An Unexpected Turn

Chapter 62

The Deflowering

Ian crumpled the paper and threw it in the waste basket. He and Steve had decided to write their own vows and Ian was stressing with what to write. He started with what the traditional vows were and was trying to tailor it to his own, but it didn’t seem right. He eventually became frustrated and gave up for the moment. Then he received a call from Ryan, which was unexpected as he was back at college and didn’t usually call unless there was something being planned. Ian answered the call, “Ryan, this is a surprise”. Ryan’s voice sounded a little concerned, “Hey, I’m really happy that Mike’s going to be ok, but Peter just got some bad news that his mom’s in the hospital, and he needs to come down to see her, but there’s a problem”. There was a pause. Ian waited and then Ryan continued, “Peter recently came out to his parents and his mom took it well, but his dad freaked out and told him that he needed some time to process it. He doesn’t think staying at home for the weekend with his dad will be very comfortable for either of them. Do you think Peter could stay with you guys while he visits his mom? I tried to reach Steve but got his voice mail. Peter is already on his way to come home to see his mom and I told him I’d reach out to you. He doesn’t care where he’ll sleep”. Ian assured Ryan, “Of course he can stay with us Ryan. Can you let him know he can just come over whenever he’s done visiting his mom or if he wants to drop his stuff off first, that would be fine as well”? Ryan responded, “Thanks Ian. You guys are the best. I’ll let Peter know”.

Just then Steve called Ian to let him know he would be late as a new client wanted to have a late meeting with him. He said Mike was supposed to stop by and to let him know he’d be late, but he still wanted him to wait until he got home. Ian then told him about Peter, and the fact that he invited him to stay for a few days. Steve said, “Good call Ian. I would have made the same decision to let him stay with us,”.  Ian smiled, “I knew you would, but Ryan couldn’t reach you, obviously because of your meetings”. Steve apologized, “Yeah, sorry stud, but I’m trying to get things wrapped up so we can enjoy our wedding and honeymoon”. Ian said, “I realize that Steve and understand. I just miss you and our time together after work that we normally have. I guess it’s a sacrifice I’m willing to make. I’ll entertain our guests until you get home”. Steve grinned and said, “Thanks stud”.

Mike arrived at the house around 5 PM. Ian met him at the door and let him know Steve would be late but hoped he could wait for him. Ian then invited Mike for dinner so that wouldn’t be a concern. Mike was more than happy to join Ian and Steve for dinner. Ian then said, “It will actually be four of us. Our friend Peter will be staying for a few days so he can visit his mom in the hospital. You remember him, don’t you”? Mike replied, “Yeah, the guy from the restaurant”. Ian said, “That’s him”. Mike asked, “Isn’t his family from around here”? Ian replied, “Yeah, but he just came out to his family and his dad isn’t taking it so well”. Mike smiled, “It’s like some kind of masculinity thing, isn’t it”? Ian replied, “Whatever it is, it does more to tear families apart than it does to bring them together. Talk about family values”. Mike laughed, “I know, right, and to think I was raised with those same beliefs. I can’t believe how much I’ve changed my perspective in the last year”. Ian laughed, “And your vocabulary. Steve must be rubbing off on you”. Mike laughed as well, realizing he had said perspective, “I’ll take that as a complement”. Ian replied, “As intended”.

Just then the doorbell rang, and Ian went to see who it was. Ian returned with Peter in tow. Mike greeted him, “Hey Peter! Good to see you again”. Peter smiled and said, “Hi. You’re Mike, right”? Mike stood up and offered his hand, “Yep. How’s college treating you”? Peter smiled, “It’s going great! Thanks to Ryan, I’ve settled in pretty well”. Mike asked, “Speaking of Ryan, didn’t he come along”? Peter replied, “No, he needed to stay and attend classes. I got a few days off so I can visit my mom in the hospital”. “I’m sorry to hear that. Is it something serious”? Peter said, “It could be, but we’re hoping everything goes ok”. Mike then said, “I hear you and your dad are not seeing eye to eye on your coming out. My dad was a huge homophobe as well until I got stabbed. He started rethinking it after he thought he might lose me. I thought I’d woken up in a different reality when I saw him embracing Steve when I opened my eyes. He’s even stopped watching the hate network he used to watch twenty-four-seven”. Peter said, “I hope it doesn’t take a near death experience on my part for my dad to come around”. Mike grinned and said, “Yeah, those are no fun, trust me”. Ian broke in, “Why don’t you guys grab a drink and hang out. I have to get dinner ready”.

