Gay First Time Stories

GayDemon's Stories: On this page you can find erotic fiction where you can read about male virgins and first time gay sex.

Straight Best Mate

By Jack Writes 24 Jul 2026

Gay uni student Jack is in love with his straight best mate Dean - a tale as old as time but with a dangerous twist.

9.3 (55) 2936 9 Min Comments

Fear of the Physical

By Preston Toushin 23 Jul 2026

A disciplined college athlete who prides himself on control finds it slipping the moment a routine exam becomes something else entirely.

9.6 (62) 3923 28 Min Comments

Beefy, Chalked Up and Taken Hard (ch. 5)

By Soren Kraft 22 Jul 2026

What happens when a thick, sarcastic factory worker walks into a boulder gym and straight into the hands of two men who want him exactly as he is?

9.8 (41) 1917 8 Min Comments

Blindfolded Bro (ch. 2)

By teenhungtop 22 Jul 2026

The stranger leaned down, chest pressing heavy against the jock’s sweaty back, lips brushing his ear with a low, cocky growl. “After all that shit you talked last night, jock… you’re gonna take it all.”

9.0 (44) 1567 4 Min Comments

The Silent Stares Between Sets (ch. 4)

By P Henning Writes 22 Jul 2026

Chapter 4: Borrowed Sheets

9.8 (27) 1123 6 Min Comments

A Most Unexpected Crossing (ch. 4)

By BumFun 21 Jul 2026

The voyage may be over, but neither man is ready to leave what happened at sea behind. As the Queen Mary 2 reaches New York, John and his “good lad” exchange numbers and part with no promises, only the ache of unfinished possibility. But when a message turns into an invitation, their shipboard romance follows them onto land, into a Manhattan hotel, a private terrace and one more night of desire, tenderness and discovery. This time, choosing ...

9.8 (27) 781 19 Min Comments

I’m Fulfilling My Straight Friend’s Fantasies (ch. 3)

By StoriesByMattVane 21 Jul 2026

Part 3: I Fulfilled His Shower Fantasy

9.3 (31) 2059 6 Min Comments

Rowing Jocks Team Bonding (ch. 13)

By JustinWritesXXX 21 Jul 2026

Rowing partners Luke and Mark capsize in the pre-dawn river, their suppressed tension boiling over into a passionate, wet encounter against the overturned shell and into much more.

9.8 (6) 474 10 Min Comments

The Lad's Holiday (ch. 3)

By Spiritual Camera 21 Jul 2026

Things continue to escalate between the boys and they push their boundaries ever further

9.6 (16) 1091 9 Min Comments

Pageant Boys

By SluttyPrince27 20 Jul 2026

George only joined the Mr. Accountancy pageant because his classmate talked him into it. Winning was never his goal - until he met guys at the competition. As rehearsals bring them closer, admiration slowly turns into something he did not expected. What began as competition soon becomes a journey of self-discovery and finding the courage to embrace who he truly is.

8.4 (9) 432 6 Min Comments

Pinned by the Straight Wrestling Champ (ch. 2)

By Spiritual Camera 20 Jul 2026

Everything has changed for these two best friends - when your best mate makes it clear he wants your dick it's hard to go back to normal

8.6 (15) 1864 4 Min Comments

Rushing ΔΚΣ ("Dicks") (ch. 7)

By KaiAfterPractice 20 Jul 2026

I'd been a yes my whole life. Turns out the terrifying part isn't saying yes to somebody. It's being the one who asks.

9.1 (23) 581 12 Min Comments

How it all began

By BirminghamBoy 18 Jul 2026

This is a partially true story with some fiction as to how I was introduced to men.

8.5 (30) 2822 10 Min Comments

My Roommates Took Care of My Every Need

By StoriesByMattVane 18 Jul 2026

Matt returns to the apartment with an injured wrist and quickly realizes that it limits him more than he expected. When his growing tension becomes a problem, his confident roommate Ryan notices the situation and offers intimate help. The encounter changes the atmosphere between them.

9.2 (88) 3915 8 Min Comments

The Famous Footballer Off the Pitch (ch. 6)

By DanXWrites 18 Jul 2026

After the most perfect night of his life, Noah wakes up to silence. No texts. No calls. Javier has completely disappeared, blocking him without a word. What felt like the beginning of something real becomes devastating emptiness, leaving Noah replaying every touch, every moan, and wondering if he was ever more than a secret one-night fantasy to his idol.

9.0 (17) 680 4 Min Comments

Wrestling Roommates: No Gear Required (ch. 21)

By JustinWritesXXX 18 Jul 2026

Wrestling roommates Asher and Jake navigate their complex relationship and sexual awakening through intense drills and erotic encounters.

8.4 (7) 444 7 Min Comments

Baby Factory

By Mike Harrigan 17 Jul 2026

A drunken encounter on Prom Night sends Tyler Reynolds and his dad Rick forever changes their relationship and sets them both on a new path they never knew was possible.

9.8 (44) 6461 58 Min Comments

My Roommate’s Big Secret (ch. 4)

By StoriesByMattVane 17 Jul 2026

Part 4: The Guys Finally Saw the Truth About Jack

9.6 (41) 2306 5 Min Comments

Papa Manuel (ch. 6)

By Akira Nishimura 17 Jul 2026

Ken and Manuel meet Dr. Bezerra for their doctor's appointment.

