Take it Like a Man

Let me know what you think of this one! As always, leave a comment below or email me if you liked the story, or have any feedback! Follow me on twitter @QuesadillaNFrys for previews and depictions of my stories! If you have a story idea you'd like me to write, check my profile for instructions and email me at [email protected]!

Thank you, and enjoy!

---

Beck Miller stood outside the dormitory, staring up at the towering building. He couldn't believe he was finally here - college. It had been a lifelong dream of his, but now that he was attending a university far from home, he felt a mix of excitement and apprehension. Beck was a small, yet tall guy with dirty blond hair. He didn't do a lot in terms of working out, but he did like to run and jog.

As a bisexual man, Beck had always felt like he didn't quite fit in. He had grown up in a conservative town where being gay was frowned upon, and he had never felt comfortable coming out to many people. But now, he had the chance to be himself, away from the judgmental eyes of his hometown.

However, the idea of being in a new place, with new people, was daunting. Beck worried that he wouldn't find anyone he could connect with, or worse, that he would face discrimination for his sexuality. But as he stepped into his dorm room and met his new roommate, he felt a glimmer of hope.

Noah Wheeler was on top of the world in High School. An all-star quarterback for the football team and pitcher for the baseball team, he was attending college on a scholarship. He'd practically gotten a full ride from the university. He was a muscular jock with dark brown hair and could pretty much get any girl he wanted.

Beck and Noah were assigned as roommates. They got along fine, but didn't have a whole lot in common, and mostly didn't interact with each other unless it concerned their shared living space. Noah was straight, but he was fine with Beck's sexuality. "So long as it doesn't affect me," Noah had said. Fair enough.

Noah had women around the dorm room almost as often as he was around; the standard sock on the door indicated he was not to be disturbed, and Beck would hang out in a friend's room until Noah texted him that he was good to come back. Beck had brought a few partners around the room too, but nowhere near as frequently as Noah did. For the most part, if Beck wanted to get off, he'd take out a dildo and play with it for a while. He didn't get fucked often, but he liked using a small, vibrating dildo he had stashed away in a drawer. There was little risk of Noah finding it in there.

One October day, while Noah was out, Beck decided to get the dildo out and use it. Pulling off his pants and wearing just a jockstrap, Beck lined the toy up to his tight hole and pushed it in.

"Aaaaaaahhhh fuck..." he moaned, as the dildo slid into him. Slowly, he worked it into his tight ass, squeezing it as he did. Eventually, he got it in all the way and his hole closed around the base. He turned on the vibration feature. "Fuuuuuuuck yeaaaahhh..." he groaned, as the vibrator worked his prostate.

He laid there for a few minutes and let it work him over until his cock was hard and leaking precum into the pouch of his jockstrap. It felt like waves of pleasure were moving through him, as if the dildo was generating an electric current plugged into his prostate. "Yeeessssss..." he moaned aloud. Beck began to fuck himself with the toy.

He started to slide the toy in and out of his hole, and then he heard the door open...

As Noah entered the room, he froze, seeing his roommate fucking himself on a dildo. He stared in shock for a moment, watching Beck's ass eagerly bounce up and down on the toy. After a minute, he cleared his throat.

"Shit!" Beck cursed, and turned around, seeing Noah and his date standing there. Beck had forgotten to put a sock on the door.

"Dude," Noah said. "What the fuck?"

"I thought you were out," Beck stammered, hurriedly pulling the dildo out of himself.

"We came back here to hook up," Noah said.

"Yeah, I should probably go," Noah's date said. She left the room in a hurry. "FUCK!" Noah yelled. Now he'd be blue-balled for the rest of the night.

"I'm sorry!" Beck said, fumbling to put his pants back on.

"Fucking bitch. She wasn't that hot anyway," Noah mumbled. "Now I'm gonna be fucking blue-balled, though. Shit."

"I'll make it up to you, I swear!"

