An Unexpected Turn
by Derek D
31 Dec 2022 420 readers Score 9.7 (27 votes) PDF Mobi ePub Txt
Facing One’s Truths
“Then don’t lie to her Mike, and don’t lie to yourself either”, those words echoed in Mike’s head as he drove home. What did Steve mean about not lying to himself? He was still straight. Just because he enjoyed every bit of last night didn’t mean anything. He loves Jules and wants to spend the rest of his life with her regardless of what happened last night. He now knew though why Scott had that look on his face as Tony fucked him. That incredible feeling as his cock rubbed across his prostate. He could picture the look on Scott’s face that day and wondered if he had the same look on his face last night. His cock was hard and throbbing in his jeans now and he rubbed it thinking about Peter’s cock sliding in and out of him. He was a little sore from it, but it had been worth every minute of the pain to feel that awesome sensation. He grinned as he realized he was unconsciously grinding his butt into the car seat.
He snapped out of it when he thought of Julie and what he would tell her. He couldn’t lie to her and how would she react when he told her he had enjoyed having sex with guys. Yes, guys. Two of them. David first at the bachelor party and then Peter last night. Both had been an awesome experience, but it had been just that, an experience. Right?
Mike recalled kissing Julie’s soft lips, her tender touch, her soft hands, and her infectious smile. She was his best friend and moral compass. It was her that reminded him that his friendship with Tony and Scott was more important than their sexual orientation. He wanted to have and raise children with Jules. He’d be lost without her.
How did he get himself into this situation? That fateful day when he stumbled upon Tony and Scott having sex. Why had he been frozen there, watching? He wasn’t sure. A train wreck he couldn’t look away from? No, it wasn’t that. He now knew what it was. He’d experienced it himself. It was unbridled passionate sex felt by both parties involved, not some dominant figure painfully taking advantage of another. He had felt it before, but never with another guy. He had felt it with Jules. No, he had felt that passion on that day and it had excited him. It had made him feel the sexual energy that was in the room. He didn’t know why at the time. Suddenly, Mike knew what Steve had meant by being honest with himself. He knew he needed to be honest with Jules and hope for the best, but he now knew he had to be honest with himself. He was not straight. Was any guy or girl really straight? Yes, it’s true that a lot of people never experiment with people of the same sex, but that’s usually because of the stigma around it, not because they didn’t feel the urge to do it. Mike now knew that he not only had to be honest with Julie about the fact that he had enjoyed having sex with guys but had to be honest with himself and he knew what that meant.
After Mike left, Ian asked Steve, “What did you mean when you told Mike he had to be honest with himself”? Steve looked at Ian and said, “I think there’s a reason Mike came to me to talk about his discovery of Tony and Scott fucking and what resulted”. Ian said, “You think Mike’s gay”? Steve shook his head, “Not exactly. I think he’s bi like me, and enjoys sex with girls and guys. The choice he has to make is who he loves. I made my choice or rather I think that choice was made for me because consciously or not, I love you with all of my heart and that will never change. I’m just so happy that you chose me as well”. Ian’s eyes were watering, “How could I not choose you Steve? How could I not love you? You are the best thing that’s ever happened to me. Even when I had amnesia, I felt a connection somehow. You are and always will be my life”. They embraced and then kissed feeling each other’s love. When they eventually separated, Ian said, “I really hope things work out for Mike. He’s a great guy. I think Julie’s right for him and hope they choose each other, but I guess that will be up to each of them. I think Mike really does love her though”. Steve nodded, “I think Julie loves Mike as well. Let’s just hope things work out and if not, we’ll help them both through it”. Ian smiled, “That’s one of the many reasons why I love you so much. You’re always willing to help others”.
Peter arrived just before dinner. He had a smile on his face that lit up the room. “Someone’s in a good mood”, Steve said as Peter walked into the kitchen. Ian asked, “I take it your mom is doing ok”? Peter nodded his head, “She’s doing fine. The surgery was a complete success. When they brought her lunch, my dad asked me if I would join him for lunch. We had a long talk. The short of it was that even though he doesn’t understand why I’m gay, he’s ok with it because I’m his son and he loves me no matter what”. Peter’s eyes watered up as he gave them the news, but the huge smile remained. Steve and Ian both smiled, and Steve said, “That’s great news Peter. Let’s eat dinner and then we should celebrate the good news of your mom and your dad”. Peter then asked, “Where’s Mike”? Ian looked at Steve as Steve said, “Mike left. He’s got a lot on his mind”. Peter grew concerned, “I hope he’s not regretting what we did last night. He seemed fine this morning.”. Steve grinned and explained, “I don’t think Mike regrets what you two did last night. He just must come to grips with it and deal with things going forward. Mike is in kind of a dilemma right now. He followed through on his agreement with Julie but didn’t expect the results”. Peter looked confused, “I’m not sure I’m following you”. Ian said, “I think Mike thought he could just go through the motions and get it over with and let Julie know, and they could move on. The problem is that Mike obviously liked it, a lot from what Steve and I heard”. Steve nodded. Peter turned red and smiled, “I guess we were pretty loud. I was trying to take it slow and be gentle for his first time but after a while he started bucking and begging for me to go harder”. “We heard”, Steve said, grinning. Peter laughed and said, “I think I created a monster”. Steve’s smile faded and he said, “That’s the problem he’s dealing with now. He didn’t expect it to be as good as it obviously was for him, and he now has to reconcile that with his feelings for Julie”. Peter sobered up, “I hadn’t thought about that. He did tell me how it was supposed to be just an experiment. I feel kind of bad for him now”.
