The beach was fun. I'd spent the rest of week hanging out with the guys during the day and sleeping with John at night. Alex gave us space, but said he looked forward to hooking up more when we got back home.
Zach and Daniel found out. There was no getting around it, really. It was clear I was going to John's room. Zach asked me about it when we had a moment alone on the beach. Rather than tell him some lie, I fessed up.
"You know what you're doing, Brian?"
"Maybe not," I said. "But it feels right. I feel I can trust these guys."
He winced. Zach definitely didn't like the house bottom idea. "You know I won't judge you man, but I love you like a brother. I don't want those guys taking advantage of you."
"They won't," I insisted. I sighed. Zach tapped into a nagging doubt I had. And truth was, I could stop this House Bottom business anytime. Chalk it up to beach week horns.
But something drew me to it, and I was trying to say what it was, for myself as much as for Zach. "I dunno, bro," I continued. "You know I keep a count of the dudes I've been with?"
That got a surprised smile from my buddy. "Yeah?" he said. "I stopped counting after like thirty." Zach went through a real daddy-chaser phase.
I laughed. "It's been exactly 10 for me.... Part of me wants to go crazy, you know, go chase lots of dick... the other part of me feels better keeping it in the Frat House."
"You got issues being a bottom," he said simply.
I nodded. "Physically, I fucking love it," I said. "But I don't like the way guys look down on bottoms." I was thinking of Army Mike from my hookup at the start of the week, but also the guys on Grindr, or even the way some of the guys would make catty, feminizing comments about bottoms.
Zach nodded. He was a masculine hockey bro who found his own peace with his sexuality. He was less hung up than I was, less inclined to give a fuck what guys thought. "I don't have patience for that BS. That's why being vers is great. You just do what you want and don't build your whole fucking life around a sexual position."
I had to take in my bro's gym-pumped build. Because of our different types, there wasn't sexual tension, but my friend was good looking. Thinning hair and maybe looking older than his 27 years. He's grown his facial hair out, though he confessed he and Daniel were trying to decide if they preferred the more youthful clean-shaven look.
"I've fucked guys," I said. "It was fun, I guess." It was a tone that said it didn’t push my buttons in the same intense way.
Zach laughed. "I honestly love that you decided what you like, Powers. Just look out for yourself."
"Bro, everyone keeps telling me that."
****
It was tough getting back to reality. Work was surprisingly busy for summer, and I had stuff to catch up on. And the previous week had given me extra motivation to spend more time at the gym. It was funny because Zach was on the same wavelength. Even if he wasn't on the market, he loved being in top shape for Daniel.
John was even more in the throes of work, and Alex was meeting all the training clients he'd had to reschedule.
But Kyle was around. He sometimes stuck to his room or had a date or something. He kind of hung out with the guys from our rec league team, but also had his own group of gay friends in the city. That Thursday night he joined me in watching some Netflix show. I'd avoided drinking since getting back from the beach, to recover and focus on my health some. But with the weekend almost there, I helped myself to a beer.
I'd gone hard at the gym, and I was kind of zoned out watching the show, but as it ended Kyle and I made small talk. Him asking me how the beach was, what we did. I filled him in, some.
"Maybe I'll try to go next year," he said.
"You should," I replied. "I definitely will."
Kyle looked at me more steadily. Like something was on his mind. Something was. "So... Alex said some stuff went down."
"Oh," I replied. I wasn’t sure how much A had told him. "Yeah. We got a little wild. It was fun."
"I feel a little left out," he said with a grin. Kyle wasn't a bro with major game. He did really well dating because he was good looking and tall and had the gay jock thing going on. But his confidence now made me realize that A had filled him in completely, maybe even set this up.
I was OK with that. "You don't have to be, man," I said.
I could tell Kyle was surprised. Like he didn't want to believe Alex but was faced with the reality that A had told the truth about me. "You'd put out for me, Powers?"
I nodded and stood up. I was chubbing already, into the idea of spontaneous sex. Somehow my tiredness was gone. "Give me fifteen and meet me in my room?"
This was the most matter of fact I'd been about sex, and it felt liberating. Like I was in control even if I was the one putting out.
"Oh yeah," he replied.
I'd cleaned up and gotten on my bed face down when Kyle walked in, tugging off his shirt. He wasn't super buff like the other guys, but he was tall and decently well built.
"I can't believe this is happening," he laughed.
"You don't gotta, White," I said. "But I want it if you do."
"God yes."
I turned and watched him peel down his shorts. His dick was big, not huge, but solid and thick, with a curve to the left.