8.7 (1) 461 21 Min Comments

The Silent Stares Between Sets (ch. 3)

By P Henning Writes 17 Jul 2026

Chapter 3 - No More Breaks.

9.8 (31) 1029 4 Min Comments

Beefy, Chalked Up and Taken Hard (ch. 4)

By Soren Kraft 16 Jul 2026

What happens when a thick, sarcastic factory worker walks into a boulder gym and straight into the hands of two men who want him exactly as he is?

9.7 (40) 2167 9 Min Comments

Thinking Straight

By Brown_Munda 15 Jul 2026

One hundred percent I am straight... I was having a girlfriend with whom I recently broke up. But why Brad's peck on my cheek changed everything... AM I GAY?

7.7 (27) 3037 3 Min Comments

A Most Unexpected Crossing (ch. 3)

By BumFun 14 Jul 2026

On the fourth day of a transatlantic crossing, Adam wakes in John’s arms and discovers that what began as desire is becoming something deeper. Through humour, tenderness and a refusal to be shamed, he learns to stop hiding and trust the happiness he has found. But with New York drawing closer and real life waiting ashore, their final days at sea force them to face what this connection means, whether it can survive beyond the ship, and who Adam ...

9.7 (31) 760 73 Min Comments

A Most Unexpected Crossing (ch. 2)

By BumFun 13 Jul 2026

Shaken by a stranger’s cruel judgement, he retreats to his cabin questioning everything the night with John awakened. But as shame gives way to hunger, humour and an undeniable desire for more, their connection deepens beyond sex into trust, tenderness and public affection. Against the unlikely elegance of a transatlantic cruise, he begins to realise that accepting what feels right may be far less frightening than continuing to hide from it.

9.8 (37) 793 69 Min Comments

A Most Unexpected Crossing

By BumFun 12 Jul 2026

After sacrificing years of his life to building a successful business, a solitary businessman boards a transatlantic cruise expecting nothing more than peace, whisky and ocean views. Instead, an unexpected connection with an older traveller leads to a night of passion, vulnerability and startling self-discovery, forcing him to confront desire, judgement and what it truly means to accept himself.

9.8 (43) 1430 19 Min Comments

Beefy, Chalked Up and Taken Hard (ch. 2)

By Soren Kraft 12 Jul 2026

What happens when a thick, sarcastic factory worker walks into a boulder gym and straight into the hands of two men who want him exactly as he is?

9.1 (40) 2731 9 Min Comments

Private Tutoring Lessons (ch. 3)

By StoriesByTroy 12 Jul 2026

Evan showed up at Maxwell’s apartment expecting a quiet tutoring session and strict rules. What he got instead was the professors hands under his shirt, clothes on the floor, and the kind of night that turns forbidden tension into something neither of them can walk away from. Some lessons are best learned with your legs wrapped around your tutor.

9.4 (28) 1471 6 Min Comments

Rushing ΔΚΣ ("Dicks") (ch. 6)

By KaiAfterPractice 12 Jul 2026

He was from the Springs like me. He said "I get it," and I almost couldn't breathe, which made no sense, because nobody had even taken their shirt off.

9.2 (22) 721 8 Min Comments

The Silent Stares Between Sets

By P Henning Writes 12 Jul 2026

Every morning at 5:30, the gym belongs to them alone.For over a year, Nico has quietly obsessed over the straight boy next door — the lean, taken man who lives with his girlfriend just buildings away. What begins as stolen glances and silent tension slowly spirals into something risky, addictive, and impossible to resist… while Nico is in an open relationship of his own.

9.3 (50) 2513 5 Min Comments

Warhammer, Grindr, and the Glorious Realisation

By BumFun 12 Jul 2026

A funny, filthy and unexpectedly tender story about a bearded Warhammer fan finally exploring a desire he has avoided for years. What begins as a nervous Grindr encounter above an Italian restaurant becomes a night of discovery, intimacy and gloriously ridiculous pleasure.

8.9 (12) 740 7 Min Comments

I Played the Sex Game with My Straight Friends

By StoriesByMattVane 11 Jul 2026

Bored with another slow evening, Matt proposes a daring game to his straight friends, Justin and Noah, based on drawing names, body parts, and sexual acts.

9.2 (84) 4291 6 Min Comments

Beefy, Chalked Up and Taken Hard

By Soren Kraft 10 Jul 2026

What happens when a thick, sarcastic factory worker walks into a boulder gym and straight into the hands of two men who want him exactly as he is?

8.9 (38) 4355 6 Min Comments

Rowing Jocks Team Bonding (ch. 12)

By JustinWritesXXX 10 Jul 2026

Rowing partners Luke and Mark capsize in the pre-dawn river, their suppressed tension boiling over into a passionate, wet encounter against the overturned shell and into much more.

9.2 (9) 456 6 Min Comments

The Beggar's Claim

By Vivian 10 Jul 2026

A cocky 19-year-old bully secretly tries his first same-sex encounter with a rugged stranger behind an abandoned building. What begins as a simple thrill quickly becomes an intense, prolonged session of passion and dominance that leaves him marked and deeply changed.

8.4 (32) 2858 3 Min Comments

Fucking The Fitty From Across The Road (ch. 91)

By Gazzaq 9 Jul 2026

Sorin is still fucking his boyfriends Kevin’s father Kyle taking his arse virginity and has lots and lots of sex with him, before it all come to an end. On his way to work on the tube Kyle is distracted by a number of male commuters

9.4 (6) 555 16 Min Comments