How I Got My Revenge

Chapter 23

Relief and Trepidation

Once in my bedroom, we dropped our shorts and climbed into bed. We snuggled together side by side and Elijah put his head on my chest and began circling his finger on my abs. It tickled a little bit. I asked him, “So, Josh wanted to sleep with Carl again? I guess he’s taking to him.” Elijah giggled. I asked, “What’s so funny?” Elijah turned his head to me and said, “You are.” Then kissed me on the cheek. I smiled and shook my head and asked, “I noticed the wink he gave you. Why else would he have done that?” Elijah grinned and then kissed me on the lips.  “Can I fuck you after I suck your cock?”

I blinked a few times and smiled at Elijah before responding, “You must be part rabbit.” Elijah giggled and leaned toward me, and we kissed. I was surprised at his aggressiveness as he climbed on top of me as we continued to kiss. He broke the kiss and smiled at me before going to my neck, licking, and kissing it. Suddenly his tongue was licking into my ear and my cock began throbbing, “Holy fuck! Where did you learn that?” Elijah giggled and said, “I don’t know. I just thought you had sexy ears and went for it. Did you like it?” I laughed and said, “Oh yeah, and so did my cock. I think I almost shot my load.” Elijah said, “You better not. I want that fresh from the tap.” I laughed and said, “Josh is right. You’re a pervert. I love it.” Elijah moved down to lick and nibble on my nipples causing me to squirm and then moved down from my chest across my solar plexus to my belly button where he stuck his tongue in and out tickling me. My cock was leaving a puddle of precum on my abs where Elijah soon diverted his attention. He looked at the puddle on my abs and then up to me, “I see you left me an appetizer, yum.” He then began licking the precum from my abs before licking it from the head of my cock, causing it to twitch with excitement. He continued to just lick around the head for a while lapping up the precum which was freely flowing now. Then he moved down to lick my balls. I groaned with pleasure as he looked into my eyes as he took each ball in his mouth and swirled his tongue around it and wetted it with his saliva. Once he released my balls, he continued to lick the sack between them, ensuring he included my taint. He seemed to keep eye contact with me to insure I was enjoying what he was doing. I most definitely was. My whole body jumped as a jolt of electricity shot through me as his tongue ran across my tight ring. Seeing my reaction, he repeated it several times wetting my hole before he began licking upward on my twitching shaft which was so hard by now that it actually ached. Elijah then pulled my cock perpendicular to my body as it strained to snap back against my abs. He began licking around the head as I moaned in pleasure, “Fuck, Elijah! Your gonna make me cum!” I noticed Elijah grin even though he was working the head of my cock with his tongue, and I saw a mischievous twinkle in his eyes. He paused for a few seconds as he stuck several of his fingers in his mouth to wet them. Elijah then took the head of my cock into his mouth as he continued making eye contact with me. I felt a finger pressing at my hole and then it pressed inside. I groaned as my cock flooded out another batch of precum, “Oh, fuuuck”. Elijah moaned his approval on my cock, “Mmmmm.” Elijah added another finger as he bobbed up and down on my cock while swirling his tongue around it. As he added a third finger, I warned him, “Elijah! You’re gonna make me cum! Fuck! I’m cumming!” Elijah didn’t skip a beat as my body spasmed with each was of seed filled his mouth. He continued bobbing and slurping as it did, “Mmmm MMmmm.”  As my orgasm slowly ebbed and Elijah drained the last droplets of cum from my cock, he pulled off me and smiled as I caught my breath.  He moved up my body and leaned down and we kissed. Elijah hadn’t swallowed all of my load as he shared it with me and we snowballed it back and forth until it was gone. We gazed into each other’s eyes as we eventually broke our cum-filled kiss. We smiled at each other and then I said, “Fuck me, Elijah.” His smile widened and he asked, “Could I fuck you on your stomach for a little? I want to see and feel those muscular buns I’ve admired for years, but then I want to fuck you missionary so I can see that handsome face as I fuck you.” I laughed and said, “Flattery like that will get you a piece of ass.” As Elijah got up so I could flip over, I heard him almost whisper to himself, “Actually, I want the whole package.”