"There's lube on the nightstand," I said. "And I'm on PReP. Just go slow to start."
"Got it."
I lay mostly face down, head resting on my folded arms, ass up. I wondered if Kyle was the kind of guy for foreplay. But other than a quick application of lube to my hole, I wasn't going to get any tonight.
I felt his presence above and behind me, nudging that tool of his into my crack and pucker.
"You take dick a lot, Powers?" he asked. I think it was surprise more than anything. He was clearly horny to be tapping my ass.
"Just guys I feel comfortable with," I answered.
"Cool."
He breached me. His caution paid off. That curved dick felt awesome pushing into me. I hiked my ass up and relaxed, letting him go deeper.
"Fuck."
There was something about sex with Kyle that felt taboo. I was buddies with all of the guys in the House and had blurred the lines between friendship and sex. But I was letting White dick me not because I was attracted to him but because he was my friend. Because he was part of the House. It was messed up maybe, but the mental part of that fantasy was turning me on.
"Your dick feels great man," I said in a dreamy, mellow voice. I was enjoying this a lot but hadn't been overstimulated yet.
"Jesus, Powers," Kyle hissed. He leaned in and really started fucking. White didn't throw a hard fuck, but he gave an appreciative one. Whimpering some in excitement, kissing behind my ear, smoothly pumping in and out.
My prostate was singing now. This was the first curved dick I'd taken, and it felt different in a good way.
"Fuck me," I hissed more excitedly. Humping back into Kyle's thrust.
"I don't think I can hold off," he grunted, apologetic.
"Don't, man. Breed me," I urged. I wasn't quite there, but I was close.
A few heavier thrusts and I felt Kyle's defenseman body jerk on top of mine, kind of collapsing his weight on me.
I didn't have lube on my hand, so I gave small thrusts against my sheets and combined with the feeling of that dick sliding in and out with softer motions, that was enough to make me cum.
"Oh GOD!" I hissed. It was fun to lose it now that White had had his pleasure.
"Nice, bro," he said in my ear, licking it as I nutted.
It was a little awkward when he dismounted. But I thanked him for being a good top.
"Jesus, Powers, I should be thanking you." He pulled his shorts back on. "That was amazing." He paused. "What do you do after buddy sex?" he asked laughing. "A fist bump seems weird."
"Don't have to do anything, White. But how about a bro hug?"
"Sure," he smiled.
We hugged it out then he left me to clean up and crash for the evening.
****
The next night, Alex called a house meeting. I had a good idea what it was about. Indeed, he pulled me aside before the other guys got home. "Just wanna check, little bro. You OK with this House Bottom business?"
I'd been doing a lot of thinking. I was OK with it, and told A as much. Still, I had some misgivings. "How's it gonna go down?"
"However you want it to go down, Bri," A said. "That's what we're gonna talk about."
We gathered in the kitchen. Kyle seemed unsure what was going on. John had a smirk on his face that suggested he had a good idea. "So guys..." Alex said. "Powers is officially the House Bottom. So we need to set some ground rules. I'll go over a couple and Bri can add whatever he wants to them."
"First, no talking about this with the other guys. Bri hates gossip and I do too," Alex said, and flashed me a reassuring grin. "Second, any of us can say no, not interested, especially Bri. Third, no messing around in the common areas." He was addressing my housemates then turned to me. "Anything to add?"
I thought for a second. "Yeah... if I'm dating someone the House Bottom thing is off unless I say so, OK?" Who knows if I'd have an open relationship or not, but I wanted to make sure the buddy sex wasn't going to get in the way of my dating life. And I wanted the guys to know that.
"Cool, absolutely," Kyle chimed in. I could tell from his smile he was getting very excited by the House Bottom arrangement.
"Anything else?" A asked.
"Not that I can think of," I said. "If something comes to me, I'll let you know."
"I have one," John interjected. We looked at him. "We gotta respect the House Bottom," he said. "He's a dude helping us out, not some pass-around bitch." Like A, John knew some of my hangups about bottoming, and it warmed my heart to realize he was looking out for me.
"Agreed," A chimed in. "The name of the game is Respect, guys."
Kyle had Friday plans. I sensed John wanted a crack at me again, but I slept with A that night.
****
It was fun as we found a groove. I was surprised the guys didn't go hog wild. Kyle was the shyest about hitting me up again, and John was busy with work.
