The Cheater

Note: this is a fictional story. Any references to people are coincidental as this is fictional and not based on real people.  

---

A week has gone by and AJ finally gets the text message he's been waiting for. It is from Mandy: "Hey AJ we are on for tonight. My folks are out of town. Does 4 pm work for you to come over?" She writes. AJ responds with "heck yes, that sounds good for me!" AJ can't wait to make this cocky straight jock submit to him but he also has to contain his excitement so Mandy doesn't catch on.  

It has been an exhausting week for Brad. Coach has been working the team hard during practice. He is ready for a nice relaxing weekend. His phone pings and he sees he received a text from Mandy: "Hey babe, let's hangout tonight and have a nice romantic evening what do you say? Dinner and a nice movie?" Brad is relieved as she doesn't seem to know about what happened at the party. He knows he needs to make sure everything seems okay and not let her get suspicious. He immediately replies: "yeah, I'm so down! It's been a stressful week I am so ready to relax." She replies back: "sounds good, let's plan on 7 pm. Bring your favorite bottle of alcohol we are so going to have a fun night baby!" Brad is shocked and very happy and responds: "mmm yes baby I will be there I am so looking forward to it!" Brad then strips down and looks down at his big cock and stares at himself in the mirror before stepping into the shower and smiles and flexes as he knows he will get more action with Mandy tonight. He then spends the rest of the afternoon getting ready. 

AJ arrives at Mandy's house right at 4. He has all the gear he needs in a duffle bag. He brought extra stuff and some lubricant as he knows it's going to be a long fun night for him. He also hopes Brad ends up wanting more and fantasizes how the night will shake out. He is hoping Mandy leaves the room at the point of him fucking Brad leaving him alone to do what he pleases to his bound captive.  

Mandy greets him in the driveway as he walks up with his gear. "Are you sure you are okay with this? I don't want you to chicken out at the last minute," he says to her. "Of course I am, this asshole is getting what he deserves," Mandy says. "Okay good, just making sure. Trust me he will not be hurt just shown who's boss and taught a valuable lesson on cheating," AJ says. "Come this way, we are going to have all this take place here in my poolhouse, it is secluded and private. No one in the main house can hear anything, not that anyone is home. I am a little worried about the neighbors though I don't want them to hear anything," she said. "Don't worry, I got that covered he will be gagged really well I can assure you, and there might have to be some light smacking and blackmail threats if he doesn't cooperate. Leave it to me you don't have to worry and won't need to do much except lure him here and get him to agree to be tied up. I will do the rest," AJ says.  

They both step into the poolhouse and AJ is amazed how big and spacious it is. It has a big living room and one bedroom in the back with a bed with a perfect headboard for being tied to the bed. The room has a bathroom and a big walk in closet. "You can hide in the closet until I have him all bound and blindfolded. I will then open the door and signal you out to do your thing," Mandy says. "Sounds good, I will be ready. I have the handcuffs and rope for you to tie up to the bed. I will put them in the side table drawer here along with the blindfold. Once you have successfully tied him up, is when I will come out of the closet. I will also let you know when to take his blindfold off by gestering you. But don't do it right away, I will wait for the perfect time," AJ says. "Okay, sounds good, I hope you don't get too bored he should be here around 7 pm. It may take me until 730/8 o' clock before I am able to get him tied to the bed. Is that okay?" Mandy says. Knowing he can wait as long as it takes for this moment, he plays it cool and says "Not a problem, just don't be too long!" Mandy gives him a hug and says, "thank you again for doing this, it means a lot! I have never had a friend like you before this means everything to me!" AJ replied, "of course, I am always happy to help my best friend in her time of need. I assure you he will learn his lesson." Mandy then shuts the closet door with AJ inside and goes into the living room to await Brad's arrival...... 

********** 

It is 6:55 pm and Brad messages Mandy that he is parking his car. "I am parking now, could you let me in?" Brad says. Mandy's house has a big electronic gate in front and can only be opened with a code or from the inside. She never gives the code out as that is a rule her parents instituted. Brad gets out of his car and walks towards the gate and it begins to open. He sees Mandy come walking out of the main house and towards him. He walks through and gives her a big hug and kiss. In his hand he has a bag with two bottles of liquor and a bottle of red wine. She smiles and says "what do you got there?" "Just some whiskey and rum as well as wine, our favorites!" Brad says. "That's awesome! This way, let's go to the poolhouse it is nice and private and more romantic," Mandy says. Not thinking much of it, he says "Sounds good, I don't think I've ever been there before, maybe we can do some skinny dipping in the hot tub later?" Brad says. "I like the way you think, sounds like a plan," Mandy says knowing that won't be happening.