"You're damn right you will, asshat!" Noah said. "Fucking blue-balled 'cause you had a dildo in your ass. I should show you what real dick feels like in there," he laughed, pointing to his crotch. "Fuck, with that tiny-ass dildo, you probably couldn't even take all this!" Noah flopped down on his bed.

"Speak for yourself, dude. I've had plenty of dicks bigger than that. Probably wouldn't even crack the top ten," Beck retorted. "'Least I could take one. You couldn't handle it."

"What's that supposed to mean?!" Noah's head shot up.

"Nothing, man."

"No, tell me, you fucker!"

"It means you could never handle a dick in your ass. It's hard, and you're not tough enough. Only a real man could truly take a good ass fucking." Noah started getting angry. "You're straight, dude. Your hole is tighter than a shrink-wrapped package. You probably couldn't even handle my 'tiny-ass dildo'".

"Fuck you Beck, I'm a star fucking quarterback! I'm more than tough enough to handle anything," Noah retorted.

"Look man, it's not a big deal. It just takes a certain type of guy to handle an ass-pounding, and you just aren't the type," Beck responded again.

"I could fucking take it if I wanted to, bitch," Noah kept going.

"You wanna prove me wrong? Here you go," Beck got his dildo and a bottle of lube out of the drawer and tossed it on the bed. "Knock yourself out."

"Fuck no, dude. I don't need to prove anything, and I definitely don't need to put a fucking dildo in my ass, especially after it's been in yours."

"What, the big, tough quarterback is too scared to handle 'tiny-ass dildo'? It's just a little vibrator. A real man could take it whether he's gay or not. It'll hurt a bit and then it'll feel good. If you're such a tough guy I'm sure you can handle a little pain. Unless the pleasure is what you're really afraid of?"

Noah stood there for a moment. "Fuck you, dude." He grabbed the dildo and lube before he could have a chance to contemplate what he was actually doing. He was gonna prove to his punk-ass bitch roommate that he was tough enough to handle anything. He couldn't believe he was just goaded into shoving a dildo up his butt, but admittedly he did have a bad habit of doing stupid things for the sake of his ego. Back in high school, he got sick trying to prove he could drink month-old milk simply because someone said he'd never be able to do it. He wasn't gonna let Beck get away with crapping on his reputation to his face. He'd never done this before, but Noah was a real man, a star quarterback, of course he could handle a tiny little dildo. He was a real man, after all. Like Beck said, a real man could do it even if he were straight, Noah supposed. And once Noah set his mind to something, he was always determined to see it through, even to his own detriment.

Noah laid on Beck's bed and pulled his pants and underwear down. He kicked them off and squirted a generous amount of lube on the dildo and his pristine asshole. He rubbed it on there, and began pressing the tip of the dildo against his hole. Immediately, he encountered stiff resistance. He'd never had anything in there, and he'd found it was difficult to open it up. "Arrggghhh, shitttt..." he grunted, as he tried to push it through his anal ring. "Fucking hell..." he was determined to get it in, but it just wouldn't budge. It didn't help that he was at a bad angle for his arms to reach.

Beck couldn't believe Noah was actually attempting it. That jackass had a dildo pressed against his asshole! His own cock hardened at the sight. Unfortunately, it was clear Noah had no idea what he was doing though.

"Fuck it. You don't know what the hell you're doing. Let me do it, dude," Beck said.

"I've got it!" Noah grunted.

"No, you don't. You could seriously hurt yourself. I'll show you how to get it in there," Beck repeated.

Despite his apprehension, Noah relented. He clearly wasn't getting anywhere, and it was true he had no idea what he was doing.

"Fine, dude." Noah handed Beck the dildo. Beck squirted more lube onto it, and began teasing Noah's hole with the tip of it, gradually coaxing it open.

"Fuuuuuck, holy shit!" Noah moaned.

"Relax, man. You can't just shove it in there, you gotta open the hole up first," Beck told him.