I actually made the move on Alex. Surprisingly nervous, I found him up in his room, door open. He'd just stepped out of the shower, with a towel wrapped around his waist. His build was just incredible, with massive muscle. It wasn't even my chosen type I went for generally, but the jacked look was incredible, accentuated by a summer tan and a light dusting of chest fur.
I gave a gentle knock. "Hey A," I announced.
He flashed a smile when he saw me. "Hey little bro, what's up?"
I didn't answer him but instead gestured to his mostly nude state. "Got a hot date?"
He could read the question behind that. "Was gonna hit up the apps. Unless you're offering."
"I'm offering, A," I said simply. This was fun. Flirtatious and matter of fact at the same time.
He grinned and undid his towel. That long snake fell out. While Alex wasn't a short guy exactly, he wasn't tall and that dick seemed out of proportion to his frame. Particularly when it lengthened and stood up, almost mesmerizing me.
I slid off my shorts. I had a more regular piece, and it was sticking up rigid already as I kicked off my shorts and stood before my housemate naked.
"Why don't you lean over the bed, bro?" he asked as he was already pulling out his lube.
"OK," I said. Alex could be good for a more intimate connection, but maybe this was going to be a quickie. I was starting to doubt whether the House Bottom thing was a good thing for the kind of sex I ultimately wanted. But I leaned over onto Alex's bed. I don't think I noticed before how neatly he made his bed, completely folded and tucked. I braced my arms on the duvet. The woody scent of his cologne lingered on the bed.
Even without watching, I could sense my housemate crouch behind me. He parted my ass and dove right in.
"Oh fuck, A..." I hissed. I'd been slow to get into being eaten out, but if Alex Ramirez was doing the rimming, I was gonna love it. "Eat my hole, bro."
That seemed to drive A to munch more fervently, hungry in his desire to lick up into me. I spread my legs just slightly and pushed out my clean hole for him. This wasn't a quickie, this was ten solid minutes of foreplay. And Alex was going to make me wild for his dick.
When he finally stood up, he wasted no time in pressing that slicked up dong into me. Not a hard jab but a steady shove, right into my guts. I wanted it.
"Damn, little bro... this ass is velvet, dude."
"For you, big bro," I hissed in response. There was just a hint of that discomfort and stretch, but that somehow made his bottoming out even hotter. Alex had huge heavy balls that tapped against my taint.
"Your brother's gonna take care of you, Powers." With that, he pulled out and slowly slid back in. He'd lubed up really well and that fucking motion was smooth and steady. My hole gripped against the wet bone pistoning in and out, and yet my spasms simply provided more friction rather than impeded his progress.
"Fuck, bro..." he hissed.
I had no idea how deep we'd go with the brother roleplay. And it was also fraternity brother talk, too. Going back and forth in my head, and probably A's too. As he took me, I lived out the fantasy of being Alex's fraternity brother back in the day, or him being mine. Horny, unable to stop fucking.
Those hips pumped me faster. And faster. Alex's only speed it seemed. I could feel the urgency in his fuck, in his whole body taking charge of my ass. It wouldn't always work for me, but right then I grooved on his excitement.
"Gonna nut in my little brother," he hissed, the mellow voice growing strained. Then those strong fingers gripped my waist hard and he barreled into me. "FUCK!" I was getting seeded with a good dose of A's cum.
He gave me a gentle pat and slowly withdrew. I thought of telling him to push back in so I could jerk to completion, but already A was reading my mind.
"Just wanna take a look, bro," he said with a more relaxed satisfied voice. "Not gonna leave you and and dry."
I started to lift my body up and twist my head around when I felt his still hard dick bore back in. Slower now, as if he was savoring the feel of his own cum inside me. I know I loved the change of pace. I grabbed the lube next to me and squirted enough in my hand to get the right friction on my bone.
It was easy and quick to get off. Alex slow pumping me while I gave a few frantic jerks. And A's strong arm wrapped around me, pulling me up into his hard chest and kissing my neck. Him possessing me physically, and I was giving into that strong embrace. I felt my body go hot and then that wave of pleasure washed over me. Shots of my cum flung out and probably made a mess of A's duvet.
"Nice," he said. He withdrew and helped me clean up. It was great to see his content smile and we kept looking at one another. Not in an about-to-fuck way, or in a romantic way, but just enjoying the sexual chemistry. "You wanna sleep in here tonight, Bri?" he asked.
"Yah," I nodded. John could be more romantic in sex than Alex, far more romantic, but A seemed to enjoy me sleeping in his bed.
We got under the covers and A put his arm around my shoulder, drawing me close. We just talked.