Tony and Scott were cuddled on the sofa trying to decide whether to watch a movie or play video games. Scott suggested, “Why don’t we watch a movie and invite Mike to join us”. Tony smiled, “That sounds like a plan. He’s been a stranger the last week anyway. I’ll call him”. Tony picked up his phone and called Mike, “Hey Mike. Me and Scott are about to watch a movie and wondered if you wanted to join us since you’ve been a stranger the past week. Hey, that’s not a problem. That’s what best friends are for. Come on over. We won’t take no for an answer”.
Mike’s phone lit up and he looked to see who was calling, “Hey Tony. What’s up? Yeah, I’m not sure I’d make good company right now. I have a lot on my mind. You sure? OK”.
Mike walked in and made his way to the family room where he found Tony and Scott on the sofa. Scott looked over and smiled, “Hey stranger”! Mike smiled weakly as he walked over, “’rents gone again”? Tony replied, “Yeah, they flew down to Austin to visit my aunt Karen, dad’s sister, and her husband. They won’t be back for a few more days. I’ll go grab us a beer and then you can tell us what’s bothering you”. Tony got up and went upstairs to retrieve some beers from the fridge and Scott moved over to make room for Mike, “Plop your butt down here and tell Dr. Scott and his associate Dr. Tony what ails ya”. Mike grinned and sat down next to Scott, “I’m not sure I want to tell anyone about it, at least not yet. It’s still all jumbled in my head”. Tony returned with a twelve-pack and loaded up the mini fridge, then handed them each a bottle. Scott said, “Mike’s not ready to spill the beans”. Tony sat down on the other side of Mike and said, "That’s ok. You can tell us when you’re ready Mike. We’re here for you whenever”. Scott put on the movie, and they were starting on their third beer when Mike said, “I get it now guys”. Tony wasn’t sure he heard right and turned to look at Mike. Scott paused the movie and turned to Mike as well, “Wait! What”? Mike said, “I get it now. The sex between guys thing”. Tony asked, “Are you saying you did it? You did anal with a guy”? Mike nodded. Scott grinned and asked, “Was it that David guy again”? Mike shook his head. Scott nudged him, “Who was it then”? “Peter”, Mike replied. “Peter”, Tony asked? “Peter as in the kid from the restaurant”, Scott asked? Mike nodded. Tony nudged Mike’s shoulder, “No way! You fucked that young waiter? That’s awesome dude”! Scott nudged Mike’s other shoulder, “Dude, how was he, pretty tight”? Mike smiled, “Yeah, it was ok I guess”. Tony nudged Mike again, “Ok, you guess”? Scott then said, “Ok, Mike, spill it! We want details”. Mike said, “No details”. Tony began tickling Mike and Scott piled on. Mike began laughing and squirming in an attempt to get away but to no avail. The tickling became torture until Mike yelled, “OK! I’ll give the details”! Scott sopped up the beer they spilled during the ruckus and then Mike explained the details from the conversation he and Peter had and then how he and Peter resumed the conversation after Steve and Ian had gone to bed. That conversation led to them meeting in the bedroom which moved to them sixty-nining, and then how he had fucked Peter. Scott then interrupted, “So, you said it was ok, you guess”? Mike shrugged, “I mean it was good and tighter than Jule’s pussy, but it was just a fuck. It wasn’t like when Jules and I are doing it. It’s different. I’m not saying I wasn’t into it. I was. I enjoyed it completely, but it wasn’t..”. “Love”, Tony finished the sentence for Mike as he locked eyes with Scott who smiled back at him. Mike smiled more at that moment than he had all night. “Exactly”, he said as much to himself as to Tony and Scott. Then Scott said, “So then you still haven’t had a cock up your butt yet”. Mike said, “I didn’t say that”. Tony looked at Scott, then Mike, “Wait! There’s more? You got fucked”? Mike grinned widely and nodded his head. Tony grinned, “So young Peter popped your cherry”? Scott asked, “So, how was your first cock”? Mike couldn’t wipe the smile off his face as he said, “Peter was very gentle, but it still burned like hell. It took some getting used to”. Scott said, “But..”. Mike continued, “But once he was all the way in and I relaxed, the pain faded enough for him to start. He began fucking me, and started hitting my prostate! I was seeing stars! I couldn’t believe what he was doing to me! I couldn’t get enough. I really embarrassed myself. I started begging him to pound me harder. Dudes, I think I’m bisexual”. Tony said, “You think”? Scott laughed, “That’s great Mike, but I don’t think you should be embarrassed about begging Peter to fuck you harder. I’m sure it was a complete turn-on for him”. Mike turned a shade of pink, “Yeah, except Steve and Ian heard me”. Tony and Scott both began rolling in laughter. Mike grinned and said, “Sure, get your jollies over my embarrassment”. Scott, still laughing, said, “Sorry Mike but it is hilarious. I can’t even imagine hearing you begging to get fucked harder. I hope Steve or Ian recorded it”. Mike suddenly considered it, “Fuck! I hope not. It was embarrassing enough when I found out they had heard me”. Tony asked, “So, are you feeling better now than you did earlier”? Mike smiled and said, “Yes, thanks to you two pain-in-the-butts. I’m still worried about telling Jules when she gets back though”. Scott said, “I’m sure you two love birds will work it out. Julie adores you Mike”, then he asked, “Speaking of pain-in-the-butts, how’s yours feeling today”? Mike grinned, “Not as sore as I thought it would be”. Then Tony suggested they return to watching their movie.
