First Time Gay Sex Stories

GayDemon's gay porn library: in this story category you can read erotic stories & sex fiction involving first time gay sex experiences.

The Dancing Gamer

By Habu 22 Nov 2021

Dancer/gamer lured into a video game store and beyond.

9.3 (45) 2294 21 Min Comments

Lascivious Initiation

By Tiberiu 20 Nov 2021

Very good buddies discover their friendship goes much deeper and lustful than ever thought.

8.5 (32) 1914 8 Min Comments

Unce Mark and Jack

By Scott Sauce 12 Nov 2021

Mark isn't really Jack's uncle. And that's a good thing, because Mark has plans for young Jack. Plans that..... well, let's just say they're plans that shouldn't involve family.

9.0 (103) 5608 25 Min Comments

My first real gay encounter

By BillyBoy 3 Nov 2021

I reluctantly go to a party with my girlfriend. She gets drunk and I get gay.

8.2 (44) 4710 5 Min Comments

Against All Odds

By Avery Jones 1 Nov 2021

Eric is a recent graduate who ends up at an end of school party. After almost leaving his crush walks in. Can Eric pick up the nerve to speak to him or will he end up going home to sleep?

9.1 (85) 3100 7 Min Comments

Breaking Bernie's Cherry

By Simon Peter 1 Nov 2021

The first time an ass takes a cock is an ordeal. A painful ordeal. Especially with a big cock like Jake's and a tight cherry hole like Bernie's.

9.3 (125) 7604 8 Min Comments

A Night At The Old Graveyard

By Scott Sauce 29 Oct 2021

It had been a horrible year. I had come out to the wrong person. He outed me, forcing me to move to a new school. There I met a guy. I would have let him do anything to me, but before our secret could come out he lied about me. Now I'm stuck in a dare: spend Halloween at the old graveyard or face being bullied for the rest of my school career.

9.3 (129) 4727 31 Min Comments

Devin (ch. 2)

By Foreskinlover269 28 Oct 2021

I try new things with Devin to make him mine

9.2 (24) 1079 6 Min Comments

Top turned bottom at glory hole

By bottomsup 26 Oct 2021

Went to glory hole to drop a load ended up on my back getting bb anal

8.4 (38) 3143 3 Min Comments

See, Smell, Touch, Taste and Hear You

By Paul François 21 Oct 2021

At 18, Antoine is still a virgin, but that will soon change with the help of a 65-year-old man living in his building, who has a five-step scenario for initiation to manly pleasures.

7.9 (22) 1726 6 Min Comments

A boxer's fetish (ch. 4)

By Daniel Berasaluce 16 Oct 2021

Amos and Mark fight and certainly the winner ends up fucking the loser, but later the winner also surrenders his ass.

9.4 (13) 2323 7 Min Comments

Breaking In the Birthday Boy (ch. 2)

By Flyboy 15 Oct 2021

Several weeks after I let Jacob fuck me on his 18th birthday, he’s now ready to bottom for me and let me take his ass cherry. But he has a couple of conditions first.

9.5 (90) 6683 15 Min Comments

Let's Play

By Zeen 8 Oct 2021

Narrative fictional story. A successful real estate agent tells the story of how he developed a connection with a much younger college jock after moving to San Diego.

9.1 (49) 2274 16 Min Comments

My jail bird story

By Tommy 8 Oct 2021

Older man fucking me for the first time.

8.9 (72) 4428 7 Min Comments

To Tell The Truth

By Clark Wayne 6 Oct 2021

Wes is a straight guy with a man-crush. He's taken to his first gay party with a buddy and it proves to be a little to tempting to experiment.

9.2 (174) 8614 19 Min Comments

A First Taste of Cum

By Tristan Decker 4 Oct 2021

A chance encounter leads to a cock in my mouth for the first time.

8.8 (128) 17048 6 Min Comments

Brad Meets Troy

By F.E. Cooper 28 Sep 2021

A concerned, single mother, wanting her son to be updated to local standards, engages his idol, gorgeous sports star Brad Pittman. Brad has one day to accomplish what usually in that town takes longer. He rises to the task with surprising results as year-younger Troy Donahoe responds.

8.8 (39) 3875 14 Min Comments

19 Year Old Stright Guy Has His First Gay Sex

By Naughty Eric 22 Sep 2021

Bret, a blond hot horny 19-year-old straight guy with a girlfriend, gets drunk and winds up in bed with one of his college professors resulting in getting it on with his first man sex.

8.8 (165) 17111 7 Min Comments

Ups and Downs (ch. 6)

By Brock Archer 22 Sep 2021

After seeing Ethan off to college, Joe meets another young virgin ready for deflowering, but a shock not only interrupts the ceremony, it sets in motion a chain of events that may completely change the course of Joe's future.

9.4 (53) 2168 10 Min Comments

Virgin boy (ch. 2)

By Drew 22 Sep 2021

The rain continued to fall heavily. Drenching Pete and Sam even more. Pete’s libido was high and he wanted to engage in more sexual activity, now not later. Pete grabbed at Sam, but failed to grab hold of him. Sam could see the wild angry look on Pete’s face and decided to run.

8.8 (28) 1755 9 Min Comments

First Sexual Experience

By MontanaBiGuy 18 Sep 2021

A young man has his first experience with a trusted and dear friend

9.3 (87) 5196 17 Min Comments

Hot and Steamy in the Locker Room

By Smut is My Middle Name 18 Sep 2021

Hardened by the idea of a queer losing his virginity in a steamy, passionate session in the Locker Room? Look no further. This Twink is about to experience the time of his life when caught masturbating by hunky athlete after football practice!

9.3 (111) 6421 7 Min Comments

My Real First Experience With A Man (ch. 2)

By Jjj1975x 13 Sep 2021

After a week of thinking of my first time in the hotel with David, I now had a week contemplating whether I should see David again. On Friday, I finally gave in to my urges.

9.7 (84) 5752 20 Min Comments

My First Blowjob Encounter (ch. 3)

By Alex 11 Sep 2021

First time ever for sex

7.5 (22) 2306 2 Min Comments

The Real First Time

By Randy Rogue 30 Aug 2021

This is the true story of the first time I had sex. Although I feel I am bi, I always say the first time I had sex was with my high school sweetheart on our junior prom night. I had forgotten all about what happened to me when I was younger.

8.9 (71) 3465 10 Min Comments

Camp Lady of the Lake

By Aiden 26 Aug 2021

Tommy and Dan are about to graduate. Feeling the seriousness of college and adulthood looming, they decide to make this last summer of freedom their last hoorah!

9.2 (89) 5026 15 Min Comments

Campus Nerd

By Zeen 24 Aug 2021

While attempting to adjust to college life among shallow students, Arthur befriends a guy who is part of a fraternity that bullies him but later takes a liking to him... or so he thought.

9.1 (97) 5413 16 Min Comments

First Steps

By nadabit 24 Aug 2021

Unexpected entry to cock sucking hunger.

8.2 (23) 2627 20 Min Comments

The Thousand and Second Night

By Habu 23 Aug 2021

Summer of seduction for Scott on the French Riviera

9.5 (40) 2477 27 Min Comments

Attention Starved

By Habu 21 Aug 2021

Lonely and vulnerable Munich summer for Gregor

8.8 (52) 2908 15 Min Comments