I flipped over and opened my legs and waited for Elijah to penetrate me. Instead, he laid on top of me and started sliding his precum-leaking cock between my butt cheeks and started planting kisses on the back of my neck. His cock felt great sliding between my cheeks and his kisses were gentle, but passionate.

Elijah was ecstatic. He’d been checking out Jeremy since jr. high school and had been fantasizing about sliding his cock between those hard, muscular buns since high school. At the time, he equated it to sliding his cock between a pair of girl’s boobs. Nothing gay about that. Jeremy always stayed late though, working out after practice was over, so he rarely saw him in the showers. When he did, he always stayed longer to steal unseen glances at him. On many of those occasions, he also had to eventually face the shower wall to hide his hardening cock. At the time, he had himself convinced it was just normal guy stuff, comparing. Now, he understood his feelings toward Jeremy, and they weren’t just normal, straight guy stuff. He was sexually attracted to him and now that Jeremy had opened himself up to him, he was attracted to him personally. He was falling for him, “Oh, fuck! Shit! Oh my god!” He was so into his thoughts and the feel of his cock smoothly gliding between Jeremy’s hard, muscular orbs that his orgasm had crept up on him and now he couldn’t stop it as his cock shot wad after wad of cum across Jeremy’s back, some in Jeremy’s hair, and even one shot hitting him in his own chin, “Oh,fuck! I’m so sorry, Jeremy! It happened so quick! I’m so sorry.”

I was getting into the feel of Elijah’s cock sliding between my butt cheeks and his kisses and licking my neck were really turning me on. I was looking forward to having him fuck me. The more he continued, the hotter I got. Then suddenly, I felt a warm blast up the center of my back and Elijah was crying out about how sorry he was. He was cumming from just humping me between my buns. I wasn’t sure whether to be amused or disappointed. I glanced back at Elijah, about to kid him about what had just happened, but noticed tears in his eyes and a look of sadness. I felt bad that I was just about to bust his butt, and instead smiled at him and said, “Hey, you almost made me cum from just humping my butt cheeks, so don’t feel bad. Are you still up for fucking me?” My smile widened as his eyes lit up and he said, “Yeah I am.” Then I caught him off guard and asked, “Can I have a taste?” At first, he looked at me, confused by my request. Then it hit him and he turned bright red and nodded as he licked some of his cum from the middle of my back, which sent shivers down my spine, and then leaned forward as we kissed and snowballed his cum back and forth between us until it had been consumed. Elijah’s cock was still fully hard, and he began sliding back and forth between my butt cheeks again, though with his cum lubricating the area between my buns even more than before. Another chill went up my back as Elijah ran his tongue up the center of my back once more but this time, the entire length of my back. I turned back to find his mouth waiting for mine and we snowballed more of his cum. When we broke that kiss, I felt Elijah shift and then the tip of his cock was pressing at my hole. It felt slimy with his precum and cum and slid past my sphincter with little resistance. I drew a sharp breath from the suddenness of it regardless. Elijah asked, “Are you ok? Was I too quick?” I turned back to him and said, “I’m ok, but ease in slowly.” He nodded, then pushed in another inch before stopping. I soon felt him pressed against my buns as he said, “Fuck yes. I love the feel of your firm buns. I could just lay here forever.” I chuckled and said, “That’s not going to happen.” Elijah giggled and said, “I know, right. Are you ready?” I nodded and said, “Fuck me, Elijah.” Elijah then began slowly sawing across my prostate making me moan in pleasure. It felt great as waves of pleasure swept over me as he massaged my prostate as he slowly sped up his pushing and tugging. He was withdrawing almost fully before plunging back inside until he was pressed tightly against my buns as if trying to go deeper each time. I was in heaven, “Ohh, fuuuck. Yessss, that’s the spot. Fucking rake my prostate, Elijah. Fuuuck.” Elijah continued stroking in and out of me while saying softly, “I love your ass, Jeremy. Your hard buns and tight hole feel so fucking good. This is my heaven. You feel so good and taste so good.” He began kissing and licking my shoulders and the back of my neck. It was driving me crazy. My cock was so hard pressing into the bed beneath me as he raked across my prostate again and again. “Fuuuck yeah, Elijah. Fuck me.” I think I grew incoherent at some point as the waves of pleasure kept washing over me. Elijah wasn’t fucking me; he was making love to me. I’m not sure how long we were at it, but he suddenly stopped and slowly withdrew from me, then said, “As much as I love the feel of those awesome buns beneath me, I want you to roll onto your back so we can watch each other as we make love.” I did as he asked and rolled onto my back and pulled my legs up while the words he used were sinking in. He said, “Make love”, and that’s what it felt like and even though in a more rational moment, red flags may have been going off, in this moment, it felt right. It felt perfect. I looked into his eyes as he pushed back inside me and saw the intensity in them. I smiled and he smiled back as he resumed sawing in and out across my prostate once more. He leaned down and we kissed as he continued pumping in and out of me. My own cock, soaked with my precum was sliding across his abdomen as he pistoned in and out of me in a slow rhythm as I moaned against his mouth. He broke the kiss and smiled at me asking, “Are you ready?” I knew what he was asking and said, “Yes! Fuck me, Elijah. Fuck me hard and fast. I want you to breed me!” He began speeding up, slapping against my ass harder and harder. The slapping sounds filled the room as I urged him on, “Yes! Fucking ram me! Fuck me! Harder! Oh god, yes! Fuck yeah!” He reached down and took my cock in his hand and started to pump my cock in rhythm to our fuck, but it only took a few strokes and I was soon bathing us in my cum, “Oh! Fuck!” Elijah started breathing heavier as he said, “Fuck! I’m about to cum! Fuck!” I felt his cock pulsing and his warm cum filling my insides. He was almost jolting with tremors with each blast inside me as sweat ran down his temples. As his cock pumped the last of his seed inside me, he heaved as he caught his breath while looking into my eyes. As his breathing slowed, we smiled at each other and I said, “Thank you. That was amazing.” He replied, “That was fire.” He moved over me and began licking my cum from my abs and upward. When he had finished, I licked my cum from him as well, then we kissed, sharing my cum back and forth until it was all consumed. He remained on top of me, resting his head on my chest and left shoulder. I pulled the sheet over us, and we drifted to sleep. Just before I fell unconscious, I heard Elijah whisper, “I think I’m falling in love with you, Jeremy.”

