First Time Gay Sex Stories

GayDemon's gay porn library: in this story category you can read erotic stories & sex fiction involving first time gay sex experiences.

CMNM Awakening (ch. 3)

By fegatan13 25 Apr 2025

The two older gentlemen help the sales guy pick out the perfect swimsuit for the nervous young muscle jock

9.8 (43) 2414 14 Min Comments

I Said Yes. My Ass Will Never Be the Same

By Fizzy040 23 Apr 2025

I always thought I was straight—until one night I invited a hung stranger over to fuck me senseless. His cock was huge, his moves rough, and what started as a fantasy turned into the filthiest night of my life. I didn’t just lose my ass virginity… I found what I really craved.

9.6 (92) 6294 31 Min Comments

Becoming a Himbo Slut for Coach

By aFFicionado 22 Apr 2025

Devin recalls how he seduced his gym coach for a passing grade and set him on the road to becoming a himbo slut.

8.7 (48) 5688 12 Min Comments

My Shy Roommate's First Time

By DanXWrites 22 Apr 2025

My Shy Roommate Oliver is gay

8.5 (93) 7301 4 Min Comments

Friend's Lips

By Guy fell in love with his Friend 16 Apr 2025

My first time experience with my Hot handsome friend

7.3 (15) 1955 3 Min Comments

My first blowjob

By Bottomonce99 13 Apr 2025

My first time giving head to a Older Man

7.8 (24) 3258 2 Min Comments

Hunted

By ClosetCase 2 Apr 2025

Dan, a married father of three, decides to visit a gay bar for the first time while on a work trip. Little does he know what's in store when he meets Justin.

9.3 (163) 8956 28 Min Comments

Finally Satiated (ch. 2)

By throwagay617 27 Mar 2025

Peter finally fulfills my deepest desires

9.7 (39) 2416 22 Min Comments

The Rainbow's Edge (ch. 3)

By carlsnap12 26 Mar 2025

In the aftermath of being forced into an act he never signed up for, Steve desperately awaits the invitation to finish the job, fully crossing the rainbow's edge.

8.9 (7) 625 35 Min Comments

My landlord became my Daddy

By sandybotm 23 Mar 2025

My first time my dream come true

8.9 (83) 5666 6 Min Comments

Learning to Drive, Learning to Fuck

By gloryandhope 17 Mar 2025

Jamie is 18 years old and learning to drive. Its the day of the test and he feels uber confident. How one small decision leads to a different kind of pass.

7.9 (23) 3591 29 Min Comments

Neighbors

By Aiden 13 Mar 2025

Stan’s neighbor has a secret and Stan is going to pull it out of him. Stan is a bold young man a few months away from his 21st birthday. Bill, Stan’s quiet, reserved and married neighbor is a little to interested in Stan. After getting caught watching Stan mowing the lawn, Bill is faced with an opportunity. It’s not what you think.

9.2 (86) 5094 14 Min Comments

Stretching

By Rio Mack 11 Mar 2025

Ben's GF doesn't understand a gym bro's needs.

9.1 (91) 6464 20 Min Comments

A menage A Trois In Indiana (ch. 2)

By Borehamwoodman 9 Mar 2025

Marianne catches Steven and Ralf red-handed and is quite upset, but somehow she sees her husband in a different light and perhaps Ralf confessing to being bi might bring some spice into everyone's life.

9.6 (21) 1172 33 Min Comments

Jake's True Love (ch. 4)

By 138b 8 Mar 2025

Two former friends and classmates are getting together after a year of separation from one another.

8.8 (26) 1219 8 Min Comments

My first time

By sandybotm 6 Mar 2025

Part two of the saga of young mature love

8.6 (43) 3292 6 Min Comments

Buying a Globe-Wernicke (ch. 14)

By Max Markham 4 Mar 2025

He nipped over to a chest of drawers and came back with some equipment. Included among it was a pair of handcuffs, which he quickly slipped on me. 

9.4 (2) 304 6 Min Comments

My first time prequel

By sandybotm 4 Mar 2025

My first experience with a top man while home from college.

8.7 (51) 4268 3 Min Comments

Perfect Love On The Isles of Scilly (ch. 2)

By Borehamwoodman 3 Mar 2025

The next morning, I woke with the sun, the light peeking through the curtains like a shy lover. I padded out to the patio; the cool stone tiles a shock to my bare feet. The air was crisp and clean, the scent of saltwater and blooming flowers a heady mix that filled my lungs and cleared my mind.

9.6 (19) 931 22 Min Comments

HardCore Fucker Guy for Bottoms

By CT Reddy 27 Feb 2025

Hi All Greetings from CTR from Bangalore. Hope everyone doing great. This is my first story let's go to story. There is a boy connected me through Facebook. He was texting me so I replied.

4.4 (15) 1479 1 Min Comments

Love Can Be Blind To the Point You Don't See It until It Hits You (ch. 2)

By Borehamwoodman 25 Feb 2025

Steven, Rachel and Josh become better friends and Josh has a desire to visualise Steven and to ride Samson bareback. Samson is fine about it but Steven suggests he shares the experience with Josh since he cannot see.

9.5 (19) 605 34 Min Comments

Chocolate Lava Cake

By Gray Rose 21 Feb 2025

When Chad's girlfriend breaks up with him right before Valentine's Day, it's up to his best friend to give him a V-Day he'll never forget. I forgot to post this last week. I hope you enjoy it!

9.3 (160) 6880 13 Min Comments

A Gun Deep Inside My Ass

By Paul François 20 Feb 2025

A young cowboy and a horse back rider meet in a pellet gun club. They quickly bond and explore each other’s body, including with a kinky twist.

8.1 (34) 2723 5 Min Comments

First Time With A Lifeguard

By StrykerJ 20 Feb 2025

I do have some experience with men. One guy in particular. It happened at the local indoor swimming pool. The first time I got properly butt-fucked, I won’t forget that quickly. It happened so unexpectedly. I could not believe it at first. I fucking loved the rudeness of it all. The first time left me lusting for more.

9.0 (104) 7166 8 Min Comments

Love Found In South Carolina (ch. 3)

By Borehamwoodman 19 Feb 2025

Tim and Mark plan their wedding as their relationship evolves. Mark's sister arrives early for the wedding and the three of them become friends and not just family. What could happen to change things?

9.9 (28) 754 29 Min Comments

One hot afternoon

By hiwayrobbie 17 Feb 2025

My exploits of youthful exhibitionism naked in my back garden as a boy of 21 which turned into a lesson Id never forget.

9.0 (20) 4013 15 Min Comments

First Time Surprise

By str8ish23 16 Feb 2025

My first time turned into more than I had bargained for.

9.4 (81) 5736 16 Min Comments

Selling My Anal Virginity To My Neighbour (ch. 53)

By Gazzaq 16 Feb 2025

Toby finishes his tale of how he came to be with Dag Long and just as he is finished in walks his boyfriend bringing in with him 6 pals. And with that we come to the end of their adventures

9.5 (8) 1257 12 Min Comments

Leather Den Daddy

By aFFicionado 13 Feb 2025

Devin tries his luck at a local leather bar with the intent to lose his virginity to a leather daddy.

8.8 (52) 3281 12 Min Comments

Raw

By Graham Nancledra 12 Feb 2025

On the site I'm doing Catch up. Publishing a number of Stories I've written during the last year, some at the request of correspondent's who have been so kind as to say they like my writing and my description. Here is one where for the first time, Gerren and Stephen fuck raw.

8.7 (16) 1472 21 Min Comments