Teddy
I felt the heat rush to my face when CJ said that Meg asked if I was single. Meg was just as good-looking as Wendy; she had short dark brown hair and very pretty brown eyes. Her boobs were a little bigger than Wendy’s, but Wendy had a little nicer ass. Not that Meg’s ass wasn’t nice. I stammered as I tried to think of a response.
I saw her look upset as she said, “it’s ok, if you don’t like me.”
I took a deep breath, I had told myself that I wasn’t going to hide who I was, I told her I was gay. She was the first person that I told that, besides my family, CJ and Wendy. I was glad that she understood and by the end of the weekend we were friends. She was even joking about us going out to find guys together. I guess I was glad that CJ and Wendy were letting me decide who I wanted to tell that I was gay. They had kept their promise not to tell everyone.
We all got settled into our routine, CJ had practice after his classes, I was spending most of my time studying, just as I had done in high school. Wendy and Meg were spending time in our room, and we were spending time in theirs. The dorm we lived in was coed, the girls on the first floor and guys on the second. We just had to leave each other’s room by 10pm. The dorm manager was an older lady and every night she would announce over the PA system that visiting hours were over and quiet hours were now in effect. We were always in our rooms by 10, the manager was a stickler for the rules. I was liking my classes and had made a few new friends, but had yet to meet anyone that I was sure was gay. I did see a few guys around campus that were obviously gay, they were flamboyant and acted very feminine. I was happy that they were being themselves, but I was attracted to more masculine guys, jocks mostly. I still was not sure how I was going to find those guys, but the search continued.
We were a few weeks into the semester when CJ came into the room, all smiles.
He said, “I invited a teammate of mine over to study, would you help us with our math homework?”
I helped all our friends with their math homework all through high school, so I was used to it.
I said, “sure, I’m just about done with my homework anyway.”
CJ smiled, “thanks Teddy, I appreciate it, he should be here in about an hour.”
I nodded, “ok, I went for a run after classes, I guess I should grab a shower before he gets here.”
After my shower, I threw on a pair of shorts and a t-shirt and sat back on bed to study a bit more until CJ’s friend arrived, CJ was doing the same. We heard a knock and CJ jumped up to answer the door.
My eyes went wide when I saw him walk in, he was gorgeous. His coffee brown eyes were the first thing that I noticed, they were beautiful. Like me, he was wearing a t-shirt, shorts and a pair of high-top Reeboks. His perfectly smooth brown skin contrasted with the white shirt he was wearing and the bright white teeth he flashed when he smiled. That smile caused his eyes to squint, almost closed. Shit, it was going to be hard to control the twitching I was suddenly feeling in my shorts while we studied.
CJ introduced us and invited Dom inside. He only got better looking as he walked closer to me. We moved some chairs around my desk, and I had CJ and Dom show what they were working on. I was a bit surprised; I know CJ had no issues with these type of problems in high school. It made more sense that Dom was struggling as he told me about his school back in Puerto Rico. CJ was just sitting there grinning at me as I tried to help Dom without drooling all over him. What the hell was he up to? I went over the problems with them for about a half hour.
CJ’s grin got bigger when he looked at his watch and said, “oh shit, I was supposed to meet Wendy 10 minutes ago.”
He jumped up and walked out the door. Dom asked, “who is Wendy?”
I said, “she’s CJ’s girlfriend.”
Dom nodded, “oh, I guess I should be going to then.”
I said, “well, we aren’t done with your homework yet, you are welcome to stay, I don’t mind helping.”
He smiled, “thanks.”
My mind was racing, did CJ know something about Dom that he didn’t tell me? Did he set this whole thing up. I tried to concentrate and get back to helping Dom, God he smelled so good. I don’t know if was just the soap that he used or if he was wearing cologne, but it was driving me crazy. We continued to work for another hour, Dom was finally understanding the problems.
As he finished the last one, he smiled and put his hand on my arm, “I think it makes sense now, thank you so much.”
