Broke Straight Boys
brokestraightboys.com 27 Sep 2025
Broke Straight Boys features college-aged, amateur, straight guys—and some who aren’t so straight—sucking, jerking, and fucking on camera for cash, whether it’s their first time or they’ve come back for more. 2,201 exclusive videos to stream or download on your mobiles, with weekly updates, 900+ behind-the-scenes videos that keep growing, plus plenty of extras.
Overall Score: 90 / 100
In This Review
Broke Straight Boys Review
Broke Straight Boys is a gay-for-pay porn site that started shooting in 2006, and this site has a split personality. Straight guys (and some with bisexual tendencies) in their twenties through thirty switch teams for an afternoon of carnal romping or they jack off in solo shoots to earn some cash to pay their bills. The guys here run the gamut from boys next door to bad boys to bistro waiters, and you'll find a mix of scruffy and well-groomed guys, as well as some with tattoos and a few with interesting piercings. Body types range from slender twinks to middle-weight wrestlers with lots of average guys and athletic jocks. Cock sizes vary, and some are nice and big. And while the guys in the older content looked more polished, the performers in the newer episodes come across as distinctly amateur and sometimes a little rough around the edges.
In the older videos, many of the guys do appear to be both straight and inexperienced, and they're sometimes in need of convincing (in the form of a handful of cash or some fast talking) to get them to do more. These are intimate videos where the director does his best to convince the guys to push their sexual limits for cash, but returning guys who decided this is a great way to make some extra money need no convincing. The older episodes sometimes try to trick the straight guys, telling them they'll get paid $100 to jerk off on camera and often convincing them for another $100 to let another guy suck their dick, and so on. The camera work and lighting are less than studio pro work, but the action is hot, and at least some of the supposed first-timers do appear to be the real deal.
The newer scenes are quite a contrast to the older. They're still mostly from 18 years of age through their twenties, ranging from slim to athletic, some with tattoos or facial hair, but they don't have that amateur look. There are still some first-timers, but a lot of the guys in the newer episodes appear in six or more scenes; Ben Dover did his first jackoff video in 2016, and he's appeared in almost 60 videos and may be found on other sites, as well. In the new scenes, the photography and lighting are more professional, and there's no director offering guys cash; the two guys sit on a bed together, chat for a few minutes, then get down to business, sucking, fucking, and shooting their loads. And they certainly don't seem to need any convincing as most of them suck dick like pros.
Broke Straight Boys now offers 2,201 videos. Streams are available in 1080p (full HD), 720p (HD), 540p (SD), and 240p (low SD), giving members a range of playback options. Older videos are limited to just 540p and 240p, and their age shows in the noticeably lower quality. Downloads, however, are more restricted and only provided in 720p and 540p. The newer content streams well across devices, while the older scenes look best on smaller screens.
Each of the videos comes with a set of pics. The newer galleries feature good quality digital stills, while the older sets include a mix of digital photos and screencaps at lower quality. While there are no slideshows, picture sets can be downloaded as zip files or you can easily save just the individual photos you want to keep.
When it comes to updates, BrokeStraightBoys continues to update every week with one new video. We’ve checked and verified that they are sticking to this schedule, with 25 new videos added over the past 6 months.
Member extras include over 900 behind-the-scenes videos including interviews, candid naked guys during the shoots, looks at the models and staff in public locations, i.e. Pride festivals, beaches, and other gay events. Members also get access to four bonus sites. One site, College Boy Physicals, focuses on sex with doctors or male nurses. You can find a link inside College Boy Physicals to Straight Boys Jerk Off, which no longer updates but has a collection of exclusive videos of amateurs stroking their meat. Another bonus site is Boy Gusher, and last is HS Boys, which is a portal offering tons of gay feeds. There is also the Message Board, where members can talk about Broke Straight Boys, sex, the models, and more.
Now let's talk about BrokeStraightBoys downsides. There's a pre-checked offer on the billing page, but it's easy to uncheck if you're not interested. By joining, you agree to receive commercial emails with no way to opt out until later. There are ads for live chat scattered around the members homepage including two rows of large ads on the bottom, but these are easy to ignore. The Links section is all ads, and the BSB Live link leads to a third-party site and requires payment for action or full nudity.
There are some debatable tour claims to examine. Despite the claim of "Unlimited Access", the site now limits full members to just 5 downloads per day, which is even more restrictive than before (previously 15), and far from unlimited. The site also promotes "Full HD Video", but the HD downloads are a size down from full HD, and the older vids aren’t HD at all.
Broke Straight Boys is a hybrid gay-for-pay / hardcore gay sex site featuring guys (some straight and some not-so-straight) willing to perform with other men (and solo) in exchange for cash. The newer videos, however, feature models who often don’t come across as either straight or amateur, giving the recent content a different feel. Still, there’s a wide variety of performers across 2,201 exclusive videos to download, stream, and watch on your mobiles. The site adds an update every week along with behind-the-scenes extras. What I liked most about BrokeStraightBoys remains the earlier amateur (and sometimes scruffy) straight guys going all the way for cash, plus the sheer size of the collection.
Pros
- Exclusive content
- Straight guys and some not-so-straight
- Mix of gay-for-pay and gay sex action
- Videos are downloadable
- Tons of behind-the-scenes vids
- 3 bonus sites
Cons
- Newer vids don't have gay-for-pay theme
- Members limited to 5 downloads per day
- Oldest vids much smaller, lower quality
Changes Since Last Review
- Added 25 videos in 6 months
- Download limited decreased to 5 per day
- More behind-the-scenes vids
Videos
Videos are available for download and streaming.
2,201 videos in MP4 format. Streaming available at 1080p (Full HD), 720p (HD), 540p (SD), and 240p (low SD). Older videos limited to 540p and 240p only. Downloads offered in 720p and 540p. Videos are fully mobile compatible.
Pictures
2,201 picture sets. Newer galleries feature good quality digital stills, while older sets include a mix of photos and screencaps at lower quality. Zip downloads are available, and individual images can also be saved.
Bonus Content
900+ behind-the-scenes and interview videos, 3 bonus sites, plus 1 bonus site has a link to a fourth bonus site. Member forum.
Site Issues
Pre-checked offer (called a cross sale) on billing page. Full members can download a max of 15 videos per day. Some exaggerated tour claims. By joining, you automatically agree to receive commercial emails with no way to opt out until later. Some ads can be mistaken for content.
Membership Prices
Special Offer: Just $14.87/month – 50% Off!
There are pre-checked options on signup page. If left checked, you will automatically be subscribed to another site.
- Monthly: $29.87 (recurring)
- Yearly: $99.87 (recurring)
Why You Can Trust Our Review
Online since 1999, GayDemon is your trusted, expert guide to membership sites. Our team of seasoned editors has decades of combined experience in the gay porn industry, providing objective & critical reviews with your interests in mind. We pride ourselves on being thorough, honest, & transparent in every review we publish. The review of Broke Straight Boys details what you can expect as a member if you choose to subscribe, providing an accurate overview as of 27 Sep 2025. Please note that websites evolve, and we cannot guarantee that the content, prices, or features will be exactly the same when you visit https://www.brokestraightboys.com.
At GayDemon, we maintain full editorial independence, and while we may earn a commission if you purchase through links on our site, this has no impact on our opinions or review quality. Our goal is to always provide honest, unbiased assessments to help you make informed decisions about BrokeStraightBoys & other membership sites. If you have any questions, feel free to contact us or leave a comment.