The Cabin (ch. 2)
By CassiNotSoSure 5 Jun 2026
Short chapter. Caleb struggles to comprehend his first interaction with Julian. After a restless night, his excitement returns and he tries something new.
First Time Gay Sex Stories
GayDemon's gay porn library: in this story category you can read erotic stories & sex fiction involving first time gay sex experiences.
The Swimmer
By Will Bottom 5 Jun 2026
My partner and I heard a splash. We both ran to the sliding glass doors looking out to the pool area of our very private home. WTF?
The Most Fuckable Ass Contest
By StoriesByMattVane 3 Jun 2026
During an evening with friends, an innocent joke about who has the best ass turns into a provocative contest. Ryan, Max, and Liam agree to go through three tests judged by Matt. The first round reveals their reactions, tension, and control, while quiet Liam unexpectedly takes the lead.
Cole and Steve Find Each Other (ch. 2)
By Borehamwoodman 2 Jun 2026
As Cole and Steve explore their growing bond, Uncle Bill grows increasingly impatient with their hesitation and the lack of gratuitous sex between them as they cautiously dance around deeper trust and boundaries, frustrated that they are still holding back despite having already witnessed each other at their absolute most vulnerable.
Pleasure and Pain
By Topofthehill 2 Jun 2026
20 year old Troy needed the P&P treatment for his unexpected E.D.
Pride Goeth Before a Fall
By The Gemini Fox 2 Jun 2026
A Pride Special - Dylan and Jace spend Pride Day together in Chicago, discovering friendship, community, and an unexpected connection that neither saw coming.
Ron and Evan (ch. 37)
By Derek D 1 Jun 2026
Ron, Tony and Bobby are still camping, and Tony has a request he's not sure he can ask. Ron gives Tony a scare. Later, a strange encounter ensues.
Fucking The Fitty From Across The Road (ch. 79)
By Gazzaq 31 May 2026
Cary gets carried away and Rob lets this go but things eventually come to a head back in their home across the road
Paid in Full
By Chip 26 May 2026
First time leads to a profitable life
My Roommate’s Big Secret (ch. 2)
By StoriesByMattVane 25 May 2026
I slipped in quietly. Jack was sitting in a chair at his desk, with his back to me. Naked. Broad back, tense shoulders, a perfect line of spine all the way down to his hips. I didn't know exactly what he was doing until I looked lower.
Advertisement - Please visit our sponsor!
Billionaire Stud's Two Hot Sons (ch. 8)
By Horst Bowman 22 May 2026
18 y/o Carter Hepburn, is a star wide receiver, the heir to a multibillion dollar fortune, and a handsome stud. He heads home early from his trip to Ibiza. On the plane ride home, he has flashbacks about dirty encounters with his DILF neighbor Daniel that occurred shortly after he first turned 18.
My landlord of all people
By sandybotm 16 May 2026
Sandy figures out how to date an older man by moving in
Taking Care of My Roommate
By StoriesByMattVane 16 May 2026
When Mike comes home injured and frustrated, Matt offers the kind of help a roommate usually doesn’t. What starts as care turns into something more intimate, exposing the tension that has been building between them for over a year. One injured wrist, one quiet request, and everything between them begins to change.
Too Handsome to be in Jail (ch. 2)
By Will Bottom 13 May 2026
Bruno and Tommy Barder for protection
Doing a Straight Guy (ch. 4)
By Skyreader 5 May 2026
Tim, a straight hottie from my sports group, paid an unexpected visit one night. That was a surprise because he had ignored my invitation to do that several weeks earlier. He had been drinking a lot and one thing led to another.
In the night
By Birdman69 5 May 2026
After a few drinks and spending a short time in a gay bar who follows me to the hotel
My CEO and I worked out together in our underwear
By Will Bottom 5 May 2026
I was assigned to be the intern for the CEO of Gatwick Industries to complete my business degree. He turned out to a horny hunk who set his sights on me, Jude the virgin nerd at 20 years old.
I came all over my new Doctor
By Will Bottom 2 May 2026
My father started nagging me about getting a doctor immediately after I accepted a job offer. My girlfriend made the same comment. She was a junior in college studying pre-med.
