Gay Blackmail Stories

GayDemon's Stories: On this page you can find erotic fiction where you can read about gay men blackmailed.

Slave of My Younger Step Brother (ch. 2)

By Dormdog🐾 8 Jun 2025

This is the story about absolute domination of younger step brother over his elder brother. This chapter contains Blackmail , humiliation, spanking, anal and oral sex , bisexual rough sex . Hope you like this story.

7.6 (30) 7384 10 Min Comments

I Wish (ch. 7)

By Marine Rope Stud 7 Jun 2025

Stuart Holden, attorney and Army Reserve officer and Buck Masters, motorcycle cop trick straight cop Anthony Marino into a blackmail situation.

9.0 (30) 1930 9 Min Comments

Big Ben (ch. 2)

By Araloth 30 May 2025

Colton gets involved, and things get worse for big brother Ben

9.4 (162) 7841 16 Min Comments

The Interview

By HornyGaymer 23 Apr 2025

Dillon is unemployed and his girlfriend is pregnant. He’s desperate for a job, and Ken just might have a job for him, if he can get through the interview.

8.5 (54) 4791 9 Min Comments

Caught Crossdressing

By BillyBoy 15 Apr 2025

in her underwear, I'm exposed and turned into his cock slave.

5.9 (13) 5245 2 Min Comments

The Village (ch. 153)

By Lil Guy 15 Mar 2025

Zach just turned his back for two seconds... The gang goes on a hunt for the little guys. After a couple of days of Disney fun, Auntie Mo and the OG Phoenix crew hiyt the streets of Orlando looking for adult fun...

9.7 (69) 1206 16 Min Comments

Laundry Room Mishap

By Ted_Brown 9 Mar 2025

A university student was planning on doing his laundry but was surprised to meet his black neighbour for the first time in the buildings laundry room.

9.1 (179) 10317 6 Min Comments

Caught behind the bikeshed

By StrykerJ 5 Mar 2025

The curious jock Ricky Walker (20) heard strange noises coming from behind the bike shed at the sports park. Curious, he went to investigate and found a scene he had never imagined. A rough biker (32) was dominating a local homophobic politician (61). The excited young college man snuck into the bushes for a closer look. (Update version 2025)

9.2 (131) 10106 29 Min Comments

Bait and Switch (ch. 6)

By Dominic Cooper 25 Feb 2025

Cocky college footballer turned chastity slave has whored himself out with the promise of earning an orgasm. Now, he finally has a chance to cum - through being brutally fucked in chastity. Will he be able to blow, or was this another cruel trick by his sadistic Dom?

9.6 (53) 7732 22 Min Comments

Shit happens

By Olisub 24 Feb 2025

A prank failure causes the 18-year-old to fall into the hands of a former military man who names the boy Shitrag and intends to turn him into a toilet slave.

9.0 (87) 13014 11 Min Comments

Closeted Crossdresser

By slut4roughuse 15 Feb 2025

Blackmailed crossdresser sissy used by neighbor

9.2 (42) 9015 18 Min Comments

Loading Dock Lust (ch. 2)

By Jon Royale 1 Feb 2025

In part one, straight-acting Rafe had his fantasy come true when he made it with the hunky supermarket delivery guy out on the loading dock. Neither noticed the surveillance cameras above them. And now the big, black security guard threatens blackmail unless.....

9.6 (72) 3998 19 Min Comments

No Choice But To Obey

By Subby 29 Jan 2025

A young boy becomes a tempting and unwilling prey for a horny muscle bear.

9.0 (84) 17417 17 Min Comments

Black Orchid (ch. 5)

By Bruce Silver 24 Jan 2025

Months have passed by as Minni healed from his piercings along with training under his new Master. Duke has more up his sleeve to show Minni the lengths he is willing to go for him. Now, Minni comes face-to-face with an old friend.

9.3 (29) 3111 13 Min Comments

Sexual Blackmail

By KellyGirl2010 23 Jan 2025

When your coworker finds out that you might not be who who are...

9.1 (23) 4956 32 Min Comments

Black Orchid (ch. 3)

By Bruce Silver 22 Jan 2025

After Minni's ordeal, Duke reveals some of his past in an attempt to connect with Minni on a level that he himself had never done before. With his fate sealed as Duke's slave he starts to grapple with hidden feelings that started to bud within him.

9.0 (30) 3020 15 Min Comments

Black Orchid (ch. 2)

By Bruce Silver 21 Jan 2025

Trapped with his captor, Mick is beginning to realize what horrid and twisted plans Duke has in store for his new slave. Now panicking, Mick is desperately trying to find a way out before time runs out. What will happen to him now? How much deeper does the rabbit hole go?