As Steve, Ian and Peter toasted Peter’s reconciliation with his father, and his mom’s successful surgery with a glass of wine, the doorbell chimed. Ian went to answer it and when he returned, he had Chad and Carl in tow. “Hey guys”, Steve greeted them, “What’s up”? Carl said, “We were in the area and thought we’d stop by and see how you guys were coming with your vows. Hey Peter. Good to see you”. Ian cringed, “I’ve got a long way to go”. Then Peter said, “Good to see you as well. I’m back for a visit while my mom recovers from surgery. She’s doing very well though”. Chad said, “That’s good to hear, Peter. That’s not good to hear, Ian”. Steve laughed as he poured a glass of wine for Carl and Chad. They then talked about the wedding plans and about Melissa’s latest tests and Steve and Ian’s future children.
Chad then suggested playing a game. Since there were five of them, pool was out so Carl suggested poker. Peter said he didn’t have any money to risk on poker and Ian said, “Then we’ll play for clothes, strip poker”. Steve grinned and shook his head, “Always wanting to show off that hot bod of yours”. Everyone laughed and then Chad said, “Ok, the losers get fucked”. Peter grinned and said, “I guess I’m planning to win then”. They then agreed on some rules. They would play Five Card Draw and the first two who lost all their clothes would bottom. The next loser would get his cock sucked, spit-roasting the losers and the final two would top and switch partners halfway through. Lowest hand would lose an article of clothing. They agreed to five pieces of clothing to make things even. Steve and Ian knew there wouldn’t be many more of these in their near future with the children taking up most of their time.
Fifteen hands later, Steve had lost two and had removed his shoes and socks. Ian had lost four and had only his tight black briefs left on. Chad had also lost four and also had only his red boxer briefs left. Carl had lost three and had his pants, and underwear on. Peter also had lost two and still had his t-shirt, pants, and underwear on. Peter lost the next hand and shed his t-shirt. Ian lost again and pulled off his black briefs, becoming the first loser. Carl was next and deposited his pants to the pile, leaving his yellow briefs. Steve lost his t-shirt next, then Peter followed, adding his pants to the pile, showing off his blue bikini briefs. It was down to the wire and Carl lost the next hand making him the second loser. Steve then lost his pants to the pile and then Chad. It didn’t make any difference except for bragging rights, but Steve and Peter played the last hand. Steve won and with it, the call as to who he’d fuck first. He decided on Carl, so he could finish with Ian.
As Steve and Peter put on condoms, Chad began taking turns plunging his cock in Carl‘s and Ian’s mouths with great zeal. Then, lubed up, Peter lined up behind Ian’s fine ass and slowly sank in. Steve did the same to Carl as Chad continued to switch between the two. After the agreed upon ten minutes, Steve and Peter put on fresh condoms and traded partners. Peter had already been close to cumming just from the thought of being in Ian’s hot butt, so he slowed his pace after entering Carl. After another ten minutes or more, Peter said, “I can’t hold out much longer Steve. You about ready”? “Yep”, Steve said as he slid out of Ian. Peter pulled out of Carl, and both got rid of their condoms. Steve then positioned Ian and Carl cheek to cheek and then moved as Peter stepped in front of them and blasted his cum over both their faces. When he was spent, he moved to let Steve do the same. After Steve had painted Ian and Carl’s faces Chad stepped up, “Holy shit! Their faces are already covered”, but he added his load as well. Steve and Chad blocked their attempts to wipe their faces, instead ordering them to flip head to toe and jerk each other off into each other’s faces. Ian complained a little, but Carl was more than happy to comply since he was licking up any cum that came near his mouth. Chad laughed and said, “What a cum whore”, good-naturedly. Carl laughed and said, “I love cum”, just as Ian unloaded several jets directly at Carl’s mouth. He opened up and caught as much as he could. Then he blew his own load all over Ian’s face, adding to an already cummy mess. Steve took a picture of Ian’s face with his phone and said, “A memory to keep”. Ian yelled, “Hey! That’s not fair Steve”. Steve leaned down and kissed Ian’s cummy lips and said, “I love you Stud”, another flash. Steve had given Peter his phone to take that pic, then Steve said to Ian, “A memory for the both of us”. After wiping off Ian and Carl’s faces, all five of them laid down on the mat and rested from their sex. Afterward, they went back upstairs and had another drink before Carl and Chad headed out.