Mandy opens the door to the poolhouse and she and Brad both come in. Inside a nice meal is prepared and the TV is on ready for movie watching. "Come sit down and have some dinner, pop open that wine as well," Mandy says. She excuses herself from the table, saying she has a surprise for Brad that he's gonna like.   After eating a bowl of pasta and having a glass of wine, Brad sits at the couch in front of the TV waiting for Mandy to start the movie. He is surprised she has been gone for over 20 minutes. Then the bedroom door opens revealing Mandy wearing a sexy lingerie. His cock immediately gets hard seeing her in that red lingerie and bright red lipstick. "Wow babe, you look so hot! What a surprise!," Brad says. "Let's have some fun in the bedroom, baby, take off your clothes. First, crack open the whiskey and let's do some shots," she says. "Sure babe, I'll get a couple glasses," Brad says. They both take two shots and Mandy goes in for the kiss. They both make out and she starts unbuckling his pants pulling them down so he's in his briefs. He takes off his shirt while still kissing her passionately at the same time until his sexy chest is revealed. Now he is only in his briefs as she holds his hand and guides him to the bedroom.  

They both lay on the bed kissing as she then takes her hand and rubs his hard wet cock in his briefs. He moans as he kisses her and starts thrusting on her hand. She then pulls down his briefs revealing his 8.5 inche hard cock dripping with precum as he then goes to unzip her lingerie. She stops kissing and says "Now we can have some more fun, baby. Why don't we try spicing things up. What do you say about you letting me tie you up and riding you while you are in bondage?" She asks. "Nah babe, I don't know, doesn't sound too appealing let's just fuck like we normally do," Brad says. "Ah come on, babe, please? Just this once. If you don't end up liking it then we won't do it again I just want to try it and see what it's like. My friend Emily and her boyfriend do it all the time and they said their sex is incredible," She says. "Really? I didn't know Jeff and her do that stuff, he's never said anything to me. I mean I guess if Jeff and Emily do it then it's more normal than I thought," Brad says. "Yeah baby please? For me. Just one time I promise I'll make it a night you won't forget it'll be so hot and fun!" Mandy says. "Ugh well okay, fine, but just this once and if I don't like it then don't ask to do it again, okay?" Brad says. "Deal, I promise baby," Mandy says.

Brad takes another shot and says, "Alright let's get this over with," in an annoyed tone.  "Go ahead and lay down face up." Mandy says. Brad complies and Mandy walks over to the dresser drawer and takes out the handcuffs. She cuffs the left wrist first to the bedpost and then follows with the right one so that Brad's arms are spread widely out above his head. He pulls on them, surprised how restrained he is. She then goes to the drawer and grabs some rope and then ties his left ankle to the end bedpost and then does the same to the right one spreading them out wide. Brad is naked tied spread eagled and secured to the bed. "Haha okay baby let's fuck now, my cock is getting impatient," Brad says. "Aww okay baby I'm not done yet almost," she says. She then grabs a night shade blindfold and puts it over his eyes. She then finds some brown tights and ties it around his blindfold. "Ugh baby, you didn't say anything about a blindfold, I'm not sure I like this I want to see you while having sex," Brad says. "Aww babe, don't you trust me? It'll be fine it adds to the experience I want to be able to tease you a bit. Trust me it'll be fun," Mandy says. "Fine, whatever, just don't do anything else, let's start the fucking babe," Brad says. "Patience, baby, just relax and enjoy this, there's no rush," Mandy says.   Brad contined to pull on his restraints and moves around side to side. His big hard cock sways as he shifts side to side. His legs move trying to pull away but are tightly restrained. "Ugh you got me tied pretty good babe, was that really necessary?" Brad says. "Of course baby, it's all part of the experience, just relax, okay? Let's start," Mandy says.

