Page 6, Gay First Time Stories

I stole my first under garment, a jockstrap, Senior year in high school. I was 18 and didn't know why I stole it. My name is David Hall Jr. and this is my story.

8.6 (33) 2673 6 Min Comments

My Valentine Came With a QR code (ch. 8)

By Soren Kraft 19 Feb 2026

A 36-year-old consultant finds both routine and unexpected connection when he joins a new Arlington gym and becomes drawn to Steph, a clumsy, flirtatious younger lifter whose relationship with his girlfriend is quietly unraveling.

9.4 (41) 817 6 Min Comments

Our Straight Friend Needs A Little "Favor" at a Sleepover (ch. 3)

By Golden Ghost Pen 19 Feb 2026

Two high school senior friends helping their buddy out with making a video to impress a girl...but with drinks in hand, things don't go exactly according to plan...

8.7 (23) 3365 7 Min Comments

The Apartment Neighbor (ch. 10)

By JustinWritesXXX 18 Feb 2026

A routine coffee run turns electric when Leo’s flirting stops being a game and Ben realizes he’s the one being cornered. In the cramped heat of a Brooklyn café, jealousy, desire, and a single reckless question threaten to change everything between them.

8.1 (11) 406 5 Min Comments

Twins coming out together (ch. 2)

By Will Bottom 17 Feb 2026

On the Saturday before classes began new roommates Gary and Tim explored the campus together. Autumn was coming and the boys were become good friends. While their brothers were getting down and dirty.

8.4 (21) 1050 4 Min Comments

My Valentine Came With a QR code (ch. 7)

By Soren Kraft 16 Feb 2026

A 36-year-old consultant finds both routine and unexpected connection when he joins a new Arlington gym and becomes drawn to Steph, a clumsy, flirtatious younger lifter whose relationship with his girlfriend is quietly unraveling.

9.5 (53) 879 5 Min Comments

Father, I do believe I'm gay

By Will Bottom 15 Feb 2026

A gay pornographic comedy set in England. Alex returns home after a year at boarding school with a shocking confession.

7.9 (25) 1493 4 Min Comments

Just Two Country Boys

By Grant 15 Feb 2026

Zeke lived an isolated life until the day a stranger came through town.

9.4 (147) 3834 37 Min Comments

My Valentine Came With a QR code (ch. 6)

By Soren Kraft 15 Feb 2026

A 36-year-old consultant finds both routine and unexpected connection when he joins a new Arlington gym and becomes drawn to Steph, a clumsy, flirtatious younger lifter whose relationship with his girlfriend is quietly unraveling.

9.3 (38) 858 7 Min Comments

A Soccer Match with a Blowjob for the Winner

By Golden Ghost Pen 14 Feb 2026

Two 18 year old soccer captains, Jack and Matt, challenge each other to a soccer shootout with a lot more on the line than either straight guy was previously prepared to wager!

9.2 (55) 3041 13 Min Comments

My Valentine Came With a QR code (ch. 5)

By Soren Kraft 14 Feb 2026

A 36-year-old consultant finds both routine and unexpected connection when he joins a new Arlington gym and becomes drawn to Steph, a clumsy, flirtatious younger lifter whose relationship with his girlfriend is quietly unraveling.

9.4 (42) 827 4 Min Comments

Two Cabins, Two men, One Violent Storm (ch. 2)

By Will Bottom 14 Feb 2026

Having rescued Thor and stripped him of his wet clothes. Tries to wake up his naked neighbor as the storm rages.

8.2 (58) 2229 5 Min Comments

My Valentine Came With a QR code (ch. 4)

By Soren Kraft 13 Feb 2026

A 36-year-old consultant finds both routine and unexpected connection when he joins a new Arlington gym and becomes drawn to Steph, a clumsy, flirtatious younger lifter whose relationship with his girlfriend is quietly unraveling.

9.3 (31) 951 5 Min Comments

Ron and Evan (ch. 31)

By Derek D 13 Feb 2026

The guys play a different kind of ball, then Bobby suggests a camping trip to Evan's disappointment. Tony tries to convince Bobby to tell Ron what he confessed to Tony. He then tells Tony about what happened after the last swim practice.