Ian noticed Peter had been quiet for a bit and asked, “Is something bothering you Peter”? Peter said, “Sorry, I was just thinking about Mike. I hope he’s doing ok”. Ian said, “Why don’t you call him”. Peter said, “I don’t have his number”. Steve said, “Here”, and handed Peter his phone after entering Mike’s number.
Mike excused himself from the sofa to answer his phone, “Steve, what’s up? Oh, hey Peter, how’s your mom doing? Glad to hear. What’s up”?
Peter on the other end, “It’s Peter, Steve called you for me since I didn’t get your number. She’s doing great. She should be home in a couple days. I’m staying until then. I was just wondering how you’re doing. I know last night was a lot to digest. I hope you had a good time, but I understand your situation with your girlfriend”.
Mike, “Actually, I had a talk with Steve and was trying to figure things out, then my best friends, Tony and Scott talked me into coming over and now I’m in a good place. I now realize I’m Bi and hope Jules will be ok with it. I still love her and want to spend the rest of my life with her and have her children. Um, actually the other way around, but you get what I mean. I want to thank you for last night. It was really fantastic”.
Peter, “That’s great to hear Mike. She’s a good person and I think she’s really into you, after all, you risked your life for her. I’m glad you had a good time. I had a great time myself”.
Mike, “Yeah, that didn’t turn out too well. Some hero I turned out to be. You did? That’s good to hear. You said you’re staying for a few more days? Would you like to get together tomorrow or the day after if you’re busy”?
Peter, “Mike, you made the attempt and risked your life. It was the attempt that counted and rallied the rest of us to kick their asses. I have to visit my mom tomorrow and promised my dad I’d have lunch with him, but after that I’m free”.
Mike, “Great, I’ll buy us dinner and we can go from there. Give me your number and I’ll send you mine”
Peter, “Ok, it’s ###-###-####”.
Mike, “Got it”.
Peter, “Yep phone just logged it. See you tomorrow”.
Peter handed Steve his phone back and Steve said, “You realize what you’re getting into here. This is a fragile time for Mike”. Peter replied, “I do realize that Steve. I have no plans to get between Mike and Julie. I like them both and hope they have children and live the rest of their lives together. On the other hand, I can’t reject Mike when he needs me either”. Steve smiled and placed a hand on Peter’s leg, “You are a good person Peter and far wiser than your years. You are a good friend, but I wonder if you’re doing the right thing seeing him again this soon. You may be doing precisely what you said you don’t want to do”. Peter smiled and said, “I want to be there for him, but don’t want to get in the way if you can understand that and Julie isn’t returning for a few more days,”. Steve said, “That’s being a great friend, Peter. I’m glad to have you as a friend as well. You have a good heart and good intentions”. Peter smiled and said, “Thanks Steve. I’m glad to have you and Ian as friends”. Ian said, “Ditto! Group hug!”, and then jumped on both of them. They went down in a pile, laughing.
Tony said, “Wait! Did we just hear you set up a date with the guy who took your cherry”? Mike groaned and said, “I’m not some schoolgirl who lost her cherry and it isn’t a date. We’re just going to go to dinner and then hang out for a while”. Scott laughed, “Dinner and then hanging out together sure sounds like a date to me, and you may not be some schoolgirl, but from what you said, you definitely lost your cherry last night”. Mike tossed a pillow at Scott, and he tossed one back. Soon all three were in a pillow fight which turned into a wrestling free-for-all on the floor. Tony pried himself away and climbed up on the sofa to watch Scott and Mike go at it. Eventually, Mike pinned Scott on his back and was sitting on his chest with his arms pinned over his head. Tony took advantage of that to jump back down on the floor and start tickling Scott’s waist. Scott began squirming and bucking, frantically trying to break free which resulted in Mike being bucked forward. His crotch ended up planted in Scott’s face and they both froze. Scott felt Mike’s hardness pressing against his face and Mike then realized he was hard. He didn’t know what to do, but Scott, being playful, took Mike hard shaft between his teeth. Mike looked down and groaned and saw a playful twinkle in Scott’s eyes. Tony at first didn’t know why the action had stopped until he glanced over Mike’s shoulder and said, “Oh”. Mike quickly rolled off Scott and said, “I’m sorry. I didn’t want that to happen”. Then he got up and sat in a chair across the room. Tony realized Mike was embarrassed at what had happened, “Mike, it’s ok. Don’t worry about it”. Scott got up and agreed, “Mike, I guess I shouldn’t have done that. I was just teasing you”. Mike said, “No, it’s ok. It’s just that you’re my best friends and after everything. I’m sorry”. Tony then said, “Mike, stop apologizing and relax. What happened in the past is in the past. You have to get over this guilt trip. We’ve forgiven you a thousand times over. You’re our best friend”. Mike smiled, “You’re right. I need to get over it. I just ruined the fun we were having. I’m sorry” “Mike”, both Tony and Scott yelled in unison! Mike started laughing and Scott and Tony both jumped on him, overturning the chair in the process. They both tickled him until he begged them to stop. After they picked the chair back up, they moved back to the sofa and finished watching the movie. As the credits rolled, Tony whispered, “Scott”. When Scott looked over, he found Mike leaning against Tony with his head against his shoulder, fast asleep. Scott quietly got up and grabbed a blanket and they gently laid Mike down on the sofa, covered him and went up to bed themselves.
