Gay Butt Plug Sex Stories

GayDemon's Stories: On this page you can find erotic fiction where you can read about men having anal sex using butt plugs.

The Playdate of Pump and his Balloon

By baddragonboy 19 Sep 2025

This story is about Pump and his Balloon the day they can finally meet. Balloon becomes complitely Pumps, submitting his body and mind to him. Both of you have a very deep desire for inflation but in the opposite roles. Pump wants to pump and you want to be pumped, the perfect combination for something HUGE! The story will be continued!

9.6 (14) 2700 15 Min Comments

Only When We Play (ch. 12)

By Erik Tyger 17 Sep 2025

Joey realizes what he needs to be with Justin, and Justin likes it too.

9.7 (27) 2059 24 Min Comments

Sir William's Barn (ch. 3)

By Baltcumcump 2 Sep 2025

A third visit to Sir William’s barn involved some electro play while being flogged, restrained to a St Andrew’s cross for a serious caning, then bred by the Alpha Dom himself. I confessed to Jace about 2 unapproved orgasms.

9.9 (23) 2874 11 Min Comments

Skater Snooping on the College Prof’s Sex Toys (ch. 3)

By Mr.X 30 Aug 2025

Tommy Cums out to Dad. As he had begun to expect, Dad is Gay as well. They know that they have to get it over, and soon they must have sex in front of the Homies and Professor. Eddie is in Love with Tommy; Chase and Seth have been fucking since the prom last year. The four have a quick DP in Tommy's cunt and all are now going up to #2020 For Fist

9.7 (66) 2423 16 Min Comments

Getting Plugged by my husband

By DanXWrites 28 Aug 2025

Waking Up Next To My Husband

8.9 (29) 3749 8 Min Comments

Locked Cock Attracts Cock (ch. 5)

By Baltcumcump 12 Aug 2025

This time I found a top on Sniffies looking for a locked cocksucker first thing in the morning.

9.2 (32) 2840 5 Min Comments

Learning bondage basics (ch. 2)

By Sars 14 Jul 2025

I turned to close it when I remembered my hands were still attached the stomach strap of the harness.

9.5 (32) 3757 15 Min Comments

Halloween is a great time to experiment

By BillyBoy 9 Jul 2025

My roommate suggested we try some crazy costumes and other fun stuff for this years Halloween party. I didn't know he was trying to seduce me. But it worked.

8.3 (39) 6897 3 Min Comments

Gay Chicken

By NickNick 5 Jul 2025

My friend came up with the idea to play gay chicken. It was more twisted than I anticipated.

9.3 (146) 12437 18 Min Comments

Cumdump Academy

By Shanica Lopez 4 Jul 2025

Shemale Pornstar, Shanica Lopez visits her old principle who knew her when she was a he.

8.6 (23) 4908 12 Min Comments

Will’s family time

By Gammyzine 3 Jul 2025

Slut Will is a live-at-home cumdump for his brother and father.

7.6 (58) 11751 3 Min Comments

Saving The Twink and ... (ch. 7)

By Mr.X 29 Jun 2025

Finally, Carter and Ethan arrive at their destination. The Town is excited to see Ethan back. Seems he has quite a reputation and following. Carter deep throats Ethan's massive cock on the black leather couch in the garage and then the two have a great missionary fuck and cum fest. Ethan's Hideaway is like A Bruce Wayne Super sex fortress! And so

9.8 (54) 1248 27 Min Comments

A Fort Nite (ch. 2)

By Michael Dee 25 Jun 2025

Michael gets home and ready for a party night at the fort.

8.8 (31) 2938 8 Min Comments

Somewhere to Go (ch. 8)

By AstroGuy42 25 Jun 2025

Luke is caught after suddenly materializing where and when he did. What will his captor do? Why does his captor suddenly want to have sex with him?

8.7 (13) 1402 15 Min Comments

Saving The Twink and ... (ch. 5)

By Mr.X 11 Jun 2025

Well, what are the chances? Carter and Ethan are introduced to some chums and acquaintances. More hot Twink fisting Orgies are in the future mix. Carter and Ethan share more about themselves and have fun pr. Hot deep throat and Cow-boy sex occurs in the truck cab on the Ferry With Ginger Twink Rowan beating his flame red cock in the truck next over

9.9 (60) 1648 28 Min Comments

Frat Games: The House Slut (ch. 5)

By StoriesByTroy 6 Jun 2025

They Put a Vibrator Up My Ass and Made Me Suck Cock While They Controlled It

9.3 (74) 6834 6 Min Comments

To New Experiences (ch. 5)

By Topofthehill 6 Jun 2025

The fall of a Dean, a former strict TOP.

9.7 (70) 6665 28 Min Comments

Saving The Twink and ... (ch. 3)

By Mr.X 27 May 2025

Ethan and Carter reach out to the building staff and devise a brilliant plan for another escape in disguise. They enjoy and wonderful cock sucking while driving. All the while, Cater is cock caged and has a massive butt plus up his sweet man cunt! The cum is flowing like Niagara Falls!

