GayDemon reviewed Club Amateur USA on 19 May 2014
Club Amateur USA puts the focus on real straight amateur guys who are up for a little sexual exploration on camera. There's a nice mix of guys here; you'll find hairy and smooth men, and a mix of average, handsome and cute. Body types also range from thin to "regular guy", muscular to chubby, and a few bodybuilders. You'll find clean shaven, scruffy and bearded amateurs here, and some of the performers are tattooed while lots aren't. While there are more white guys, expect to find some Latinos and black studs. In fact, it's almost like someone walked around town and chose random guys off the street to appear naked on camera.
Unlike a lot of straight guy sites that have their models jumping right into sucking cock and getting fucked, the men here seem to be truly straight or bi curious, and are obviously real first-timers, although some do return later to do additional vids. Some of the guys are a bit nervous on camera at first, and while you'll find that a number are willing to get a massage from another guy, a handjob and maybe try a little assplay with a dildo, these aren't the so-called str8 guys riding a cock like a pro. The newer videos include a fair amount of virgin buttholes getting fingered, as well.
Club Amateur USA currently offers 464 exclusive videos, each with pics and a model profile. The site is adding 2 updates each week, but one of the weekly updates seems to be remastered versions of the old vids. The vids are now all offered in MP4 format. The newer videos look very good, sharp and clear; most are sized at 1920x1080, although some recent vids are sized at 1280x720. Some of the older videos and the remastered versions don't look too sharp at their largest size, so it might be better to download those at smaller sizes. All videos are also available to stream, the medium sized ones are good for tablets, and there are mobile versions for iPhone, Android and other mobiles.
Each episode also comes with a set of pics. These are screencaps, but they're good quality for screencaps - you might guess that the newer sets and even some of the older ones were digital stills. The newer photos are sized at 1024x576 when viewing online, and are also offered in zip files in 3 sizes, the largest of which are shown at 1600x900. Older pics are sized at 640x480, and they still look pretty good. Hands-free slideshows and pic-to-pic navigation are available, and the pics can be individually downloaded.
When it comes to extras, there's the Club Amateur USA blog, which is where you'll find a profile of each model. The site also gives members full access to long-running gay megasite BadPuppy plus its 13 assorted bonus sites and 50+ feeds. Not only is that a LOT of content, but it means almost daily updates plus a live feed from a male strip club in Florida.
Does the site have any issues? Not many, but the member home page has a bunch of thumbs on the bottom that are actually ads - they lead to a live cam site where you must pay in order to see full nudity or go one-on-one. Older videos are lower quality than newer ones, and may be below average quality when watched at their largest size.
Club Amateur USA offers regular guys being serviced by a guy for the first times or jerking off, which is refreshing in a world full of sites featuring perfect men and porn stars. The 464 videos are downloadable and DRM free, there are mobile versions and streaming versions available, too. There are 2 updates per week, although 1 of them is a remastered "classic" video. And when it comes to extras, members get full access to BadPuppy and their collection of bonus sites and feeds. In a world full of so-called straight guys who suck cock like cock-hungry pigs, it's refreshing to visit a site where the straight guys and first timers actually look like they're getting first gay blowjobs on video. Club Amateur USA delivers with their men, weekly updates, downloadable videos and nice bonus collection.