"So Bri... you getting cold feet with the House Bottom arrangement?" he asked.
"Not really," I said.
"I dunno... you seemed nervous coming up here for sex tonight." His fingers softly grazed my delt muscle. Even though I'd cum I was gonna stay hard from the body contact, something that usually didn't happen with me.
He was right. I thought about it. "Maybe it's hard to just start it up." I reached over and felt for A's cock. It was soft now and I heard a satisfied chuckle as I started playing with his lube-sticky meat. "Too sensitive?" I asked.
"Nah, but I'm spent bro. I jerked off early this morning so you got the best of me just now."
"I'm not looking for round two, A... I just like your dick."
"I know, bro," Alex said, turning to kiss my forehead.
God, that was the sexiest part of Alex Ramirez for me, the way he could be an alpha without making a big deal of it or putting me down. He was confident as fuck.
I played with that meat some more. "You know," I said. "I thought the other guys would want to do me by now."
He patted my shoulder and replied. "I think they're not sure how to start up either.... I'm pretty sure John and K are grade-A horndogs waiting to come out. If that's what you want."
"Maybe I don't know what I want," I said. "But I definitely wanna try this."
A looked at me with an amused expression then pulled me into a kiss. It was sensual and deep, and I loved it.
"You're the best, little bro," he said. "How bout this? You have a standing date to sleep up here on Tuesdays. I have a later start on Wednesday."
"Yeah?" I asked. I was intrigued by the idea.
Alex nodded. "I think the regular sex will help break the ice a little for the House Bottom thing."
"That'd be hot, A," I said. I noticed his cock start to respond. "You're getting hard," I chuckled.
"I know you need cock, Bri."
The next kiss was even softer somehow. I kinda wish A went this speed more, but I also was learning to take each man with their own vibe and sexual chemistry.
He finally pulled back, like he didn't want to get carried away. That's how I knew he was fully spent sexually.
"So, bro... I think it's time to rent out the extra room," Alex said. "I'll make sure he's cool with the House Bottom thing. And of course you get full veto over the selection."
"Oh," I said. I hadn't thought of this extending beyond A, John, and Kyle. But Alex was right. If he brought another renter and housemate, the guy would have to be part of that dynamic.
"Think it over," he said, maybe sensing some hesitation.
"Yeah, I will," I said.
"We'll make it work, Bri," he said.
****
That following weekend I took a couple of days off work for a long weekend and went away for the hiking trip I had planned with my buddy Tyler. It was good bonding time, but I missed my gang. Zach and the guys in the Frat House.
When I got back from my trip, I saw the following written out in A's handwriting and stuck to the fridge with a magnet.
HOUSE RULES
1. Powers is our bro, first and foremost.
2. What the House Bottom says, goes.
3. Guys in the house can approach the House Bottom, or the House Bottom can approach a top.
4. If the House Bottom is dating someone, guys in the house won't hit him up for sex.
5. If a House Top is dating someone, the House Bottom won't hit him up for sex.
6. No sex in the common areas.
7. A blue band on the House Bottom's room doorknob means any House Top can come in for a fuck.
8. Remove the blue band if you want a private fuck. Put it back on when you leave if House Bottom wants you to.
9. No jealousy, no drama, no pushing boundaries.
10. No talking to others outside the house about the House Bottom or our arrangement.
11. The House Bottom won't skip leg day.
12. Respect the House Bottom.
John came in and saw me reading it. He was wearing a more form fitting T-shirt, which suggested he'd just come back from the gym.
"Each of us got a copy, Brian," he said. "But Alex wanted it up there for a week as a reminder."
I finished reading the last few of the rules. "I like it," I said with a smile.
That made John smile. "I helped out with the list. I was hoping it was OK. We can take number 11 out, we just that it was funny."
"It's cool," I said. "I like it." I gave the list another quick read. It made it all feel real.
As I looked back, we kind of stood awkwardly looking at each other. But John wasn't saying anything.
"It's OK, bro, you can ask me," I offered.
He laughed nervously. God, he was a cute fucker. Harris's shy thing was winning me over. "I know you just got home," he said.
"It's Ok," I replied. "You can always ask, I can always say yes or no."
He nodded. "Wanna fuck, Brian?"
I smiled. "Give me twenty minutes? Maybe thirty?" I wanted a good shower and to get properly ready for John.
"Oh yeah."
Awkwardly he stepped up, not sure if he should kiss me. But I gave a slight nod and felt that amazing skilled kiss, just a little tongue before he brought out something deeper. "That OK?" he asked, checking in to make sure he wasn't crossing a line.