I froze at his touch, it felt like 1000 volts of electricity was running through my arm. Our eyes locked on each other when Dom realized what he had done, he quickly pulled his hand away and blushed.
He looked down at my arm and said, “you have very hairy arms.”
I nodded, “yeah, I guess I do.”
He ran his hands up my arm again, I remained frozen, not sure what to do or say. He moved his hand to my bare leg, pausing his hand on my knee. He said, “hairy legs too.” My mouth went dry as I again just nodded.
His eyes once again locked on mine and he said, “I don’t have any hair at all.” I of course had already noticed that the second he walked into my room.
He swallowed hard and continued, “I’m sure you have a hairy chest too.”
Still unable to find any words, I just nodded. Dom reached down and started to pull my shirt up, I didn’t stop him. He pulled my shirt completely off and was soon running his hand across my chest. The electricity in my body only increased at his touch. He kept his eyes locked on mine and quickly pulled his own shirt off. I gasped when I saw his ripped abs and muscular chest, he was perfect, like every wet dream I had ever had. He took my hand and placed it on his chest as he continued to explore mine. I slowly moved my hand around, tracing every ridge and muscle. Our eyes remained locked on each other as he slowly leaned closer to me, until our lips finally met. We were now up to 100,000 volts.
Dom pulled me to my feet and wrapped his arms around me, our bare chest now tight against each other. It felt amazing. I could feel our hard cocks rubbing against each other through our shorts as we started to kiss. My first real kiss with a man was far more than I ever expected, Dom’s lips were so soft. I was surprised that I was good at kissing, considering I had never done it before, at least I hoped I was good at it. Dom grabbed my ass as we continued to make out. My hands instinctively went to his ass, and I started to squeeze it, just as he was doing to me.
Dom broke our kiss and smiled as he stepped back slightly, he said, “that was nice.”
I squeaked out, “it was amazing.”
He locked his eyes back on mine as he slid his fingers under the waistband of my shorts and pushed them off my hips, they fell to the floor. He looked down at my hard cock and smiled, “that is nice too.” I’m sure I was blushing as he slowly went to his knees in front of me. I nearly melted into a puddle on the floor when Dom licked the precum that had formed on the head my dick. I looked down as he swallowed me, I’m sure my cock had never been this big or hard in my life. I grabbed his shoulders when my knees buckled as my cock was now completely down Dom’s throat. It only took a minute for me to feel my nuts tighten, I pulled Dom up for another kiss before I shot my load. I panted, “I want to suck you before I cum.” He grinned, “do whatever you want.” I sat on the edge of my bed, he kicked off his shoes and was standing in front of me, his hard cock formed a tent in his shorts. I pulled his shorts over his erection and let them fall to the floor. I felt the breath leave my lungs as I was staring at the first uncut that I had ever seen. I guess I did see one in a porn magazine that my brother had snuck into the house when he was in college. It was a scene with a hung black guy fucking a girl, seeing an uncut cock in person was so much hotter. About a quarter of the pink head was peeking out of the foreskin, a drop of clear precum was just about to drip. I quickly stuck my tongue out to catch it, God it was the most delicious thing I have ever tasted. Dom let out a deep moan as I sucked his manhood into my mouth as far as I could. I didn’t take him quite as far as he took me, but with every try, I was getting further.
Dom pushed me away and said, “you had me close.” He leaned down for another kiss, and we fell back on the bed, kissing with Dom on top of me. Our naked bodies were rubbing against each other, I loved the feel of the skin-to-skin contact. Dom broke our kiss and asked, “do you want to try something else?” I sighed and nodded, “sure.” He grinned as he kissed his way down my chest and gave my cock a quick lick. He rolled my nuts around in his mouth for a bit and pushed my legs into the air, not sure what was coming next. I almost jumped out of my skin when I felt his tongue rake across my hole. I groaned as Dom worked over my hole, I had never considered that I would like my ass licked, but it was amazing. I held my ankles tight pulling my legs up as far as I could, wanting to give Dom all the access he wanted. Just as I thought I couldn’t take it any longer, Dom got off the bed and grabbed something from his backpack. When he turned back around, he was rolling a condom on his hard cock. I was so excited and nervous at the same time.
