How I Got My Revenge

Chapter 35

Need I Choose?

As we sat around making small talk, Carl asked, “So, what did you guys do this afternoon?” Suddenly, I felt both Chris’ and Elijah’s eyes on me, waiting for the answer I was going to give. I smiled and said, “After breakfast, we came back here and hung out.” Chris and Elijah both turned crimson when Carl said, “Hung out as in letting it all hang out? I saw that the cover on the sofa was changed.” I couldn’t keep a straight face and had already told Carl we had a little fun this afternoon. Then Carl asked the question, “So, is anyone interested in having a little more fun? I have some time before I have to go to bed.” I looked over at Elijah and then at Chris. They were both looking toward me and then they turned to look at each other. They both smiled and Elijah said to Chris, “I’m game if you are.” Chris turned back to me, I smiled and shrugged. Chris then said, “Sounds like fun. I’ve never been in a foursome before.” Elijah said, “I have been, once. That was when Josh and I visited a few weeks ago. That is unless you count, uh, never mind.” Carl said, “Why don’t we go inside?”

We arrived in the living room and Carl had Elijah help him with the coffee table. I saw Elijah about to pull off his T-shirt and said, “Elijah, wait! Let’s make this a little more interesting. Why don’t we get a deck of cards out.” Carl said, “A game of strip poker might take too long.” I said, “I’m not talking about playing a game of strip poker but making it more fun as we undress.” That got everyone’s attention. I continued, “We each pick a card from the deck. High card removes a piece of clothing from the low card. The second highest card removes a piece of clothing from the second lowest card until everyone is naked. We can go from there.” Carl said, “That should go pretty quickly.” We had fun with that. As one of us was undressing another, the other two were catcalling and cheering them on. It went pretty quickly until we were all naked except Chris. Elijah was to remove his briefs and Carl and I insisted that he do it hands free. Elijah didn’t protest. Chris turned bright red as we cheered Elijah on as he began using his teeth, trying to grasp the waistband of Chris’ tight briefs. Chris yelled, “Hey! Watch the teeth!” The only spot on the waistband of Chris’ briefs that had a gap between the waistband and Chris’ skin was where the head of his stiffening cock was pulling it away. Carl and I were both leaking precum as we watched the sexy show. As we looked on, Elijah finally had the waistband of Chris’ briefs in his mouth, and he began slowly working them down. As he did, Chris’ cock sprang against his cheek and remained pressed against Elijah’s face as he struggled to get Chris’ briefs over his hips. Eventually, Elijah moved to different areas where the waistband was exposed to pull the briefs down. He even ended up with his nose between Chris’ firm butt cheeks while getting the briefs over Chris’ buns, then he returned to the front until finally they were around Chris’ ankles. As Chris stood there with a red face and a deep dimpled smile, Elijah stood up and took a bow as Carl and I cheered.

Since Elijah and Chris had been the last to lose their clothes, we had them step in front of Carl and me. We were sitting side by side on the sofa. By the order of how the game went, Elijah stepped in front of me and Chris in front of Carl. I licked Elijah’s cock from base to tip as I held his balls with my left hand. My right hand found its way to cup and massage Elijah’s hard, left butt cheek. I glanced to my left and saw Carl licking the head of Chris’ cock before taking it into his mouth. I glanced up at Chris and saw his head tilted slightly forward and his eyes closed. As I took Elijah’s cock in my mouth, I looked up at him to see him smiling down at me. He put his hands on my head and began running his fingers through my hair as he said, “That feels good, Jeremy.” After a few minutes, Carl suggested, “Let’s move to the floor.” Carl had Elijah and Chris lie on the floor with their heads next to the other’s crotch and about two feet apart. Carl then crawled across Elijah’s head with his stiff cock over Elijah’s face and resumed sucking Chris’ cock. I then fed Chris my cock while taking Elijah’s cock back in my mouth. We were basically in a square, four-way sixty-nine.  The sounds of moaning and mouths slurping on cocks filled the room. I soon began probing Elijah’s pucker with a wet finger. His moans grew louder on Carl’s cock. After a minute of this, I felt a finger pushing into my own hole. Apparently, this had prompted each of the others to follow my lead. Suddenly, Carl pulled off Chris’ cock and pulled his own from Elijah’s mouth. He said, “I was getting close, and you guys probably are too. I think it’s time for some fucking.” I got up as well, and then asked, “So, who’s fucking whom?” Elijah spoke up, “Chris fucked me this afternoon, so if he’s ok with it, I’d like to fuck him.” Before Chris could respond, Carl said, “I was hoping to fuck you, Elijah.” Carl looked to me to see if I was going to object. I smiled and shrugged. Chris then said, “I’d be ok with you fucking me, but how would that work with Carl wanting to fuck you?” Elijah said, “The same as this afternoon. We chain fuck. You climb on your back, and I fuck you missionary. Carl can take me doggy.” Carl then asked, “What about Jeremy?” I grinned and said, “I guess I’ll be the caboose on this train and fuck you, Carl.” Carl smiled and suggested, “Let’s move this to a bed. My room or yours.”