9.3 (18) 427 17 Min Comments

Love on a Tropical island

By Will Bottom 12 Feb 2026

The Boss invites me to my first conference in Barbados

8.6 (46) 2348 6 Min Comments

My Valentine Came With a QR code (ch. 3)

By Soren Kraft 11 Feb 2026

A 36-year-old consultant finds both routine and unexpected connection when he joins a new Arlington gym and becomes drawn to Steph, a clumsy, flirtatious younger lifter whose relationship with his girlfriend is quietly unraveling.

9.3 (43) 1057 4 Min Comments

Rent Matthew (ch. 7)

By Jay X 11 Feb 2026

#7 Birthday Surprise – Matthew reveals a shocking secret related to Gordon's past.

9.1 (38) 1946 5 Min Comments

Wrestling Roommates: No Gear Required (ch. 10)

By JustinWritesXXX 11 Feb 2026

After his first foray into the world of gay sex after practice, Mateo surprises Jake with an unannounced visit to his dorm room where he's ready to broaden his horizons.

9.2 (14) 873 19 Min Comments

My Valentine Came With a QR code (ch. 2)

By Soren Kraft 10 Feb 2026

A 36-year-old consultant finds both routine and unexpected connection when he joins a new Arlington gym and becomes drawn to Steph, a clumsy, flirtatious younger lifter whose relationship with his girlfriend is quietly unraveling.

9.2 (50) 1254 4 Min Comments

Rent Matthew (ch. 6)

By Jay X 10 Feb 2026

#6 Birthday Surprise – The kid had taken everything off except his pants, and Gordon wanted them off too.

9.6 (35) 1963 7 Min Comments

My Valentine Came With a QR code

By Soren Kraft 9 Feb 2026

A 36-year-old consultant finds both routine and unexpected connection when he joins a new Arlington gym and becomes drawn to Steph, a clumsy, flirtatious younger lifter whose relationship with his girlfriend is quietly unraveling.

9.0 (49) 1617 5 Min Comments

Rent Matthew (ch. 5)

By Jay X 9 Feb 2026

#5 Study Break – Although he gave the kid a well-deserved study break, it was Gordon who got the better end of the stick.

8.9 (35) 1804 5 Min Comments

The Decorators

By 243907 9 Feb 2026

Realising I was in love with my mate

9.0 (46) 1764 5 Min Comments

Rent Matthew (ch. 4)

By Jay X 8 Feb 2026

#4 Substitute Payment – It was time for Matthew to pay the rent again.

8.4 (38) 2339 4 Min Comments

I Lost My Virginity Fucking the Librarian

By Zachary Zane 7 Feb 2026

While reaching for a top-shelf book in the basement, he toppled onto me. What happened next was better than any dream.

9.0 (65) 3871 8 Min Comments

Rent Matthew (ch. 3)

By Jay X 7 Feb 2026

#3 Infatuation – Just thinking about the things that he wanted to do to the kid gave Gordon a heartache.

8.5 (49) 2309 3 Min Comments

The Jock and the Gymnastic Coach

By Will Bottom 7 Feb 2026

A sophomore at Dragan College develops a crush on his hot new Coach. But is he gay or straight?

8.7 (55) 3828 4 Min Comments

Amster-Damn Hot (ch. 7)

By The Men We Crave 6 Feb 2026

Two best friend. One wild holiday. A romantic awakening.

8.7 (21) 1038 8 Min Comments

Lucas the Rugby Lad

By Shaneo 6 Feb 2026

Aussie lad Lucas was playing rugby league when Ben took him down. After the match, Lucas found the incredibly attractive Ben and discovered it was his birthday. Things took a turn when Lucas offered the player a 'birthday blowie'.

9.2 (70) 3085 14 Min Comments

Rent Matthew (ch. 2)

By Jay X 6 Feb 2026

#2 Short on Rent – Staring at the beautiful youth on his bed, Gordon was struck by what he saw.

9.1 (58) 3103 6 Min Comments

The Apartment Neighbor (ch. 9)

By JustinWritesXXX 6 Feb 2026

Ben wakes, panicked to discover he's slept naked with his friend Leo, their cocks throbbing between them. Is this a boundary broken and a line crossed or could this lead to more pleasure?

9.4 (6) 558 9 Min Comments

Rent Matthew

By Jay X 5 Feb 2026

#1 Short on Rent – Gordon owned a sizable property that he partially leased to students attending the nearby university.

8.7 (80) 5839 6 Min Comments