The next few days were spent unpacking and organising the place. It was beginning to feel like home, and I knew we would be happy here. We hadn’t see Benjy since that first day, and I was starting to feel less anxious about our attractive new neighbour. I had been silly to worry; I just get jealous around other guys sometimes. Will is so handsome; I honestly don't know why he is with me sometimes, especially when I see other very attractive people checking him out. He could clearly attract more attractive people than me if he wanted. But I have to remember that he chose to be with me. I might not fully understand it, but he was with me because he wanted to be, so I just needed to stop worrying, stop being jealous, and be happy that I got to be Will’s boyfriend.
One night, a few days later, I was naked on our sofa with my legs spread as Will pounded me with his fat cock. I was moaning loudly, and he was grunting as he fucked me, my ass was stretched wide from his cock slamming into me.
“Ohhh fuck yes baby take my cock”, Will grunted.
His muscly body was covered in sweat, and he looked so fucking hot fucking me. I was wanking my cock as I looked up at him. His cock was hotting me deep, and it felt so good.
“Urghh fuck yes, fuck me baby”, I moaned back.
Suddenly, I heard a knock on the door. Who the hell was that? Will paused his fucking and held his dick deep inside me. We both waited, listening. There was a louder knock on the door now. Will slid his cock out of me. I was so annoyed. I was getting close, and now he had to stop.
He grabbed his jogging bottoms and slipped them on, but not his underwear, so his cock was still visible underneath. Then he grabbed his t-shirt and threw it on as he headed for the door.
“I’ll see who it is, baby,” he said. I moved off the sofa and hid around the side because I was naked.
“Make them go away quick, I want to keep fucking”, I said as he headed off.
I heard the door open a second later, then I heard Benjy’s voice. Fuck’s sake, what does he want? Also, how long was he at the door? We weren’t very quiet, so he must have heard us fucking.
“Sorry! Don’t want to disturb. There’s a leak in my kitchen, and I don’t know how to stop the water. Is there any chance you could help? I have no idea what to do!” Benjy said, sounding stressed.
“Of course, I can come have a look”, Will said.
“Oh my gosh, thank you!” Benjy said.
“Babe, I’ll be back in a bit, just helping Benjy,” Will yelled into the flat.
“Ok!” I yelled back. I was still completely naked, hiding behind the corner so Benjy couldn’t see me from the door.
I heard the door close and then peered around the corner. They were gone. This was so annoying, I get being neighbourly, but we were in the middle of a hot fuck, Will was literally balls deep in me when Benjy knocked. Also, I suddenly realised with a pang of jealousy that Will was going over to Benjy’s place still sweaty and with a semi-hard cock from fucking me, and he wasn’t wearing any underwear.
I got worried again, but I was determined to shake it off this time. It’s fine. He is my boyfriend, and I can trust him. I may not fully trust Benjy, but that doesn’t matter; even if he does have a crush on Will, nothing was going to happen.
I put my underwear back on and went to make a drink, then I put the tv on and waited.
-
Half an hour later, Will was still not back, and I was starting to get worried. How long could it take to help with his issue? It was really starting to hit me that my boyfriend had gone over to our hot neighbour’s house while still horned up from sex and hadn’t come back yet. Fuck. He wouldn’t? Surely, he wouldn’t do anything with Benjy? No…no, he wouldn’t.
But something happened. My cock woke up. It started getting hard. I was having these intense images of Benjy kissing Will, grabbing his hard cock through his sweatpants…Will kissing him back…in the apartment right next door. My hand moved to my now hard cock and slowly started stroking it, like I was in a trance…I wasn’t even aware it was happening…I moaned.
Just then, the door opened.
“Baby?” Will called out.
I quickly took my hand off my cock and slipped it back into my underwear, just as Will came around the corner.
“Hey”, I said, turning to see him, “all, ok? You were gone a while.”
He came over to the sofa and sat down next to me.
“Sorry, his tap was leaking, and he couldn’t work out how to turn the water off. I managed to stop it but waited while he called a plumber just to make sure it doesn't get worse,” he said.
“Ok, what did you do while you waited?” I asked, nervously.
Just spoke to him; he’s a genuinely nice guy. Said he owes us a dinner to thank us. But enough about Benjy—do you want to carry on from where we left off? He said, smiling at me.
I smiled back and leaned in. I was still really horny, and even hornier after those dark thoughts I was having...though I would never admit that. Will kissed me, and I kissed him back. Quickly, our clothes were gone again, and I straddled him as he sat back on the sofa, my ass lowering itself onto his hard cock.
I started fucking myself with his cock as I kissed him. When I pulled away from the kiss, I noticed Will had his eyes closed. He didn’t normally do that; he would be staring at me hungrily as he fucked me, but his eyes were closed, and he looked so horny. I wondered what he was thinking about, was he imagining someone else…was he imagining Benjy? That thought made my stomach turn, but it also made my cock even harder.
I tried to push it from my mind, but I couldn’t, so I started thinking about how Will was imagining fucking Benjy while he was with me. Imagining Benjy’s perfect ass on his cock. I felt my orgasm building, I was getting so close thinking about this while Will’s cock impaled me and he moaned, still with his eyes closed.
“I’m gonna cum”, I moaned.
“Me too,” he moaned back.
I shot my load all over Will’s chest, a huge load that shot hard from my cock, as Will yelled as he unloaded inside me, gripping my ass as he did.
Finally, I collapsed on top of him and slowly got my breathing back to normal.
Will kissed me, now with his eyes open as he smiled at me.
“Shower?” he asked.
“Yes, please”, I said.
I rolled off him and lay back as he jumped up and headed to the bathroom. I felt nice and relaxed, I needed to cum. I tried not to think about what had got me off…that is not happening again.
I heard a buzzing sound and picked up Will’s sweatpants from the floor, pulling his phone out of the pocket. There was a text from an unknown number. I glanced towards the bathroom. Will was still in there. I quickly opened his phone and read the text:
Thanks for being my handyman! I owe you! The actual plumber was nowhere near as hot as you haha 😉 Benjy xx
There was no way this wasn’t flirty. But again, my cock reacted.
“Babe, you coming?” Will said from the bathroom.
I put the phone back and got up to go to the bathroom. I decided I wouldn’t say anything. Let’s see if Will does.
But I was now sure Benjy was into my man.
If you enjoyed this story, consider supporting the author on Patreon.
To get in touch with the author, send them an email.