"Definitely." I said. I patted his arm and told him I'd come to his room.
I found John naked and rock hard in his bed. "I was gonna look at some porn," he said as I slid into his room and shut the door behind me. "But I don't need to." He gave his big cock a soft stroke and let go, making that prick ride up into full erection. "Besides, it's been a few days."
I crossed over and climbed into his bed. The kiss was amazing but so was the body contact. My hands on John's smooth muscle and his hands roving over my body.
"Mmmf," he moaned into our kiss. "Feel like riding me, Bri?" he asked.
"If you want," I said.
He looked at me with those soulful eyes. "What do you want, man?"
I knew my immediate answer. "Missionary. Slow, then hard." With Charlie, I got off hardest in doggie, but John Harris delivered an incredible missionary fuck.
He got a big smile and rolled us over. Making out with me more impetuously, feeling me up and kissing along my neck and ear.
"I need you in me, bro," I sighed. I was SO hard against his abs and could feel his thick erection against my leg. I began spreading my legs as John pulled off and reached for the lube. A couple of pumps, which he slathered on his dick, my hole, then my own cock, and he was good to go.
"Easy," he said as he pushed.
I looked up at him and nodded. My legs were pulled back, which wasn't the most comfortable position, but it allowed John good access. He locked eyes and nudged more in.
"I love your dick," I said. I hadn't perfected sex talk, but I learned that sometimes simple is best. I was discovering that tops loved to know you want them and that their dicks are turning you on.
He slid more in, opening up my tightness then plowing forward. He didn't rest at full penetration but slowly began to pump me.
"Good?" he asked.
"Amazing," I said. "Fuck."
He went harder. Full body into it, like John often did. In two minutes flat, he'd taken me from tight to crazed and eager.
"Stroke your cock," John urged as I wrapped my hand my meat. "Get off on me fucking you."
Then he pulled on some additional power reserve from his glutes and his hips to really drive into me.
"Oh FUCK!" I cried. My p-spot was going wild, and I felt my balls tingle. I was cumming in waves of intense pleasure that preceded my ejaculation. A few more thrusts and John's thick dick began pushing the cum right out of me. "Oh fuck oh fuck," I grunted, my face feeling hot and my whole body alive with pleasure.
He was waiting for this, and my tightening guts helped him orgasm too. I felt his body clench and jerk as he got off inside me, deeply.
His face was reddened as he slowed and cooled down.
"Thank you, Brian," he said, leaning down for a kiss.
We cuddled a little in the afterglow and kissed some. I finally told John I needed to get settled in and do laundry after my trip.
“Yeah, sure,” he said removing his arm from my shoulder. It was a respectful distance he put out, as I slid out of bed and looked at him. His dick was soft and heavy between his legs.
“You’re really good at that, John,” I said simply.
He smiled. “Anytime, bro.”
****
Kyle White was shy but pretended not to be when he hit me up the next night. He must have been thinking about it all day, because he was throwing a full on boner in his shorts when he walked into the kitchen as I made a quick post-gym dinner.
"Hey Powers," he said. "Sorry for the ambush, but you think you could help me out later?"
I looked down at that hardon, which curved up and pushed out the mesh fabric. Sex with John had primed the pump and I found the idea of more buddy sex appealing. "For sure, you look hard up."
He laughed. "Been working too much, but yeah..."
"Your room?" I offered. "Give me a little time."
"Of course." He patted my delt muscle. "You're the best, Powers." He then walked out and down the hall.
I scarfed down my meal, less in eagerness for sex and more because it was almost 8 and I was starved after a hard workout. Zach was pushing me more, and I was amping up leg day. I already had an amazing muscle ass and super strong legs, but I decided to lean into my best assets.
I got extra clean, with the hopes I could convince White for a longer or at least a harder session. It was one of those nights where I could take an Alex Ramirez sprint-fuck no problem, the horniness was just building in me. I knew White wasn't a rimmer, or at least he hadn't been with me, so I went ahead and applied a healthy amount of lube to my semi-relaxed hole. If Kyle enjoyed tonight's fuck, he'd partly have John to thank. I was worked up for sure.
I slipped on my old college-logo gym shorts and ball cap and padded my way down the hall. My housemate's eyes lit up when I slid into his room.
"Jesus, Powers," he said, blue eyes widened as he took in my shorter, more compact build. "You're off the charts hot."
"Thanks," I said. "Why don't you show me that big dick?" I urged.
