Best Gay Porn Stories

Explore the best gay porn stories, as voted by our readers. Featuring top-ranked stories with more than 100 votes & score of 9.4+, this collection showcases the most loved & highest-rated erotica. Whether you’re looking for literary masterpieces or kinky favorites, these porn stories have earned their place as the very best!

My Son's Best Friend

By Clark Wayne 6 Jul 2025

An older man develops an obsession with his son's best friend.

9.5 (109) 7271 68 Min Comments

Carl's journey to manhood

By Cigarlover 22 Jun 2025

A friend asks his ex-army buddy to take his son on a rugged wilderness trip to “make a man out of him.” The son, eager to impress the old family friend, who was always a cool, hyper-masculine role model for him, he doesn’t realize what he’s stepping into. Beneath the bootcamp facade simmers a darker, more intimate power dynamic. As the line between

9.5 (102) 3474 19 Min Comments

A cabin in the shadows

By GayExCop 10 Jun 2025

An ex-Marine takes a job with the Sheriff's Office. He needs a place to live. In the end, he finds himself and he finds a home.

9.5 (112) 3092 69 Min Comments

Rough

By ClosetCase 22 Feb 2025

Matthew, a virgin twink, visits a leather bar where he meets Todd, a dominant Top who turns him out.

9.5 (102) 5361 25 Min Comments

Honeymoon Cruise

By ClosetCase 9 Jul 2025

After being jilted at the altar, a young straight man decides to take the cruise that was supposed to be his honeymoon. There, he meets Brian.

9.4 (137) 4401 22 Min Comments

Risk and Restraint

By Topofthehill 26 Dec 2024

Adam's mounting debt leads him to an unthinkable proposition—one that plunges him into a world of control, submission, and raw power dynamics. As he navigates shame, desire, and survival, he discovers the limits of his body and the depths of his choices. A provocative journey of vulnerability and dominance awaits.

9.4 (108) 6177 29 Min Comments

Rescott Brothers

By Zane McGuire 31 Aug 2020

A straight brother asks his gay brother for a unique favor... What follows is an exploration of hidden desires and lots of playful banter and teasing.

9.4 (118) 7410 10 Min Comments

My alcoholic father

By AnalB8 24 Jun 2025

My hunky dad is drunk and asleep and I fall to the temptation…

9.4 (124) 6298 4 Min Comments

CD Hotel sex

By Jester4fun 3 Oct 2024

Sissy CD takes dick in hotel

9.4 (120) 9521 8 Min Comments

Traveling Together

By AtlantisGuy 24 Jul 2024

Years back, I met Jesse—a guy who, surprisingly, rocked my world. Now, years later... did I just see him again...? What the hell should I do...??

9.4 (123) 6268 64 Min Comments

Sketchy Drunk Hookup

By BurnAfterReading17 26 Oct 2021

I had a sketchy hookup while on my way home from a party.

9.4 (128) 9350 8 Min Comments

The Parish Priest

By Hunknown 20 Apr 2020

The small forgotten country church of St. George in Chains, in Southern Sicily, is being renovated by a brawny worker to welcome the new parish priest, who happens to be someone he knew very well, years before. The young priest will find very hard to stick to his strict education and his lifestile of celibacy, and in the end he'll be "forced" to listen to his body's long-denied calls.

9.4 (121) 7453 19 Min Comments

Best Friends Forever

By Lee Obrien 20 Apr 2025

Teddy Baker and CJ Miller have been best friends since they met in 1st grade. They are graduating from high school today and getting ready to head off to college. They spend their final summer at home with their friends and having fun.

9.4 (106) 5264 18 Min Comments

On The Run

By Oliver Amzell 11 Mar 2025

A chance encounter. Two brought together by fate? Time and their desires would sort things out… (updated version 2025)

9.4 (120) 2589 11 Min Comments

Pool Bear

By ClosetCase 11 Dec 2024

A straight married man has a surprise encounter with a hairy bear at a hotel pool in New Orleans.

9.4 (127) 6739 17 Min Comments

Aaron the hot masseur

By JonnyB 2 Feb 2024

I’ve had a few erotic massages but the one with Aaron was by far the best. He’s sexy, has a beautiful dick and was a great fuck.

9.4 (129) 8124 16 Min Comments

Tables Turned

By Coach Dad 30 Oct 2022

Coach Yates reconnects with an old star player who switches up their dynamic.

9.4 (128) 4705 8 Min Comments

Fun at the River

By B David Ethan 24 May 2022

Mark, a chiseled, well-hung sunbather in a secluded mountain river canyon, gets a surprising visitor.

