Seeing How the Other Team Plays

Author's Note:  This was originally a part of a story I wrote on another site a year ago.  It didn't fit really well for that story line, but I saved it for another time.  I made some modifications for posting here.  There's only one part.  Hopefully someone will enjoy it. 

---

Alex was lounging around in his dorm room, getting a few more moments of zen before heading to his afternoon class.  He liked the diversity of his floor and the amount of acceptance almost all of them had of each other.  It didn't matter what combination of sexual preference, race or religion anyone was, they felt comfortable there.  It was his second year on the floor and except for a few weeks in another dorm floor that had almost the opposite attitude, it was the only place he had lived in college.  

He was out and proud, but he didn't make it the primary focus of his personality.  Just like the color of his hair (jet black), the color of his skin (light brown from his Latinx parents) or his height, his queerness was only part of his genetic makeup.  Other things like how he trimmed his beard, the tattoos or the piercings he had gotten were choices.  Alex had made many friends in his time on the dorm floor and even met his boyfriend there who was now his roommate.

When it was time for class, Alex got up, walked to the elevator and saw a guy already waiting.  "Hey, Garrett.  How's it going?" he asked.  Alex had talked with him occasionally over the past year and a half, but knew he was straight so most of their conversations were non-sexual.   He found him attractive, but knew he was off limits.  Garrett was tall, about six foot two, toned and had a trimmed beard and glasses. He kept his dark blond hair cut short, just a little shorter than his beard.  Alex had never seen him in the shower, but when he wore shorts and a tank he saw that Garrett was a little hairy and had recently added a full right arm tattoo to the two other smaller ones Alex had seen.

"Meh.  Got dumped last week so life's been really quiet.  How about you?" Garret asked.

"Sorry to hear.  You should be able to find someone new pretty quick.  All the girls love smart, sexy guys... I hear.  I'm doing good.  Way too many tests this week though" Alex replied.

Garret laughed.  "I think they prefer the dumb ones that they can manipulate.  The last one got pissed since I didn't consult her before getting the new tattoo.  She had to know I was thinking about since I'd said a few things, but I guess it wasn't interesting enough to her.  From the sounds coming from these dorm rooms, you gay guys seem to get laid a lot more than us straight guys."

"Not always.  We still have preferences and they don't always match up, but since most are only looking for quick sex, not a relationship, it IS easier.   You should try it sometime.  It's better than using your hand" Alex replied.

Garrett's surprised look told Alex that he may have not understood his meaning.  "What? Me fuck a dude?  I don't think so" he told Alex.

"I meant casual sex, not necessarily with guys.  But... that could work too.  There's a lot more gay bottom guys looking to get fucked than top guys to fuck them.   Maybe you SHOULD try it.  Ever do anal with a girl?" Alex asked.

Garrett's expression took the level of surprise up a few notches.  He tapped the elevator button a few times as he got more uncomfortable by the second.  "Uh... no" he replied quietly.

Alex knew he'd gone too far and figured it was best to stop there.  "It's just pussy.  Anyway... good luck" Alex said as the elevator arrived.

Friday came quickly and Alex was studying before his afternoon class when there was a knock on the door.  Alex and his boyfriend usually left the door open unless they really needed to concentrate.  Garrett was there, looking nervous.  "Hey, what's up?" Alex asked.

Garrett came in and closed the door.  "Uh... I was thinking about what you said the other day."

Alex chuckled and wondered which part he was thinking about.  "About casual sex?   I have no idea where to look for a girl that is interested in that... other than hitting a few of the meat market bars.  Just make sure they know it's a one night stand first" Alex said.

"Yeah, probably not. I think lots of girls would love to get with a good looking guy like you, though.  Uh... I... Uh.. was talking about guys, though."  There was a pause and he continued "I was thinking it might not hurt to try since I'm not seeing anyone and my balls are really full."

It was Alex's turn to look surprised.  "Oh... wow.  I was kind of joking about you fucking guys, but if you're interested I can answer some questions you might have" Alex replied.

"Oh... I guess it comes down to two things...  What's it feel like and where do I find guys?" Garrett asked.

