Page 4, Gay Blackmail Stories

A group of men in the late 90's discover they've all been scammed by the same twink. For a weekend he's held captive in a leather bar while they teach him a lesson, he'll never get over.

9.6 (46) 7277 21 Min Comments

Revenge Porn (ch. 3)

By Hangry Holz 17 Jan 2024

A group of men in the late 90's discover they've all been scammed by the same twink. For a weekend he's held captive in a leather bar while they teach him a lesson, he'll never get over.

9.5 (33) 5761 14 Min Comments

Revenge Porn (ch. 2)

By Hangry Holz 16 Jan 2024

A group of men in the late 90's discover they've all been scammed by the same twink. For a weekend he's held captive in a leather bar while they teach him a lesson, he'll never get over.

9.7 (44) 8395 15 Min Comments

A cocky frat boy is hiding a secret… no more (ch. 4)

By Jeremy Miller 2 Dec 2023

Now that he has come out to the entire frat house, Zach has a lot of catching up to do, not the least of which is to figure out if he likes topping or bottoming better. But first, he has some business to take care of with John, his bro who recorded him getting pounded for the first time and tried to blackmail him into submission. It’s revenge time!

9.5 (85) 9090 17 Min Comments

Confessions of a Rural State Whore (ch. 9)

By B. N. M. 2 Dec 2023

Years ago, I was a male prostitute in a rural New England State. Chapter 9 details my last experience in my "night job," following up with the cute bartender from the previous chapter.

9.8 (45) 3676 14 Min Comments

Perfect Addition (ch. 8)

By JadedGayKnight 2 Dec 2023

The plan is enacted and Sayid's truth comes tumbling out.

9.0 (12) 1088 6 Min Comments

Confessions of a Rural State Whore (ch. 8)

By B. N. M. 1 Dec 2023

Years ago, I was a male prostitute in a rural New England state. Chapter 8 tells of the beginning of the end of my "night job." The night begins as a non-sexual gig but ends with me nearly getting gangraped.

9.3 (36) 3494 17 Min Comments

Charity Hole

By Hangry Holz 28 Nov 2023

With one man waiting to use him for a charity event, a man stops by work to help a customer during off hours and gets filled with two dicks.

9.4 (94) 15938 15 Min Comments

Perfect Addition (ch. 3)

By JadedGayKnight 27 Nov 2023

Sayid takes action and Hamilton makes a decision that could impact the rest of his career.

9.6 (26) 1658 10 Min Comments

The blackmailed slave (ch. 6)

By Derekhello 24 Oct 2023

Irish slave gets blackmailed and the story of his submission and life through kink and slavery

9.1 (23) 5812 10 Min Comments

Blackmailed Teacher

By BJJL 17 Oct 2023

A teacher goes for a usual hike in the woods to have some alone time. Three teens interrupt his fun with nature.

8.2 (102) 13023 7 Min Comments

Oh, Brother! (ch. 6)

By Jon Royale 13 Oct 2023

Has bully Donny gone too far when siccing a band of white supremacists on his beleaguered brother Billy? Can either of them make it through the night unscathed?

8.6 (28) 6848 33 Min Comments

Fucking in Hollyoaks (ch. 32)

By HollyGuys 13 Sep 2023

Eric blackmails James into bring Romeo to the prison, where he uses his knowledge to his advantage

9.4 (5) 858 17 Min Comments

Eleon Trysts

By Habu 25 Aug 2023

U.S. and Russian spies play cat and mouse in Cyprus.

9.4 (24) 1227 23 Min Comments

Oh, Brother! (ch. 5)

By Jon Royale 18 Aug 2023

Poor little Billy suffers even more humiliation at the Old Folk's Home.

9.2 (42) 10197 36 Min Comments

Cruel Revenge (ch. 3)

By StraightForMen 14 Aug 2023

Oliver gets even more blackmail material and reveals a little surprise to make sure Tom has to return to him on a regular basis for humiliating service.

9.4 (155) 20685 8 Min Comments

Cruel Revenge (ch. 2)

By StraightForMen 11 Aug 2023

A gay nerd continues his revenge and plans to blackmail a homophobic bully into a beta man pleaser.

9.4 (135) 16007 11 Min Comments

Cruel Revenge

By StraightForMen 9 Aug 2023

A gay nerd gets revenge on his class bully who is out of his league but will soon be his slave bitch.

9.2 (180) 22049 10 Min Comments

Blackmailed

By gary_4_u 1 Aug 2023

Used at the park

8.7 (106) 12079 5 Min Comments

Alexander "Alex" Ulrich: Going for the Gold (ch. 3)

By vinnymusclestallion 18 Jul 2023

Alexander "Alex" Ulrich, a cocky alpha heel and a pretty boy, heads to a mysterious midtown Manhattan address to find out who is doctoring his photos and attempting to blackmail him--this just on the eve of the Olympic games. He's about to receive the Dandy Dawson treatment.

9.7 (98) 2698 11 Min Comments

Oh, Brother! (ch. 4)

By Jon Royale 15 Jul 2023

Bully Donny turns his motley group of buddies loose on beleaguered brother Billy.

9.2 (57) 9843 48 Min Comments

Blackmailed out of Boredom

By MileHighScribbler 12 Jul 2023

Not everything that happens in Vegas stays in Vegas. A bored and lonely married man’s night of debauchery in Sin City results in blackmail and/or freedom.

9.4 (53) 6950 38 Min Comments

A Long, Hard Life (ch. 14)

By The Donling 25 Jun 2023

The princes are missing, the Royal Guard has led him into a trap, and now Chonay faces down against Count Owain. What happens next?

8.9 (10) 697 13 Min Comments

Our Senior Year and More (ch. 36)

By djfmonkey 19 Jun 2023

FAST FORWARD. We advance 5 years, reflection and future thoughts, a nemesis reappears to stir the pot, or does he seal his fate?

9.5 (45) 704 11 Min Comments

Oh, Brother! (ch. 3)

By Jon Royale 17 Jun 2023

In the dimly lit parking lot of an out-of-the-way road house Billy's night of debauchery continues with truckers and others. But if the teenager truly is being blackmailed why is he enjoying it so much?

9.7 (70) 9469 26 Min Comments

Straight Jock Catfished (ch. 5)

By grey 16 Jun 2023

Straight Jock Caleb’s first official sex tape.

9.6 (86) 16489 5 Min Comments

D'Kass Black Presents Jail's Bait: Lockdown (Book 1) (ch. 6)

By Phaggotry 4 Jun 2023

Officer Dan and Warden Hill and his guards

9.2 (20) 1884 14 Min Comments

Too Easy

By Habu 29 May 2023

Student initiated in Mile High Club by pro footballer.

9.3 (52) 5197 25 Min Comments

ApolloBiotech (ch. 7)

By Local 20 May 2023

You take control of a tech bro

9.6 (64) 4590 5 Min Comments

Oh, Brother! (ch. 2)

By Jon Royale 19 May 2023

Big bully brother Donny humiliates his younger sibling with sex blackmail.

9.2 (91) 14206 40 Min Comments

Family fun and games

By BillyBoy 15 May 2023

my uncle and aunt invite me to meet them and stay over for the weekend. they are naughty, nasty people, and i loved it!

8.4 (42) 5626 6 Min Comments

ApolloBiotech (ch. 5)

By Local 10 May 2023

You take control of a tech bro

9.6 (57) 5397 9 Min Comments