After Ian headed to the kitchen, Mike and Peter grabbed a drink and continued their conversation in the living room. Peter asked, “I thought you were straight? Why would your dad and you have a problem”? Mike smiled and said, “Well, it started with him being against me being involved in Steve and Ian’s wedding, a wedding between two guys. He actually was trying to forbid it at first, so I moved out”. Peter looked at Mike questioningly, “You said at first. What did you mean by that”? Mike realized he had said more than he had intended and wondered how much he was willing to say to Peter, who he didn’t really know very well, “It’s kind of complicated. I came across something I shouldn’t have, and it changed my own view on certain things”. Peter said, “I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to pry about something personal. It’s none of my business”. Mike nodded, “Thanks”. There was an uncomfortable quiet then for several minutes and Peter felt he needed to open a new subject, “So, what brings you here tonight, just visiting”? Mike chuckled as he realized it was bringing back the same conversation they’d been just having, and that Peter had no idea that it was. He looked at Peter for a few moments and then decided, “As you might recall, I almost blew my relationship with my two best friends after I found out they were gay and had become boyfriends. After Steve and Ian were buried under all that rubble, I began to realize how short life could be and how I’d feel if one of them were gone. I decided I couldn’t let hatred that I’d been taught since I was a child get in the way of the friendship I’d always had. I started to see what that hatred can do to a person. I just thought I was allowing that hatred to push the love I had for my friends out of my heart, and I decided I wasn’t going to accept that”. Peter nodded, “I wish more people could look at life that way”. Mike began to laugh which puzzled Peter, “What’s so funny”? Mike replied, “It’s what you said about looking at life. I got a look at life that I hadn’t expected which is why I’m here”. Peter asked, “What do you mean”? Mike didn’t get a chance to reply as they heard the front door open. Steve was home. Mike said, “Maybe we can talk about it later”. Peter replied, “I’d like that”, and then they greeted Steve as he entered the room.

Steve sat down and almost immediately Ian came in and handed Steve a drink before kissing him, then said, “Dinner will be ready in fifteen minutes”. Steve smiled up at Ian and said, “Thanks Stud. I’m sorry I got delayed at work and thanks for taking care of our guests and dinner”. Ian bent down and kissed Steve again before whispering, “Love you Steve”. Steve smiled and said, “Right back at you”. Mike and Peter glanced at each other smiling and Peter thought, ‘Looking at life’.

