and forth, bobbing on my hard shaft. He periodically glanced up to see how I was reacting. Elijah slid off his shirt and then began removing my shirt as well. Elijah stepped back slightly, staring at my body and his friend, Josh, sucking on my cock. He was obviously hard as a rock, and I noticed a wet spot forming at the tip of his shaft causing me to grin. While Elijah watched as Josh sucked on my cock, he unbuckled his belt, unbuttoned his pants and slid them down to his ankles. Stepping out of them, he moved over next to Josh before sliding his tight, red, precum-wetted briefs off. His stiff boner sprung straight out in front of him excitedly. He then tapped Josh on the shoulder and said, “My turn.” Elijah then dropped to his knees. Josh pulled his mouth off my cock and moved over slightly to allow Elijah to take over. Elijah immediately took my cock in his mouth and began sucking and sliding his lips up and down my hard shaft. Elijah was going at it eagerly it seemed, and I said, “Yeah, Elijah. Suck on my hard cock! Your hot mouth feels great.” Josh in the meantime was tapping on Elijah’s stiff, horizontal rod playfully, and then gave it a few strokes before standing up to remove his own pants, quickly unbuttoning his skinny jeans revealing his own hard cock beneath a pair of black boxer briefs. I pulled my attention away from Elijah long enough to watch Josh slide his boxer briefs down over his hips. His steely shaft sprung out as he slid them down his thighs to his ankles before stepping out of them. His creamy pale rod was highlighted by the dark pubic hair surrounding it. Josh glanced up and saw me watching him and gave me a dimpled smile. Josh continued looking at me as he gave his cock a few strokes before dropping to his knees next to Elijah. While Elijah continued sucking my cock, Josh began licking at my balls, taking each one in his mouth a slathering it up before switching to the other one. Soon, Elijah and Josh were switching back and forth between my cock and my balls. I was not expecting the night to be going so well and soon felt my balls churning. I was going to cum soon. I was so close. Suddenly, I pulled back from them and freed my cock and balls from their mouths. Elijah and Josh both looked up at me in surprise. I said, “Put your cheeks together!”, and I helped guide their heads, so they were cheek to cheek facing me. As they looked on, I began to finish myself off, stroking my cock and said, “Open your mouths!” They both opened their mouths, and I could see the smile on their faces as they knew what was coming. I cried out, “Oh, fuck!”, as bolts of cum began firing from my cock. Elijah and Josh both flinched but didn’t move as my cum showered their faces and mouths as well as their hair with my seed. As my cock finished shooting and the last of my cum dribbled out of its head, I slid my cock in and out of their mouths a few times before stepping back to admire my work. I reached out to swipe some of my cum from Elijah’s right eye with my thumb and then inserted it into his mouth as Josh looked on with a dimpled grin. They seemed to be enjoying this as much as I was. It made me wonder if being aloof was the real reason for what they had done to me. I then said to them, “Ok, now turn and look at each other.” They spun ninety degrees on one knee to face each other’s cum-covered face. They were both grinning in amusement at each other. I then commanded, “Now lick each other’s face clean.” My cock throbbed anew as I looked on as they willingly complied. Josh giggled a little before leaning in and licking the cum from Elijah’s face. Elijah closed his eyes and smiled as he received the tongue bath from Josh. When josh moved from Elijah’s face, he opened his eyes, still smiling and then leaned in and began lapping away at Josh’s face. When he finished, I said, “Now kiss and swap tongues.” Their grins grew wider before they leaned together and began kissing. While they kissed, I noticed both of their stiff cocks had precum drooling from them. I said, “Ok guys, you can stop. Guys!” I grinned as I realized they were very much into their kiss. They reluctantly broke their lip lock and I said, “You two were really enjoying that, weren’t you?” They both turned beet red, but while Elijah’s eyes lowered from embarrassment, Josh broke into a wide, dimpled grin. Seeing their stiff cocks drooling with precum gave me an idea, “Looks like your cocks are begging for attention. Elijah, why don’t you get on your back.” Josh then offered, “Why don’t we go upstairs to my bedroom?” I agreed, “Good idea, Josh. Lead the way.” Actually, it was Josh’s stiff cock leading the way, protruding out like a divining rod. Elijah followed right behind him, and I was behind them, taking in the view of their hard, muscular buns as they ascended the stairs to our destination. Once we were in Josh’s bedroom, I directed Elijah to lie on the bed on his back, knees up, with his feet flat at the edge of the bed. I then had Josh climb on top of him in a sixty-nine position and said, “Ok guys, help each other out.” They wasted no time latching onto each other’s cocks and slurping away. I smiled as I watched them enthusiastically bobbing up and down on each other’s cocks. I wished I was filming it. It was that hot. I stepped up to the edge of the bed where Josh was bobbing on Elijah’s cock and began slapping Josh’s cheeks and forehead with my stiff cock. After a bit of that, I walked around to the other side of the bed and began playing with Josh’s firm butt cheeks. Then I started sliding my middle finger in the valley between his cheeks, moving closer and closer to his tight pucker. Josh let out a moan as he felt the finger probing at the entrance to his hole and began sucking harder on Elijah’s cock. Having the best seat in the house, Elijah watched as he bobbed up and down on Josh’s cock. I could see it in his eyes, he couldn’t wait to see my finger plunge inside. What I couldn’t see was Elijah’s own hole quivering with excitement. Josh let out a loud groan as I slid my finger inside him. I started working my finger in and out, working his hole, and then added my index finger as his moan became continuous while his lips slid up and down Elijah’s cock. I worked my fingers in Josh’s hole for a while before slowly withdrawing them.

