Bait Buddies is one of the original "tricked straight guy" sites, and has been around since 2007. The straight guys mostly do seem straight - many are well-built jocks or hunks, and there are also some cute but average guy next door types, as well as some guys who are heavily tattooed. While more of the performers (can you call a str8 first timer a performer?) are smooth, a number are hairy - either lightly or some are pretty furry. Dick sizes are all over the map, as are heights, hair color and style and facial hair. There's a lot of variety with the bait boys, as well; and all the guys here are in their twenties or maybe early thirties. The latest straight guy to go gay-for-pay on the site looks like a lumberjack - he's a big guy, tall and muscular with a beard and mustache and a tan. And he's paired with a slender, much less tall Latino who in reality has a taste for tall, blond guys.
There are differences between the older videos and the newer, and not all the new scenes are alike. The older vids often have a woman as "bait" to lure in the straight guys. She talks the subject into stripping down and getting hard for her, indicating she might do a scene with him. Sometimes the guy is so horny that he decides to go for the bait boy when they bring him out, other times he jerks off for the camera, and sometimes they skip the bait girl and just go for it. In the newer videos, the straight first-timers aren't lured with a woman; they're tempted by the idea of doing a straight porn shoot, teased by watching a str8 video as the interview progresses, told that if they can get hard "right now" in front of the bait boy and director, they get the part.
And of course, we all know where this goes. First the str8 guy is told he and the other guys should jack off in front of the camera. Then the director suggests they trade handjobs. If the guy is willing and he's horny, the next step is to let the bait boy suck his dick, and since the bait boys love pulling straight guys, they can't wait to wrap their lips around those rigid str8 cocks. And once those straight guys are worked-up - remember, they were planning to fuck a girl, and they're primed to fuck - they're ready to pound any hole to get off, and end up fucking the bait boys good and hard before blowing their loads.
Bait Buddies has grown to 397 videos, and the site still adds a new episode every Thursday like clockwork. The videos are DRM-free and can be downloaded in MP4 and WMV formats. New MP4s are sized at 1920x1080 plus there's a smaller size for mobile users. WMVs are sized at 720x404, but while they're smaller, they're also sharper and clearer; the large MP4s aren't bad, either. The oldest vids are sized at 640x480 (plus a smaller MP4 for mobiles) at fairly good amateur quality. There is also a streaming version of each video available.
Each video comes with a set of pics. These are good amateur quality digital stills, the newest sized at 960x1440 and the oldest sized at 365x550, although the pics may be displayed at a somewhat different size online. Each set is displayed in a tiny gallery on the same page with the video, and each set can be downloaded in a zip file.
Bait Buddies members get access to a bonus site called Island Porno that offers a collection of full-length DVDs that rotate out each month, so every month members have new DVDs to watch. Niches vary, so you may get porn stars or amateurs, first timers or straight guys, interracial or group sex.
In addition the to low cost trial and full membership options, the site now offers a free trial that doesn't require a credit card. Once you sign up, you can browse everything the site has to offer and get an idea of how the member area works. You can browse all the guys, stream trailers for all of the videos (that's over 10 hours of trailers to watch) and get access to the first pics in each pic set. If you want more, you have to upgrade; if you don't, you don't even have to cancel as you didn't give them your credit card info.
When it comes to issues, there are a few things worth mentioning. Full members can download "up to" 20 hours of videos per week, depending on a number of variables, and after that you will not be able to do more downloads for between 12 and 72 hours - but you will still be able to stream. Trial members can stream all the videos but cannot download them, which is clearly listed on the join page. And the older videos are lower quality than the newer ones, but they're still quite watchable. Other than that, there's not a lot to complain about; the site is easy to navigate, updates regularly and there's a model index with profiles. One last thing is that some of the straight guys seem less straight than others, if you see what I mean.
Bait Buddies is one of the better and more consistent tricked straight guy sites, and there's a really good mix of horny models in 397 videos that can be downloaded, streamed or watched on your mobile. Each episode also comes with a set of pics, and the site updates every Thursday and has done so for years. In addition to all that exclusive content, there's also a bonus site. But what's most important is all those straight guys tricked or paid - or both - into getting stroked and sucked by another guy, not to mention fucking their first male asses; some of the older videos are jerk-off sessions. The straight dudes at Bait Buddies come to fuck a girl on video and end up getting blowjobs and fucking gay porn regulars who love doing straight guys for their first time. And if that isn't a hot fantasy, I don't know what is.