Page 5, Gay Blackmail Stories

Cruel Revenge

By StraightForMen 9 Aug 2023

A gay nerd gets revenge on his class bully who is out of his league but will soon be his slave bitch.

9.2 (182) 22374 10 Min Comments

Blackmailed

By gary_4_u 1 Aug 2023

Used at the park

8.7 (107) 12173 5 Min Comments

Alexander "Alex" Ulrich: Going for the Gold (ch. 3)

By vinnymusclestallion 18 Jul 2023

Alexander "Alex" Ulrich, a cocky alpha heel and a pretty boy, heads to a mysterious midtown Manhattan address to find out who is doctoring his photos and attempting to blackmail him--this just on the eve of the Olympic games. He's about to receive the Dandy Dawson treatment.

9.7 (98) 2714 11 Min Comments

Oh, Brother! (ch. 4)

By Jon Royale 15 Jul 2023

Bully Donny turns his motley group of buddies loose on beleaguered brother Billy.

9.3 (58) 9956 48 Min Comments

Blackmailed out of Boredom

By MileHighScribbler 12 Jul 2023

Not everything that happens in Vegas stays in Vegas. A bored and lonely married man’s night of debauchery in Sin City results in blackmail and/or freedom.

9.4 (53) 7003 38 Min Comments

A Long, Hard Life (ch. 14)

By The Donling 25 Jun 2023

The princes are missing, the Royal Guard has led him into a trap, and now Chonay faces down against Count Owain. What happens next?

8.9 (10) 699 13 Min Comments

Our Senior Year and More (ch. 36)

By djfmonkey 19 Jun 2023

FAST FORWARD. We advance 5 years, reflection and future thoughts, a nemesis reappears to stir the pot, or does he seal his fate?

9.5 (45) 707 11 Min Comments

Oh, Brother! (ch. 3)

By Jon Royale 17 Jun 2023

In the dimly lit parking lot of an out-of-the-way road house Billy's night of debauchery continues with truckers and others. But if the teenager truly is being blackmailed why is he enjoying it so much?

9.7 (71) 9567 26 Min Comments

Straight Jock Catfished (ch. 5)

By grey 16 Jun 2023

Straight Jock Caleb’s first official sex tape.

9.6 (86) 16686 5 Min Comments

D'Kass Black Presents Jail's Bait: Lockdown (Book 1) (ch. 6)

By Phaggotry 4 Jun 2023

Officer Dan and Warden Hill and his guards

9.2 (20) 1893 14 Min Comments

Too Easy

By Habu 29 May 2023

Student initiated in Mile High Club by pro footballer.

9.3 (52) 5236 25 Min Comments

ApolloBiotech (ch. 7)

By Local 20 May 2023

You take control of a tech bro

9.6 (64) 4621 5 Min Comments

Oh, Brother! (ch. 2)

By Jon Royale 19 May 2023

Big bully brother Donny humiliates his younger sibling with sex blackmail.

9.2 (91) 14376 40 Min Comments

Family fun and games

By BillyBoy 15 May 2023

my uncle and aunt invite me to meet them and stay over for the weekend. they are naughty, nasty people, and i loved it!

8.4 (42) 5664 6 Min Comments

ApolloBiotech (ch. 5)

By Local 10 May 2023

You take control of a tech bro

9.6 (57) 5423 9 Min Comments

ApolloBiotech (ch. 4)

By Local 8 May 2023

Control a tech bro

9.6 (61) 4246 6 Min Comments

ApolloBiotech (ch. 3)

By Local 5 May 2023

Control a tech bro

9.7 (63) 5982 6 Min Comments

A cocky frat boy is hiding a secret… no more (ch. 3)

By Jeremy Miller 29 Apr 2023

Having spread his jock legs for the very first time, Zach now starts exploring his sexuality further. What better place to do this than at the frat house where rumors about his newfound desires start spreading? It turns out Zach is not the only bro in the frat house who likes dicks.

9.3 (182) 17322 30 Min Comments

ApolloBiotech (ch. 2)

By Local 29 Apr 2023

Control a tech bro

9.7 (73) 8474 8 Min Comments

ApolloBiotech

By Local 28 Apr 2023

Control a tech bro

9.1 (102) 16417 8 Min Comments

Bras, Bros and Blowjobs

By BillyBoy 21 Apr 2023

my study buddy caught me playing in my sisters underwear

7.5 (25) 7874 5 Min Comments

Father's Love (ch. 2)

By paulivan2023 9 Apr 2023

A new father is forced to agree to an arrangement of a perverted man to pay for his daughter's hospital bills. --- Father meets a perverted doc. Can he keep his sanity or will he break?

8.8 (26) 5781 24 Min Comments

Man Pussy Moan

By JadedGayKnight 28 Mar 2023

Tyrone gets his pussy wet in the club

9.3 (55) 11285 9 Min Comments

Russian Roommate (ch. 3)

By TyPeirson 27 Mar 2023

After finally taking Danyl's cock, "Jess" is ready to submit totally. After a trip to the gym, things don't end up going according to plan, and Jess's level of submission to the life of being a sissy is tested.

9.4 (69) 11441 13 Min Comments

Russian Roommate

By TyPeirson 28 Feb 2023

A feminine twink finally finds a roommate before starting at a Catholic university, and chats with him online before moving in. He quickly learns that this may be more than he bargained for. Part 1.

9.0 (99) 17475 15 Min Comments