9.8 (70) 2672 21 Min Comments

To New Experiences (ch. 2)

By Topofthehill 16 May 2025

Its Deans second date and already hes leaning so much.

9.7 (80) 6912 18 Min Comments

Addicted to Piss (ch. 9)

By Michael Dee 5 May 2025

Brad and Ash continue to play after shaving his pubic hair smooth.

9.6 (28) 3325 15 Min Comments

This Is What We're Made For (ch. 6)

By Erik Tyger 26 Apr 2025

Noah steps into the apartment, the weight of the day clinging to him. On the bed: a baby blue bikini, waiting. He strips, muscles taut, slipping into the tiny suit Adam picked for him. A message: Waiting for you… His phone buzzes back. Good girl. The shower steams. Noah stands exposed, aching, owned—ready.

9.0 (29) 3558 34 Min Comments

This Is What We're Made For (ch. 5)

By Erik Tyger 22 Apr 2025

The plane ticket waits on the counter, sharp and final. Adam watches Noah in his sweatshirt, legs curled, cage snug beneath soft fabric. No words. Just a touch—fingers at the nape, a slow drag of breath. When he leaves, the ache hits. Between Noah’s legs, in his chest. The thong presses tight. The lock holds. He’s wet anyway.

8.9 (37) 2732 24 Min Comments

This Is What We're Made For (ch. 4)

By Erik Tyger 16 Apr 2025

Adam had watched Noah for a long moment as he dressed, noting the subtle hesitations—the way Noah’s hands trembled when he reached to adjust the lace thong, the way his eyes flickered downward when he caught sight of himself in the mirror.

9.1 (39) 3509 19 Min Comments

This Is What We're Made For (ch. 3)

By Erik Tyger 9 Apr 2025

One quiet evening, Adam handed Noah a small box and told him to open it. What followed unfolded slowly—deliberate touches, quiet commands, and a gaze that never wavered. Noah stood, exposed and trembling, but willing. Each movement deepened the charge between them until Noah wasn’t just seen—he was claimed.

9.2 (39) 3381 19 Min Comments

Rookie in the deep end (ch. 3)

By ShawnRs 1 Apr 2025

I go on a first date with Brent. He helps me be desperate, plug-stuffed exhibitionist, trembling in public under a handsome man's thumb—and loving every second of it.

9.8 (55) 4666 18 Min Comments

The Bookshop Owner (ch. 11)

By Men Undressing (MU) 24 Mar 2025

A burned-out poet finds new purpose through an unexpected encounter with the local bookshop owner, a rugged, enigmatic man with a passion for butt plugs, chastity cages and discipline.

8.9 (20) 3745 12 Min Comments

Sunday Morning with Tareeq and DeShawn

By aFFicionado 20 Mar 2025

Devin's dreams come true he is used like a fleshlight by the hot interracial couple he's been chatting with.

9.4 (41) 5056 21 Min Comments

Laundry Room Mishap (ch. 2)

By Ted_Brown 15 Mar 2025

After getting to know his neighbor, our protagonist meets an Amazon worker who fuels his newfound desire.

9.3 (80) 5568 6 Min Comments

Dirt in the dunes (ch. 7)

By Dave Alexander 28 Feb 2025

I head down South for a couple of days of surfing, and manage a hookup with a hot young surfer and a paid-for session with a fit older dude.

9.3 (28) 1731 22 Min Comments

Anal in the Trailer Park (ch. 14)

By James Smith 25 Feb 2025

Casey Goes to the Bookstore

9.5 (28) 3484 15 Min Comments

My exhibitionist boyfriend (ch. 18)

By Derrick Stirling 25 Feb 2025

After a crazy night out where Derrick goes past his limits, he is trying to piece his night together when John from the sex shop recruits him to be an anonymous slut bottom for the richest and most powerful men in town. Will Derrick be able to take dick after dick for hours?

9.1 (31) 4612 18 Min Comments

To Serve and Obey (ch. 19)

By gtenny 18 Feb 2025

Lukas spends extended time away from Steven, trying to improve, struggling to do so.

9.8 (49) 2191 32 Min Comments

The Bookshop Owner (ch. 10)

By Men Undressing (MU) 9 Feb 2025

A burned-out poet finds new purpose through an unexpected encounter with the local bookshop owner, a rugged, enigmatic man with a passion for butt plugs, chastity cages and discipline.

9.9 (28) 2446 12 Min Comments

My exhibitionist boyfriend (ch. 4)

By Derrick Stirling 3 Feb 2025

After Derrick receives a shipment of dildos and butt plugs he begins training his hole in preparation for taking Gus’s monster cock. ¿Will he be able to handle Gus’s 9 and half long dick?

9.4 (51) 4694 7 Min Comments

My exhibitionist boyfriend (ch. 3)

By Derrick Stirling 2 Feb 2025

6 weeks into dating Gus, Derrick is no longer allowed to wear clothes nor has access to them. Derrick is an inexperienced bottom so he must enlist the help of his neighbors for advice on how to take Gus’s monster dick, of course he must do it naked while they are fully clothed.

9.2 (44) 5434 16 Min Comments