Beck took a deep breath, knowing full well he was about to push a dildo into Noah's straight ass. He rubbed the lube around Noah's hole, and as he did so, he couldn't help but glance over at Noah's hard cock that started growing. It twitched in anticipation. The more Beck teased Noah’s hole, the more it jerked. He had to remind himself that this was not purely about sex, but proving a point.

Beck began sliding the tip of the sex toy into Noah. “OHHHH shit!” Noah cried out as he was penetrated for the first time. His cock jumped up at the sensation. It hurt like hell, but he wasn’t about to prove Beck right. He’d take the whole thing, even if it hurt him. His coaches always told him, “No Pain, No Gain,” after all. A little ass pain wouldn’t kill him. Beck began sliding the dildo deeper, and Noah grimaced as he felt it stretch him open. With one final thrust of the dildo, it slid in easily. “FUCK!” Noah yelled out, as the base pressed against him.

"There," Beck said. "That wasn't so bad. It’ll feel good in a minute." Beck turned on the vibration setting, sending unexpected shockwaves throughout his body.

“GYaaaaah! Shit! What was that?!” Noah panted.

“It was just the vibrator, relax dude.”

Beck started moving it in and out slowly as Noah moaned, his muscular ass flexing and relaxing around the toy. "Oh fuck..." Noah groaned as a wave of pleasure washed over him. He tried to focus on the pleasure building up inside himself instead of the pain that accompanied it. The vibrations were incredible, and the friction felt amazing against his prostate every time it hit its mark. As Beck worked the dildo in and out faster, Noah's walls clenched down on it hungrily while precum leaked out of his cock like a faucet.

"You see," Beck grinned, "I told you it would feel good." His eyes never left Noah's crotch as his roommate began to pant and sweat underneath him, with the dildo fucking him harder and faster now. 

"Yeah yeah..." Noah moaned between groans, "I told you I was tough enough to handle it.”

“Sure man, you can handle my tiny dildo. I concede. I still don’t think you could handle a real fucking.”

“Bullshit. I could handle anything you could throw at me,” Noah retorted.

“Is that so?” Beck responded. He pulled off his pants and pulled out his cock - a massive, thick, 11-inch long shaft that was aching for a tight hole. Beck pulled the dildo out of Noah’s hole, now slightly stretched open. He began applying very copious amounts of lube to both his cock and Noah's straight, virgin hole.

Noah’s eyes widened at the sight of Beck’s massive cock. “FUCK dude, that thing is a fucking monster!” Noah said. Turns out, Noah had nothing on him in the size department. For a twink, Beck had him beat.

Beck pressed the head of his cock against Noah’s hole. “Well? Still think you’re tough enough to handle it?”

Noah hesitated for a moment, but his ego got the better of him. “Fuck you, dude,” Noah glared at him. “I can take anything you’ve got, bitch.”

Beck smirked, and began pressing the tip of his cock slowly into Noah.

“FUUUUUUUUCK! GODDAMMIT! HRRRGGGGGHHHHH!!!” As Beck's massive cockhead pressed against Noah's already open asshole, the jock grunted in pain. He was grimacing intensely at the sensation of his virgin hole stretching open by such a huge cock. It filled him up so much more than the dildo did. The size difference was astounding, and his hole felt like it was being ripped open. "GYAAAAH! HOLY SHITTTT!!!" he cried out, his tight hole clenching down on Beck's shaft. 

“You okay dude?” Beck asked, briefly pausing his insertion.

“I’m fine! Just fucking get it over with and put it in,” Noah growled. He wasn’t about to back down now.

“Okay man, don’t say I didn’t warn you.” Beck continued sliding in; he could feel his cock grinding against the tight walls of Noah’s fuckhole.

"AAAAAHHHH! FUUUCK ME, THAT'S HUGE! SHIIITTT!!! FUCKING HELL!!" Noah bellowed, his hole feeling like it was on fire. It hurt so bad, but at the same time, his cock was rock-hard. "GOD DAMN, MAN!"

