First Time Gay Sex Stories

GayDemon's gay porn library: in this story category you can read erotic stories & sex fiction involving first time gay sex experiences.

Tinker Tailor

By Jak0b 12 Dec 2025

Polite tailor takes charge of visibly aroused young groom at fitting.

9.4 (130) 5572 44 Min Comments

A Dildo in the Wash, Reels in the Twins

By Mr.X 9 Dec 2025

Pete is 45 years old, well-established. Gay, single, enjoys group BDSM hookups. He gifts and donates a rental unit to the 18-year-old Identical Twin brothers, Ash & Zack. Under the foster care program, both were messed up by religious fanatics. The Two Boys cum out as gay, but absolutely know nothing about pleasure and sex between young men...Pete.

9.2 (77) 5656 21 Min Comments

Stuck in the Middle With You

By Jak0b 8 Dec 2025

Adam gets owned by his girlfriend’s father in their tent.

9.3 (133) 7891 21 Min Comments

The Unveiling

By ShyHottie 6 Dec 2025

A young 20 yr old named Ben meets Victor, a 55 yr old artist and finds himself in a situation he may want to experience.

9.2 (18) 1886 35 Min Comments

Gay College Roommates (ch. 2)

By BigJohnDoe 3 Dec 2025

After having his first gay experience, his "friend" returned for more...

8.7 (74) 4393 9 Min Comments

I Told Him I Cum Fast

By DanXWrites 3 Dec 2025

After a breakup leaves him insecure and withdrawn, Noah confides in his roommate Tyler about his struggle with premature release. What starts as an awkward confession turns into an unexpected journey of trust, intimacy, and learning control.

8.5 (67) 4582 9 Min Comments

Jake harper

By peterholt 28 Nov 2025

The taking of an army man

9.5 (36) 2332 32 Min Comments

Cum on Camera (ch. 3)

By 243907 25 Nov 2025

Our romance blossoms, and we fuck

8.6 (14) 684 3 Min Comments

1st Time: Dean

By Danny Galen Cooper 23 Nov 2025

You can find everything you need at your local Walmart.

9.7 (76) 4048 16 Min Comments

Lost Guy Learns He's Bisexual

By GrantsXploits 23 Nov 2025

Guy lost on an LGBTQ beach relaxes and we help him ease into his gay awakening.

9.0 (50) 3196 10 Min Comments

1st Time: Stuart & Lindon

By Danny Galen Cooper 22 Nov 2025

The day before Lindon heads off for college, he admits to Stuart that he's had a crush. But it's more than a crush--for both of them.

9.8 (77) 2521 33 Min Comments

Crushing on Caleb (ch. 2)

By str8ish23 19 Nov 2025

I was straight with a long term girlfriend until I saw Caleb. I wasn't prepared for what he would do to me.

9.8 (56) 2734 20 Min Comments

Freedom of Chains

By Txcubslut 16 Nov 2025

A story that introduces someone who was cheated on, and despite his lust for that world, he leaves it, just to be brought into it directly, and learning from someone willing to both love and use him properly.

9.2 (27) 1054 9 Min Comments

Track Friends

By Evan Russelburg 15 Nov 2025

Two friends finally succumb to thier desires.

8.4 (32) 2175 7 Min Comments

1st Time: Mark & Neal

By Danny Galen Cooper 14 Nov 2025

Two men, introverts, forced to meet by the good intentions of others, find a connection

9.3 (56) 2398 10 Min Comments

A Lost Bet

By Grant 9 Nov 2025

How far would they go?

9.3 (130) 7578 30 Min Comments

Seduced by my straight friend

By Playboy18 9 Nov 2025

Lot of hot sex

7.7 (21) 4324 4 Min Comments

Clay Pigeons

By Borehamwoodman 7 Nov 2025

Ben Jacobs owns a clay pigeon shooting range. Steven and Richard like to find the clays that are missed. As Ben Jacobs sets a trap to capture the boys, he regards as thieves. He also discovers the boys have a secret that they haven't shared with anyone until that fateful day.

9.6 (33) 1694 35 Min Comments

Helping My Roommate (ch. 2)

By StoriesByMattVane 7 Nov 2025

This Time, I Gave Him Something Bigger.

9.5 (119) 5861 6 Min Comments

When We Travel at Night (ch. 13)

By Chris Lewis Gibson 4 Nov 2025

Beside great Lake Michigan, the magic of Chicago leaves Jimmy, Flipper and Ross changed forever, and prepares them for the journey south.

9.4 (2) 137 17 Min Comments

Mr. J

By Danny Galen Cooper 3 Nov 2025

Kurt is an older man who has given up finding someone special.

9.6 (78) 3237 19 Min Comments

Stepdad's Cabin Fever

By Gaymoanmaker 3 Nov 2025

A dad takes his stepson to a cabins in the woods. What could go wrong?

8.6 (48) 5099 5 Min Comments

Trainer turns straight hole

By cant-think-straight 3 Nov 2025

Jax stepped up, positioning himself at the head of the bench. To get the best angle, he straddled the end, his sneakers planted on either side of Adam's head. As Adam pressed the bar up, his eyes flicked upward involuntarily. There, inches from his face, hung Jax's package—bulging against the thin fabric of his gym shorts.

9.3 (112) 5279 11 Min Comments

Tinder Dates (ch. 2)

By Augie DuPont 2 Nov 2025

Augie gets a Tinder match with an 18-year old freshman and experiences three hot sessions in a matter of several hours.

9.6 (9) 1106 16 Min Comments

My Straight Crush Grants My Birthday Wishes

By StoriesByMattVane 1 Nov 2025

My Birthday

9.2 (110) 5071 5 Min Comments

My Hung Roommate Keeps Teasing Me (ch. 2)

By StoriesByMattVane 24 Oct 2025

My Roommate Asked Me to Measure His Dick. I Ended Up Doing a Lot More.

9.3 (142) 8424 7 Min Comments

Out With The Old. In With The New.

By Borehamwoodman 22 Oct 2025

Richard Shaw arrives home to find his trusty boxers missing from his washing line replaced with pristine Y-Fronts and matching white vests. Flabbergasted and confused, the incident takes a turn for the curious when he receives a text message saying, "You will look good wearing these and please meet me at 7pm."

9.5 (25) 2039 32 Min Comments

Special Delivery

By Lee Obrien 20 Oct 2025

Beau is trying to make a little extra money after his girlfriend leaves him broke. On his last delivery for the night, he gets an unexpected tip.

9.3 (142) 6211 15 Min Comments

Myrtle Beach Campground

By Miles 13 Oct 2025

A chance meeting in the showers at a campground leads to a teen’s first time on the beach. This story is a combination of actual events and fiction. You be the judge!

9.2 (90) 3929 16 Min Comments

Sweat and Sawdust (ch. 2)

By Fox Emerson 9 Oct 2025

What started as too many beers turned into something neither of them expected. The tension between Andy and Scott finally breaks in the quiet of a small-town night, and what follows is sweat, sawdust, and a taste of something real enough to scare them both.

9.5 (67) 2965 14 Min Comments