With a grin, Kyle slid the sheets off and I gazed at that thick curved boner. I could tell the guy was leaking some. I stepped up and reached out, enjoying Kyle's amused expression.
"I'm really horny," I said. "I might be in the mood to go a little wild tonight. If that's OK."
"God yeah, Powers," Kyle hissed. I could tell he was pleasantly surprised. Our previous fuck had been no nonsense. This was something else. Kyle may have been the initiator, but I was now the sexual aggressor. I slid down my shorts and let my housemate see me erect and naked except for my ball cap and watch.
I climbed onto the bed and straddled him. I took a second to feel up his smooth ripped torso. White wasn't built like John or Charlie, and those bigger dudes were definitely my normal type. But Kyle was a tall, athletic guy, and what most guys would consider a total catch.
I rode his cock a little then leaned up and reached back. John Harris was thicker by far, and my hole had its muscle memory from the night before. I slowly pressed back and felt Kyle's bare dick enter me.
"Jesus, Powers," he hissed. "You're already lubed."
I nodded and smiled. I sat down on him more fully. I had to pause about three or four inches in, getting used to that curve. But White felt good, real good. He was using me to get his rocks off, and I was using him. Slowly I began bouncing up and down about an inch or so, working more of that hardon into my guts.
His hands now clenched my outer legs. "Take my cock, man..." then he caught himself. "Hope that's not against the rules to say."
I shook my head. "I'm good, White," I replied. "We're friends, but don't let that get in the way of a good fuck."
He smiled and nodded. And fucked up into me. THAT felt amazing. Even then the doubt in my head made me wish I didn't love this so much. I wished I was a top like these guys. But damnit I loved this feeling. The stretched and full sensation in my ass combined with the stimulation of my p-spot. I held off jerking off as I rode Kyle and that made it all more incredible.
"Shit, man, I'm gonna cum if you keep that up, Brian," Kyle said, his sexy smile getting more serious, almost whimpery.
That made me go into full power bottom mode, riding him urgently and milking him off with my ass muscles. It was hot to watch him get into that orgasm and to know I was being loaded up good.
Indeed when I rose off I reached behind and felt a heavy amount of semen ooze out onto my fingers. It would be enough, I decided as I gripped my boner with my cummy hand.
"Put it back in me, White," I urged, settling back onto his crotch.
He nodded and dutifully guided his still rigid meat into me. I settled all the way down into his lap, feeling the curve stretch my insides as I jerked and kind of rode back and forth on his dick.
My own cum was great. I stopped comparing them. If I was gonna be House Bottom, I knew I had a lot of incredible orgasms ahead of me.
I finally let go of my dick and caught my breath. Kyle looked up at me with satisfaction and also an impressed look. He definitely wasn't expecting sex this good. I hadn't either. Slowly I rose off and felt his hockey jock load seep out more easily. It took me a sec to get over my sea legs as I dismounted. But I climbed off the bed and patted his leg.
"I needed that, man, thanks," I said.
"I did, too. You have no idea, Powers," Kyle grinned. "I'm gonna sleep well."
"Good." I said. I reached for my shorts and slid them on. It turns out these would be my unofficial House Bottom shorts, something easy to slip on and off as I walked through the house to my top's bedroom.
And now I was walking back to my room. Maybe A was right that John and Kyle had a real horndog side waiting to come out. But for now I was feeling like I was the one letting my horny side show.
****
John actually found the next housemate. An ex and sort-of friend of his from another city had a partner who was an econ professor who commuted in and was looking for a place two to three nights a week. It was a perfect arrangement. The room was pretty small and came with less rent. It had less natural light than the rest, and A had furnished it for this kind of rental. We all liked the idea of a roommate who wouldn't be around all the time.
Mark was the guy's name, and he came by the house the next Wednesday to meet us and for us to meet him. He was strikingly handsome, easily in his late 30s with premature gray that was really make a salt and pepper look kick in. Mark was friendly as he shook our hands. A gave him a tour of the place and showed him the room. When he came back to the living room, the guy seemed interested, at least if I could read his facial expression right.
I took a second to appraise him physically. About six foot even and solidly gym built. Not jacked like John, and maybe more normal, but definitely fit, with nice, broad shoulders and a broad chest beneath his button-down. I didn't know how this would play out, but A told me I had veto over anyone. I now looked over at Alex and gave a small, imperceptible nod of agreement. Alex smiled back.
Alex and Mark sat down, and A went over the basics. Finally he broached the big subject.
