• Broke Straight Boys Trial $1.00
    • 84 score
    • 16 Mar 2014

    Broke Straight Boys

    Amateur straight guys - and some who aren't so straight - suck and fuck or jerk off on camera for their first time or return to the site for more gay-for-pay action. Downloadable videos, 3 full weekly updates and some nice extras make this a site worth checking out.

    http://www.brokestraightboys.com

  • Straight Fraternity Editor Pick
    • 79 score
    • 2 Nov 2012

    Straight Fraternity

    Straight Fraternity is a great mix of college jocks and older men, with straight guys being serviced, shared jerking, sucking and sometimes fucking. With a varied collection of models and regular new arrivals, Straight Fraternity is one to check out!

    http://www.straightfraternity.com

  • The Casting Room
    • 78 score
    • 30 Jul 2014

    The Casting Room

    The Casting Room tricks amateur straight guys who want to get into the porn industry, gets them to strip on camera and gives them a thorough (and humiliating) exam before having them jack off on camera. Over 950 downloadable videos, an average of 4 updates per month and lots of str8 guys with uncut cocks.

    http://www.thecastingroom.net

  • Bait Buddies
    • 75 score
    • 20 Nov 2013

    Bait Buddies

    Bait Buddies is one of the better "tricked straight guy" sites around, with a nice variety of men. The site offers regular weekly updates, downloadable DRM-free videos, videos for mobiles, and plenty of hot str8 guys stroking their cocks or having gay sex.

    http://www.baitbuddies.com

  • Like Em Straight Editor Pick
    • 75 score
    • 20 Sep 2011

    Like Em Straight

    Like 'em Straight is a large collection of exclusive videos where amateur straight men find themselves involved in jerking off on camera or gay sex. Whether they are coerced or go willingly you get to see horny scenes that work well, run for a good length of time and deliver on the tour promises.

    http://www.like-em-straight.com

  • Str8boyz Seduced
    • 71 score
    • 11 Aug 2013

    Str8boyz Seduced

    Str8 Boyz Seduced offers over 600 straight boy jerk and blowjob videos, all of which are downloadable and also available for mobiles. While the site updates daily, it also hasn't grown in 2 years. Still, the content has a hot amateur vibe, and the guys are real first timers.

    http://www.str8boyzseduced.com

  • Straight guys 4 Gay Eyes
    • 70 score
    • 5 Aug 2013

    Straight guys 4 Gay Eyes

    Straight Guys For Gay Eyes features horny straight men fucking their girlfriends - but the camera focuses on the men. There are some solo jerkoffs, too, plus some hot porn stars. No updates, but with 439 downloadable videos, each with a set of pics, I had a great time in this site.

    http://www.sg4ge.com

  • Bait Bus Trial $1.00
    • 69 score
    • 26 Jun 2014

    Bait Bus

    Bait Bus is still chugging along as straight guys are tricked into the back of the van on the promise of hot girlie sex, then discover their partner is a guy. The 340 videos are exclusive and decent amateur quality, the theme is fun, but the site sometimes goes months without updates. Still one of the hotter gay reality porn sites ...

    http://www.baitbus.com

  • Straight Naked Thugs Trial $1.95
    • 69 score
    • 14 Feb 2014

    Straight Naked Thugs

    Straight Naked Thugs offers white bad boys from the streets. These straight amateurs jerk off, get sucked off or play with toys, alone or together. There are 123 videos, which you can download or stream. Full members get access to a whole gay porn network.

    http://www.straightnakedthugs.com

  • Debt Dandy
    • 68 score
    • 30 May 2014

    Debt Dandy

    These amateur Czech guys are in debt, and they go to the Debt Dandy for help. He'll pay off all their bills, but he wants an hour of their time, and they'll have to do whatever he asks of them. He makes them dance and strip, among other things, then they suck his cock, he fucks them and cums on their faces.