We ended up in my room which is a little larger. I noticed Chris glance my way a few times on the way. He looked nervous. I wasn’t sure why, especially after this afternoon. He climbed onto my bed on his back as Elijah slid a condom over his cock. Carl whispered into my ear, “Are you ok with this?” I nodded and smiled at him. After lubing Chris’ hole up with his fingers, Elijah lubed up his condom-sheathed cock and pressed it against Chris’ tight pucker. I stepped over to Chris, bent down and kissed him as Elijah slowly sank inside his tight passage. Chris groaned into my mouth as Elijah entered him and eventually bottomed out inside him. I broke the kiss with Chris, and he looked up at me smiling, looking more at ease. Then his face grew more serious as Elijah slowly tugged outward before sliding back inside, beginning a slow fuck. I glance at Elijah and saw a huge smile as he slowly pistoned in and out of Chris. Then I noticed Carl getting ready. He had already donned a condom and was applying some lube. Once he had lubed up his rigid cock, he began fingering Elijah’s hole. Elijah grunted, “Uhhh! Yeah, get me ready for that big cock, Carl.” Carl smiled as he added a second finger, mostly just holding his hand still and allowing Elijah to move onto the fingers as he tugged outward from Chris’ tight hole. Carl wiped the excess lube from his fingers and then moved up behind Elijah. When Elijah felt Carl getting ready to penetrate him, he sank into Chris and waited. Carl then pressed the head of his steely rod at the entrance to Elijah’s love tunnel and slowly sank inside him. Once he bottomed out in Elijah, he pulled Elijah up by his chest. Elijah turned his head and they kissed briefly. Then Elijah began moving his hips back and forth, fucking Chris and Fucking himself on Carl’s cock at the same time. Elijah said, “Fuck yeah! This is hot!” Carl groaned, “Yeah! Fuck yourself with my cock, Elijah! Give it to Chris!” Meanwhile, I was sliding a condom over my stiff rod to prepare to fuck Carl’s tight ass. After fingering Carl’s tight hole for a while, I began inserting my cock inside him. The three of them were moaning and groaning as Elijah fucked both Chris and himself. I was soon tightly pressed against Carl’s firm buns. He turned his head smiling, and we kissed as I began fucking him. We must have resembled a well-oiled machine as Chris laid there taking Elijah’s cock as he moved his hips back and forth while at the same time impaling himself on Carl’s cock while I pistoned my cock in and out of Carl’s tight hole. As Elijah was fucking Chris, he noticed Chris’ throbbing cock and reached for it. Chris blocked his hand and said, “No I’m not ready to cum yet.” Elijah said, “I’m getting close, dude. I wanted you to cum too.” Chris, through grunts and pleasure moans, said, “It’s ok. Cum for me. Cum on me!” Chris’ encouragement brought Elijah to the edge and Carl’s cock hitting his prostate continuously brought him over it. He pulled out of Chris quickly and almost shot his load right then and there. When he quickly pulled back, he impaled himself fully on Carl’s cock and it was a direct hit on his prostate. He was able to get the condom off though, but then his cock unleashed rope after rope of cum blasting through the air. The first shot went over Chris’ head. The next landed on his forehead. Another hit his chin. The rest landed on his abs and crotch as Elijah’s chest heaved as he tried to catch his breath as Carl remained planted fully inside him. Carl then began moving in and out of Elijah, allowing me to remain in place as Carl moved onto my cock as he tugged out of Elijah. Suddenly, Chris rolled off the bed and grabbed a condom and the lube. He then climbed