"I'm not an expert... I've only fucked a few women so I can't really compare the two" Alex said.  He had tried having sex with women, but it never turned him on.  With guys, he'd be hard in an instant and excited about a long session of energetic sex.  For the last attempt with a girl, he even got some pills to get him hard, but it was bad. He even apologized to the girl for the lame sex.  Alex told Garrett "Just like pussies, asses can be different.   Most are tighter than pussy, but there are some well used guys that aren't.  I assume from your 'balls full' comment that you're looking to fuck, not get fucked."

Garrett's anxiety was growing again and Alex could see it in the nervous twitches his body was making.  Garrett had never had a conversation like this before.  He'd had a few short conversations with other straight guys at parties talking about women, but he didn't like to brag like many guys did or even say what he liked to do.  "Oh fuck..  Uh... Yeah. I want to be the one fucking.  So... what do you do when you meet a guy?"

Alex chuckled to himself, watching Garrett stand there sweating.  "Have a seat.  The sex isn't much different, it's just what hole you use.   Casual sex usually skips the making out stage or it's really quick.  There may be a little foreplay, but a lot of time it's just some oral to get you hard and then you fuck. You can go harder with guys than women, but you just fuck to get off.  Usually it's not an hour long session and you're not making love.  Don't over think it.  It's a hookup you may never see again, OK?" Alex explained.

"Damn, I never thought about that.  Almost every time I've had sex it's with a girlfriend.  I think I've only done one or two bar hookups in my life and I was drunk.   Uh... I don't want to look for a guy in a gay bar though... I don't want anyone to know..." Garrett said.

"There's apps to hookup easily.  You'll probably be popular since you're fresh meat and a top.  The straight guy experimenting thing will turn some guys on and make others run away.  I don't know if hooking up with guys on the floor is a good thing.  While a few guys I know might be into it,  I wouldn't want to out them without asking first and you probably don't want anyone else to know."     

"Yeah... But if you know which guys I could trust not to say anything... that might be ok" Garrett said.  Alex could see that the idea was taking hold inside Garrett's mind and he was getting more excited and less nervous.

"What kinds of guys do you think you would want to meet?  Tall, short, butch, effeminate, hairy, smooth?" Alex asked.

"I dunno... something in the middle,  I guess.  Someone nice who won't be too hard on me if I don't know what I'm doing" Garrett answered.  

Alex pulled out his tablet and opened up a gay hookup app.  He scrolled through the bottom guys looking and showed the profiles to Garrett.  After a few dozen, Alex had an idea of the type that Garrett liked.  "Let's get a few pics to post for you."  Alex snapped a few on his phone and said "I'll edit these to crop out anything that could easily identify you, like your new tattoo or too much of your face.   I have to get to class, so let's meet up some time tonight unless you have plans" Alex said, giving Garrett a wink.

During his class he was thinking more about Garrett than the class lecture.  When Alex got back to the dorm, he got off the elevator to a group of guys joking around and chugging beer.  Garrett was there along with a few other straightish guys from the floor.  One guy, Derek, had flirted a few times with Alex but it never lasted for long before he was flirting with someone else.  Derek grabbed Alex's ass and gave a firm squeeze.  "Damn, you can probably bounce quarters off that, Alex" Derek said.

Alex spun around, grabbed the beer out of Derek's hand and took a swig.  "I got some good exercises to keep it tight.  I can show 'em to you sometime" Alex said, handing the beer bottle back.  He liked these kinds of interactions where it was all innuendos to let the guys still appear straight to their friends and dorm mates.

Derek leaned in and whispered "Any time.  You know where I live" and gave him a wink.  Alex nodded and went down the hallway towards his friend Jack's room.  He wasn't looking for Jack, but his roommate Toby.  Toby played on one of the intramural soccer teams and some of his teammates had taught him the pleasures of gay sex.  Once they finally realized they were both queer, Toby and Jack's relationship added a new, sexual dimension.  It worked well since Jack preferred to top and Toby loved to bottom. 

The door was open and Toby was there, folding his freshly washed clothes.  "Hi Alex, Jack's not back yet" Toby said.

"Actually, I wanted to talk to you.  Got a minute?" Alex asked.  A smile came over Toby's face and he nodded, hoping his afternoon was about to get a lot more fun.  Alex closed the door before saying "So... I know a straight guy that wants to try to fuck his first guy.  He's really nervous and just wants to experiment and see how it goes.   I know you were in his spot not too long ago.  Could you talk to him a bit?  Give him a few suggestions?  But you got to keep it just between us three.  OK?" 