I woke Sunday morning with Elijah still sleeping on top of me. His steady breath caressing my left nipple. Then I recalled the last words I had heard before I drifted off. A tear ran down my temple and across my left ear. I smelled coffee. Someone was awake. I strained my neck to see the time. It was already after eight. I felt Elijah stirring on top of me and said, “Morning sunshine.” He nuzzled up to my neck and asked groggily, “What time is it?” I replied, “It’s twenty after eight. We need to get in the shower.” He pulled his head up and looked at me, then brought his lips to mine and kissed me before rolling off me and asking, “Can we shower together? We have to head back today.” I said, “Yeah, I know. Yes, together.” We shampooed each other’s hair and soaped up each other’s bodies, caressing the soap into each other’s skin, enjoying each other’s touch, but I was troubled. Elijah sensed something was wrong and asked, “What’s wrong, Jeremy?” I said, “Nothing. Everything is fine. I just got distracted.” As we dried and moved back to my bedroom to get dressed, Elijah said, “Jeremy, I had a really great time this weekend. If it’s ok with you, I’d like to make it a regular thing if that’s ok with you. Even if Josh can’t make it.”  I looked at Elijah, and a tear rolled down my cheek. Elijah looked at me with concern, “What’s wrong, Jeremy? Did I say or do something to upset you? I’m sorry if I did.” I tried to smile and took him by the shoulders and guided him to sit on my bed. I bent down and touched his forehead to mine and sighed. He looked me in the eye, and I saw the sadness of rejection. I smiled and said, “Elijah, I feel it too.” His visage changed to confusion, “Feel what?” I explained, “I heard what you said last night just before falling asleep.” He said, “Oh, then if you feel it too, why do you seem so sad?” I took his hand in mine and said, “Elijah, I’ve come to learn the hard way that long distance relationships don’t work out. I don’t want you to expect that one between us would. I’d still love to have you visit and even would go out with you, but I don’t want you to think we could have a boyfriend kind of relationship.” Elijah looked at me with both disappointment and understanding in his eyes, “This is about your ex-girlfriend, isn’t it?” I sighed and nodded, then said, “I thought we could weather anything. I still miss her, but I don’t regret encouraging her to follow her dreams.” Elijah looked me in the eyes and said, “You’ve got a great heart, Jeremy. That’s just one of the reasons that I find you so attractive. Yes, I said it. I’m not just attracted to your hard, muscular buns or your gorgeous face or your totally hard body.’ He giggled, “I’m also attracted to you, your personality. You submerge yourself into whatever you decide to do, totally, but you also bring others along with you. Unlike what I said I thought about you, you’re the opposite of selfish. You’re generous to a fault. Just look what you did for your ex. Sorry, I guess I shouldn’t bring that up, but it just shows how much you’re willing to sacrifice for others even when it hurts you.” I said, “Elijah! Stop! This is hard enough as it is. I don’t want you to be hurt. I’m open to having you visit whenever you can and I’m even willing to go out with you on dates like dinner and stuff, but without either of us being under the assumption that we’re in a relationship. Is that ok with you?” Elijah smiled and said, “Yes. I understand where you’re coming from. I never had to deal with that situation, and you’ve sacrificed a lot. I’m willing to wait and see, and if things don’t work out between us, I’ll deal with it then.” I smiled and kissed Elijah on his forehead and said, “Thanks for understanding, Elijah.” He smiled back and said, "Broken hearts are hard to heal and worse, thinking it will happen all over again can be worse. I’m going to try to not let that happen.”