Dom asked, “you ok with this?”
I nodded, “yeah, just go slow, it’s my first time.”
He smiled, “I got you baby. You have any lube?”
I kept my legs in the air as I reached into my nightstand and handed him a bottle of hand lotion. Dom was soon coating my hole and his cock, and I felt him at my entrance. He locked his eyes on mine as he said, “just relax.” I took a deep breath as I felt him push in, I grabbed his hips, and he paused until I was ready to continue. I continued to breath until I felt his nuts tight against my ass, the discomfort had been replaced by pure ecstasy. Dom smiled as he started to pump in and out while he kissed me. I soon grabbed his ass and was pulling him into me as we seemed to melt into one. My over stimulated cock was trapped between our stomachs, and I was about to lose control. I pulled Dom in tight, and I exploded, covering our torsos in my hot creamy juices, trying to suck in enough air to breath. I saw Dom’s eyes roll back in his head as his body started to convulse and he filled his condom.
We kissed as we both came down from our post-nut high. Dom smiled at me and asked, “so, did you enjoy that?”
I grinned, “that was incredible.”
He asked, “was that your first time doing anything with another guy?”
I felt me face turn red, “yes.”
He smiled, “you are so cute when you are embarrassed.”
I think I turned even redder as he said, “you were great, maybe next time you can fuck me.”
My mind raced, “I would like that. So that means you want to see me again?”
Dom said, “hell yeah, if you want to see me.”
I smiled, “absolutely I do.”
He gave me another kiss and we crawled out of the bed and cleaned up. I got my first good look as Dom’s ass, it was even more perfect than Donnie’s was.
Dom gave me a kiss as he left, and I let out a big breath as I fell back onto my bed. I looked at the clock, it was a little before 10, CJ would probably be home soon. I grabbed one of my books, so it would look like I was studying. A few minutes later he walked in with a big smile on his face.
He asked, “so, how was your study session?”
I tried to keep my poker face and shrugged, “it was good, I think Dom understands those problems now.”
He chuckled, “that’s not the study session I was talking about.”
I asked, “what do you mean?”
CJ pointed to the lotion and the condom wrapper laying on my nightstand.
I couldn’t control it any longer, I grinned my biggest grin and said, “my virgin card has been played.”
CJ
After I knew Dom was gay, I started to figure out how I could introduce him to Teddy. I thought both guys were good-looking and would hit it off. When I saw that Dom was having a little trouble in our math class, I knew that was the perfect way to get them together. I noticed how Teddy and Dom looked at each other when I introduced them, I knew they liked what they saw. I could tell that Teddy was having a little trouble concentrating, but once he calmed down, I decided it was time for me to leave. I was smiling all the way down to Wendy and Meg’s room, proud of my little match making stunt.
Wendy opened the door to see me grinning ear to ear, she asked, “what’s up with you?”
Meg added, “yeah, you look like the cat that swallowed the canary.”
I shrugged, “I just left Teddy and my teammate, Dom, alone in our room. Teddy is helping Dom with his math homework.”
Wendy rolled her eyes, “oh, that’s cool and all, but I’m not sure it’s worth that cheshire cat grin.”
I said, “Dom is gay, and from the way those two looked at each other, we might just see Teddy get his first boyfriend.”
Meg sighed, “can’t you fix me up with one of the guys on your team? I’m sure some of them must be straight.”
I laughed, “yes, Dom is the only one that I know is gay. I’ll see what I can do Meg.”
Wendy shook her head, “don’t go around claiming to be Chuck Woolery just yet, you have no idea if they will get along.”
I shrugged, “if you could have seen the look on their faces, I’m sure they both liked what they saw.”
I continued to brag about my match making skills and Meg was asking about all the guys on the team. I told her I would think of a couple of guys to introduce her to. I stayed in their room until just before 10, then I headed upstairs. I opened the door slowly, just in case Dom might still be there. I saw Teddy sitting on his bed, acting like he was studying. He tried to play it cool, but as soon as I pointed out the condom wrapper, he couldn’t contain his excitement. I laughed out loud when he said his virgin card had been played.