Mike woke up the following morning on the sofa with a blanket covering him. He realized where he was and smiled. He got up and folded the blanket and put it back in the closet, knowing where it was kept. He then went up to the kitchen and made some coffee and started breakfast. When breakfast was almost ready, he decided he would have to go up and wake Tony and Scott. He thought they’d wake up from the smell of coffee and breakfast. He tapped on their bedroom door and then opened it. Scott and Tony were waiting for him, “Good morning, Mike”, they said together, then Scott asked, “Where’s coffee and breakfast?" Mike grinned and said, “Good morning, guys, and breakfast is in the kitchen, I’m not your butler.” Mike then turned and as he walked out the door, said, “I don’t know about you, but I’m hungry.” As soon as Mike entered the kitchen, he heard Tony and Scott coming down the stairs. They entered the kitchen dressed only in their briefs. Mike just shook his head. They ate breakfast while Tony and Scott gave each other mischievous glances. Mike ignored it but was inwardly amused by their mischief. After breakfast, Mike prepared to leave, having to run some errands. As he was heading to the door, Scott called out, “Hey Mike! You can’t leave without a hug”, and then walked toward Mike, still in only his briefs. They hugged and Mike caught Scott off guard by squeezing his buns. As Scott stepped back, he had a wide grin on his face. Tony then stepped in the room and said, “Have a nice date tonight”, to Mike before hugging him. Mike surprised Tony by saying, “I’m sure I will”, and then squeezed Tony’s buns as well. Not to be outdone, as Tony released the hug, he quickly kissed Mike on the lips. Mike turned a bit pink, but he grinned as he waved goodbye. Things were good between them again.
Mike and Peter ended up at a small restaurant in an upper-class neighborhood and Peter was surprised Mike had made reservations, “This place looks expensive”. Mike smiled and said, “Don’t worry, I have a coupon”. Peter laughed and said, “Like this place takes coupons”. They were seated at a table near the back and almost immediately a server came up to their table with a bottle of wine and poured them each a glass and then left the bottle. Mike asked, “Do you like steak”? Peter said, “Of course”. Mike then asked, “Do you like lobster”? Peter said, "Yeah, why? Are those my choices”? Mike said, “If you’d rather have something else, you could look at the menu”. Peter said, “I’d love either of those, but they’re both expensive”. Mike then looked over to one of the waiters and nodded. The waiter nodded back and left the room. Peter then said, “As you know I worked at a restaurant, and I can recognize a high-class AKA expensive restaurant when I’m in one. Did you win the lottery or something”? Mike smiled and said, “I did not win the lottery, but don’t worry about how I’m going to pay for it, just enjoy the meal”. The waiter Mike had nodded to brought out several appetizers and had two other waiters deliver them to the table. A plate of crackers with crab meat, another with caviar and a plate with jalapeño poppers. Peter laughed and asked, “Isn’t that one out of place”? Mike grinned, “They’re my favorite”. Fifteen minutes later, the waiters cleared the table and then brought out salads. After the salads, the waiters cleared the table again and brought out the main course of filet mignon, lobster, baked potatoes stuffed with bacon and cheese and for a vegetable, broccoli along with melted butter. By the time they were finished, they were stuffed and had to take dessert, death by chocolate and cheesecake, with them.
Mike then drove them to a large park with a lake in the middle where they took a long walk. They talked about Peter’s college studies and Mike’s job. Then Peter asked, “Look, I really am enjoying tonight, but this seems a little over the top. I’m getting the impression this is more than a thank you dinner”. They were on a path at the edge of the lake and suddenly Mike dropped down in front of Peter on one knee and looked up to him, “It is Peter. Would you marry me?” Peter began shaking and said, “Mike, this is all so sudden. What about Julie and a family. It’s too soon”. Mike then reached for Peter’s zipper and tugged it down, “Then can I at least give you a blowjob”? Peter looked around frantically to see if anyone was around as he said, “Mike! Not out here in the open”!
Peter’s eyes shot open, and he sat up in a sweat. He was hard as a rock and realized he had been dreaming. He was still shaking as he climbed from bed and walked to the bathroom to wash the sweat off. Ian passed by on his way to the bathroom and said, “Good morning, Peter. I hope you slept well. It looks like you had a rough night”. Peter smiled and replied, “Good morning. Yeah, I had a really weird dream”.
As Steve and Ian prepared to head over to Benjamin and Melissa’s for dinner, Steve handed Peter a key to the house, “Have a good time at dinner. Here’s a key so you can get back in later as Ian and I may be late”, and then smiled. Ian said, “Have fun tonight” and then winked. Peter couldn’t help but grin as he said, “Thanks”.