9.4 (122) 4318 4 Min Comments

The German Lieutenant

By munichguy 8 Dec 2021

A young German officer and his girlfriend move into the condo complex where I live. He is curious about whether there's any truth to what he's heard, that gay men give better head than women. He seeks my help in resolving that question in his mind. I am always ready to assist a neighbor.

9.4 (105) 4438 10 Min Comments

Chis(topher) & Chris(tina)

By djfmonkey 22 Nov 2021

I met and fell for a crossdresser, explore chapter 1 introducing us, and future chapters meeting family and friends

9.4 (126) 4139 9 Min Comments

Rec League

By Bill Drake 18 Sep 2020

Evan Bailey crushes out on the coach of his baseball rec league.

9.4 (160) 6197 22 Min Comments

The Black Sheep

By A4F Tales 8 Aug 2020

Last Christmas, something happened between Cooper and his uncle. Now hot, mysterious, rugged Uncle Linc is back in town for the holidays. Cooper's grown a lot over the last year, and so have his interests. When he and his hunky black-sheep uncle are left alone for the evening, the stage is set for things to grow even more... Part 1 of a lusty 3-part #longread.

9.4 (108) 9378 44 Min Comments

The Short Straw

By A4F Tales 24 Jul 2020

The Stadler men have a family tradition. Two sets of fathers and sons, taking the boat out on the lake on Father's Day weekend to relax and unwind, and much, much more. Jason's a star football jock and the star of their special family tradition, and even as he pretends not to enjoy it, this pussy-fucking BMOC is about to show his true self to the men who know him best. An intense, lusty 3-parter.

9.4 (106) 10055 30 Min Comments

Affection

By Grant 19 Jul 2020

The farm was for his brother, for he had another path in life. One that would take him away from home.

9.4 (222) 6392 57 Min Comments

Mikey

By Phil 7 Jul 2020

Two young men are brought together by their love of athletics and prove to be an example to the world.

9.4 (111) 4676 28 Min Comments

Boy Next Door

By Danny Galen Cooper 6 Jul 2020

Mr. Johnson always knew Sam was special. Sam has crushed on Mr. Johnson since he first moved in next door. Now Sam's 18, and he shares his secret. Can Mr. Johnson 'ignore the boy next door' ? (This is a rewrite of an earlier story, "The Boy Next Door")

9.4 (133) 7074 14 Min Comments

David Was My High School Crush

By Danny Galen Cooper 4 Jul 2020

Jacob goes on vacation and runs into his high school crush.

9.4 (152) 5241 17 Min Comments

Dominating a Neighbor

By MaxPotter 13 Jun 2020

I discover the recon profile of my neighbor

9.4 (100) 15489 24 Min Comments

Chris, the Trophy Husband

By Robert Foley 3 Jun 2020

Jose needs a break and his friend gets him the opportunity to housesit for a high-profile author and her younger, very hot husband. Once he arrives, it becomes clear that Chris is actually not leaving and that there's much more to the couple than meets the eye.

9.4 (121) 5479 11 Min Comments

Searching

By Danny Galen Cooper 31 May 2020

Dan spends his Friday nights dating the wrong men. With nothing to do this Friday, he asks out the new guy from work. Lucas is quiet, shy, and cute. Haven't you been told that the quiet ones are the ones to watch out for?

9.4 (117) 2282 8 Min Comments

The best gay porn stories chosen by readers

Welcome to our curated collection of the best gay porn stories, chosen by you, our readers. This page is dedicated to showcasing the highest-rated erotic tales that have truly made an impact on our queer community. To ensure only the very best stories are featured, we’ve set a high bar for selection: each story must have received at least 50 votes and achieved an outstanding score of 9.4 or higher. These top-ranked erotic stories are more than just popular—they represent the pinnacle of reader satisfaction and critical acclaim. Our readers have carefully rated and reviewed these narratives, ensuring that only the most compelling, well-crafted, and memorable tales make it onto this list. Whether you’re searching for literary masterpieces that stir the soul, encounters between gay men or thrilling sexual adventures that keep you on the edge of your seat, this collection has something for everyone. These gay porn stories have not only captured the hearts of many but have also earned their place as the best of the best on GayDemon. Dive into these exceptional erotic tales and discover why they've been so highly praised by our reader community!

We Value Your Feedback!

Your experience matters to us. If you have any feedback or suggestions about the best gay porn stories featured on this page, we'd love to hear from you. Whether it’s a recommendation for a story you think should be included or any ideas on how we can improve, please let us know. Click here to share your thoughts with us!