Straight Jock Catfished

“Hey beautiful.” He sent me with a picture of his wet tanned body wrapped up in a thick towel. If only he dropped it.

”Hey stud. I’m so horny.”

“Same!” He sent me a picture of his delicious wet naked body. 

“Oh jerk off for me!! Then spread your cheeks and show me!” 

“Okay…” He then sent me a video of him jerking off and then spreading his cheeks. Of course I had to screen record it. 

“Now suck on your fingers and stick it in your asshold you hot jock!”

”No!!! I am NOT gay!” He replied back.

”I know you’re not gay, but do it for me! I’ll send you a pic.”

Without a doubt, the dumb hunk sent me a video of him sucking on his fingers and putting one in his tight virgin hole. He then started to fuck himself while caressing his dick. Soon, he cummed buckets moaning loudly into the camera. “Ughhhh. ughhhh…” He quickly pulled his finger out of his hole and ended the video.

”Don’t wipe your cum off just yet! I want to see you wipe it all over your pecs and abs and leave if there!” 

Soon he sent me a video following my instructions. I then went to my viral NSFW account with now hundreds of thousands of gay guys liking and commenting on my previous posts about Caleb. I then posted.

Straight boy Caleb fingering his tight virgin hole and spreading his cum on his torso! Like and follow to see more!

Now I understand that I am his best friend, but from the beginning my first intentions were to explore this man’s hot beefy body like the piece of meat he is! At school, I was the type of person who wasn’t popular but well-known. Everyone knew me as, “the one who plays basketball” while they genuinely know Caleb and want to know him. I guess I have been left in the shadows while he got all of the attention! I mean who can blame him, he’s unknowingly getting a ton of attention from gay men around the world because of his body. I went to my NSFW page to see that many people already commented.

”So he is willing to explore his ass! Please make him put dildos and plugs in there!”

”Are you willing to sell HIM? I’ll do anything for that hot body.”

But there was one comment that was weirdly eerie.

”Caleb Michaels. He lives in the United States. I have been watching him..” 

What the fuck? I quickly deleted that comment. How did someone find him? What do they mean watching him?

Now is the part of the story where I did something absolutely stupid that’ll backfire later. I continued to post Caleb. I know, I know, someone really knows who and where Caleb is. But I was getting famous! I never got this much attention, and Caleb will never find out. He’s not gay. He’s not friends with anyone who is gay. So who’s going to show him? Nobody. I sent Caleb a package that night. I put no return address on so he didn’t know where it came from. It was a box of toys. A red 4 inch dildo, a blue 5 inch dildo, and a 7 inch black dildo. I also bought him a butt plug! And a note. It read: It’s Makayla, I know I know.. you’re not gay! But you’re soooo hot and it makes me so happy when you snap me! So I would love to watch you try these out.

The package came two days later. He opened it with shock.

”How did you know my address?” He texted me. Shit. I didn’t think that through.

”You told me silly!! Don’t your remember we exchanged addresses?” 

“Oh yeah! Sorry, I must have forgot.” Damn, he was dumb enough to fall for that! That night Caleb sent me a video. He was trying to push the red dildo in. I started to screen record.

”Oh fuck! Babe.. it’s too big! I think I have to put lube in it.” He generously lubed the toy up while fitting it into his tight hair asshole. He then got it all the way through. He started to fuck himself with it. He looked of pleasure. Like he was surprised that it felt so good. He started moaning with that deep sexy voice of his. I cant believe Caleb Michaels had a dick in his ass before I did, even if it was artificial. He started pushing it in and pulling it out repetitive, making it fuck him. He was fucking himself like a faggot. “ohhhh…. OHHHHH,” He then shot out 7 squirts of cum hands free. He’ll be getting used to this lifestyle. The video ended. I sent him another picture of my blonde personas tits. I went to my account.

Straight jock Caleb fucking his tight hole with a 4 inch dildo for the first time.

It was the next day. This has become the most liked post I had ever uploaded. Caleb texted me.

”Hey Mike.. do you wanna hang out?”

”Sure! Let’s have lunch at the park.” It was the weekend and in my town the park was a hot spot for all teens. I then went to snapchat as my blonde persona and texted him.

”I want you to wear the butt plug for the rest of the day. And send proof every hour that you have it in you.” He obeyed. What he didn’t know is that I could control whether it vibrates or not.

I walked into the park seeing Caleb. He didn’t see me. So I went to the app for the butt plug and set it to its max level. I saw caleb instantly drop his phone and start to moan and shiver. People began to look at him. What was his deal? He then started to bite his lip and adjust his pants trying not to make a fool of himself. His gray sweatpants showed off his huge bulge. I walked over to him.

”Whatsup bro!”

”Haa… ughh… hey!”

”You good??”

”YeAAHHH yeah!” He then started to breathe heavier until he started to grunt. His face looked like he just climaxed. He then felt a second of relief before realizing his ass was still vibrating. Did it hit his g-spot? Did he just cum right in front of me? In public? 

I discreetly watched him and looked over his pants while we were eating lunch. He made little noises here and there. He was sweating. While we sat at a picnic table I noticed how hard he was focusing on trying to not make a scene, and I felt empathetic so I mostly talked. After an hour, he told me he had to head back.

My blonde persona then got a message from him.

”What the fuck? The stupid butt thing was vibrating into my ass! I was with friends! I’m taking it off!”

”It vibrated? Oh I didn’t know! I’m so sorry. I’m guessing you didn’t like it.”

”I’m sorry if I seem mad! It’s not your fault, I was just caught off guard.” I sent him a picture of Makayla in a push up bra making her look extra snatched. I felt kinda bad that he made such a scene in public. A lot of people from our school were glancing over at him. I kinda got a little embarrassed, but also a little aroused. 

Late at night, I was scrolling through the erotic website I use for my NSFW account. A lot of decent looking boys showing off their average cock. Then I found a familiar face. 

Straight boy Caleb fucking a gay guy! I lured him into my condo posing as a girl, and now I HAVE HIM! Prepare for tons of content. After he’s done fucking me, I’m going to make him fuck into a pump for hours so I can sell many of his cum for many of you. I will also put tit pumps on his fat jiggly breasts in hopes to get milk from there! Find updates on this account daily on him, it’s going to be a long weekend! And after i’m done with him, i’m going to stuff his big cock in a chastity cage. Or should I not let him go out into the world after this weekend? Should I keep him as my personal fucktoy? His cock is mine and only mine. Sorry to the original page who was baiting him. Your days are over! 

WHAT THE FUCK!?!?!??!?! I watched the 10 minute video. It started off as Caleb walking into the apartment and forced to wear a blindfold. He was then tied up and his blindfold was released. The man using him was old and fat. FUCK!! CALEB! HES TRAPPED! The old man licked caleb’s body and sucked on his dick. Caleb was mortified! Then the video cut to Caleb fucking the old man with the old man tugging on his gold chain. A few minutes later Caleb came into the man. The old man then flipped Caleb onto his stomach and started devouring his ass. The video ended.

I was upset and shocked. What did the old man say for Caleb to fuck him? Caleb was a strong guy! I thought he could handle himself! What happened! I went too far! Now my best friend is trapped! The account updated. It was a livestream. FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK. WHATS HAPPENING???? I clicked on it.

---

Hi all! I’m sorry for not responding to comments, I don’t know how! Let me know what you think about this story and the ending to this chapter… Prepare for LOTS TO CUM!