Gay Wrestling Stories

GayDemon's Stories: On this page you can find erotic fiction where you can read about gay sex involving wrestling or men wrestling.

I'm Not Gay (ch. 2)

By Alex Avery 12 Jan 2023

In the aftermath of Blaine and Lyle's hookup on Christmas vacation, Lyle struggles to make sense of the situation and the depression of losing his best friend, until at a Bonfire he gets more than he bargained for.

9.6 (197) 8036 52 Min Comments

JoelAlphaHunk v RedDante for the PR Alpha Stud Title (ch. 3)

By vinnymusclestallion 12 Jan 2023

The title fight begins in P.R.'s Choliseo between the Champ JoelAlphaHunk and Challenger, the Ginger Giant RedDante. As a naked and rope-bound Cortez watches helplessly, the two Titans go at it in the ring. Who will emerge as the P.R. Alpha Stud and what "stakes" are planned by the victor?

9.0 (8) 549 10 Min Comments

Wrestling the Coach

By Danny / Dane 11 Jan 2023

The singlet was tight, tighter than my usual uniform. It hugged my body, the white fabric stretched over my butt and bulge, straining with each movement. Devin wore the same thing, standing before me with a smirk and a heavy looking package. From what I could see, he wasn't wearing underwear. I wasn't either

8.9 (62) 5724 9 Min Comments

JoelAlphaHunk v RedDante for the PR Alpha Stud Title (ch. 2)

By vinnymusclestallion 6 Jan 2023

As JoelAlphaHunk gears up for his P.R. Alpha Stud title match in his dressing room at the Choliseo, he discovers proof that his protege, the huge Muscle Hunk Cortez, may be conspiring with the Ginger Giant RedDante. Now the Latino King must wage a war on two fronts. But don’t count him out. He is, after all, the P.R. Alpha Stud and drilling would-be Alphas is his forte.

9.1 (6) 501 7 Min Comments

JoelAlphaHunk v RedDante for the PR Alpha Stud Title

By vinnymusclestallion 1 Jan 2023

JoelAlphaHunk is still licking his wounds after being demolished and humiliated by SwimmerBoy in a hotel room match. Now he must defend his P.R. Alpha Stud title against SB’s compatriot, the Ginger Giant RedDante. And JAH’s protege, the Stud Incarnate Cortez, wants his own title shot soon.

9.2 (9) 882 7 Min Comments

Crushed by Tim (ch. 33)

By Fightlad 27 Dec 2022

For two years now! young rugby Jock Tim has beaten my ass with multiple scissors and choke holds. On vacation, he finds me again, this time it's brutal!

9.6 (15) 2534 7 Min Comments

AsianMuscleGod vs Blonde Tarzan JackedStud (ch. 4)

By vinnymusclestallion 26 Dec 2022

After Daddy Dom Sal’s interference, JackedStud has the upper hand and the AsianMuscleGod is in danger of reliving his humiliation in the shower stall at SUNY Geneseo three years earlier. Who will owe stakes when this epic match between two Alpha Hunks concludes at Sal’s gym?

9.6 (20) 2430 11 Min Comments

AsianMuscleGod vs Blonde Tarzan JackedStud (ch. 3)

By vinnymusclestallion 22 Dec 2022

The bell has rung. It’s finally time for the two Alpha Titans to wrestle for the chance to take on Champ VinnyMuscleStallion. Both Muscle Studs—the Blonde Tarzan and the AsianMuscleGod— want to demolish and humiliate the other. But only one will.

8.8 (19) 1236 4 Min Comments

AsianMuscleGod vs Blonde Tarzan JackedStud (ch. 2)

By vinnymusclestallion 20 Dec 2022

The Blonde Tarzan awaits the arrival of the AsianMuscleGod at Daddy Dom Sal’s gym. He wonders if he’s met Tanner Wu in the past. The name is familiar but the Tanner Jack Taylor knew at SUNY Geneseo almost three years earlier was barely more than a handsome twink.

9.3 (21) 1406 7 Min Comments

AsianMuscleGod vs Blonde Tarzan JackedStud

By vinnymusclestallion 18 Dec 2022

This is the prequel to the Fed contender wrestling match between the AsianMuscleGod Tanner Wu and JackedStud. At 21, Tanner was a lightweight wrestler on the SUNY Geneseo team. Three upperclassmen led by team captain Jack Taylor decide the Asian wrestler needs to be schooled….in the shower stalls after all. It is a humiliation that will change Tanner’s life forever.