"Oh yeah.  I know what he's going through.  I was so freaked out when one of the other guys on the team asked me.  But god... it felt so good once I tried.  You want me to just talk?  Or..." Toby asked.

Alex chuckled.  "Talk at least.  Just tell him its ok to try stuff.  It doesn't make him gay.  Maybe bi... if he does it more than a couple times and likes it.  Of course... once he feels that hot ass of yours he might be hooked" Alex replied.

"Yeah, look at me.  I might have checked guys out in the locker room, but never did anything for years.  Then once I got fucked I couldn't get enough" Toby said.

"Is now good?  I saw him wandering around when I got back from class" Alex asked.

"Sure... it might lead to a real slutty night with my ass dripping" Toby replied.

"Cool, I'll be back in a minute" Alex said, slipping out the door and walking back toward the elevator area.  Alex stopped at the edge of the open area and motioned for Garrett to come over to him.

"Uh... I talked to a guy on the floor that was in your spot last year.  He promised to not tell anyone else... so... if you want to meet him now, you two can talk a bit.  Get more comfortable about meeting a guy or maybe fool around if you two want" Alex said quietly.

Garrett looked terrified.  "I... dunno" he stammered out.

"Look, just talk for a couple minutes.  If you don't click, just tell him you have plans to meet someone.  But you might want to stop at your room and grab a condom.  I got some lube packets in my backpack."

Alex started to dig into his backpack for the lube packets and when he looked up, Garrett was gone.  He closed the backpack up and stood there with two lube packets in his hand.  A few moments later, Garrett came back looking nervous but also excited.

"I got ribbed and ultra thin" Garrett said, making Alex chuckle.  

He passed Garrett the lube packets and said "He said he wouldn't tell anyone about you, the same goes for you.  Right?"  and Garrett nodded back at him.

One tap on the door frame to Toby and Jack's room and Toby replied "Yeah, come in" followed by "Oh, yeah...  Hi Garrett."  Alex noticed that Toby had changed clothes and now had on basketball shorts and a tank and wondered if he was wearing anything under the shorts.

Alex closed the door most of the way.  He said "I'll let you guys talk... catch you later" before he turned around and started out the door.

"Wait!  You're not going to stay?" Garrett asked.

"I wasn't planning on it.  It might get awkward if you guys do anything more than talk" Alex replied.  Garrett motioned for him to come back and Toby just shrugged his shoulders.

With the door closed, Alex sat on Jack's bed with Garrett sharing Toby's bed on the other side of the room.  Toby told Garrett his story and soon Garrett was much more relaxed.  "I really don't care what label people want to give me.  I just know that I like fucking girls and getting fucked by guys.  It just means I get laid a lot more" Toby said as he slid closer to Garrett and grinned at him.  Alex could see Garrett start to breathe heavier and glance back and forth between Toby and himself.  

Alex quickly put together a plan to see just how horny Garrett was.  He stood up and moved to the center of the room and unbuttoned his jeans.  Toby took the cue and slipped off the bed on to his knees.  He unzipped Alex's jeans before pulling them down and burying his face in Alex's crotch.  Toby gnawed at the growing bulge while Alex watched Garrett's reaction.   

A quick motion of Alex's fingers had Garrett standing up and moving closer.  Garrett unbuttoned and pushed his jeans down, just like Alex's were.  He then moved closer to Alex until he was next to him with their upper arms touching, which surprised Alex.  Toby turned slightly, burying his face in Garrett's smaller bulge.

Alex felt Garrett's body jump slightly as he felt Toby start to work on his cloth covered cock.   It didn't stay covered long when Toby tugged down the briefs, freeing a very hard seven inches of uncut cock.  Alex looked over and saw Garrett had his eyes closed with an expression that showed he was enjoying Toby's efforts.   A few minutes later, Toby turned back to Alex and tugged his underwear down too.   Alex knew from experience that while Toby had only been sucking cock for months, not years, he was pretty good.   Whether it had been Jack, Toby's soccer buddies or someone else, they had taught him well.