After dinner, Peter left for the hospital to see his mom and Mike sat in the living room with Steve and Ian. Ian asked Mike, “Mike, would you rather talk to Steve alone? I have some things I could do”. Mike put his hand up and said, “No, Ian, it’s ok. I would rather you stay”. There was a silence in the room for a couple minutes and then Mike said, “I’ve been trying to make some sense of what I’ve been experiencing lately. Ian, I’m not sure what Steve has told you, but I stumbled on Tony and Scott having sex one afternoon and couldn’t look away. I was actually into watching it I guess and ended up embarrassing myself. I don’t know what’s going on in my head, and I had to let Julie know. I love her so much. She said before we make a commitment to get married, I had to be sure by experiencing the other side. I have done that to some degree with someone during your bachelor party”. Ian grinned and asked, “Really? You had sex with someone during our bachelor party? Can I ask who it was”? Mike was a little surprised, “You mean Steve didn’t tell you”? Steve said, “I kept our private conversation to myself, although we do have some kind of connection where we convey thoughts to each other sometimes”, and then smiled at Ian. Mike volunteered, “It was with Benjamin’s son, David. We only did oral sex. At first, I was only going to let him do me, but I got curious, and we ended up doing each other”. Ian was now intrigued, “So, what did you think”? Mike smiled and turned a little pink, “At first, I thought I might puke, but after taking a few cautious licks with the tip of my tongue, I wasn’t grossed out at all and after a few minutes I was sucking cock for the first time in my life”. Ian grinned and said, “I remember my first time. It took me a little before I had the courage to put my mouth on it. I found I like the taste of most guy’s cum, but they all taste a little different. So, where does that leave you and Julie”? Steve broke in, “Ian, I don’t think we should pry into their relationship”. Ian realized he had overstepped, “Sorry Mike. I shouldn’t have asked that question”. Mike thought about it for a moment, then said, “It’s ok. It’s a fair question and I’ll let you know when I know the answer. I hope we can both get through this”. Mike’s eyes were watering after he said it, then added, “I’m glad to have you guys to talk to about this. I thought Tony and Scott might be too close to both Julie and I and Steve has been with both guys and girls, so I thought he might understand this better”. Ian smiled and said, “Steve’s the right guy. So, are you going to try anal”? Mike’s face turned crimson, and he nodded, “I have to. We agreed on me trying both. I’m just not sure who I’m going to do it with yet. I’m not about to ask Tony or Scott”. Ian looked in Steve’s direction and said, “Steve was my first and he helped Ryan during his first time although I was actually the one to take Ryan’s cherry”. Mike nodded and said, “I have to give it some thought. I was thinking about David, but I’m not sure I’d be able to take his big cock and after seeing Steve’s, I know I can’t take his”. Ian then offered, “Well, whoever it’s with, just make sure you clean out beforehand to avoid any embarrassment”. Mike grinned, “Yeah, Steve and I already had that conversation, thanks”.

The conversation changed to other things and a few drinks later, Peter returned from the hospital. As he entered the living room, everyone looked to him questioningly. Peter smiled and said, “The surgery went well and she’s in recuperation. They said she’ll sleep through the night. Dad’s staying until she wakes up. He said he’d text me when she wakes”. Ian asked, “Can I get you a drink, Peter”? He replied, “I’ll take a coke if you have it”. Ian retrieved the soda and then asked, “So, are you and your dad ok”? Peter gave a slight smile and said, “He didn’t talk much. I think he needs some time but he wasn’t hostile or anything”. Mike said, “Well, that’s a good sign”.

They talked for a while longer and then went down and shot several games of pool, switching partners around so each game was a different pairing. It was near midnight when Steve suggested Mike stay the night since he had a few alcoholic drinks. Mike agreed and they played one more game before Steve and Ian said they were going to go to bed. As Steve and Ian headed up for bed, Peter looked to Mike and said, “I appreciate your concern about my dad, but I think we’ll get through it”, and once Steve and Ian were upstairs, he asked, “So, what did you mean by ‘a look at life you hadn’t expected’”? Mike smiled and said, “I almost forgot we agreed to continue that discussion”. Mike then explained about finding Tony and Scott in the middle of fucking and being frozen in place, his admission to Julie, their agreement, and his encounter with David during the bachelor party. Peter smiled, “So that’s where you disappeared to. Not many people took notice, but I noticed you looked a little uncomfortable and saw you sneak off and then return a while later”. Mike nodded, “Yep, Tony and Scott noticed too. They thought I didn’t want to see the strippers doing their show”. Peter began wondering then asked, “So was that a one time thing with David”? Mike shrugged and said, “Probably. I mean I’m still with Julie. I’m not planning on dating David or anything like that”. Peter shook his head, “I meant the sex part”. Mike said, “I still have to try anal sex yet, but I’m not”. Peter interrupted, “Would you consider oral again”? It then dawned on Mike that Peter might be hitting on him, and he felt his cock stir. Mike grinned and said, “I might consider it”. Peter wasn’t sure how to take Mike’s reply, but decided to ask, “Would you consider it if I offered”? Mike noticed Peter’s pants tenting and his own cock was coming to life as well, “I would”.  Peter then said, “I’m going to get cleaned up a bit. How about we meet in the spare bedroom farthest from Steve and Ian’s”? Mike nodded, “Ok”. Peter headed upstairs to the bathroom and Mike made use of the one downstairs.