8.8 (39) 4438 16 Min Comments

Black Orchid

By Bruce Silver 20 Jan 2025

Just starting his college career, Mick is starting his path to a business major. However, watchful eyes have been monitoring Mick's progress and has insidious plans in store for his prey.

8.8 (50) 6409 15 Min Comments

Adult Store and Theater experience (ch. 2)

By RiverDylan 16 Nov 2024

Straight man finds himself drawn to the latino man that abused him.

9.3 (71) 6473 12 Min Comments

Fucked For More Info

By Sven Benters 23 Sep 2024

Chad Dimera (Billy Flynn) visits Clyde Weston (James Read) for info about his late wife. Clyde has info to prove to Chad that his wife is still alive but for that, Clyde wants to have sex with him.

7.9 (18) 2356 7 Min Comments

The beginning of it all (ch. 6)

By Handsome cumdump 12 Sep 2024

A man approaches me at the tennis club and tells me he has seen some compromising pictures of me.

9.4 (32) 5289 11 Min Comments

Putting On A Show

By Sven Benters 2 Sep 2024

In this story John Cates (Adam J. Harrington) takes his revenge at his rival through his son. John will fuck Michael (Chad Duell), for Michael the hope that John will finally leave his parents alone.

8.9 (23) 2120 7 Min Comments

Shit gets real

By Eroticfateim 21 Aug 2024

James sets out to do an edgy scene, not realizing what he had agreed to had not time limit and that the scene was going to go on....

6.7 (31) 4125 3 Min Comments

Addiction! (ch. 7)

By Andrew Mark 14 Aug 2024

Andy's spiral into the world of depravity continues, his addictions getting stronger and stronger. His dependency leads him into the depth's of taboo. Once again a big thank you to my 'sources' for their honesty and openness. Think of them as you read of their trials and traumas.

9.3 (36) 5823 15 Min Comments

Blake's new life (ch. 3)

By Archer25 19 Jul 2024

Blake’s ordeal continues at a gay retirement home and he runs into an unexpected person from his past.

9.1 (49) 8736 22 Min Comments

Breaking the Gymnast (ch. 2)

By Badcolinbaxter 30 Jun 2024

The hot young 18 year old gymnast is initiated in the fine art of sucking cock.

9.2 (79) 7580 11 Min Comments

Breaking the Gymnast

By Badcolinbaxter 28 Jun 2024

A cock teasing gymnast gets himself in trouble.

9.0 (99) 14963 28 Min Comments

Old FwB takes control (ch. 4)

By Sub.to.use 28 Jun 2024

Joe deals with the effects his submission has on his personal life, realises how deep his addiction to Sam is and finds a new kink

9.6 (77) 6172 14 Min Comments

Old FwB takes control (ch. 3)

By Sub.to.use 18 Jun 2024

Joe falls deeper into submission and is taken to a sauna, and gives up complete control of his body. And loves it.

9.7 (61) 6601 12 Min Comments

Old FwB takes control (ch. 2)

By Sub.to.use 14 Jun 2024

Engaged man forced to submit again, and falls deeper

9.6 (85) 8711 9 Min Comments

A Fag's Worth

By Jack Hoffman 13 Jun 2024

When Brady, a lonely forty-three-year old university professor, discovers the world of faggots and Daddies, he gets more than he bargains for.

8.5 (32) 5672 36 Min Comments

Old FwB takes control

By Sub.to.use 13 Jun 2024

Engaged man meets old FwB and gets taken.

9.2 (83) 10975 7 Min Comments

Straight Jock Catfished (ch. 7)

By grey 11 Jun 2024

Despite his straight jock best friend continuously getting exploited on the internet, all Mike could do was watch. He liked seeing Caleb’s beefy body on display all the time.

9.3 (59) 9215 4 Min Comments

Nineteenth Hole

By Hangry Holz 10 Jun 2024

After taking care of his husband for months, Eric takes a job at a golf course in a retirement community. The job quickly becomes more fulfilling than any work he’s done before.

9.2 (77) 8477 19 Min Comments

Return From Sick Leave

By Casper Prince 24 May 2024

And just like a good little piggy, his dad pushed like he was trying to take a shit. His hole twitched a few times, then he began farting out slimy cum. Zayn filmed it, getting close so the camera would pick up the little plopping noises as globs of cum dripped down his taint and off his balls, pooling on the dirty tile of the public restroom.

8.8 (58) 11911 15 Min Comments