Mike then drove them to a large park with a lake in the middle where they took a long walk. They talked about Peter’s college studies and Mike’s job. Then Peter asked, “Look, I really am enjoying tonight, but this seems a little over the top. I’m getting the impression this is more than a thank you dinner. I feel like I’m about to be proposed to”. Mike burst out laughing before saying, “In your dreams. I really had an awesome night with you, and I wanted to let you know how important it was for me. I finally am facing the truth about myself that I like girls, but I like guys as well. I still want to marry Jules and have a family, but I now know that some of my homophobia wasn’t just from my dad, I was suppressing these feelings I had for other guys without understanding it. I hurt my best friends with my hateful comments at them and though I’m glad they’ve forgiven me, as Tony said ’a thousand times’, it still pains me that I said it. You made my first time fantastic. You went slow and gentle. It was a night I’ll never forget Peter. Thank you”. By the time Mike had finished, Peter was glowing. Then Peter smiled and said, “I’m glad I could be there for you, Mike. I went slow and gentle until you began begging me to pound you”, Peter added laughing and ribbing Mike. Mike turned beet red and rolled his eyes, “I had no idea what it would feel like. It drove me crazy. I was seeing stars”. Peter grinned and said, “Yeah, my first time went pretty much the same way. That’s why I wanted to do the same for you”. Mike smiled, then asked, “So, what would you like to do now”? Peter said, “Why don’t we go back to Steve and Ian’s and share that dessert”? Mike said, “Ok. Then what”. Peter smiled and said, “We’ll think of something. Steve gave me a key because he and Ian said they’d be out late”. Mike smiled and said, “Is that right? Well let’s go”.
Once they were back at Steve and Ian’s house, they went into the kitchen and grabbed some forks and shared the desserts. As they finished and were putting the dishes in the dishwasher, Peter said to Mike, “Hold still. You have something on your nose”. Mike stopped and looked to Peter who then wiped some chocolate he had on his finger from one of the plates on Mike’s nose and then ran. “You fucker”, Mike yelled and chased after him! Peter ran downstairs with Mike right behind him and soon Peter realized he had nowhere to escape. He stopped on the exercise mat and turned, saying, “I give! I give!” Mike tackled him down on the mat and Peter tried to escape but ended up on his back with Mike pinning his arms. Peter cried out, “I said I give”! Mike grinned and leaned down toward Peter’s face, “Then give me your tongue. You need to lick the chocolate off my nose”. Peter grinned up at him and said, “But you look cute with a brown nose”. Mike pinned Peter’s arms to his sides using his legs and then began tickling Peter. Peter began laughing and screaming for Mike to stop and then yelled, “Ok! Ok! I’ll lick off the chocolate”. Mike stopped tickling Peter and Peter extended his tongue waiting for Mike to bend his face down toward him. Instead, Mike grinned while he pulled his zipper down and fished out his semi-hard cock. He then wiped some of the chocolate from his nose with a finger before wiping it on the head of his cock just above the drop of precum that was gathering at its tip. Mike then put that finger up to Peter’s mouth and Peter took it into his mouth and sucked on it. Mike pulled his finger out of Peter’s mouth and then leaned down, grinning at Peter. Peter grinned back at him and then licked Mike’s cheek instead of his nose. Mike flinched and pulled his head up before saying, “You want more tickling then”? Peter’s eyes opened wide as he yelled, “No! No! I’ll lick the chocolate off”. Mike leaned back down, and Peter licked his nose until all the chocolate was gone. Mike sat back up and then moved forward on Peter’s chest bringing his now fully hard cock with chocolate and precum to Peter’s lips, “You said you’d lick the chocolate off, now lick away”. Peter giggled and then licked at the head of Mike’s cock, licking up both precum and chocolate, then said, “MMMmm, sweet and salty”, before taking the head of Mike’s cock into his mouth. Soon Mike was feeding Peter his whole cock as he propped himself up on his arms. That freed Peter’s arms and he reached around and grabbed onto Mike’s hips as the cock plunged in and out of his mouth. Peter shifted his grip to Mike’s firm butt cheeks as Mike’s cock continued its assault on his mouth. Suddenly, Mike pulled his cock from Peter’s mouth and began pulling Peter’s clothes off, followed by his own. Once they were both naked, Mike said, “My turn”, and then crawled between Peter’s legs and took Peter’s cock into his mouth. He was still new to sucking cock, but he was improving. He could go deeper than before though he still choked when he went a little too far. He also made sure to protect the cock from his teeth. Something Jules hadn’t perfected as of yet. He almost choked as the thought crossed his mind that he was a better cocksucker than she was. He began playing with Peter’s balls as he bobbed on his cock. He pulled off the cock, and began stroking it as he began licking Peter’s balls and taking them into his mouth, trying to do things he’d want done to himself. He could tell he wasn’t doing too badly because Peter was moaning and periodically encouraging him, Fuck, that feels good. You’re doing great Mike. So much better than the last time”. Then suddenly Peter was trying to push him off his cock, “Hold on Mike. You’re getting me close. Why don’t we sixty-nine and get each other off?” Mike nodded and swung around over Peter giving him access to his own cock. They were soon slurping on each other’s cocks and before long, Mike felt a wet finger playing around in his butt crack. Mike moaned in anticipation and pulled Peter’s legs up to get access to Peter’s hole as well. Soon their fingers were working each other’s holes as their mouths were slurping on cock. Peter had already been close, and the stimulation of his hole had Mike’s balls churning up a load as well. Suddenly Peter began moaning loudly on Mike’s cock and his cock grew harder. Then suddenly Peter’s cock began pulsing as wads of creamy cum shot into Mike’s mouth and his anal ring spasmed around Mike’s middle finger. Mike tried to swallow Peter’s cum while at the same time his own seed began jetting from his balls. It caused him to choke a little which resulted in some of Peter’s cum dribbling down his chin. Peter had the same trouble and some of Mike’s huge load escaped from the cracks of his mouth and ran down his cheeks to his ear lobes and neck. When they both had finally finished emptying their balls, Mike climbed off Peter and laid down on the matt next to him. They turned and looked at each other and both began laughing at what they saw. Peter reached over and pulled Mike’s face toward his and kissed him and soon their lips were locked in a cummy kiss, their dueling tongues blending their cum together.
