Gay Catfishing Stories

GayDemon's Stories: On this page you can find erotic fiction where you can read about catfishing male victims lured into gay sexual relationships.

Straight married dad catfished and exposed (ch. 3)

By Justdance 28 Mar 2026

Levi,a friend of Jeff’s son,has a crush on him. Spies on Jeff and finds out about Jeff’s baited videos and tricks Jeff into a night in a hotel he will never forget. Jeff soon finds himself unknowingly being a rentboy for gays.

8.8 (24) 1613 8 Min Comments

Baiting The Jocks

By grey 20 Apr 2025

A university’s hockey star is lured into the online world of a gay forum that wants to bait him.

8.8 (89) 5584 7 Min Comments

Straight Jock Catfished (ch. 7)

By grey 11 Jun 2024

Despite his straight jock best friend continuously getting exploited on the internet, all Mike could do was watch. He liked seeing Caleb’s beefy body on display all the time.

9.3 (59) 9219 4 Min Comments

Nate's Surprise

By DickDork 2 Jun 2024

Nate goes to the bath house, fully expecting to meet up with a mystery man off of Grindr...and gets far more than he bargained for, and far more men than he'd anticipated.

9.2 (79) 7647 16 Min Comments

Bait and Switch (ch. 4)

By Dominic Cooper 6 Dec 2023

Struggling star college footballer Asher has made the ultimate deal with the cruel Dom, Henry: become his sex slave in exchange for Henry improving his football skills. But when Henry's first demand is to put Asher in chastity, Asher refuses. Will Asher learn to obey his new Master, and how much exactly has he gotten himself into?

9.7 (86) 9804 15 Min Comments

Bait and Switch (ch. 3)

By Dominic Cooper 27 Nov 2023

After gorgeous but cocky college football star Asher rudely rejected the Dom Henry for not being hot enough, Henry has finally got his revenge. Henry has Asher bound and naked with his cum forced down his throat. Will Asher be able to get out from Henry's grasp - or does some sick part of him want this?

9.6 (88) 9453 18 Min Comments

Straight Jock Catfished (ch. 6)

By grey 12 Jul 2023

Straight jock has finally found a new purpose in life.

9.2 (75) 13152 4 Min Comments

Straight Jock Catfished (ch. 5)

By grey 16 Jun 2023

Straight Jock Caleb’s first official sex tape.

9.6 (86) 16311 5 Min Comments

Straight Jock Catfished (ch. 4)

By grey 24 Apr 2023

Straight jock Caleb is used by a stranger who kidnapped him after discovering him on a NSFW page.

9.4 (118) 18634 4 Min Comments

Straight Jock Catfished (ch. 3)

By grey 19 Apr 2023

Straight jock caleb is continuously tricked into selling nudes for a NSFW page

9.5 (110) 16846 7 Min Comments

Straight Jock Catfished (ch. 2)

By grey 16 Apr 2023

A gay man uses and catfishes straight boy Caleb for more views.

9.3 (114) 16628 5 Min Comments

Straight Jock Catfished

By grey 15 Apr 2023

A gay man tricks straight boy caleb into sending nudes for his NSFW account.

9.3 (138) 26188 5 Min Comments

Andy and Sebastian (ch. 2)

By Blegosi 22 Jun 2021

After being catfished in an online chatroom, Andy finds himself having been kidnapped and brought to an unfamiliar and now glaringly unwelcoming place. It's his second day in captivity, the first having been spent in a short but incredibly painful introduction to his new life as a slave. Today he'll be tortured by having his hair electrocuted off of his body...

8.8 (40) 7767 8 Min Comments

Andy and Sebastian

By Blegosi 21 Jun 2021

Andy, after being catfished in an online chatroom, finds himself kidnapped and in an unfamiliar space. His captor introduces himself as his master and starts to get him adjusted to his new life as a slave. The introduction to an ongoing series with new drama and torment in each chapter.

8.7 (50) 16797 16 Min Comments

Danger of a Stranger

By Danny Galen Cooper 2 Jan 2021

Stella Parton, Dolly’s sister, sang about the Danger of a Stranger that you meet in the dark. That stranger ran off with her heart. Jason’s stranger is a little different.

8.2 (41) 1517 9 Min Comments

Catfish

By Ralphe Brandon 13 Jul 2020

Alexander Prescott was so angry that he'd arranged to meet the person he saw impersonating him on a dating app. Little did he know that that meeting would change his life forever.

9.3 (140) 8846 7 Min Comments

Work Slave

By Gowl 3 Nov 2019

My manager at a cabinet factory has me work late to learn a new machine, or so I thought... I am captured and trained inside the place I once worked.

8.4 (41) 7983 8 Min Comments

Catfishing gone wrong

By Tim Bagging 19 Nov 2017

Steve has a run in with a open catfish online, after the 'lady' confesses to be a man, they decide to go along with the lie and it gets him into a lot of trouble. (Disclaimer: This was written whilst quiet drunk, I have checked it over but it came out as a lot of pages. Its very story heavy and flits between texts and conversations )

8.4 (17) 3941 17 Min Comments

Daddy's New Bitch

By brandonnsd 22 Jan 2014

Story of me finally meeting my longtime online chat friend and how I became Daddy's Bitch!

8.8 (81) 17308 12 Min Comments