He said, “it was great CJ, Dom is so hot, it was the first time I saw an uncut cock in person. It was…”
I held up my hand, “I love ya Teddy, but I don’t want any more details. No offense.”
He laughed, “sorry, I guess the was a little too much information.”
I said, “it’s ok, I’m happy for you. Are you going to see him again”
Teddy nodded, “yep, we’re going to study again tomorrow night, in his room. His roommate has a night class.”
I sat on my bed and smiled, he looked so happy. I said, “I’m glad to see you’re being careful.” I pointed again to the condom wrapper.
He sighed, “yeah, after tonight, I think I know what dad meant when he told me to be careful when I started to date.” (In 1985 the AIDS epidemic was just reaching its peak.)
Teddy asked, “so did you know that Dom was gay?”
I nodded, “I heard some rumors, but I wasn’t 100% sure.”
He said, “so you faked needing help with your math, and invited him over to just to meet me?”
I shrugged, “kind of, I didn’t really need any help, but I knew Dom did. I did wait around until I knew you guys were going to get along.”
Teddy smiled, “yeah, I guess you did, thanks for introducing us. He is a nice guy.”
I said, “hey, I told you I would help you find a guy once we got to college.”
Relieved that Dom and Teddy got along, I was glad to see a new look of confidence in Teddy’s eyes. I was a bit concerned that the only way I knew Dom was gay, was because he was caught with another guy by his roommate. The next week after our math class I walked with him to our next class.
I asked, “so, is the help Teddy is giving you, helping your grades?”
He smiled, “yeah, it sure is. The way he explains everything is so much easier for me to understand than the way our professor teaches it.”
I nodded, “he is going to be a great teacher. Can I ask you another question?”
Dom looked at me and said, “sure, what’s up?”
I asked, “your roommate caught with another guy, right?”
He paused, “yes, he did.”
I pushed on, “so, what’s the story with that guy now?”
Dom sighed, “it was just a hook up CJ. I don’t even remember his name. I haven’t seen or heard from him since that night.”
Somewhat relieved I said, “so you guys aren’t still seeing each other, or any other guys now that you are seeing Teddy?”
He shook his head, “no. Why are you asking me this?”
I said, “Teddy is like my little brother, I don’t want to see him hurt. He has been really happy since you guys got together.”
Dom asked, “does he want us to be exclusive?”
I sighed, “I’ve known Teddy almost my entire life. He always fully commits to whatever he is doing. I know he will not even look at each other if he thinks you guys are a couple.”
He took a deep breath, “I can honestly say that I haven’t looked at another guy either. I admit, I had been with a few guys before, but I never met anyone that I thought long term about. I can see what a great guy Teddy is, I promise you that I will never intentionally hurt him.”
I smiled, “thanks Dom, I think you guys should at least have a talk. I know it’s early in your relationship, but please be honest with each other about your expectations. Take things slow, you are the first person that Teddy has ever been with.”
Dom nodded, “I understand, we are getting together tonight, I’ll talk to him then.”
I felt a little better about Dom after our talk, I just hope that Teddy doesn’t go overboard and start planning his life around Dom. I know I have only had one girlfriend, but I have seen a few of these young romances flame out quickly after the initial infatuation wears off. I went back to our room after classes, Teddy was already there studying as usual.
He smiled as I walked in, “hey CJ.”
I returned his smile, “hey Teddy, how were classes today?”
He said, “good, how about yours.”
I nodded, “they were ok. I had a talk with Dom after our math class.”
He suddenly looked concerned, “oh yeah, what about?”
I told him everything we talked about, and I also told him how I found out that Dom was gay. I felt better when he told me that Dom had already told him about that, at least Dom was being honest. Teddy assured me that he was taking things slowly and understood that these things sometimes fizzle out. I was satisfied that they were both being realistic and glad that I had my talks with both Dom and Teddy.
To be Continued…