8.8 (26) 2865 11 Min Comments

Steve the Amateur Wrestler Takes On The Ginger Giant

By vinnymusclestallion 13 Dec 2022

Steve Newbie was persuaded by his buddy Joe Wonder to attend a gay wrestling event in Jamaica Queens. It’s a special Tri-State Wrestling Federation night where one lucky (or not so lucky) fan in the audience will be picked at random to take on the Ginger Giant RedDante, the Alpha Dog with the fattest cock in the Fed. Steve has some amateur wrestling experience but will it be enough?

8.8 (25) 2339 16 Min Comments

Kept (ch. 2)

By Clark Wayne 8 Dec 2022

Matt, a closeted college wrestler, is propositioned to be kept by his married DILF

9.4 (143) 8772 16 Min Comments

Vinny Muscle Stallion v. SwimmerBoy (ch. 3)

By vinnymusclestallion 6 Dec 2022

VinnyMuscleStallion was on the verge of forcing SwimmerBoy to submit when JackedStud interfered and KO’d the Champ. Will VMS owe stakes? Or will his Coach and lover BlackAlpha rescue the Bay Ridge Hero. That seems doubtful when the Ebony Hunk remains tied up.

9.4 (13) 1362 11 Min Comments

Vinny Muscle Stallion v. SwimmerBoy (ch. 2)

By vinnymusclestallion 3 Dec 2022

The olive-skinned Stallion must defend his Tri-State Wrestling Federation title without BlackAlpha in his corner. Still, the Champ’s confident he can demolish SwimmerBoy. Stakes are on the line as the muscular hunks meet at center ring under the watchful eyes of promoter Dandy Dawson.

9.2 (9) 923 9 Min Comments

Mistaken Identity

By Str8SensitiveGuy 2 Dec 2022

A regular (ticklish) guy with gets thrown into the ring and a professional wrestler known as The Torturous Tickler, assumes he needs to pay for something he didn't do. In front of 6000 screaming fans, he gets stripped, tickled, milked and humiliated.

9.0 (31) 4418 32 Min Comments

Joel Alpha Hunk’s Pre-Title Match With SwimmerBoy (ch. 3)

By vinnymusclestallion 25 Nov 2022

Joel Alpha Hunk regains consciousness after screaming out his submission and being KO’d only to find that SwimmerBoy has restrained him. It’s time for stakes but, with a camera recording the action, the Aquatic Hunk has more than a humiliating fuck planned for the PR Alpha Stud.

9.7 (13) 1881 7 Min Comments

Single and Singlet Obsessed

By Paul François 23 Nov 2022

Gérard’s interest in sports is limited to wrestling, not to the match itself but rather to the sportswear and how it can give him a hard-on.

7.7 (11) 1754 3 Min Comments

Joel Alpha Hunk’s Pre-Title Match With SwimmerBoy (ch. 2)

By vinnymusclestallion 22 Nov 2022

Joel Alpha Hunk has invited SwimmerBoy to his Hells Kitchen hotel for a warm up match the night before the PR Alpha Stud takes on Vinny Muscle Stallion for the Tri-State Wrestling Federation title. The two muscle hunks have already trash talked each other online. Now it’s time to see which muscular Alpha Stud will prevail and take stakes.

8.8 (12) 1543 6 Min Comments

Muscle Stallion and Mysterious Masked Daddy Heel (ch. 3)

By vinnymusclestallion 14 Nov 2022

Vinny Muscle Stallion has just won the Tri-State Wrestling Fed Title after defeating Daddy Dom Sal (aka Blue Alpha Daddy). He and retired Champ Black Alpha are headed to a post-match victory fuck in the locker room. When they refuse a promoter’s request to film the celebration, the promoter sets in motion “Plan B.” Will the Stallion and Ebony Stud pay the price?

9.4 (14) 1526 14 Min Comments

Wrestling Nathan

By Fightlad 6 Nov 2022

I can't take my eyes off the muscular lad in the local store. He must be my age 21? he's giving me attitude, I want to wrestle him!

8.3 (29) 4198 3 Min Comments

Muscle Stallion and Mysterious Masked Daddy Heel (ch. 2)

By vinnymusclestallion 4 Nov 2022

The sculpted and smooth Stallion is in a world of hurt about to be KO’d in a face to crotch scissors by Blue Alpha Heel. And it’s not just Vinny’s ass that is on the line if he loses. Will the Mysterious Daddy Heel prevail and own the Stallion’s hole or will Vinny finally win the Tri-State Wrestling Federation title and become, with Black Alpha, the worst nightmare for BAD and Coach Stan?