After laying together in the afterglow of their orgasms, kissing periodically, they went up and shared a shower. Mike wasn’t new to showering with other people. He’d showered in the locker room after gym class or sporting events with the guys and he showered with Julie on quite a few occasions where they would wash each other and occasionally, have sex. Showering with another guy and soaping each other up was different. Peter’s body, though not overly muscular, was harder, the muscles more defined. Caressing the soap in his arm pits was strangely exciting as his pits weren’t shaved like Julie’s. The experience was making him semi hard. As Peter washed his hair, Mike lathered the soap down his chest and sides, hesitating for a bit at his nipples where he elicited a sharp inhale and giggle from Peter when he tongued the hard nubs. As Peter was rinsing the shampoo from his hair, Mike lowered himself down massaging the soap across and down his hips and thighs, avoiding his crotch area for the moment. After soaping up Peter’s lower legs and feet, Mike moved up to Peter’s cock and balls. Peter became instantly hard as Mike playfully soaped them up and rubbed his soapy hands up behind Peter across his firm buns and into the crack between them. His soapy finger penetrated Peter a few times eliciting a moan from him. As the soap was rinsed off Peter’s stiff cock and balls, Mike looked up into Peter’s eyes and smiled before taking his hardness into his mouth. Mike sucked on Peter’s cock for a while before Peter pulled him back to his feet and said, “My turn”. Mike smiled as he allowed Peter to gently caress soap onto his face and neck as well as behind his ears. Peter’s closeness had their cocks in sword play as both were rock hard. Peter moved on to Mike’s shoulder and then to his sides where he had Mike lift his arm so he could soap up Mike’s pits which were slightly hairier than his own. Initially, as his soapy hands moved under Mike’s pits, Mike quickly moved his arms down, “That tickles”, he said laughing. Peter held his hands under Mike’s arms and soaped him up. Eventually Mike lifted his arms back up and after his pits were rinsed of soap, Peter leaned in and licked at the right one. Mike groaned, “Fuck. That feels so good”. Peter then moved, kissing, and licking Mike’s neck before moving to lick the other arm pit. Mike’s cock was throbbing from the sensuousness of it. Peter eventually moved to Mike’s chest as he lathered the soap across his chest, sides, and abs, leaning in to lick and nibble on his perky nipples. Mike jumped in response, “Fuck Peter! You’re driving me nuts!” Peter looked up at him, grinning before moving down to soap his legs up. As he finished Mike’s legs and feet, Peter looked to Mike’s crotch where he noticed a shiny string of precum hanging from the tip of his rigid cock. He put his tongue under it and moved up before taking Mike’s hardness into his mouth. He sucked on it for a while before beginning to soap him up. Mike groaned, “Fuck Peter. You’re going to make me cum if you keep that up”. After bringing Mike to the edge by his soapy hands, he stopped and let Mike be rinsed off, then Peter rose and turned, saying, “My turn again. Wash my back, will you?” Mike smiled and said, “My pleasure”. He soaped up Peter’s shoulders and upper back, using his thumbs to massage the hard muscles. Peter leaned his head back, enjoying the sensation. Mike slowly moved down to Peter’s lower back to his waist before dropping down to his legs. He then kissed Peter’s butt cheeks before applying soap and rubbing it in between his cheeks and caress his firm buns. He rose and continued to soap and massage Peter’s butt and then inserted a soapy finger. Peter inhaled sharply and leaned his head back. Mike worked his finger in and out of Peter’s hole, leaned down and began kissing Peter’s neck. Peter melted back into him, “Fuck me Mike”. Mike removed his finger and then soaped up his already precum-soaked rigid cock and then began sliding it up and down between Peter’s hard buns. Mike knew he better get inside Peter soon before he lost his load from the sensation of sliding up and down his butt crack. He positioned himself at Peter’s hole and then slowly pushed inside. Once there, he stopped and waited for Peter to get accustomed to him. Peter wanted him inside, so he pushed back, taking Mike’s cock into him until he was firmly pushed against Mike’s pubes. Peter glanced back at Mike and smiled, then Mike leaned in and kissed him briefly. Peter grinned and said, “Fuck me straight boy”. Mike grinned and said, “I’m not as straight as I thought I was.” and then began thrusting away plunging in and out of Peter. “Oh yeah! Fuck my hole, Mike!” Mike wasn’t taking it easy this time and was pistoning in and out of Peter. Peter had his hands against the shower wall for support as Mike hammered away inside him. Suddenly, Mike pulled his cock from Peter and turned him around facing him, and said, “I just realized I’m not wearing a condom.” Peter said, “I’m ok with it if you are.” Mike smiled and said, “Too late now anyway”, and then lifted Peter up against the wall and held him under his buns as Peter wrapped his legs around Mike’s hips. Mike then plunged his cock back inside Peter and resumed fucking him against the shower wall. They looked in each other’s eyes as they fucked away, kissing periodically. A few minutes later Mike announced, “I’m getting close”. Peter replied, “Cum inside me Mike. Please. Give me your cum”. Mike just stared into Peter’s eyes and after a few seconds grunted, “Uh! Oh! Oh fuck! Yeah! Take my seed!” Peter felt Mike’s cock spasming inside him and the cum coating his insides. Once Mike was drained, they remained positioned against the shower wall catching their breath.