Peter wasn’t sure if Mike would be into anything more than oral sex, but he made sure he was ready for whatever happened. Once finished, he made his way into the bedroom. Mike wasn’t there yet and Peter thought whether or not to drop most of his clothes. He decided to wait, thinking it might turn Mike on more if they undressed each other. He had carried his shoes from the bathroom and set them down beside a chair in the room, then dropped onto the bed to wait on Mike. After fifteen minutes, Peter began to worry that Mike had changed his mind, then there was a light tap on the door and Peter answered, “Come in”.

The door opened and mike stepped in and closed the door behind him. Peter jumped up from the bed saying, “I thought maybe you’d changed your mind”. Mike smiled sheepishly and said, “Yeah, sorry I took so long”. Peter was now standing right in front of him. He grabbed Mike’s t-shirt on either side and asked, “May I”? Mike nodded shyly and Peter pulled his t-shirt over his head and tossed it over the back of the chair and then lifted his arms up to allow Mike to pull his off as well. Peter smiled as he noticed the bulge in Mike’s jeans, ‘great! He’s turned on’. They looked into each other’s eyes and Peter asked, “Can I kiss you”? Mike was too nervous to answer, so he just nodded. Peter wasn’t used to being the one to take the lead, especially with a guy older than him, but he took Mike’s chin between his thumb and index finger, then leaned in and kissed him, lightly at first. After Mike responded to the kiss, Peter ran his tongue along Mike’s teeth, and he slowly opened his mouth welcoming Peter’s tongue with his own. Mike’s cock throbbed in reaction to Peter’s palm rubbing against his hardness and he let out a moan into Peter’s mouth. Peter then moved his mouth to Mike’s neck and kissed him under his right ear, then moved down his neck while he unfastened Mike’s belt, undid the button and slid the zipper down. Mike’s breathing grew heavier and he let out a few more soft moans as Peter worked his way down to his hard nipples and slid his pants down around his ankles. Peter worked his way down Mike’s abs as he moved too his knees. He tongued Mike’s belly button before stopping to eye the hardness under the fabric of his blue Jockey briefs with a wet spot at its tip. Peter placed the tip of his tongue on that wet spot as he looked up into Mike’s eyes. “Fuuuuck”, Mike sighed as he looked down at Peter. Peter continued to look up at Mike as he took his hardness between his teeth, all the while untying his sneakers. The wet spot grew larger as precum began flowing from Mike’s cock as Peter held it in his teeth. Peter released Mike’s cock and then licked and sucked at the wet spot before moving back to allow Mike to step out of his sneakers and jeans. Peter then stood up and they kissed some more before Mike slowly kissed his way down until he was on his knees. He rubbed Peter’s own hardness before opening his jeans and pulling them down. Peter stepped out of them, and Mike tossed them aside. A big smile spread across Mike’s face as he saw the wet spot in Peter’s own red American Eagle briefs. He imitated Peter as he looked up at him while taking Peter’s hardness between his teeth. Peter grinned and said, “That looks so fucking hot”! Mike then licked at the wet spot before fishing Peter’s stiff cock out of his briefs. Mike began licking it like a lollipop up the shaft, but stopping before he reached the head. Peter stared down and said, “Fuck yes”, as Mike continued until the precum leaking from Peter’s cock began overflowing down his shaft. Mike then took Peter’s cock in his mouth, tasting the sweet nectar being produced copiously. What Mike lacked in experience, he was more than making it up in enthusiasm. Peter had to slow him down. He reached down under Mike’s arms and said, “Hey, why don’t we move this to the bed”? Mike looked up and nodded, then stood and followed Peter to the bed. Mike’s eyes focused on Peter’s butt and thought about how his cock would feel rubbing in the valley between those small muscular mounds. Peter stopped at the edge of the bed and helped Mike out of his briefs. Then Peter told Mike to lie down on his back. Peter then climbed over him in a sixty-nine position. Soon they were slurping up and down each other’s cocks.

Several times Peter noticed Mike’s breathing getting heavier and he slowed down or moved to his balls instead. He wanted this to last and for Mike’s orgasm to be something he’d remember.