Drop the bitch and make the switch (ch. 2)
By Will Bottom 1 May 2026
Andrew is stunned when his neighbor, Tomas (straight) wants to see what it's feels like to kiss a man.
My Summer Fling (ch. 3)
By Richard 1 May 2026
In the second chapter we saw Jason giving Chris a ride home. Chris then asked him if he wanted to spend the night, explaining that his parents were gone and they would have the house to themselves. It didn’t take long for the two of them to strip down and go at it again. Jason, realizing Chris had never had anal sex, invited him to fuck him. Chris
Advertisement - Please visit our sponsor!
First time
By Birdman69 30 Apr 2026
Unexpected first time turned into so much more.
Priests and Choirboys (ch. 2)
By 243907 30 Apr 2026
Carrying on from the 1st chapter, that got uploaded unintentionally
Sgt. Big Dick
By Man7975 29 Apr 2026
A straight middle aged lawyer gets pulled over by a young aggressive muscular police officer for speeding,but the lawyer found out the consequences is real "hard"!!
Tutoring
By Richard 18 Apr 2026
Nervous, but willing. Shy, but horny. We remember those days when we bloomed and had our first lover.
Special Delivery
By Richard 16 Apr 2026
Paperboy, soaking wet, letting me take his clothing off to dry, a bit shy. You know what's going to happen next.
Daddy Bred the Best Friend
By Jack R 15 Apr 2026
Craig Forsythe has been divorced for three years and has become extremely sexually experimental. His ultimate fantasy is to find a man to hook up with and he ends up fining it… with his son’s best friend Max.
Coffee Boy
By Richard 14 Apr 2026
A young man in the coffee shop has an erection and I take his virginity.
Pound of meat
By guymeat 14 Apr 2026
International student in UK university, studies hard, works weekends to try make ends meet; rent, stationary, lab necessities, seminar fees, food, transport and most dreaded is the termly high tuition fees foreign students lumbered with, Jake was drowning in debts and worries until his mate threw him a life line ...
1st Time: Devyn and Dwayne
By Danny Galen Cooper 11 Apr 2026
Two college guys afraid to admit the truth until that one stormy night
Spring Trekking
By S R Kingston 10 Apr 2026
Straight best friends Brian and Jason return from a spring hike, but Jason falls through the ice when crossing the river. Brian takes control and uses his body heat to warm Jason up, which turns into their first gay experience.
A son teaches his father a Lesson
By Will Bottom 9 Apr 2026
Steven Carlson raised his son, Troy, alone after his wife died in childbirth. When Troy was 18 years old, he told his father that he was gay. All of a sudden, his suppressed feelings came rushing back to him.
Ball Practice
By Ricardo Zinggy 7 Apr 2026
A fictional story about the protagonist having a brief erotic moment with a team mate in the lockers. 1st time experiencing a frot
Another Saturday Night and I ain't got nobody
By Will Bottom 4 Apr 2026
Cody and Ross made a double date with sisters Elosie and Harriet. The sisters worked at Haven Bank next door to Joe's Auto Shop. The woman were late.
Jack’s First Massage
By S R Kingston 2 Apr 2026
Best friends Ben and Jack take their friendship to an unexpected new dimension after Jack’s first massage turns into an afternoon of passionate first-time gay sex.
Eating Out
By Clark Wayne 1 Apr 2026
I always wondered what I was like to have someone eat my ass. I was surprised to find that a friend of mine had done it and was open to showing me himself. If I was going to experiment, it was going to be with a dude like him.
About our first time sex stories
GayDemon Story Library has been online since 1999 and is currently a topmost destination for reading the best gay erotica first time stories. With an extensive collection of gay first time experiences described by authors from imagination or reality, our story library is completely at your disposal, free to read and download. Any short story or novel you can read here is the creation of an individual author. Therefore, we kindly ask that you respect the writer's copyright and not repost the stories you like without their consent. Consider leaving a vote and a comment when you enjoy these gay sex stories, as it's a way to show authors your appreciation of their hard work.