Peter looked in Mike’s eyes and said, “That was so lit, feeling you shooting inside me”. Mike smiled and then leaned in and kissed Peter. Their tongues played a duet for a few minutes before Mike eased out of Peter and allowed Peter’s legs back onto the shower floor. They faced each other smiling, then Peter asked, “My turn?” Mike nodded, then quickly turned around, put his hands on the shower wall, and spread his legs. Peter used his fingers and some conditioner to open Mike up to prepare him for his cock and after using a third finger for a bit, decided he was ready. He soaped up Mike’s butt and his stiff cock and slid the hot shaft between Mike’s firm cheeks, reveling in the sensation until Mike pleaded, “Stick it in me, Peter. Please?” Peter kissed the back of Mike’s neck as he pushed up against Mike’s tight little hole. Peter then bit Mike’s shoulder as he simultaneously pushed past the tight ring. “Uhh!”, Mike groaned from the dual pain of both the penetration and the bite on his shoulder, but the bite had caught him by surprise and the searing pain he had felt from the penetration the other night didn’t happen. It still burned some, but nothing like the other night. He turned his head and smiled at Peter knowingly, then Peter pushed in a little further until Mike winced. Peter continued to edge in until he was tightly pushed against Mike’s firm buns. Mike glanced back, and then reached back, grabbing Peter’s head and pulled him in for a kiss. The Peter began fucking him. Mike moaned with each inward thrust. Peter slowly increased his pace and Mike encouraged him, “Yeah. Fuck me, Peter! Uh! Oh fuck! Yes! Give me that cock!” Soon Peter was violently slamming into Mike and then he would go softer but more rapidly and then back to hard, violent slams. Mike was once again seeing stars and gutturally crying out for Peter to fuck him harder. He sounded like a wild animal, growling out, “Uhhh! Slam my ass! Give me that hot cock! Fuck me harder! Harder! Fuck me! Yes!” Peter suddenly felt his impending orgasm, “I’m getting ready to cum, Mike!” Mike yelled out, “Cum in me! Breed my ass!” Peter then began to unload blast after blast deep inside Mike and then Peter felt Mike’s hole spasming around his cock, helping to milk his seed as Mike’s own seed splashed against the shower wall. Mike’s hands were against the shower wall, holding on for dear life as he saw stars. His whole body was a spasming orgasm, a feeling he’d never felt before. His knees were too weak, so he leaned his chest against the shower wall to hold himself from collapsing. Peter leaned up against Mike’s back, kissing his neck and whispered, “Oh my god. That was fucking incredible”. Mike looked back and gave Peter a weak smile and said, “I think I need to lie down”. Peter said, “Let’s get you cleaned up some more and dried off and I’ll help you into the bedroom.
As they entered the bedroom, Peter pulled back the sheets, and they both collapsed down onto the bed, side by side. As they laid there, Mike said, “That felt so incredible. I just had a whole-body orgasm in there. I’ve never felt anything like it before”. Peter turned onto his side, facing him, and put his arm across Mike’s chest, kissed him on the cheek and said, “Yes. I saw it happen. It was incredible for me too”. They soon both fell asleep.
Steve and Ian returned home. They saw Peter and Mike’s cars and the lights were out so they assumed they were either downstairs or were asleep. Sure enough, as they walked over to an open bedroom door, there lay Mike and Peter. The covers were pulled back and both were completely naked. Mike was lying on his back and Peter was laying over him with his head on Mike’s chest and his left arm draped across his abdomen. Steve looked at Ian who was grinning as they looked so peaceful as they slept. Steve pulled the covers over them and then they left the room, closing the door behind them. Ian said, “Must have been a hell of a night”. Steve continued smiling and nodded, “I’m pretty tired myself Stud. Let’s have a nightcap and go to bed”.
End of Chapter 63