Elijah realized that Jeremy’s heart had been broken by his own sacrifice. He swore to himself he would not let that happen again, at least not between them. If anything, he would let him go if it came down to it. It would hurt, badly, but he would take that hurt himself rather than hurt Jeremy again.

They dressed and found both Carl and Josh in the kitchen. Josh had a huge grin on his face. Carl had a smirk on his face as well. As Elijah made eye contact with Josh, Elijah asked, “What?” Josh’s grin grew wider as he picked up his coffee and said, “Nothing” before sipping at his cup. Carl then said, “I boiled some potatoes earlier. They should be cooled off by now so we can have home fries. Jeremy, do you want to get the bacon started?” I said, “Sure. Let me get us a cup of coffee first and I’ll get started.” Elijah asked, “Anything we can do to help?” I replied, “You could set the table.”

After setting the table, Josh and Elijah went in the living room to watch the weather forecast for their trip back, but mostly to stay out of our way as we made breakfast. While we made breakfast, Carl reminded me, “We have to mow the Reynolds’ lawn and other yard work this morning.” I replied, "Yeah I know. It will give Elijah and Josh some alone time which they haven’t had since they’ve been here.” Carl smiled at me and said, “You’re right. Good idea.”  As we were eating breakfast, we let Elijah and Josh know that we had to go over to our landlords’ place and do some yard work. They volunteered to help, but we told them thanks but they should stay here and catch up with each other.

