Straight boys first time with me and my ex

This is a story that happened many years ago. This is my first story here, so near with me.

I had been with my first boyfriend for about two months. We har both come out of the closet after hiding for almost two months more, so technically we had been together for four. And as you know, four months is forever when your 17. We were treated pretty good. Even though we lived in a small town people were more than accepting. We all of the sudden started to get invited to all the parties. Like the cool gay couple that everyone wanted to talk to and was curious about. I had never heard of other gays here. I guess they hadnt either.

It was at easter everything happened. My BFF (or faghag if you will) had the house for her self for the entire weekend since her parents where going to a wedding. And it was gonna be a kickass party!

Almost everyone at school got invited. Cool kids, nerds, you know it. And then there was HIM. He was basically the superstar of the school. Good on the soccer team, popular with the ladies, even though he went three classes under us he still hung out with the cooler, om det kids. And a face and body you could dream about every night. My friend introduced us for eachother. He had heard all about is, but never really talked to us. So him, me and my boyfriend sat down on a sofa and started talking. He had a lot of questions. Not to weird ones, but as the night went on and the wine coolers became more he started asking away. For example he asked wich one was the "woman" and which one the "man" was as I guess most straight guys do. But the party started to get cramped and since we didn't really want to sit in the middle of everyone and discuss our sex life, we asked if he wanted to take a smoke and we could tell him in private.

The garden har one of those doll houses and we decided to take the smoke in there to get away from the rain. Inside and after a little time he asked again. Who is the "woman" and "man" out of the two of us. I remember er laughed a little and said that we didn't really see it as that. And also that we switched on it. I said "Because you see. The first time we did it we decided that the one who had the biggest cock would be the one to fuck. But then we measured and turned out we're the same size."

"Hey" I asked. "Can I ask you a question if it's okey? "Sure" he replied.

"How big is your dick" I'm just wondering. He answered that he didn't know excactly. He had tried to measure it a few times, but didn't really know where to measure from.

I whispered in my boyfriends ear and he looked at him. "Have you ever compared with your friends before? And "yeah. A few times", he answered.

"Do you wanna compare?" I asked? "I mean, we'll do it if you do it to". He laughed a little, but said "Sure, okey". (I guess I figgured we wanted to see it. Haha. Not to mention that he was fairly drunk)

So we stood up in a cirkle and puled out our dicks, and both me and my bf was a little bigger than him. "It looks like we're a little bigger than you". "Yeah" he answered.

"Does it get bigger when it gets hard" my boyfriend asked, "or does it stay the same size"?

"It's alot bigger than this when it's hard" he said. "How much bigger?" My bf asked back. "Like this big?" He asked and put his finger a few inches from the tip of his cock. "Or even bigger"?

"Maybe a little bigger than that". "Hey" i asked again. If we promise to not say anything. Then can I ask another question?

"Yeah, ask away" he said.

"Could I just try to touch it? If it's okey with you ofc" I said and turned to my bf. "I promise I'm just going to feel what it feels like."

The boy got silent, didn't answer. Just thinking I guess. "I promise we won't tell anyone " I said again.

"Okey, but just a little. But I'm not gay. Just saying that".

I then slowly reached down my hand and grabbed around his dick. It was smooth and almost perfect in every way. I started thuging it really slowly while he sat there with his eyes closed. As I continued thuging I could feel it slowly starting to get semi and harder.

"Is it okey" I asked. "It's okey" he said. Still with his eyes closed. I winked to my bf and slowly took his hand and replaced it with mine. I could see my bf was as rock hard as me.

After a few minutes of feeling him he got harder and harder. "Hey, do you wanna compare now that we're all hard, I asked. He said "sure". His dick was acctually a pretty decent size.

"Hey, can I ask you two something now" he asked. "Of course" we said. Anything.

"Since you're gay you can answer this like girls. But. Do you think I'm hot og am I not hot at all?"

"It's not that easy to just answer that, my ex replied. Looks is one thing, but you gotta work them" I nodded.

How? He asked. Well, my ex said. Alot is about the pose. When you sit like that for example, you don't show ur best feats. Do you want me to show you a better pose?

We tried a few different poses but landes on him sitting on the floor with his pants down, shirt of and jerking his semi dick. He was spreading his legs and his hole was almost visible. At this point he seemed more comfortable with being nude with two guys.

Can we feel your balls to? I asked. He said that was okey. I started by rubbing them slowly and getting behind them and before I knew it I was massaging his hole. He almost humper when I did that.

"Hey, I said I'm not gay", he said. "

No worries we said, we know you're not gay. And we're not going to say to anyone that you are gay either. We're the gay ones"

Yeah, he said. But you can't fuck me. Because I'm not gay.