She starts stroking his dick, pumping up and down. He immediately starts moaning and getting into it. "Mmm baby, keep going that feels so good," Brad says. "Mm babe, do you want me to suck it?" Mandy says. "Mm yes baby, suck my big dick," Brad says. "Mm okay baby, I'll suck that massive cock of yours!" She says. She then tip toes over to the closet and quietly turns the knob. As she opens she gestures AJ to come out. AJ grins and walks towards the tied up Brad. He can't believe how big and beautiful Brad's cock looks. It goes up to the bottom of his 8 pac abs and his big balls hang down low halfway between his upper thighs and kneecaps. "You want me to suck that big meat baby?" She says. "Fuck yeah! Suck my big dick baby now!" Brad replied trying to look around for where Mandy is but the blindfold keeps him from seeing anything but blackness. "Come on babe. Stop teasing, I'm so horny right now!" Brad says. "Okay babe, I'm just trying to prolong this, it is so hot I don't want it to end," she says. AJ then quickly strips down, only down to his red jock strap he wore specifically for tonight. His big Italian dick is protruding from the jock strap as it is excited for what is to come.  

AJ then tip toes over to Brad and puts his hands on his hard cock. He then puts that massive cock in his mouth and begins sucking away. "Mmmm fuckkkkk baby, oh my God, you suck so good, where did you learn how to suck like that?" Brad says. His head leans back on the pillow and he moans away as the sensation of AJ's sucking becomes too much to control. Mandy takes out her phone and takes pictures and videos of Brad moaning and saying "mmm fuckk yeah keep sucking, fuckk baby keep sucking like that fuckkk it feels so good!!" He is thrusting up and down and facefucking AJ's mouth. AJ suddenly stops and gestures to Mandy to get the ball gag out of the drawer. "Fuck! Why did you stop? That felt so good babe!" Brad said. "I just think you are making too much noise, let's keep that big mouth shut," she replied. "Oh no, I'm not down for that babe! Don't you dare put anything in my mouttthhhpppphhh!!" Brad tries to say as he is silenced by the ball gag. "Ppwwaattthhh pphuuckkk!!" "(What the fuck!) Brad tries to say as the black ball gag is tightly secured in his mouth. "That's better, now relax babe, this will be fun, trust me!" Mandy says as she gestures AJ to go back to sucking Brad's cock. "Pppphhhmmm!!! Phhhffucckkk!!!!" Brad says as he is continuing to enjoy AJ's mouth on his cock. "Phffucckkk phhhhhaaaa" (FUCKKKKK Yeah!) Brad continues as he can't believe how amazing this feels. It's almost as if it's someone else, he thinks to himself as he's laying there unknowingly thrusting his big cock in AJ's mouth. Mandy continued to take more pictures and videos, smiling and laughing to herself as Brad looks so pathetic tied up and gagged and unknowingly enjoying a guy sucking him off. She then decides it is time to reveal AJ and their plan.

She gestures AJ to stop sucking, making Brad angry again. "Phhhffucckkk! Pphhhhnnttt ppphhhooppp!!" (Fuck! Don't stop!). "It's okay baby, I want you to now see your cock being sucked do you agree?" She says. Brad pathetically nods as drool drips down his face. "Okay baby, I will," she says as she removes the ball gag first.  "Mm fuckk that was hot babe," Brad says. "You want to keep going?" Mandy asks. "Mm yeah babe, suck my big cock!" Brad says. "Okay let me just take this blindfold off" Mandy says as she take the brown tights and lifts his head up. Then she pulls off the blindfold. Stunned and shocked what he sees he gets angry and says, "what the fuck? Why is AJ here? Why is he wearing that? What's going on?" Brad says. "Shut up! You are being punished! I know what you did at the party, how could you do this to me? Now it is your turn to learn your lesson!" Mandy says. "What the fuck? Fuck you let me out of here!" Brad says. "By the way, AJ was the one sucking you off this whole time, and he and I have a fun night in store for you!" Mandy says. AJ then pulls down his jock strap, revealing his big hard cock throbbing up and down. "Oh no, what the fuck ewww like a fucking fag as been sucking my cock?! How dare you fuck!!!" Brad says. "Untie me now or I'll beat your ass and call the cops!" Brad says. "Oh I don't think you will, I took pictures and if you go to the cops or tell anyone or even harm AJ, I will send these all over the internet and up all over the locker room!" Mandy says. "Fuck you fucking bitch! Get me out of here help!!!! Someone help!!! Fuck you fuckers!!!" AJ had enough of his loud mouth and goes over and stuffs his jock strap in Brad's mouth and holds his hand over it. "Get me the tape!" AJ yells to Mandy as she goes into the closet and takes out the duffle bag, and grabs the big roll of thick sliver duct tape. Brad shakes his head violently and tries yelling "mmppphhhnnnpohh mmpppphkkk mmmppphhh!!!!! (Nooo!! Fuck you!!) Mmpphhhllppphhh!!! (Helllpppp!!!) Brad tries saying but to no avail. Mandy then hands AJ the duct tape and he then pulls a strip off and places it over the stuffed mouth. He then lifts Brad's head up wraps it around his head several times. Six......seven....he counts to himself as the tape is so tight around Brad's mouth and head he looks so pathetic yet hot at the same time. "There you go! Silent as a mouse!" AJ laughed as Brad tries to yell out but it is hopeless and just muffled grunts. "How's the taste of my jock strap boy?" AJ says. "Can you taste my cock? I know you'll end up liking that taste when we are done here tonight!" AJ says. Brad tries to yell out angrily "Mmmppphhhkkk mmmuuuuhh!!! Mmppphhnngg mmpphhhggg!!" (Fuck you fucking fag) Brad tries to yell! "Oh I hate that word you asshole! You'll see who the fag is after tonight now lay there and relax I promise you'll enjoy this!" AJ says. Brad shakes his head and makes muffled whimpers and tries to look over at Mandy for help but she looks away. "I'm going back in the main house, you two have fun!" She laughs. "After tonight, you'll learn never to cheat again you fuckhead!" She says as she then leaves the poolhouse. Brad tries to yell out and shake his head violently and screaming in his gag for help but it's all muffled nonsense. 