After we had gone, Josh and Elijah caught up on what they’d been up to since Elijah had returned to the university. After that, Josh asked Elijah, “So, you two had a good night.” Elijah asked, “What do you mean?” Josh grinned and said, “Well, it was quiet for most of the night, but all at once you guys were making all kinds of noise. What surprised me was when I heard Jeremy begging you to fuck him harder. I would have thought he’d have been fucking you.” Elijah was bright crimson as he said, “That was the night before”. Josh grinned wider, and said, “Yeah, I know. We heard that too. So, are you and Jeremy gonna be hooking up routinely now?” Elijah said, “We plan on dating, but as far as becoming boyfriends, no.” Josh’s smile faded and he asked, “Why no? What could get in the way of that? I know you really like him, and it seemed like he’s into you as well. Is it because of Carl?” Elijah replied, “No. Apparently Carl is fine with them seeing other people. At least that’s what he told Jeremy. I know he has strong feelings for Jeremy too though. Jeremy still isn’t over his split with his ex-girlfriend and doesn’t want to get into another long-distance relationship which is what caused their split.” Josh said, “So, you went down in flames?” Elijah smiled slightly, “Not exactly. There’s still a chance. He’s up to me visiting and going out on dates, so I’m hoping I can soften him up. I’m going to remain optimistic.” Josh grinned and said, “Thatta boy, Elijah. You never were a quitter. So, now that we’re alone, do you want to catch up on some of the benefits we have as friends?” Elijah grinned and said, “I don’t know, I’m pretty worn out after last night.” Josh’s eyes grew wide as he said, “Really!” Elijah couldn’t hold back his laughter and Josh said, “You fucker!” before tackling him to the floor. They wrestled for a bit until Elijah ended up sitting on Josh holding Josh by his wrists on either side of his head. Josh initially began bucking his hips trying to eject Elijah off him but then started just moving his hips upward in a lewd gesture, grinding his crotch up into Elijah’s ass. Elijah grinned down at Josh and then leaned in for a kiss. Soon they were frantically undressing each other, and once fully naked, they got into a sixty-nine and were soon sucking away on each other’s hard cocks. When Elijah sensed Josh was getting close to cumming, he pulled off his cock, climbed off him, and said, “Fuck me, Josh!” Josh grinned and said, “I was hoping you’d want that.” Elijah got on all fours and Josh climbed behind him. When Josh began poking a finger at his hole, Elijah said, “None of that, Josh. I want you cock in me now.” Josh said, “You got it.” Elijah drew a sharp breath as Josh’s cock broke through his tight ring and then yelped, “Oh! Shit!” as Josh shoved his entire length into him at once. Josh said, “Sorry. I thought you wanted it that way.” Elijah responded by saying, “Shut up and fuck me!” Josh obliged and began fucking him, “Fuck, yeah. I missed fucking your hot, tight ass, Elijah. Take my fuckin’ cock!” Elijah grunted, “Fuck! Fuck! Yes! Fuck me! Fuck! Ahhh! Aahhh! Ohh! Fuck yes! Give me that hard cock, Josh! Harder! Yes! Pound my hole!” Josh was soon rapidly slamming Elijah’s ass and his breathing was becoming ragged. Suddenly he shouted, “Fuck! I’m cumming! I’m gonna breed you ass! Fuckin’ take my cum!” Josh slammed into Elijah hard and deep, and Elijah felt Josh’s cock spasming and felt the pressure as cum was being injected into his rectum. Elijah slowly collapsed down on his stomach, Josh along with him. Both were catching their breath. Eventually, Josh rolled off Elijah after his cock had softened and was ejected from Elijah’s hole. Elijah rolled onto his back as well. They laid there just talking for a while and then Josh climbed up on his knees and said, “I guess I owe you. Let me finish you off.” and then bent down to take Elijah’s still rigid cock in his mouth. Elijah sprung up and said, “Oh, no. You’re gonna take my cock the same way I took yours.” Elijah then pulled Josh up off his knees and led him over to the sofa. Josh was grinning the whole time and his cock was stiff as a steel rod once more. Elijah instructed Josh to bend over the arm of the sofa. Josh bent down and rested his forearms on the arm of the sofa so he was bent at the waist at a ninety degree angle with his legs spread apart. His ass was exposed as Elijah looked on. Josh looked back, grinning and said, “This way we’ll both be taking a little of each other with us when we leave.” Elijah smiled and said, “I like that idea. I’m about to give you enough to last until next time.” Josh said, “You talk a big game. Let’s see you deliver.” Elijah’s smile turned into a huge grin as he said, “I accept the challenge.” Josh said, “Oh shit. What did I just get myself into.” Elijah spit in his palm and then rubbed it on his cock then spit again and worked it into Josh’s hole. Then he slapped his cock across Josh’s buns a few times before lining up and pressing into him. Josh groaned as Elijah entered him, “Fuuuck. Wait! Wait!” Elijah said, “You mean like you did?” Josh put his hand back and said, “I thought you wanted it that way.” Elijah grinned and said, “Sure you did.” Elijah continued but went in slowly until he was pressed tightly against his best friend’s buns. Josh turned back to Elijah and said, “Thanks.” Then then kissed briefly before Josh said, “Now, fuck me, Elijah.” Elijah withdrew almost all the way and then slid back in fully in one smooth stroke. Soon Elijah was smacking into Josh’s cheeks in rhythmic strokes and the sound of skin slapping skin sounded throughout the room, pop, pop, pop.