    http://www.debtdandy.com

  • Straight Rentboys Trial $1.96
    • 67 score
    • 10 Jun 2014

    Straight Rentboys

    Straight Rent Boys features horny straight guys getting paid to try gay sex or jerk off on camera. There are 183 exclusive videos, and the site adds 1 video per month. While trial memberships are limited, and there are a few issues, the videos are downloadable and there are some nice bonuses.

    http://www.straightrentboys.com

  • His First Gay Sex Trial $1.95
    • 67 score
    • 23 May 2013

    His First Gay Sex

    His First Gay Sex focuses on straight amateur guys tricked into gay sex. There are 297 downloadable videos inside the members area, weekly updates, and members get access to lots of extras. Unfortunately there is a download limit of 15 videos per month, but unlimited streaming.

    http://www.hisfirstgaysex.com

  • Str8 to Gay Trial $1.00
    • 67 score
    • 16 Aug 2012

    Str8 to Gay

    Str8 To Gay may not deliver many straight guys trying gay sex, but they offer well-known, muscular porn stars in hot suck and fuck videos. With over 106 videos and twice a week updates, this site may have issues, but the downloadable videos and heat in the action make Str8 To Gay well worth a visit.

    http://www.str8togay.com

  • Desperate Straight Guys Updated
    • 66 score
    • 19 Dec 2014

    Desperate Straight Guys

    Desperate Straight Guys offers horny straight guys (or supposed straight guys) having gay sex to pay their bills. You will find amateurs and porn stars in 113 downloadable videos with matching picture sets. Site updates several times per month, and there are some hot bareback bonus sites.

    http://www.desperatestraightguys.com

  • Massage Bait Trial $1.00 Updated
    • 66 score
    • 27 Nov 2014

    Massage Bait

    Massage Bait is a site for guys who love to see other guys being serviced in every way possible. Headed up by the world renowned Tyler Saint, the action is slippery and wet, hard and horny as he works over man after man. 99 downloadable videos but updates are uncertain.

    http://www.massagebait.com

  • My BF Gay Trial $0.95
    • 65 score
    • 9 Dec 2013

    My BF Gay

    My BF Gay brings us amateur guys from Prague who cheat on their girlfriends with other guys - and they always get caught in the end. This new site offers 13 downloadable and streaming videos, weekly updates and 2 straight-goes-gay bonus sites.

    http://www.mybfgay.com

  • Czech Hunter
    • 64 score
    • 24 Nov 2013

    Czech Hunter

    Real Czech amateurs get paid to suck cock and fuck in public locations in this POV reality site. The site offers 117 long, downloadable videos, and are updating weekly. And the site has a gritty, real feel to it. No English spoken in the vids, but lots of uncut cocks!

    http://www.czechhunter.com

  • My Husband is Gay Trial $1.95
    • 62 score
    • 20 Dec 2013

    My Husband is Gay

    My Husband is Gay takes on not only seduced straight husbands but also guys having gay affairs and men whose wives have thrown them out. The sex is hot, the men are horny. There are 54 downloadable full scenes plus 46 interviews. No recent updates, but good bonus sites.

    http://www.myhusbandisgay.com

  • Twinks for Cash Trial $1.95
    • 61 score
    • 26 Apr 2013

    Twinks for Cash

    Twinks For Cash offers horny twinks, jocks and amateurs in hardcore sucking and fucking and solo jerkoffs. The 153 videos are downloadable, and streaming is available - a good thing since full members can only download 15 vids per month. Weekly updates and lots of bonus stuff.

    http://www.twinksforcash.com

  • Gay Creeps Trial $1.00
    • 60 score
    • 11 Apr 2012

    Gay Creeps

    Horny gay guys sneak into bed with their sleeping or drunk straight roommates, man crushes, and guys in various roommate sex scenarios. Some hot voyeurism and simulated first-time gay sex. Bonus access to seven other sites.

    http://www.gaycreeps.com

Top