A gasp was followed by "Holy shit!" as Garrett opened his eyes and looked down to see Toby slobbering over Alex's engorged shaft.  Alex smiled back at him as Toby moved back to Garrett's cock.  Alex was proud of his almost nine inch cock and was used to hearing surprised comments when anyone saw it for the first time.  Alex stepped to the side, removing his shoes, jeans, trunks and tee.  Next, he moved behind Garrett making sure his stiff cock didn't touch Garrett's body and tugged his tee over his head.  He leaned in and whispered "Just say something if it goes too fast.  We'll understand and you can stop at any time."

Alex took his place again and Toby moved back to his cock.  Garrett pushed off his shoes followed by the rest of his clothes leaving Toby as the only one still dressed.  He looked back over at Alex, smiling before glancing over his body.  Alex noticed that Garrett was now more relaxed and figured he would have no problem moving on to the next few steps of his first attempt at gay sex.

"Sit down on the bed and lean back" Alex said softly and watched Garrett do what he asked.   Alex pulled away and pulled Toby's shirt over his head.   Toby turned and swallowed Garrett's still hard shaft while Alex knelt down behind him, pulling his loose basketball shorts down and revealing a completely bare ass.  "Toby wasn't going to make it hard to get some dick today" thought Alex.

It took a little work, but Toby's shorts were completely off a few seconds later.   Alex spread his butt cheeks apart and looked over the tender pink hole he'd fucked several times since Jack had first offered his roommate's ass to him.  Alex heard Garrett gasp when he buried his face into Toby's ass.  A moment later, Toby moaned with a mouthful of cock.  The vibrations forced Garrett to cry out "OH FUCK!"  Alex figured that no woman had ever moaned or hummed around his cock before.  He tongue fucked Toby's hole a few minutes before leaning back and working his fingers into the spit soaked hole.

"Eating ass to get it lubed with spit isn't necessary, but I like to do it.  It's just like you eating a girl's pussy. Some spit and fingers is helps if the guy is tight" Alex explained to Garrett.  With spit dripping off his beard, he saw Garrett was watching every move he made with his mouth dropped open.  His fingers twisted, stretching Toby open and getting him ready to feel a cock plunge into his greedy ass.  Toby lunged forward and Alex wondered if that was the first time anyone had deep throated Garrett's cock.  Based on the moan and whimper, he guessed it was.   

After the third deep dive Toby made, Alex decided he would show Garrett his cock entering Toby's ass.   He tapped the rigid shaft along the crevice before pulling back the foreskin and resting the leaking tip on Toby's winking hole.  Alex looked up at Garrett, grinning a second before pushing in.  Garrett's eyes were open wide as Alex's cock slowly disappeared inside Toby's hole.  Alex stopped after four inches were inside and pulled back.  He rocked back and forth for a couple minutes before he pulled out.

"Your turn" Alex said. Garrett swallowed hard and got up from the bed.  Alex handed him a packet of lube and said "Don't forget the condom."

Garrett furrowed his brow and said "You didn't use one."

"Yeah, but you should.  Keep in practice for when you have sex with women" Alex replied. He watched Garrett reluctantly roll the sheath on and cover his shaft before lubing the latex.  Alex sat down on the bed in front of Toby, slapping his cock across Toby's face.  Garrett knelt behind Toby and used the rest of the packet to lube Toby's hole.  He gave a deep breath and pushed in. "Oh fuck" came out of both Garrett and Toby's mouths almost simultaneously.  Alex closely watched the expressions on Garrett's face as he felt his cock sink into Toby's talented hole.  He doubted that would be the last ass, male or female, that Garrett would fuck.  Toby's lips and tongue quickly brought Alex's cock back to full hardness.

Slowly Garrett started to rock, plowing in and out of Toby's hole.  The moans that Toby was making spurred him on to drive deeper and faster.  Alex thought that it was too gentle, but understood that Garrett was just learning and didn't want to  shoot too quickly.  Several minutes later, Alex calmly said "Drill him harder.  He'll let you know if you get too rough."

Garrett kicked it up a notch and then two, but was in an poor position to go any harder.  Alex motioned for him to bring one foot up then to move his hands from Toby's hips to his shoulders.  Toby released Alex's cock from his mouth for a moment yelling out "Oh god that feels good.   Harder, Garrett... Harder."

Garrett followed Toby's directions but seconds later yelled out "Oh, Shit!" and froze.