I walked around to the other side of the bed where Josh was bobbing on Elijah’s cock. I started playing with Elijah’s balls and then began teasing Elijah’s hole, lightly touching and rubbing it as it twitched in reaction. After a few minutes of this, I slowly pushed my middle finger inside Elijah’s tight hole. “MMMmmm!”, I heard Elijah moan from the other side of the bed, sounding like he was welcoming my invading finger. Hearing this, moments later I added another finger and worked them in and out eliciting moans of pleasure from Elijah. Josh began moaning as well. I wasn’t sure if Elijah’s moans were getting him excited, Elijah was sucking harder on his cock, or was Elijah drooling more precum from his cock. I smiled and said, “Seems like you’re both enjoying this.” Almost in unison, I received a reply, “Mmmm Hmmmm.” I gave Elijah’s butt a slap and asked, “Do you want my cock in there?” Elijah moaned, “Ummmm Hmmm.” I teased, “What? I couldn’t understand you.” Elijah didn’t pull his mouth off Josh’s cock, but responded more loudly, “Mmmmm! HHhhmMM!” Josh pulled his mouth off Elijah’s cock, grinned and said, “Yeah! Fuck his butt!”  Then went back to sucking on Elijah’s drooling cock. I slid on a condom and Josh pointed to drawer in the nightstand where I found lube. I lubed up the condom and then worked some into Elijah’s hole. Then I grabbed Elijah’s legs and slid him forward slightly, so his butt was just over the edge of the bed and his legs were on my shoulders. Josh had also moved back with us, keeping their mouths on each other’s cocks. I brought the tip of my cock to Elijah’s eager, twitching hole and pushed forward. I slowly pushed inside until just the head of my cock popped inside. Elijah grunted on Josh’s cock.

Josh was rewarded by a flood of precum into his mouth as he watched Jeremy’s cock enter Elijah. The flow of precum from his own cock increased as he watched Jeremy’s hard shaft invade his best friend’s hot hole.

I slowly sank inside Elijah’s hot hole until I was pressed tightly against his firm butt cheeks. Then I began slowly fucking him in long strokes, plunging inside and then tugging outward. Elijah’s moans and grunts grew louder as I slowly increased speed. Josh continued pumping his lips up and down on Elijah’s cock as he watched my cock pistoning in and out of his friend’s tight hole. Josh was getting close as he felt his balls tightening and suddenly Elijah’s moans grew exponentially louder and his cock began to spasm, flooding Josh’s mouth with his cum. This brought Josh over the edge, and his cock began flooding Elijah’s mouth with his own cum. I felt Elijah’s hole spasming around my cock and saw Josh flinch slightly. Then I noticed some of Elijah’s cum seeping from the corner of Josh’s mouth. I felt my own impending orgasm approaching and stopped. Then I slowly pulled my cock from Elijah and disposed of the condom and said, “That was pretty hot!”