The pressure from Noah's virgin walls was unbelievable, and the warmth and wetness made his cock tingle. Every inch that Beck slid in made his dick throb. He could tell that his roommate had never taken a cock before, and it felt so good to break him in.

After about half of his shaft was inserted, Beck stopped, letting Noah get used to his cock. Noah's breathing was heavy, and he could hear his heartbeat thumping in his ears. "Damn, dude... That is a lot to take in..." Noah huffed.

"Just wait, there's a lot more to come," Beck chuckled. He was only halfway, but his balls were already resting on the football player's ass.

"You're fucking kidding me," Noah sighed.

"No, I'm not. Are you ready for the rest, tough guy?"

"Fuck you. Yes, I'm fucking ready," Noah said.

"Alright, here we go. Try and relax your muscles. It'll make it easier to slide in," Beck suggested.

Noah relaxed his anal ring and Beck began sliding in the remaining 5 inches, causing him to moan.

"AAAAAHHH!! FUUUUCK!" Noah screamed, his entire body tensing. His hole burned, and his walls were screaming in protest.

"Relax, man. I'm almost in," Beck said.

"Fuck! FUCKING HELL, YOU'RE SO THICK!" Noah roared.

Eventually, Beck's cock reached the deepest part of Noah's ass, and he bottomed out. His balls were pressed fully up against Noah's ass. "There," he said. "I'm all the way in."

"Shit... fuck..." Noah panted, as his asshole was spread wide.

"You're so tight! It feels so fucking good," Beck said.

"It fucking hurts, man," Noah groaned.

"I'm not even moving yet, dude. Relax. You've got this. Tough guy, remember?" Beck started moving around a bit inside of Noah, massaging the straight jock's prostate. Noah's whole body tensed up before releasing a deep moan of pleasure. The dildo hadn't prepared him for this, but the pain wasn't so bad now that he knew what to expect. As Beck began thrusting, he grunted and moaned in unison with every push, matching his roommate's pace. "Fuck! Fuck! FUCK!" they both yelled out.

Noah's whole body tensed up before releasing a deep moan of pleasure. The dildo hadn't prepared him for this, but the pain wasn't so bad now that he knew what to expect. As Beck began thrusting, he grunted and moaned in unison with every push, making sure to match his roommate's pace. "Fuck! Fuck! FUCK!" they both yelled out.

Beck leaned down and began to thrust deeply into Noah, his jock roommate grunting and moaning heavily he started to fuck him hard. His muscular body jerked and flexed in response to the cock in his ass, while his strong hands gripped Beck's waist. “AAaaaaagghhh, Jeeeeezus fuckinggggg christtttt. Hooooolyyyyyy shit…” Noah cried out as he felt Beck’s massive cock drill into him.

“Come on, tough guy, take it like a fucking man!” Beck growled and taunted him, slapping his jock ass with his hands as his pelvis slammed into it. Noah moaned out. "UGGGGGHHHH. SHIT!"

It hurt, but it had also begun to feel amazing. "Oh god," Noah groaned between thrusts, "this is incredible." His cock was throbbing and leaking pre-cum all over the bedding. The sensations were intense, more so than anything he could have imagined from a dildo or a woman.

Beck leaned in and whispered into Noah's ear, "Told you that you would enjoy it."

Noah pulled away slightly, breathing heavily. "I...I can't believe I'm getting fucked by my roommate..." He gasped out.

Beck chuckled in response, his cock twitching inside Noah's hot, tight hole. "Yeah, well, you're the one who wanted to prove you were tough enough. Now you are, aren't you?" He asked, smirking down at him.

"Shut up and fuck me," Noah groaned back, arching his back and lifting his ass higher for more. Beck obliged, and pounded into him harder and faster. It was true; he never thought he'd be doing this with another man, much less his roommate. But it felt so good. “Shit! Holy fuck! Fuck me!” Noah cursed, leaning his head back with each thrust.