"What?" Alex asked.

"The condom broke" Garrett replied as he slowly pulled his cock out of Toby's hole.

"Want the other one?" Alex asked.

"Uh... No" Garrett answered.  He took a deep breath, grunted "Fuck it!" and drove his bare cock back into Toby's hole, with the latex remnants still clinging to the base of Garrett's shaft.  Alex watched him drill Toby even harder than before.  "Oh god... this feels even better!" Garrett cried out.   Each thrust from Garrett forced Alex's cock deep into Toby's throat.  Usually, Toby couldn't take it and would gag, but this time he was having no problem and Alex felt Toby's nose jabbing into his pubes.  It was getting Alex closer and closer to orgasm and when he looked up he saw Garrett was fighting off his own.

Four more thrusts was all that Garrett could muster before he drove in one more time and his body started to convulse.  Toby pulled off, yelling "Breed my ass!" before wrapping his lips around the end of Alex's cock and flicking his tongue under the shaft until Alex showered his mouth full of cum.

Grunts accompanied Garrett's cum shots, filling Toby's hole with his straight-guy seed.  Toby struggled to swallow the cum pumping out of Alex's cock, letting some drip past his lips and off his chin.  With their balls empty and Toby's gut filled with sperm, their breathing slowly settled back to normal.

Garrett was the first to speak. "Damn, that was hot.  I can't believe I did it" he said.

"That was a lot of cum.  Must have been a while since you emptied those balls" Toby said, making Garrett blush.  

"Over a week" he replied, staring at Alex and noticing his big grin.  "Why the grin, Alex?" he asked.

"Just happy to see a straight guy not run away right after he screwed his first gay guy.  Most seem to be embarrassed by it and take off as soon as their dick is out of the guy's ass" Alex said.

Garrett chuckled.  "I thought about it, but you guys have been so cool about it so it seemed silly.   Do you do this with every guy that wants to try it?" he asked.

"Not always, but you had the guts to ask so I couldn't refuse" Alex answered.

"Why did you want me to fuck with a condom?  He's not going to get pregnant and it feels so much better without" Garrett asked.

Alex started to say "Uh..." before Toby piped in.  "Alex knows I'm kind of a slut and let lots of guys fuck me.  He just wanted to protect you from anything I might have picked up" Toby explained.

"Like STDs?  Oh crap.  I never thought of that.  I was just too horny, I guess" Garrett replied.

Alex laughed and said "Yeah, that happens.  Guys think with their dicks most of the time, gay or straight.  I don't know about Toby, but let me know if you want to try something else.  There's lots of other fun stuff you can try if you don't limit yourself with one gender."

Garrett nodded as he stood up and collected his clothes, putting them back on as Alex and Toby laid there naked.  "Thanks, guys.  This was way better than I thought it would be.  My balls thank you too" Garrett said as he opened the door.  Jack was standing there with a big smile on his face, causing Garrett to gasp before he slid past and quickly headed to his room.

"That was a surprise.  Running out of gay guys to fuck you, Toby?" Jack asked.  

Toby and Alex laughed.  "Just helping a guy out, Jack" Toby replied.

A few days later, Alex and his boyfriend Max were on the bed, both in just running shorts with Max leaning back against Alex's chest.  The pair were reading stuff for their classes when they heard the tap on the door and looked up.  Garrett was standing there, nervously.  "Hey, how's it going?" Alex asked.  Max had heard from Alex about Garrett's hookup with Toby and Alex, but kept quiet.

"Uh, Alex, I want to thank you for the advice and help the other day.  It really opened my eyes.  I never thought something like that would turn me on like it did" Garrett said, glancing quickly between Alex and Max.

"Glad you enjoyed it.  I know Toby and I did.  Sometimes you have to go outside your safe zone and try new shit, even if it's just once" Alex replied.

"Uh... Yeah.  It's not going to be just once.  When you got some free time, can you show me how to set up a profile on that app you showed me?" Garrett asked.

"Sure.  Maybe after my test on Tuesday.  I already edited the pics we took.  In the mean time, I doubt Toby would say no to another visit from you" Alex said.

Garrett laughed.  "Yeah, I know.  We fucked yesterday.  He already had a load in him and I was surprised how hot it was.  Maybe we can all get together some time and fill him up."