Mike was getting close a few times, but before he erupted, Peter would change things up. He was edging him, and it was driving him crazy. Peter pulled Mike’s legs up so his knees were bent, and his feet were flat on the bed. Then he felt wet fingers slowly moving up and down between his butt cheeks. He wet his own fingers and imitated what Peter was doing to him. Peter responded with a few moans of pleasure or were they his own, he wasn’t sure.

Peter was happy to hear Mike’s moans and was soon moaning himself when Mike’s wet fingers began sliding in his own butt crack. He added more spit to his middle finger and began rubbing around Mike’s hole. Mike jumped slightly but his moans grew louder. Peter then slid his finger in just slightly and Mike grunted but didn’t complain and Peter was encouraged when Mike spread his legs further. He inserted his finger further inside and was rewarded by a gush of precum and a louder moan from Mike. Peter then felt Mike’s finger slipping inside his own hole.

Mike recalled how David’s fingering had triggered an enormous load from him and now Peter was doing the same. He decided to give Peter the same pleasure and was amazed at how tightly Peter’s ring clamped around his finger. As he felt Peter add a second finger, he reciprocated and soon they were both too far gone.

Peter and Mike were both moaning and grunting on each other as they both approached orgasm. They were beyond edging now and it was a matter of seconds before they would explode. Peter felt Mike’s cock harden further and then began firing blast after blast of hot cum into his mouth. This triggered Peter’s own orgasm as his cock began flooding Mike’s mouth with his steamy load. Mike tried swallowing it, but some escaped out of the corners of his mouth and ran down his cheeks. Peter had a similar problem with Mike’s massive load and some escaped and ran down his still pumping cock and onto his balls. As they pumped out the last of their seed, Peter dropped down onto the bed beside Mike as they both struggled to catch their breath as their chests heaved. Peter said between breaths, “Holy shit! That was so fucking lit. Thanks”. Mike laughed, “Yeah it was. No thanks necessary. I enjoyed it too”, and then Mike surprised even himself and rolled on his side and kissed Peter. They kissed for a few minutes and then Peter rolled on his side and Mike spooned him and draped his left arm over Peter’s shoulder.

