str8ish23

Below you can find the complete collection of stories by str8ish23.

Crushing on Caleb (ch. 2)

19 Nov 2025 comments

I was straight with a long term girlfriend until I saw Caleb. I wasn't prepared for what he would do to me.

9.7 (61) 2990 Reads 20 Min

Crushing on Caleb

13 Nov 2025 comments

I was straight with a long term girlfriend until I saw Caleb. I wasn't prepared for what he would do to me.

9.4 (119) 4706 Reads 22 Min

First Time on New Years

6 Aug 2025 comments

A New Years' Eve party senior year of high school goes in unexpected ways.

9.2 (94) 4465 Reads 13 Min

First Time Surprise

16 Feb 2025 comments

My first time turned into more than I had bargained for.

9.5 (97) 8237 Reads 16 Min

First Time on New Years (ch. 2)

23 Oct 2023 comments

A New Years' Eve party senior year goes in unexpected ways.

9.5 (67) 2907 Reads 8 Min

First Time on New Years

18 Oct 2023 comments

A New Years' Eve party senior year goes in unexpected ways.

8.8 (63) 3047 Reads 5 Min