8.7 (8) 1266 10 Min Comments

Muscle Stallion and Mysterious Masked Daddy Heel

By vinnymusclestallion 3 Nov 2022

With Black Alpha’s coaching, Vinny finally gets his second shot at the Tri-State Wrestling Federation Title. But a mysterious masked heel named Blue Alpha Daddy stands in his way, ready to manhandle the handsome hunk before putting him out in his signature face to crotch scissors hold. Stakes are on the line for both contenders and their coaches!

9.2 (12) 1988 16 Min Comments

Crushed by Tim (ch. 32)

By Fightlad 31 Oct 2022

Even by 20 year old, Tim's, standards, this is a punishing headscissors. His powerful rugby trained thighs, are impossible to escape. It's beyond wrestling and defeat now, he's looking for total conquest.

9.7 (12) 2089 3 Min Comments

Crushed by Tim (ch. 31)

By Fightlad 29 Oct 2022

Tim continues to wrestle me between his thighs. It's every bit as punishing and erotic as you would expect, from a twenty year old rugby jock like him!

9.2 (7) 1855 4 Min Comments

Crushed by Tim (ch. 30)

By Fightlad 27 Oct 2022

Joe is stunned when he witnesses 20 year old rugby jock, Tim, headscissors me. It's not just the way he has me on my knees, face down on his crotch, it's Tim's incredible thighs too. Tim's waiting for Joe to leave so he can get what he really wants!

9.6 (10) 1943 5 Min Comments

Dominated by Dwaine (ch. 7)

By Fightlad 26 Oct 2022

Turned in by a 20 year old gym jock, I jogg to escape my lust. The beach is empty, it's lashing rain. Local rough lad Dwaine tackles me, he's out of prison. We have a score to settle, someone's swallowing cum today!

9.4 (22) 3028 4 Min Comments

Crushed by Tim (ch. 29)

By Fightlad 17 Oct 2022

Rugby jock Tim has dominated Callum and I. Now we're wrestling for second place. I want Callum's ass.

9.5 (17) 2269 8 Min Comments

Crushed by Tim (ch. 28)

By Fightlad 16 Oct 2022

Good Looking, muscular, 20 , in his prime, the star rugby jock Tim. He biggest turn on? Domination, wrestling lads, punishing them! He's a master at it and nothing is more orgasmic than his headscissors. Today he targeted a strawberry blonde lad. Tonight I'm owning that lad.

9.4 (14) 1988 5 Min Comments

Brian's Obsession (ch. 2)

By Fightlad 19 Sep 2022

College Jock Brian has a new obsession, me! He wants to wrestle for ass? bring it on !

9.0 (54) 4801 9 Min Comments

Crushed by Tim (ch. 27)

By Fightlad 12 Sep 2022

Tim's my alpha jock mate. Every chance he gets he likes to submit other lads. With me it's total.

9.1 (18) 2758 4 Min Comments

Brooklyn Bodywrecker’s Post-Match Fun With Mr. Joshua

By vinnymusclestallion 1 Sep 2022

Brooklyn Bodywrecker’s match against Joshua Goodman is a BG East classic. After Mr. Joshua screamed out his submission and was stripped, BBW carried his prize to the locker room. What happened next was left to our imaginations. Now you will know what I imagined at least.

8.8 (27) 3042 5 Min Comments

Gay Survivor (ch. 8)

By WrestlerAdam 26 Aug 2022

Only five guys left when we become to the last day before the final. Who will take the four spots and which one will be out? Ending it all with a celebratory group fuck at the end...

8.4 (8) 610 6 Min Comments

Gay Survivor (ch. 7)

By WrestlerAdam 25 Aug 2022

Closing into the final, the guys needed to suck their way to the next round. And a bit of a hate match concluded the day in the elimination duel.

9.3 (4) 496 6 Min Comments

Gay Survivor (ch. 6)

By WrestlerAdam 24 Aug 2022

The paradise island is a place of making new friends and allies. But it might bite you in the ass if you are not careful....

8.8 (7) 844 7 Min Comments

Gay Survivor (ch. 5)

By WrestlerAdam 18 Aug 2022

The teams are getting disbanded and it is man vs man from now on. Something that gives the guys all kinds of emotions.

9.3 (5) 600 6 Min Comments