Initially, Mike had thought about going to sleep, but his cock had other plans. With Peter’s butt pushed back against his crotch, Mike’s cock began to stir back to life. Peter wasn’t helping since he was pushing back tightly against him and was even moving his butt slightly. Mike’s cock was soon fully hard again and he began sliding it up and down between those firm buns. Peter then began moving to the rhythm of Mike’s thrusts and Mike was loving it. Suddenly, Peter rolled away from Mike onto his stomach and giggled teasingly. “You little fucker”, Mike said, grinning, and then climbed over Peter and laid on top of him and resumed grinding his stiff rod up and down between Peter’s firm buns. Mike’s cock was leaking precum profusely, lubricating the warm valley. Peter resumed his participation, pushing up into Mike’s strokes. Mike was beginning to breath harder as he was getting into humping Peter. Peter had other ideas though, and after several minutes said, “Enough already! Quit playing around and stick it in”. Mike suddenly realized it was now or never, “You want me to”. Peter cut him off, “Yes! Fuck me! Please! I need you inside me now”! Peter reached into the drawer of the nightstand and pulled out a condom and some lube and gave them to Mike. Mike took them and then nervously slid on the condom and lubed up his sheathed cock. Peter moved up onto his knees and pulled his cheeks apart while Mike squeezed some lube onto his hole and massaged it inside. Mike then moved forward, pressing the tip of his cock against Peter’s tight ring. He pushed against it, but it seemed too small to accept his cock, “Are you sure about this”? Peter reached back behind him and took hold of Mike’s cock and with his other hand grabbed Mike’s hip and pulled him while at the same time pushed back onto Mike’s cock. Peter inhaled deeply as the head of Mike’s cock entered him. Mike gasped, “Oh my god that’s tight. Are you ok”? Peter said, “Yeah. No slowly push in unless I push on your hip”. Mike was amazed at the tightness as he did as Peter instructed and soon, he was buried balls deep inside Peter, “Your ass is so fucking tight. I can’t believe I’m balls deep in you”. Peter replied, “Ok, now start fucking me. Go slow at first and then give it to me”. Mike pulled back until he was almost out and then slowly sunk back inside. He repeated this a few times before Peter told him to fuck him like he means it. Mike started moving faster and soon developed a rhythm as he was soon smacking against Peter’s buns. Peter was moving back into Mike’s plunges enjoying Mike’s cock raking across his prostate, “Yeah! Fuck me straight boy! You like my hot ass”? Mike was loving the feel of Peter’s tightness gripping his cock as he fucked him, “You’re so fucking tight and hot”. “Yeah! Give me that cock! Harder! Pound my ass”, Peter grunted. Mike’s breathing grew more ragged, “Fuck! Fuck yes! I’m slamming your tight hole! Fuck yeah”! After a while, Peter turned over onto his back and let Mike fuck him missionary style. Peter liked that position since he could watch Mike as he concentrated on his fucking and it changed the way Mike’s cock slid over his prostate. Peter’s prostate was driving him over the edge as Mike’s cock repeatedly slid over it and soon Peter’s cock began spasming as it unloaded wads of cum on Mike’s chest and abdomen as well as his own chest and abdomen. A few drops even landed on his left cheek. The sight and smell of Peter’s orgasm brought Mike’s own release, “Fuck! I’m going to cum”! Peter said, “Pull out and remove the condom, quick before you cum”. Mike didn’t ask why as he was so close. He did what Peter asked and then Peter slid down between Mike’s legs so his face was in front of Mike’s cock, “Ok straight boy give it to me”. Mike didn’t have any choice as his cock unloaded onto Peter’s face and into his mouth. Mike’s brain was trying to register what had just transpired and his lungs were trying to make up the necessary air when Peter pulled him down and kissed him, sharing the cum from both their cocks. Mike’s head was spinning. This was all new territory for him, and it was both fantastic and terrifying at the same time. As they broke their kiss, Mike rolled onto his back next to Peter. Neither one bothered to wipe off the remaining cum from their faces and torsos. Peter eventually said, “For a straight boy, you are one hot fuck, especially if this was your first time fucking a dude”. Mike couldn’t help but to laugh, “I really did enjoy it and yes, you truly were my first gay fuck. Thank you for that”. Peter turned to look at Mike and said, “It was my pleasure, and it doesn’t have to be our last”. Mike considered what Peter said, and replied, “I don’t want you to get the wrong idea, Peter. I have a girlfriend who I adore”. Peter said, “I’m not looking for a boyfriend either if that’s what you were thinking. I’m just glad to have been here for you and I greatly enjoyed it”, then quickly licked some cum from Mike’s cheek, “Missed some”. Mike laughed and said, “I really like you Peter and if I were looking for a boyfriend, you’d be a top choice”. Peter smiled and said, “Thanks straight boy. Sorry, I can’t help myself, Mike”. Mike smiled and said, “No offense taken gay boy”. They both laughed as they faced each other and slowly drifted off to sleep.

About an hour later, Mike woke up suddenly. He found himself face to face with a sleeping Peter. He smiled at the cute sleeping face in front of him and recalled their night together. Peter was a sweet guy and he had a really great night with him. He considered for a while before making his decision, then decided to see if he could get up the nerve to ask. He thought of a way to help him make that decision and rolled over onto his other side and slowly moved back against Peter so that Peter was now spooning him. Mike pushed back into him and recalled what it felt like to have those fingers inside him, massaging his prostate. Suddenly, Peter’s arm reached around his shoulder and draped across his chest. Peter was still asleep, but the warm, tight butt against his crotch caused his cock to awaken and grow stiff. Mike felt Peter’s hardness pressing against his butt and it excited him since it felt so good and yet scared him because of the pain that would surely follow something that big entering him. His conflicted brain kept debating the issue until he inadvertently pushed back harder. “Oh fuck! Sorry Mike. I didn’t”. This time Mike interrupted, “Peter. Will you be my first? Will you fuck me? Please”? Peter struggled to comprehend what was going on, having just woken up, “Let me get this straight Mike. You want me to fuck you”? Mike was trying to steel himself for this now. This was it. The final test he needed to go through. At least that was his agreement with Julie. He had to do this, and he was resigned to have it be Peter. His cock was a nice size, not too big like Steve’s or even David’s and he trusted him. “I don’t know if I will be able to take you, but I want to try it with you. I trust you”. Peter looked into Mike’s eyes and realized he really wanted this, so he said, “Ok Mike. I’ll try to make your first experience a good one”. Mike added, “I cleaned myself up last night just in case”. That caught Peter off guard, but he smiled and said, “That’s good to know. No wonder it took you so long”.