up on the bed behind me and I realized what he was up to. I soon found myself sandwiched between Carl and Chris as Chris began fucking me slowly as Carl was moving his hips back and forth fucking into Elijah, and then impaling himself back onto my stiff rod. I glanced back at Chris. He was grinning and then said, “Surprise.”, before kissing me. I fed him my tongue as I smiled around our kiss. I felt Carl’s movements start to get erratic shortly before he claimed, “I’m just about there. Elijah, pull off me. I’m gonna cum.” Elijah slowly eased off of Carl’s cock. As Carl pulled off the condom, Elijah swung around and onto his back with his head just under Carl’s cock. He said, “Cum on me, Carl. Cum all over my face!” I took over the fucking as I slammed forward into Carl and then shoved back onto Chris’ cock. I heard Carl yell, “Fuuuuck!” and then his anus was clamping around my cock in spasms as ropes of his cum began painting Elijah’s face and chest. Chris was enjoying me fucking myself on his cock, “Fuck yeah, Jeremy. Take my cock! Fuck yourself good while you fuck Carl!” While I continued to fuck Carl, he bent down a pushed his cummy cock into Elijah’s mouth while taking Elijah’s semi-hard cock in his own mouth. As soon as Elijah felt Carl’s cock touch his lips, he immediately sucked it into his mouth, cleaning the residual cum from it and trying to drain anything left from him. I soon felt my own orgasm surging up from my balls and said, “I’m getting ready to cum!” Carl extracted himself from my cock and quickly flipped onto his back next to a cum-painted Elijah who still had his eyes closed because of cum on the lids. I pulled off my condom and moved forward so I was at the top of Carl and Elijah’s heads. Chris had moved forward with me to keep his cock in me while he continued to fuck me as I groaned loudly. Then my cum surged out blasting bot Carl and Elijah’s faces and chests with my creamy seed. They both held their mouths open to receive it. As my chest heaved, Chris suddenly pulled his cock from me and announced, “Oh, fuck! I’m getting ready to shoot!” I hurried to flip onto my back beneath Chris’ legs so that my head wad between and opposite Carl and Elijah’s. Elijah moved up with his knees straddling my chest so his cock head was even with my chin. Then he yelled, “Fuuuck!” I closed my eyes and opened my mouth as his seed blasted across my face and hair as well as hitting Carl and Elijah’s hair and faces. I heard Chris chuckle and then felt his tongue licking the cum from my eyelids. I then opened my eyes to see Chris’ dimpled smile looking down at me. I kissed him, sharing my cum as well as the drip on his chin from Elijah which I licked from him. The I got up and Chris and I began licking the cum from Elijah and Carl. We ended up in a four-way kiss, swapping the cum from the four of us. Elijah and Carl soon got up on their knees like Chris and I were, and we continued our four-way kiss while our hardening cocks joined in a four-way sword fight. All four of us were grinning happily. Carl then said, “I wish I had time for more, but I need to rinse off and get to bed.” I smiled and said, “If you want, while you rinse off, I’ll make you another drink and you can join us out back for a nightcap before you go to bed.” Carl kissed me and said, “That would be great. Thanks, Jeremy.” I kissed him back and said, "My pleasure, Carl.” As Carl went to get in the shower, I said, “I’m going to make us some drinks. Do you want to rinse that cum out of your hair, Elijah?” Elijah grinned and said, “I don’t mind a little cum in my hair if you don’t. Let’s head out back and get a fire going.” I grinned and said, “I didn’t know I had cum in my hair but fuck it.”