Josh slowly pulled his lips from Elijah’s cock and reached to wipe the cum seeping down his chin. Before his hand made it to his face, I grabbed it and said, “I’ll get that for you.” I leaned in and licked Elijah’s cum from Josh’s chin. As I finished and stood back up, I saw Josh staring at me in shock. I just smiled at him. His look of shock slowly faded and was replaced by that dimpled smile. I smacked Josh’s butt and said, “Your next”, then reached over and rubbed my middle finger in Elijah’s butt crack and asked Josh, “Want a piece of this?” Josh’s smile widened as he said enthusiastically, “Yeah I do!” Elijah managed to dislodge Josh’s still stiff cock from his mouth and said, “I think I should have a say about who’s cock is stuffing my butt!” Josh and I responded almost simultaneously, “Yeah?” Josh then added, “And?” As soon as Josh climbed off Elijah to allow him to get up, Elijah quickly flipped around on all fours with his butt at the edge of the bed and said, “I’m in.” Josh and I shared a grin and then Josh got behind Elijah and pushed his condomless cock into him until he was buried to the hilt. Elijah grunted, “Fuck! Oh, yeah.” Josh said, “Fuck yeah! Your ass feels so good, Elijah.” I slid on another condom and lubed up before stepping behind Josh and then began rubbing the head of my cock between Josh’s firm cheeks, inching closer and closer to his tight hole, and asked, “Ready for this?” Josh replied, “Yep.” I grinned and pushed against Josh’s tight ring. Josh cried out, “Oh fuck!”, as I broke through and then slowly sank into him until I was pressed tightly against his firm apple globes.

Once Josh was used to my cock inside him, he began moving back and forth, fucking Elijah and himself at the same time. I was making sure to pound into Josh when he pushed back onto my cock. Soon, all three of us were panting, grunting, and moaning in unison. Elijah was crying out, “Oh, fuck! Uhhh! Ohhh! Ahhh! Fuck yes! Fuck me!” as his drooling cock bounced in rhythm spraying droplets of precum everywhere as Josh fucked him. Josh’s voice soon joined Elijah’s, “Oh yeah! Fuck me! Fuck my ass! Harder!” Skin slapping into skin reverberated around the room joining the voices moaning, grunting, and pleading to be fucked harder. We were fucking like a well-oiled machine until suddenly Josh cried out, “Ohh! Oh Fuck! I’m gonna cum!” Josh then slammed into Elijah as his cock pumped his seed deep inside him. Josh thought he’d never stop cumming as each time I shoved inside him, I felt his hole clench down on my cock indicating another load pumped from his cock. I felt my own climax approaching as may balls tightened, and announced, “Fuck! I’m gonna cum too!” Elijah called out, “Hurry! I want it in my mouth!” I wasn’t sure I’d make it in time as I was so close, but I slid out of Josh, ripped the condom off and quickly stepped around the other side of the bed. No sooner did my cock enter Elijah’s warm, wet mouth, it began pumping my seed into Elijah’s mouth. Almost on queue, jets of cum shot out of Elijah’s cock, spraying the bed, his chin, and my legs. All three of us then collapsed onto the bed with Elijah sandwiched between Josh and I catching our breath.

I wasn’t sure how this night was going to turn out, but I was overjoyed at how it was going so far. I knew by how they reacted to what Carl and I did to them, that they must have realized that they were into guy-on-guy sex. Suddenly a rush of guilt swept over me. What Carl and I had done to them went even further than what Elijah and Josh had done to me. Two wrongs don’t make a right. A knot suddenly formed in my stomach, and my head drifted to what ifs. What if they hadn’t done that to me? Would I have still accepted Carl’s advances? If Carl and I hadn’t done what we had to Elijah and Josh, would I be here lying next to them after having some wild three-way sex? Would Elijah and Josh instead be in bed with girls from the reunion?

Josh finally caught his breath, and he laid back thinking about the events of the night. How things could have gone south if Jeremy had freaked out on them after they had confessed. That hadn’t happened and here he was lying next to Jeremy and his best friend, Elijah. Were they still best friends? They hadn’t really hung out since the football camping trip until this past week. Were they now more than best friends after what has happened between them the past week? What would happen to that relationship once Elijah went back to college? He’d have to have a talk with Elijah when they were alone, but what would he say? He wasn’t even sure of his feelings for Elijah. Was it just the sex or was there something more? He wanted to believe the latter.