Carl and I returned from doing the Reynolds’ yardwork and as we approached the house, Carl put his finger to his lips and snuck over to the one kitchen window closest to the doorway to the living room. He couldn’t see anything, but he heard some commotion going on in what sounded like the living room. He came back over to me and let me know. We then quietly went to the back door and slowly opened it and snuck in. As we snuck through the kitchen, we could hear Josh, “Fuck me! Harder! Yeah! Pound my ass, Elijah! Harder! Fuck! Fuck yes! Give me that fuckin’ cock! Jam it in me!’ Then Elijah’s voice, “Yeah, I’m going to send you home full of my seed! I’m getting close. Are you ready for me to breed you?” We quietly stepped into the living room. Josh was bent over the arm of the chair and Elijah was drilling him from behind. Their backs were to us, so they had no idea they had an audience. Josh continued, “Fuckin’ breed me, Elijah! Fuck me! Pound it into me! Oh fuck! Oh fuck, I’m gonna cum! You’re fuckin’ the cum outa me!” We watched as cum began to shoot in wad after wad from Josh’s untouched stiff rod as it bounced in rhythm to Elijah’s thrusts. Then Elijah cried out, “Fuck, Josh! Your hole milking the cum out of me! I’m gonna cum! Breeding your hole! Fuck!” They both seemed to tremble with the surges of their climax and slowly, Elijah sank down onto Josh’s back for support as they caught their breath. The show was over, and I couldn’t resist. I began clapping. They both almost jumped out of their skin as Elijah pulled out of and away from Josh to turn around and look our way. His face was bright red, and his mouth was hanging open. Josh had turned and had a similar look on his face as I began laughing. Josh said, “You scared the shit out of us!” I replied, “No, I’m pretty sure that was cum.” Just then both Elijah’s and Josh’s phones dinged. They picked them up and looked and suddenly they both had shocked looks on their faces once more. Carl then said from behind me, “That will give you both something to remember from you visit here and maybe something to jerk off to on lonely nights.” I turned and looked at Carl wondering what he’d sent them, and he grinned. Elijah then said, “He was recording us just now.” I grinned and said, “No shit.!” Carl said, “I couldn’t resist. Besides, now they have something to watch when they’re apart and miss each other.” Josh played it back on his phone and said, “Thanks, I think.” Carl said, “Don’t worry, I’ll erase my copy after Jeremy and I watch it again tonight.”

We had lunch and hung out for a few hours before Elijah and Josh had to head out. I made sure they had all the clothes they had brought with them. We each kissed them both before they left. Elijah and I both had tears in our eyes as we finished kissing. I squeezed his buns one las time before he stepped out through the door. We walked them to their cars and saw them off. They were to call us when they arrived at their destinations. I continued smiling, but my heart ached a little. Had Elijah gotten to me? We did watch the video of Elijah and Josh while we were in bed that night. We jerked each other off as we watched it.

Monday, I had lunch again with Chris. He asked about Elijah and Josh and said he liked them and looked forward to seeing them on the court again. He asked if they would be returning this weekend. I told him they wouldn’t, but possibly the following one. Then he asked, “What are you doing Friday night?" I said, “I don’t have any specific plans. Why?” He said, "I got great tickets to Avenged Sevenfold if you’d like to go.” I said, “Really? I love their music! I’d love to go.” He said, “It’s a date then?” I wasn’t entirely sure how he had meant that but said, “Sure.” He grinned and said, “I was hoping you’d go with me. See you Thursday for lunch then?” I said, “Of course. See you Thursday.” We then went back to the campus and went to our respective classes as I thought about what he’d said, “It’s a date then?” I smiled and thought, “Yeah, whether it’s just two friends going to a concert or two guys getting to know each other, it’s a date.

End of Chapter 23