Elijah assisted me making the drinks while Chris went out to get the fire going. Just as I was about to pick up two of the drinks, Elijah said, “Thanks, Jeremy.” I turned to him and asked, “For what?” He quickly leaned in and kissed me and then said, “For last night and today. You know, I think I like Chris. He’s really a nice guy, and those dimples are hot. They’re different than Josh’s. I always thought Josh’s dimples were cute. Chris’ are hot.” I smiled and said, “You’re making me jealous.” Elijah kissed me again and said, "Don’t be. I still want you.” I gave him a half smile and said, “I really like you too, Elijah, but you know what I told you.” Elijah nodded, “Yeah, I know. Long distance relationships don’t work. I disagree, and I’m going to try my hardest to prove you wrong.” I couldn’t help but smile, seeing the seriousness written on his face. This guy really did like me, and I liked him. Unfortunately, I liked Chris too. Fuck! Here I go again. I decided to relax and not get stressed out about it. I needed to just go with things, and see where they went, as Carl had advised. I quickly kissed Elijah, and then picked up the two drinks and said, “Ok, let’s go out back.” Elijah picked up the other two drinks and followed me.

Chris already had some logs on the fire and the flames were building. Elijah said, “Way to go, Chris! Fire starter!” Chris’ dimples came out and his face was a bit red, though it could have been from the heat from the fire. A few minutes later, Carl walked out in a pair of skimpy shorts. He sat down and I handed him his drink. Carl then said, “I think that was some of the hottest sex I’ve ever been involved with, at least with more than just two people.” Elijah asked, “What do you mean by that?” Carl looked at me for a few seconds, then turned to Elijah and replied, “Well, it’s more intimate when it’s just between two people.” Elijah and Chris both looked my way as Elijah said, “True.” Chris said, “Good point.” I just nodded my head. From they way all three looked at me, I had a feeling Carl’s remark was aimed at me. It made me feel good inside but I still felt conflicted. Elijah changed the subject, “So, are we playing ball on Saturday?” I said, “Sure. I want to ask the guys what they do once it’s cold out or even if it rains or snows. So far we’ve been lucky.” Elijah said, “I wonder if they’d be interested in a game of football. I know there’s only ten to twelve of us but that’s plenty.” Chris said, “I’d be up for that.” Carl said, “That could be risky without helmets.” I suggested, “We could make it flag football. I’m sure a set of flags aren’t that expensive.” Chris said, “Let’s talk to the guys on Saturday. I wonder if Chuck and Jesse will be there.” Carl said, “I’m sure Chuck will be. Jesse works the same hours so I would think so. Well, it’s getting late. I’m going in to bed. Good night, guys.” We all replied, “Good night, Carl.” Chris said, “I guess I should be heading home and let you guys get ready for bed too.” As Chris turned to take his empty glass into the house, Elijah pointed at his drink and then made a steering motion. I knew what he meant and I called to Chris, “Hey, Chris. You’ve had several drinks. Why don’t you just crash here tonight?" Chris said, “I don’t want to impose. I could call an uber.” Elijah caught me off guard and said, “Then you’d have to come back in the morning to get your car anyway. Besides, there’s room enough for three in Jeremy’s bed. I turned to see Elijah grinning at me. I smiled and nodded, “Elijah’s right. The three of us can fit in my bed. There’s no need for you to leave.” Chris smiled and said, “In that case, does anyone need a refill?” Elijah and I both finished our drinks and handed Chris our empty glasses. After he went into the house, I turned to Elijah and said, “I’m surprised you wanted Chris to stay.” Elijah grinned and said, “Yeah, half of me was glad he was going to leave so I could have you all to myself, but the other half didn’t want him to drive and making him take an uber home seemed wrong to me. I like Chris even though we both want the same guy.”

Chris returned with our refills, and we joked around for a while. Chris then asked, “Do you guys have any plans for tomorrow?” Elijah and I looked to each other, and both shrugged. I said, “Not really, why?” Chris said, “Want to have breakfast and then play some golf or chip and putt?” Elijah said, “I haven’t played golf since I was twelve and it was miniature golf.” I said, “Ok, maybe chip and putt would be better then. I don’t want to spend all day trying to find slices.” We all laughed and then Elijah reached over and grabbed my crotch and said, “I don’t know, I’m pretty good with balls.” Chris and I laughed. Then Chris moved onto his knees in front of me and said, “I’m pretty good with them too.” He then bent down and began mouthing my balls through my shorts and Elijah leaned down and began kissing me. Before long, Chris had my shorts around my ankles and was slurping away on my steely hard shaft. I pulled Elijah’s shorts down and took his cock into my mouth. After a few minutes, it dawned on me that we were outside, and someone could look over our fence and see what was going on. I suggested, “Let’s take this into my bedroom.” Once we were in the bedroom, it turned to fucking. I fucked Chris missionary while Elijah fucked me doggy, or rather I fucked myself on Elijah’s cock. After cumming all over himself, Elijah and I both bathed Chris in our seed as well. After we caught our breath, Elijah and I went to work cleaning up the baby batter and then feeding it back and forth between the three of us. We then showered before climbing into bed for the night with Elijah on my right and Chris on my left. They both fell asleep with their heads on my chest and their hands linked together on my abs. I had an arm around each of them. I thought of how much I adored them both and felt so good having them on either side of me. I felt their breath on my chest as I fell into a peaceful sleep.