Elijah’s heart was racing as he lay between his best friend and the guy he had always both envied, and now to admit it to himself, admired and even maybe lusted after? It hadn’t been because of Jeremy’s aloofness that led him to convince Josh to help him that night. He now admitted to himself that he had always wanted more contact with Jeremy than just in football practice. He wanted skin on skin contact with him. He wasn’t happy that Jeremy used to stay on the field after practice was over, simply because he had no excuse to stall and remain in the locker room until Jeremy would finally come in, shower and change. He caught too few glimpses of Jeremy’s naked body, his firm muscular buns, his hard six-pack abs, and sculpted chest. There was also that perfect cut cock outlined by his pubic bush. That cock he always seemed drawn to on the occasions when he saw it. That perfect body and adorable face. He had known the camping trip would be his last chance to touch him. What the fuck had he been thinking! He had crushed on the guy so much that he had convinced his best friend to help kidnap and assault him. He had apologized as he had promised he would, but he had lied while doing it.

Elijah turned his head toward Jeremy and noticed Jeremy had an almost sad expression on his face. Elijah began to wonder if now was a bad time to say what he needed to say. There was also the question of how Josh would take what he had to say. He hoped it wouldn’t hurt Josh too much as they had grown tighter than ever these past few days. He didn’t want to ruin their relationship. What was their relationship now? Regardless, he was determined to get it off his chest.

Elijah spoke softly, “Jeremy? I need to tell you something.” Elijah’s voice broke me out of my depressed state of mind, and I turned to look at him. He looked like a kid who was about to show his parents he had gotten an F on his report card. Elijah began, “Earlier, when we apologized and I had said that you seemed to act aloof, and too good for the rest of us; that was a lie. The real reason was something that I couldn’t even admit to myself until now. I had a crush on you for a long time and I refused to even acknowledge it to myself. I wished you didn’t stay out on the practice field after practice was over because I wanted to catch a glimpse of you naked and the night of the camping trip would be last chance I would have to touch you. Yes, it’s sick. I’m disgusted with myself because of it and want to apologize to you, and to Josh. Tears began running down Elijah’s cheek, “I hate myself for what I did to you. I had a secret crush on you that I didn’t want to admit and what do I do about it? I hurt you. I kidnapped and assaulted you! I’m so sorry.” The last words were almost in a whisper as he closed his eyes in shame. I wasn’t sure what to say. Elijah had just laid out his soul to me and admitted something he’d hidden from even himself. I wasn’t sure what to say, but I wanted to comfort him. It was brave of him to lay that out there. I suddenly heard myself say, “You could have stayed.” Elijah opened his eye and looked at me. He looked confused as he asked, “What?” I replied, “You could have stayed after practice with me. That would have given you the opportunity to see me naked afterward.” I could tell my reaction to what he just told me and what I just said surprised him. The look of confusion was replaced by a slight smile as he said, “I never thought of that. Besides what would Josh have thought?” Josh broke in, “Josh may have stayed with you and continued to work out, but then I might have noticed you checking Jeremy out and who knows what might have happened. Either way, here we are and what’s happened is over and done. What you just admitted to doesn’t change anything. Your reason for talking me into helping you that night doesn’t matter. I still could have said no but didn’t.” I interrupted, “It does change one thing. I no longer have to feel guilty about seeming aloof to you.” I smiled, but in the back of my mind I was thinking, ‘I am still guilty of what we did to Elijah and Josh.’ I decided to talk to Carl about it before I said anything about it to Elijah and Josh, but at some point, would tell them. I looked to Elijah again and said, “Thank you for telling me and I’m glad you found the courage to admit it to yourself. Hopefully you’ll feel better for it. As I said before, all is forgiven about that night. You admitted to it and took your punishment very well.” Elijah smiled and said, “Thank you, Jeremy, for understanding, and for tonight. It felt more like a reward than a punishment. I enjoyed myself.” Josh agreed, “Yes, thank you, Jeremy. I enjoyed this night as well. I have one question though; I ran into your mom at the store one day and she was telling me about this girlfriend that you were sharing an apartment with and tonight you licked Elijah’s cum off my chin. How does that square?” I grinned and said, “It’s a long story. Maybe I’ll share it with you some time.” Josh smiled and said, “I ‘m looking forward to it. Anyone up for a shower? My parent’s shower is large enough for all three of us then some.” All three of us then headed for the shower.

 

End of Chapter 15