Peter tried to ready Mike by fingering him, slowly adding more and more until he removed the four he was plunging inside. “Are you ready”, Peter asked? Mike’s cock was already leaking a string of precum as he positioned himself on his knees and elbows with his forehead on the pillow. Mike replied, “No, but yes. I need to do this”. Peter slid a condom on and lubed up his cock. Mike’s hole was already well lubed from the fingering. After wiping his hands off on some paper towels, Peter said to Mike, “I guess you’re as prepped as you can be after I had four fingers in you, but I’ll go slowly. Let me know if you need me to stop but try to relax. There will be pain at first, but the more you can relax, the quicker the pain will fade”. Mike looked back between his legs as Peter scooted up toward him, “Be gentle”. Peter began by rubbing the head of his cock up and down between Mike’s butt cheeks. Mike started taking deep breaths in anticipation. Then Mike felt the pressure of Peter’s cock head against his anal ring. Peter then said, “Now push back onto my cock, Mike”. Mike hadn’t expected Peter to want him to take the lead. He was expecting a sudden plunge inside him and he’d have to deal with it. Now, Peter wanted him to take the plunge. ‘Now or never’, Mike thought and pushed back. No penetration. ‘Fuck’, a harder push, “Holy fuck!”, Mike saw stars as his hole was on fire. He began taking quick, sharp breaths like he was hyperventilating. Peter began rubbing Mike’s back, “Try to relax, Mike. Slow down your breathing”. Mike tried and said between breaths, “I’m not sure this was a good idea”. Peter continued rubbing Mike’s back and shoulders and said, “Give it a moment Mike. Let the pain ease up”. Mike’s breathing began to slow and though he felt like his hole was being stretched beyond its capacity, the burning was easing. After a bit, Peter felt Mike push back a little more, “That’s it, Mike. Take it slowly. You’re doing good”. Mike felt full and he barely had the head of Peter’s cock in him, but like Peter told him, the pain was easing, though slowly. Peter was now rubbing Mike’s shoulders but was also keeping a firm grip on them. This way, as Mike would push back onto his cock, Peter’s grip would keep him from pulling back away. It seemed like it took forever, but suddenly Mike realized his butt was pushed against Peter’s pubic bush. Peter smiled, “You have my whole cock in you now Mike. You ok”? Mike waited for the pain of the last inch of Peter’s cock to ease before replying, “Amazingly, yeah. I’m ok but give me a minute”. Peter bent down across Mike’s back and kissed his neck and said, “No problem. Just let me know”. A brief thought crossed Mike’s mind that he’d never have thought he’d be in this situation, let alone position just a year ago. A lot had changed since then. Then he recalled stumbling upon Tony and Scott fucking and the look of sheer lust in Scott’s eyes as he begged Tony to fuck him harder. Mike’s own erection had softened from the pain of the penetration, but had now returned to full hardness, “Ok Peter, but slowly”, Mike said. Peter smiled and said, “No problem, Mike. I said I’d be gentle”, and then Peter pulled out slightly before pushing back in. He repeated the slight movements and little by little took longer strokes. Soon Peter was taking long, full strokes and Mike forgot about the pain as Peter’s cock was hitting something inside him that was driving him crazy, “Holy fuck! What are you doing to me? Oh my god yes! Fuck me! Oh yes”! Peter smiled as he noticed Mike pushing back into him on his forward thrusts, “You’re so fucking tight Mike. Take my cock”! Mike was lost in the sensations his prostate was giving him, “Oh fuck! Oh fuck! Give me that cock! Harder! Oh my god yes! Fuck me”! Mike’s pleas encouraged Peter and he was soon slamming into him as grunts and yells mixed with the slapping sounds in the room.