I wasn't going to, I said. I was just feeling it, you said I could? Maybe of we could see it better? Just real quick?

Okey, but REAL quick. One minute he said. He got on all four in a doggy position and lifted it up.... It was even better than imagined. Tight as fuuuuuck and totally hairless. Both of us were standing behind touching it and very slowly giving him a finger now and then.

"You can't fuck it" he said again.

"Haha, just relax" I said. "I dont think you could handle it to be honest. You gotta have balls to dare to take it behind"

"I COULD handle it" I'm just not gay.

"Nah. You would ask to stop right away. You couldnt even take the tip"

My bf got up and got over him. "Dude. You feel that?" He said and laid his cock loosely between his buttocks. Bro, u really think you could handle that? I don't.

"Okey, just the tip then" he said.

What did u say? We asked. He answered "I'll show you I can take the tip. But just the tip."

So we layed him on his back with his legs up. My ex tried first. Dry, and we could see he was clearly struggling.

"Told you" ny bf said with a smile. "I mean it's not even in. Say what, you are allowed to cheat a little. We can use some skin cream to make it glide bether"

He agreed but pointed out that IT was ONLY until it was in. Then it was over.

So I got to try now. I got over him and lifted his legs and my cock was hard as a log. I smeared the cream around his hole and started slowly going in. I could der he was biting his teeth while I did it. No wonder. He was tight as hell!

Is it in yet? He asked. Not quite yet I said. But truth is I was allmost all the way in.

"Og my god, You acctually almost did it" I'm almost in! I just need to take the last inches in. He was laying there and looking to get more relaxedand used to it.

"Hey, can we try just one thing, since your straigh?" Since we're allready inside. Could I try to go in and out a few times? Not everyday you get to do that with someone who is straight!

He said again "I'm not gay" "Well og course not we said. We're the ones who are liking this, so we're the gay ones. You're just REALLY hot u know? So we just wanna try it. You took it good this far"

"You really think I'm hot?" he asked. "Yeah. I mean. Atleast like this" we said.

Okey then. Just a little, he said. I was allready there, so I went first. I started slow, but went faster pretty quick. His soft cock were wiggling around and I started jerking it while I went deeper. And after a while, he started to get hard. He wasn't saying anything, just closed his eyes. So my bf took over his dick. And very slowly started sucking it. The boy got even harder and still not speaking. Just really low, soft moaning. I started to jerk my bf, but it wasn't so easy in that position. So we decided to switch. Now my bf were the one giving it to him.

My cock was bursting. Tried to jerk a little, but wanted a little more. So I slowly took the boys hand down around my dick. "Is this okey" I asked. He didn't answer anything back.

It started getting really hot after 30 minutes. My bf was now giving his ass a good fuck and I had him jerk me of.

"You want is to get done?" We asked. "Then we can to for more beer"

Okey, "finish then" he said. We then continued for 10 minutes before I said, I think I can't finish this way, can we switch? But my bf felt the same way. The boy had allready turned down a question if he wanted to taste my dick so oral was originaly out of the question.

"Hey I think it will go quicker if you open ut mouth a little and let us do og there for a few minutes. So if u want, we can try that. I'll go alot quicker.

At this point I guess he didn't even bother saying that he wasn't gay. He didn't answer so I just tried it. And got it in. He was laying there on his back then. Me in his mouth and my bf in his ass. Racing eachother and jerking and sucking his dick wich went a little up and down but now was hard as a rock. All of the sudden, I heard him making some sounds and his mouth was tightening. And as that happened his cock started shooting out loads! Both me and my ex realized we were close to and told him to get ready.

I don't EVER remember an orgazm line that! Him to! It was like out bodies just took controll! And before we knew it we were doing him so hard that his ass clapped and on the other side my dick was going troath deep. It wasn't even on purpose. It was like instincts took over. I remember making intensly out with my BF as I came. Filling the guys mouth so much it started pouring out. Likewise on the other side. I remember my bf grabbing his hips as he came. And the boy told us he could feel when it came. It was just pouring out after.

I got over to my bf and kisses him intensly. The boy was laying panting and breathing next to us. His hole was just staring at us. I remember thinking that I had never seen such a transformation from tight to... Not tight? Haha.

The boy chuckled a little. "You have a pretty good ass for a straight guy my ex said. Thanks for being so cool to us. And we won't say anything to anyone."

The guy seemed to get a little lighter from that and gave a little smile.

After that we dried up, got dressed and joined the party! As og nothing happened. Just giving him a sublte smile when we saw him talking to the girls.

This story is really what opened me and my bf up to having threesomes and more fun than the two of us could have. If it werent for him, we would have missed out on so much good fun. We even ended up meeting him again at occations.

There. Hope you like it. This is my first, but maybe there will be more:)