"So, this may be a deal breaker," Alex started. "But we all have an arrangement with Brian here. Kind of a no-strings sex thing."
I could see the caution in Mark's eyes, but Alex continued. "Look, you wouldn't be expected to be involved, I know you have a partner. Just know what may go on behind closed doors." He picked up a piece of paper and slid it to Mark to read. The House Rules.
I could see a surprised amusement on the man's lips. "You guys are wild," he said looking up at us, then pointedly at me. "And you're the House Bottom?"
I blushed. "That'd be me," I replied.
He paused. "I'll have to think about this. And run it by Eric."
"Of course," Alex said. "It's not an orgy thing, I swear. But we want a housemate who'll fit in and feel comfortable."
Mark said he'd get back to us in the next week. He must not have been TOO freaked out because he was still friendly as he shook our hands and bid goodbye.
"Oh well," Alex said after he left. "We'll find the right guy." A was convinced Mark was going to say no.
Only the next morning he texted us. "I heard back from Mark. He's a go."
****
Even after he started staying in the frat house, I still wasn't sure if Mark was gonna be a House Top or just a housemate. That was OK. I had my Tuesday nights with Alex, and John was around more and horny lately. I even gave Kyle a blowjob, wanting to try something new and to take a break from bottoming one night.
But on the second week of Mark's living with us, I got a knock on my door. He'd just come home from campus and was dressed in his professorial clothes, book satchel slung over his shoulder. "Hey, Brian," he said.
I looked up from my computer. A workmate had coaxed me into a fantasy football league, and I was researching stats for the week. "Hey," I said. "What's up."
A sly grin crossed his face. "So this House Bottom thing... I just ask for it?"
This was unexpected and welcome. I would have been fine not sleeping with Mark, but doing so would complete the Frat House vibe. "Pretty much," I said, leaning back. "It's a yes or no thing, but often yes." I added, "I didn't know you were interested."
"I had to ask Eric. We're open, and he hooks up when I'm out of town..." He paused and gave a self-deprecating laugh. "You probably don't need the full story."
I shrugged. "Either way is cool. You wanna give me a few minutes and come back?" I didn't spell it out, but Mark got that I was planning to clean out for him.
"Definitely. Fuck, this is fun."
It was even more fun when Mark came back, himself freshly showered and bare-chested. My suspicion was right that his body was somewhere between normal and gym-pumped. He didn't groom his chest hair and he had the hint of love handles. But as he got naked I enjoyed seeing that cock. More of a tapered torpedo shape, thick at the base and elongated at the end. Like A, Mark had big heavy balls, though his clung tightly to the stalk of his shaft.
"How you like to...?" he asked.
"I have my preferences, but I also like exploring what feels right a guy," I replied.
"Works for me." He stepped up to the bed and climbed on, connecting with my naked body. "Is kissing OK?"
"Not required but definitely OK."
Mark was very physical in his style. Feeling me up, kissing all along my neck and body, climbing on top of my naked form and thrusting against me as we made out. I loved it, the newness of a new man.
He finally pulled back and picked up the lube I'd set out. His brown eyes looked at mine intently as he slowly fingered me. Sensual and deep, those digits probed in and out, and he added more lube from time to time until I was good and wet.
"I'm going in raw, OK?" he stated as much as asked, then placed my legs on his shoulders and scooted into place.
The tapered shape was perfect for boring into me and opening me up. He didn't rush entering me, but seemed to savor my ass before he slowly pumped. Even at a slower pace his whole body seemed into the fuck, leveraging full penetration with each thrust. He looked down on me with excitement.
"Were you a jock?" he asked.
I nodded. "Hockey. Division I." I was proud of the fact, but also figured it would turn Mark on.
It did. "Fuck." He thrust in more urgently. "One of these days I'm gonna have to get the full story about how this started."
"Me taking dick? Or the House Bottom thing."
"Either," he smiled. He fucked a little quicker now. The rhythmic stretching was definitely a new experience. The Mark experience. I was getting into it even if I didn't have the same prostate feeling I sometimes craved. "How you doing?” he asked. “It might not take me long."
"Lube up my dick, and I'm good anytime."
He paused and did as instructed before he resumed a steady thrust. My palm wrapped around my prick, and I felt it. That made my butt nut come alive and I could feel each of Mark's movements against it inside me.
"Gonna cum..." he announced.
"Do it." My voice was pinched, since I was close to nutting too.