AJ then looks at his bound and gagged captive. He can't believe his luck. He has the hottest guy in college naked and tied down right in front of him. Brad's big cock is still hard as a rock and leaking precum and throbbing. "Haha I see you like this more than you thought? Cocks don't lie!" AJ says. "Mmppphuukkk mmpphuuu!!!" (Fuck you!) Brad tried to say. "Haha, that will happen later I promise, AJ said. "Mmmppphhhhhhh!!! MMPPPGGPPHHH!! Mmppphhhkkrrr!!!" (Noooo!! HELLLPPPPP!! Fucker!!!) Brad tries to say as his head violently shakes from side to side screaming in his gag. "Relax, straight boy, you'll like this more than you think. I know we had a connection at the party, now let's act on it." AJ says. Brad angrily grunts and growls in his gag as AJ goes to Brad's cock and starts stroking it. Pumping up and down, he can barely hold the big cock in his hand. "Wow! This is the biggest dick I've seen, you'd make any gay man happy such a beautiful specimen!" AJ says. Brad's muffled grunts and whimpers turn to muffled moans as he begins enjoying AJ's warm hands on his cock. "Mmm yes, your big cock loves this I know it! I've wanted to do this to you for a long time! Your stupidity created the perfect opportunity to have this happen so I thank you," AJ says. "Do you want me to suck it?" AJ asks. Reluctantly, Brad nods his eyes still closed from the sensation of his cock being jerked off. "That's what I thought. I know many of your teammates well and intimately. They too have a big crush on you and want this beautiful cock. I must be a lucky guy! They talk about your dick all the time and the things they'd do to you. Too bad for them that they aren't here!" AJ said. Brad whimpers and screams in his gag but it's muffled nonsense as AJ laughs. AJ then goes down on Brad's dick and sucks away. "Mmppphhh mmphhhhh mmpphhh!!!" Brad moans loudly as the feeling is beyond amazing. AJ stops and grabs Brad's gagged chin and makes him stare at him. "Look at me as I suck your cock, let's grow that connection bitch!" AJ says.

