• Frats Gone Gay Trial $1.00
    • 48 score
    • 18 Sep 2014

    Frats Gone Gay

    Frats Gone Gay is a reality-style porn site of mostly straight college boys doing gay hazing rituals and dorm parties, daring each other to try gay sex. The 77 videos can be downloaded or streamed, and they are good amateur quality, but the site no longer downloads. Full members get access to most of the sites in the Big Daddy network.


  • Straight Wankers Trial $4.95
    • 40 score
    • 15 Sep 2014

    Straight Wankers

    Straight Wankers features lots of European British and Eastern Euro guys jacking their uncut cocks with a few hardcore action scenes. There are 42 downloadable videos but no updates. This site's biggest strength is bonus access to 11 network sites with over 1,500 videos.


  • Dirk Yates
    • 71 score
    • 11 Sep 2014

    Dirk Yates

    Dirk Yates is synonymous with horny military guys getting off. These amateur soldiers and marines unload their nuts in solos and side-by-side jack-offs, and some get head or fuck. Dirk Yates is also a full-blown studio producing military-themed DVDs with gay porn performers.


  • All Australian Boys Updated
    • 74 score
    • 6 Sep 2014

    All Australian Boys

    All Australian Boys has delivered hot Aussie amateurs for more than a decade. The site has a nice collection of photo sets and over 500 exclusive videos. The guys are hot with nice bodies, including many surfers and jocks, and most are 18 to mid-twenties. You can watch them jerk off, get blowjobs and some get fucked, as well.


  • Gay Castings Trial $1.00
    • 65 score
    • 1 Sep 2014

    Gay Castings

    Gay Castings offers amateur hunks, twinks and regular guys auditioning in their first porn videos. Videos are HD, DRM-free and downloadable, or can be streamed, and the site usually updates once a week. A great site for those who like all sorts of guys doing their first porn shoots.


  • Gay Public Fun Trial $1.00
    • 68 score
    • 18 Aug 2014

    Gay Public Fun

    Gay Public Fun offers horny guys sucking and fucking in public places. They're athletic, good-looking and enjoy having sex while there's a risk of being caught. The 216 exclusive videos are downloadable and come with pics, and the site updates weekly. Full members get access to 11 gay reality bonus sites from the Big Daddy network.


  • The Great Canadian Male
    • 74 score
    • 15 Aug 2014

    The Great Canadian Male

    The Great Canadian Male delivers horny bi, straight and gay amateurs from Canada who get sucked, stroke their cocks, finger their holes, and sometimes fuck in duos and threesomes. There are 299 exclusive downloadable videos plus pic sets, and the site adds a new video once a week. Lot of uncut cocks and first-timers.


  • Homo Gay Sex Trial $1.00
    • 39 score
    • 12 Aug 2014

    Homo Gay Sex

    Horny twinks, jocks and regular guys suck, fuck and show off their asses and cocks in 121 homemade amateur videos. Homo Gay Sex offers videos that both stream and can be downloaded, and while the site no longer updates, full members get access to 2 larger amateur sites from the same network. Lots of amateurs jerking off, dildo play and ...


  • Nextdoor BFs Trial $1.00
    • 50 score
    • 11 Aug 2014

    Nextdoor BFs

    Nextdoor BFs features sexy amateur twinks and jocks who work their cocks and asses on their own cameras, or a few suck each other off or fuck. There are 668 videos as well as 82 albums full of selfies and mirror pics. The site doesn't update, but full members get access to two BF bonus sites with similar guys and content.


  • Straight Boyz
    • 62 score
    • 10 Aug 2014

    Straight Boyz

    Horny amateur guys get their cocks serviced through gloryholes or on beds and couches at Straight Boyz. The site is new, but already offers over 200 streaming full scenes that are good sized and play smoothly. Most of the guys wear sunglasses while they get blown by a very enthusiastic dick sucker.


  • Sex BFs Trial $1.00
    • 52 score
    • 8 Aug 2014

    Sex BFs

    Sex BFs offers a nice collection of amateur twinks and college-age jocks jerking off, taking naked selfies or having sex with each other. There are 1458 downloadable videos and 249 photo sets, but unfortunately the site no longer updates. There is a good mix of solo and hardcore action, and this is true amateur content.


  • Gay Porn Bay Trial $1.00
    • 47 score
    • 31 Jul 2014

    Gay Porn Bay

    Gay Porn Bay is a true amateur site focusing on horny twinks, jocks and other college-age guys. There are 1338 downloadable, DRM-free videos - some very short and others are much longer, but I was disappointed to note that the site no longer updates. Lots of solo and hardcore videos of amateurs stroking, sucking and fucking.


  • BigStr
    • 70 score
    • 29 Jul 2014


    BigStr brings us hot reality porn straight from Prague. The videos are long and entertaining and offers us hot straight guys having gay sex in exchange for cash. There are 195 videos and the site adds two new videos every week. Lots of big, uncut cocks and POV gay-for-pay action.


  • ExBF Trial $4.00
    • 49 score
    • 25 Jul 2014


    ExBF offers horny amateur guys stroking their cocks for the camera or sucking and fucking a buddy or two. There are 32 good quality downloadable videos that can also be streamed, but the site doesn't update. Not sure if this is real user-submitted boyfriend content, but the guys and the sex is hot, and full members get some very nice ...


  • Gay Revenge Trial $4.95
    • 53 score
    • 18 Jul 2014

    Gay Revenge

    Gay Revenge offers big-dicked amateurs and "ex-boyfriends" sucking and fucking or stroking their cocks on camera. The site offers 66 streaming videos and matching photo sets. Full members get access to 5500+ gay bonus videos.


  • 429 Videos Trial $1.00
    • 64 score
    • 12 Jul 2014

    429 Videos

    429 Videos has a huge archive of gay porn in many different categories. There are over 5000 streaming videos and about half of them can be downloaded, as well. The Boyfriend Tube section updates every day, but the site's content does not match the tour and video quality is so-so. Tons of content, plenty of cock, but no actual ...


  • Gay BF Sex
    • 55 score
    • 9 Jul 2014

    Gay BF Sex

    Amateur twinks and jocks stroke their cocks, play with sex toys or get it on with a buddy in their own homes at Gay BF Sex. Over 650 downloadable, amateur-quality videos plus 2 bonus sites, so while the site doesn't update, there's enough to keep members busy for a month or two. Some very cute boy-next-door types.


  • Auntie Bob's Amateurs
    • 63 score
    • 6 Jul 2014

    Auntie Bob's Amateurs

    Auntie Bob's Amateurs offers first-timers (and some second-timers) from cute twinks and well-built jocks to thirty-something average guys. There are 117 downloadable videos, and the site adds 2 more each week. And there's a nice selection of gay bonus sites and feeds as well. Expect solo stroking, guys getting sucked, and some hot ...


  • Gay Pawn
    • 55 score
    • 3 Jul 2014

    Gay Pawn

    If you love reality porn, Gay Pawn should be right up your alley. Guys come in to pawn their stuff, and when they need more cash, they get naked and give up their asses and cocks to the pawn store employees. Only 6 videos, but they're nice and long. Hot threesomes in an actual pawn store.


  • Teen Boy Models
    • 73 score
    • 1 Jul 2014

    Teen Boy Models

    Teen Boy Models delivers Australian amateur jocks and beach boys from 18 to their mid-twenties. The guys are fresh, boy-next-door types who either jerk off on camera or get sucked off by older men through a gloryhole. This site offers exclusive content, and while it has some quirks, the guys are fresh, hot and horny.