I actually beat him, my sperm flying all over my chest and abs. I didn't expect the orgasm to be intense, but it was. Just two seconds later Mark let out an excited cry and got his own nut, deep inside me. He was the kind of top he stopped thrusting as he came and I got to watch his facial expressions as he pumped me full.
He pulled out and we kissed.
"You good, man?" he asked.
"Very," I said. Mark had surpassed my expectation of the fourth housemate.
He smiled and patted my chest. "I can't make this an all the time thing. But we'll do this again, OK?"
"Yep. Just hit me up when you're in the mood."
He shook his head, like he couldn't believe I was so nonchalant about putting out. Deep down I wasn't really, but there were two Brian Powers, one the conservative Catholic boy who wondered what the fuck I was doing, and the other an out of control gay dude in the big city. I had a good idea which one was winning out.
I told Mark good night as he got up and put on his sweatpants. I'm often wiped after a good lay, but that evening I felt wide awake. Maybe because it was Thursday and I was already anticipating the weekend. Maybe I'd line up a hookup outside of the house. Or go out to the bars. As fun as the House Bottom thing was becoming, I didn't want to be closed off to dating again, even if I wasn't rushing that either.
I slid on some sweats myself and a long-sleeve T and went out to the living room. John was there, watching TV. Uncharacteristically he was drinking a beer on a weeknight.
"Tough day?" I asked as I came in and sat on the sofa.
He looked over at me. "It pays the bills. But yes." He took a sip from his can. "How bout you Brian?"
"Long. But it's been a good day."
He paused and looked over at me. "Wow," he said with a sly smile. "Did Mark sample the goods finally?"
I laughed. "Are you psychic?"
That got a chuckle in return and a sexy smile. I loved John's smile. He was classically cute, and after having sex with a man nearing 40, I enjoyed John's relative youth in contrast. "I'm learning to read you more, Powers," he said. He spread his legs and leaned back in the sofa cushion. "Besides, I was gonna hit you up earlier, but your room door was closed."
"Shame," I said. Until that moment, I thought I was spent for the evening. But looking at John I was mesmerized by his cute looks and his muscled bod. He was wearing shorts and his furry legs were fucking solid. And his meaty chest stretched out his polo shirt. Since moving into the house, he'd gone for shorter buzzed haircuts. He said he had better luck with that look. I liked both, but he had a point.
John smiled and his eyes probed mine. "Yeah, shame."
"If you don't mind seconds..." I offered.
He had a naughty, almost guilty look on his face. "Never done that actually."
"You wanna try it?" OK, bad-boy Brian Powers was out in full force that night.
He nodded and scooted over. The House Rules forbade doing anything in the common area, but maybe kissing was allowed. Either way, John Harris was giving me one of his amazing kisses and I was responding in turn. I ran my hand up his tree-trunk thigh, stopping myself before I went any higher.
"My room, buddy?" he asked.
I nodded.
John stood up, that thick meat of his now chubbed in his shorts as he grabbed the remote to turn off the TV. My dick was even more fully hard, improbably.
It was a classic John Harris fuck. Missionary, lots of kissing, lots of power to his thrusts. Slow, then hard. His thick dick pounding my p-spot to a hard orgasm before he let loose with his.
Only this time I got the invitation to sleep in his bed for the night.
We lay quietly and just held hands. It was weird, but right.
"John, is this messed up?" I asked.
"I don't think so, Brian. But you gotta listen to your own heart." He squeezed my hand gently. "You know I'll respect whatever you decided with us. But... well, I've enjoyed the hell out of this so far."
"Yeah?"
"You brought me out of my shell. More than you know." His voice got that shy quietness now. "Each time I'm... in you.. I just feel lucky that a guy like you would be into me."
I leaned up and looked at him. It was crazy he didn't realize how fully hot he was. I knew some of his lingering body image issues but maybe not the extent. "You have no idea, John," I said. "I try not to make a big deal out of ranking men, but you're my number #2 top I've had. You're incredible."
He smiled big. "Yeah? Is Alex number one?"
I shook my head. "Charlie."
John knew most of that story. "You miss him, Brian?"
I nodded. "I do sometimes. But I don't dwell on it. I gotta figure out when something's real and when it's not."
He seemed to think that over. "Maybe it's not cut and dry. I was with Drew for several years. It was real and it wasn't. Sorry to get sappy on you, Brian."
I squeezed his hand back. "Not at all. I like talking."
He could tell I was sleepy, and he was getting there too. "Ready for bed?"
I nodded. We kissed softly and then turned out the light.
To get in touch with the author, send them an email.