Steve and Ian were awakened by the sounds and smiled at each other. Steve said, “Sounds like Mike is fulfilling his promise and then some”. Ian giggled and said, “It’s a good thing it happened here and not somewhere other people can hear. I wasn’t that loud on my first time, was I”? Steve smiled and said, “No you weren’t, but let’s see how loud you are now that you giggled”. Ian giggled again and Steve and Ian were soon going at it themselves.

“Oh fuck! Oh fuck! Oh my god!”, Mike cried as his cock spasmed and began blasting wads of cum into his face and onto the bed beneath him. Peter felt Mike’s hole spasming around his cock and realized what was happening and it took him over the edge as well. He pulled out of Mike with a pop and pushed Mike over, saying, “Roll onto your back”. Mike was still in a daze, but he followed Peter’s instructions and rolled onto his back. Peter had yanked off the condom and as soon as Mike was on his back, climbed over him to straddle his waist. After only a few strokes, he unloaded his own seed onto Mike’s chest and abdomen as well as adding to Mike’s own cum on his face. As they both caught their breath, Peter looked down at Mike and grinned, asking, “So how was it”? With a look of awe on his face, Mike said, “Oh my god. Holy fuck! What did you do to me”? Peter grinned and said, “I was gentle until you went wild on me. Look at the mess you made”. Mike smiled and said, “We made”. Then Peter leaned down and kissed Mike, eventually lowering himself down on top of him, sandwiching the cum between them. They eventually fell asleep, totally drained.

Mike woke up and found himself face to face with Peter who was smiling at him. “Good morning, “Peter said. Mike smiled as memories of the night before flashed across his mind. Then his smile faded, “I’m so embarrassed”. Peter looked at him questioningly, “Why”? Mike said, “I must have sounded like a slutty bitch last night”. Peter shook his head and smiled, “Maybe slutty, but bitch, no way. You were all man last night”, then Peter kissed him again, then added, “We both need a shower and get all this dried cum off us. By the way Mike, you do look cute with all that dried cum on your face. Ouch”! Mike punched Peter on the arm and said, “Fucker! Why didn’t you say something”? Peter grinned, “It’s not like I let you walk out into the kitchen covered in cum”. Mike grinned and said, “You’d get more than a punch in the arm if you did”. As they came out of the bedroom, Ian was walking by and said, “Morning guys. Sleep well? Oh, Mike, you have something on your face”, before continuing to the kitchen, grinning. The dried cum on Mike’s face stood out more sharply against his now bright red face.

After their shower, Mike and Peter got dressed and then joined Steve and Ian in the kitchen for breakfast. Mike was quiet while they all ate until Ian asked him, “So Mike, I take it your pledge has been fulfilled”? Mike turned bright red, and Peter asked, “Were we that loud”. Ian giggled and said, “Let’s just say it’s a good thing the nearest neighbors are at least a quarter mile away”. Mike covered his face, saying, “I am so embarrassed”. Steve stepped in front of Mike and said, “Don’t be. What we heard was two people enjoying themselves and if that’s the case, then you have nothing to be embarrassed about. Don’t let Ian’s ribbing bother you. If you did indeed accomplish what you set out to do then I’m proud of you and if you enjoyed doing it, then that’s a plus”. Ian then added, “Steve’s right. I didn’t want to embarrass you, Mike. Sometimes my immaturity gets ahead of my brain”. Mike realized he was among friends and said, “It’s ok Ian. I need to be able to take a little ribbing”.

Just then Peter got a call from his dad. His mom was waking up. He had to leave. He finished his orange juice and headed for the hospital. As they were cleaning up from breakfast, Steve noticed a tear in Mike’s eye, “What’s wrong Mike”? Mike said, “Everything. I made a deal with Julie that I’d do this. It was to show that after I’d experienced sex with other guys, that I’d find I didn’t like it and everything would be fine between Jules and me. I did like it. Fuck, it was great. I can’t lie to Jules. I love her too much to lie to her and if I tell her the truth, I think it might be over between us. I can’t bear to think of us not being together anymore”. The tears were now streaming from Mike’s eyes. Steve looked at Mike and said, “Then don’t lie to her Mike, and don’t lie to yourself either. You need to tell her everything and hopefully, everything will turn out fine. Either way, we’ll support you”.

End of Chapter 62