They both look at each other as AJ sucks away the sound of him choking and slirping on Brad's cock echo across the room. Brad's moaning is in sync with AJ's moaning as they both moan and stare into each other. Brad can't believe what's happening, he's enjoying this and is mesmerized by the look of AJ's face with his big cock in his mouth. He sees AJ's big cock throbbing and leaking precum as his position on the bed caused his cock to press against Brad's leg. Brad can't control himself anymore and is about to release his load "MMMHHHMPPHH MMPHGGNNNAAA MPPPHHMMM!!!" (IM GONNA CUMMMM!!) Brad tries to yell out in a muffled voice. AJ immediately stops making Brad angry. "Phew that was close, you are not going to cum until I say so, bitch! I am in charge here so get used to it!" AJ says. He then takes out the lubricant and lathers his big cock with it. "Now it's time for me to teach you your lesson and to show you who's the bitch! You'll never cheat on anyone again after tonight straight boy!" AJ says. Brad goes crazy and pulls at his restraints and moves side to side and yells in his gag as loud as he can screaming and shaking his head "MMMPPPHHHHH!! MMPPPGGPPHH MMPPHLLPPHHH!!" Brad utters but it's no use. AJ then lathers the lube on his finger and then shoves it up Brad's ass causing him to scream and yell loudly in his gag shaking his head and whimpers and cries. "Trust me this will make it better so take it and relax," AJ says. He then positions himself to aim his big cock towards Brad's asshole. "You'll never forget your first bitch!" AJ says as he shoves his cock into Brad's ass. Brad screams and cries out while shaking his head "MMPPPGPPHHH!! MMPPPGGPPHHH!!! MHHPPPHHHHH MMPPPGGPPHH!!! MPPPPHHKKKHHH!!!" (HELP!! FUCK!!) Brad tries to say but AJ continues to thrust his big cock into Brad's ass thrusting in and out deeper and deeper as Brad's screams start turning into moans and now he's staring pathetically looking at the first man to dominate him and fuck him. He stops struggling and lays there making muffled grunts and whimpers as he knows there is nothing more he can do and yet he starts to enjoy it and is stating at AJ like he's in a trance. "Mmmm yess fuckk you are so tight fuck yeah take my cock!" AJ says. He sees Brad's cock slap against his chest as AJ's passionately fucks him.

The sounds of the bed creaking, Brad's muffled grunts and AJ'S moans echo across the room. It is a sound like no other. AJ then takes the lubricant and lathers it in his hand so he can jerk Brad off at the same time. They are both moaning as AJ jerks off Brad's big cock. Pumping up and down while thrusting inside him he can't believe how great and perfect this night has been. He feels the urge to cum and feels his load surge out of his cock into Brad's ass "I'm gonna cummmm fuck!!" AJ says as Brad then utters "MMMHHMM MMPHGGNNAAA MMHUMMM" (IM GONNA CUM!) As they both shoot their loads. Brad came all over himself and AJ burst his into Brad's ass. "Fuck that was amazing! Did you learn your lesson bitch?" AJ asked. "Mmmmhmm!!!" Brad tries to utter. "Hmm I think you've learned more then you think." AJ says. He then cuts the tape off of Brad's mouth and Brad spits out the jockstrap. AJ then uncuffs and unties Brad as they both are now laying next to each other naked. Their cocks are hanging low and AJ asks, "do you want to lay here with me?" Brad nods his head as they both hold one another and AJ goes in for a kiss and they both make out passionately. They both fall asleep in each other's arms.  The next morning AJ wakes up early and puts his clothes on and leaves. He sees Brad all snug in the blanket still naked sleeping away. He leaves his phone number in Brad's pants pocket hoping he will call him. He wouldn't blame him if he doesn't but he feels he was successful in unleashing Brad's inner gay... 

******* 

Three months have gone by with still no word from Brad. The Tigers went on to win the championship game and now Brad has offers to be drafted for three different professional teams. He and Mandy broke up the day after that night and he hasn't gotten with anyone yet as he's "focused on football and being drafted," he told his teammates. Though they noticed an odd change in him as his interest in sex and talking about women have decreased. His teammates also notice him glancing at other guys naked in the showers and his cock begins to swell often. None of them thought much of it though and they all graduated without any mention of it.  AJ sat at home one night staring at himself in the mirror. He is bummed he is alone and tired of the one night stands he has with jerky men. Suddenly, his phone pings. It's Brad: "Hey man, wanna hangout? We can go to a bar down the street?" AJ replies, "sure I'll, meet you there!" After a night of drinks there was no mention of the special night 3 months ago but Brad and AJ's connection grew. "Would you want to make this a thing?" Brad says. "Sure, I'd like that a lot." AJ said, as Brad's hand went onto AJ's leg. AJ then puts his hand on Brad's and they lean into each other while drinking their drinks. "I've always had a crush on you but I suppressed it, but after what happened between us those months ago, I realized I liked it and had a deep passionate connection to you I've never felt before. I was a jerk and I'm sorry can we start over and call this a date?" Brad says. "Sure, I'd like that even more," AJ said. "Good, maybe I can come by your place later and pick up where we left off?" Brad says. "Definitely, sounds amazing," AJ says.......... 

The end, or is it???