Their bodies slammed together over and over again as they both lost themselves in the heat of the moment. Beck pounded Noah ruthlessly, hitting the jock’s prostate just right every time without fail. Every thrust sent shockwaves of pleasure through Noah's body as he gripped Beck's waist tighter and moaned louder. His eyes rolled back into his head in ecstasy while he looked at the ceiling fan spinning above him; it was almost hypnotizing. “Fuck yes! Fuck!” Noah chanted. The bed squeaked loudly as their weight bounced against it uncontrollably along with their heavy breathing and grunts intermingling in the air.

Noah could feel every hard inch of Beck's sizeable cock stretching him out more than he ever thought possible, filling him entirely but also making him want more. His hole clenched down on it like a glove around a hand every time it slid out then back in again. This was unlike anything he'd ever experienced - deep penetration combined with pleasure unlike anything he knew existed before today. His rock-hard penis throbbed and swung in the air with each thrust, leaking buckets of precum that Beck was fucking out of him. The scent of sweat mixed with sex filled the room, which made everything more intense for both of them.

As time passed by, sweat started dripping off Noah's muscular body, as Beck began working him over good. It felt like hours, but Noah was sure it couldn’t have been more than a few minutes. He was getting a better workout than he did half the days he was at the gym. His hard cock throbbed in the air, sensitive to the touch. He was getting close, and so was Beck.

"Hoooooly fuck. I can't believe it, you're gonna make me fucking cum, Beck!" Noah whined, panting hard with each thrust of Beck's shaft. "This is the best damn fuck of my life, and it's not even from a woman."

"Yeah, that's right, jock. Take my big fat cock like a fucking slut," Beck growled, pounding him relentlessly. Noah's asshole tightened around Beck's length, pulling him in deeper and making him shudder. The feeling of Noah's tight, warm insides surrounding him was overwhelming.

"I'm close too. Your hole feels so good, you're gonna make me cum soon," Beck growled.

"Fuck, yeah, cum inside me. I wanna feel you explode in my ass. Fucking breed me, man," Noah groaned back, pushing his ass further into Beck.

Beck's thrusts set Noah off, and he felt himself reach the point of no return. "OH FUCK, SHIT! I'M CUMMING, BECK! AAAAAAAGGGGHHHHH!!!!" Noah bellowed as his orgasm hit him harder than ever before. "FUUU-UUU-UUUCCCKKK", Noah cried out, as he blasted ropes of thick, white, sticky cum across his abs, pecs, and face. His hole clenched around Beck's cock, milking his load out of him. "OHHHH YEAAAHHH, BECK, FUUUUCK!!!" Noah cried, his voice cracking.

"HOLY SHIT, NOOOOOAAAHHH! I’M GONNA FUCKING BREED YOU, BITCH!!" Beck yelled out, as the feeling of Noah's hole milking his cock sent him over the edge too. "FUCK YEAH! FILL ME UP!" Noah cried out, as his cock shot rope after thick rope of creamy white semen onto his stomach.

Noah's whole body trembled, his ass quivering with pleasure as his cock spurted its last few drops of cum onto his belly. With a few more rough, deep thrusts, Beck exploded inside his jock roommate. Cum flooded Noah's ass, and Noah's hole tightened up. "Oh, fuck yeah," Beck growled. "Your ass is mine now, bitch." All the spent Noah could do was moan in delirium as his roommate unleashed a tsunami of cum inside him.

"Shit, man," Noah breathed, panting.

"How do you feel?" Beck asked.

"I feel like a fucking man!" Noah declared, with a big, delirious grin on his face, still panting hard. His body was soaked in cum, and it was leaking out of his asshole.

"Damn, dude. You really did take it like a man. I gave you everything I had and you took it all! You really are one tough motherfucker."

"Guess I won't be having any blue-balls tonight," Noah laughed. "But I might not be able to sit for like a month!"

"That's just more time you can spend showing me what a man you really are," Beck grinned devilishly.

"I might have to take you up on that," Noah said, his cock twitching at the thought.