I was standing in a church. A minister was asking Chris if he took this man as his lawfully wedded husband. He smiled and said, “I do.” The minister then asked Elijah if he took this man to be his lawfully wedded husband. Elijah smiled and said, “I do.” I wasn’t upset with what was transpiring at all. I was happy as the minister then asked me if I took these men to be my lawfully wedded husbands, and I replied with a huge smile, “I do.” The minister then said, “I now pronounce the three of you, husbands.”

I woke up with a smile on my face and chuckled to myself at the ridiculousness of it all. Then looked down at the two heads on my chest and thought, ‘if only.’ I felt Elijah stir and then Chris did as well. Then they kissed each other before turning their heads to me and we shared a three-way kiss. We eventually climbed out of bed after we smelled coffee.

Carl laughed as we walked into the kitchen and said, “Looks like you all should have stayed in bed for a while longer.” At first, I took it to mean we all looked half asleep until I saw the tents in Elijah and Chris’ underwear. I didn’t need to look down to realize I was tenting too. We all laughed at the situation and Carl said, “You guys can take care of those after I leave for work, although I wish I could join you. I walked over and kissed him and replied, “Maybe we’ll wait until later after you get back from work.” Carl laughed and said, “I know better than to think you’ll be able to hold off that long, but I’m sure you’ll recover by the time I get back. Carl finished his coffee and gave us each a kiss before leaving for work. We had a great breakfast of Ham, eggs and home fries with toast and a side of bacon, along with strawberries and cantaloupe slices. Then we had a creamy, fresh dessert fresh from three willing contributors and shared between all three of us.

The three of us then went to a chip and putt course and had a blast. It was obvious that Chris had played golf before as he kicked our asses throughout the game. Elijah, on the other hand, was terrible at it as far as the chipping was concerned. He did better once he was on the green. Either way, we had a lot of fun. It was hilarious when Elijah challenged Chris to another round, knowing the outcome would be the same. Nevertheless, we played anyway. We were having too much fun. The second round was pretty much the same as the first, but Elijah didn’t spend as much time searching for his ball. Elijah and I both did better with Elijah only ending up four strokes higher than me. I won’t say how far behind Chris we were, but we had improved by ten strokes over the first game. Elijah wanted to go a third round, but it was past lunchtime, so we decided to head for lunch instead. We stopped for pizza and then headed home.

When we got back to the house, I prepared a meatloaf right away, so it was ready to be put in the oven for dinner. We then took the football out back and passed it around for a while. We then got into a game where one of us played quarterback, one played receiver and the third played corner/safety. We had a blast. I was impressed that Chris held his own given the fact that he had played soccer rather than football in high school. Although he wasn’t a great quarterback, he could catch the ball and defended very well, although there could have been quite a few pass interference calls, lol. All three of us were filthy. Yes, we were playing tackle. We apparently had lost track of time. I was currently the quarterback; Elijah was the receiver and Chris was on defense. We started the play and out of the corner of my eye, I saw Carl put up his hand. I threw a pass that looked like it was intended for Elijah, but I had intentionally hung it in the air. Both Elijah and Chris were caught off guard as Carl ran in, jumped up and intercepted the ball and ran it back. The look on Elijah and Chris’ faces was priceless. Carl and I were rolling. Chris and Elijah soon were walking back toward the house with grins on their faces, knowing they’d been had. I gave Carl a quick kiss and then went in to preheat the oven. Carl stayed out back. As Elijah and Chris reached Carl, he asked, “Have a good day?” They proceeded to tell him about golfing, lunch and playing with the football. Carl looked at them curiously and asked, “I can see you were playing hard, but you seriously didn’t play around all day? I heard that as I had returned from the house, and said, “I told you, we were going to save it for you.” He looked at me and I could tell he didn’t believe me. I confessed, “Ok, we were having so much fun, we never got to it.” Elijah and Chris both grinned and nodded, agreeing with what I’d said. Carl smiled as he looked at our muddy state, smiled, and asked, “So, how long will dinner take? You guys look pretty dirty to me.”

 

End of Chapter 35