The Tuesday night air in the caretaker's cottage was cold, but Jake didn't feel it. He was kneeling on the front room rug, his body warmed by anticipation and the low-burning fire in the hearth. He was naked, save for the fine chain around his neck, secured with a miniature gleaming padlock. Nine days apart. Nine days for the need to build, for the dynamic to settle into a low hum that now demanded to be a roar.
The crunch of Grenadier on the gravel driveway was the starting pistol. Jake's breath hitched. He didn't move, keeping his gaze fixed on the floorboards, his hands resting palms-up on his thighs. The front door opened, letting in a blast of cold air and the scent of winter. Then it closed, and Duncan was there.
Jake could feel his presence, a palpable force that seemed to suck all the air out of the room. He heard the soft thud of a duffel bag hitting the floor. Long moments of silence stretched, each one an eternity. This was the first test. Stillness. Patience. Obedience.
"Look at me," Duncan's voice was calm, low, and cut through the silence like a knife.
Jake slowly lifted his head. Duncan stood there, looking tired from the drive but with an intensity in his eyes that made Jake's heart hammer against his ribs. He looked Jake over, his gaze a physical touch, lingering on the chain around his neck. A flicker of approval crossed his face.
"Nine days," Duncan said, his voice even. "Let's see if you remember how to behave."
He walked to the heavy oak wardrobe and opened it. Jake watched as he began to pull out their gear. First, the leather body harness, its buckles and straps gleaming in the firelight. Then the spreader bar, the collection of floggers and paddles, and a black leather case Jake hadn't seen before. He looked at it. Filed it. Said nothing.
This wasn't going to be a simple welcome home. This was going to be a recalibration.
"Stand up. Arms out."
Jake rose, his body already responding to the commands. Duncan fitted the harness over his shoulders and torso, his hands moving with practiced efficiency. He tightened the straps, pulling them snug against Jake's skin, the leather creaking softly. He attached Jake's wrist cuffs to the front D-ring of the harness, then clipped an ankle spreader bar between his legs, forcing his feet wide apart. Jake was now a captive in his own body, his movements restricted, his balance precarious.
Duncan picked up a suede flogger. He walked around Jake, the soft whisper of the falls the only warning before the first strike landed across his back. Each blow landed with a deep resonant thud that Jake felt in his bones rather than on his skin. Not sharp. Not cruel. Something slower and more deliberate, working through him in waves, each strike finding the nerve endings that had gone quiet over nine days and waking them up one by one.
After a few minutes, Duncan stopped. He unclipped Jake's wrists from the harness. "On your knees. Forehead on the floor."
Jake complied, awkwardly lowering himself with the spreader bar still forcing his legs apart. His ass was high in the air, completely vulnerable. Duncan knelt behind him. Jake heard the click of a cap, the slick sound of lube. A cold, metal plug, larger than any they'd started with before, was pressed against his hole. Duncan didn't go slow. He pushed it in with a firm, steady pressure until it seated deep inside Jake. Jake gasped at the sudden, intense fullness.
"Stay," Duncan commanded.
He moved away. Jake heard the unfamiliar sound of the black leather case being opened, the particular click and arrangement of equipment he had no prior reference for. A moment later he felt the sticky pads being applied to the inside of his thighs and the base of his balls. Then Duncan turned a dial.
The buzz started low and Jake had no framework for it — none of the other sensations in his experience mapped onto this one. His muscles moved without him deciding to move them. That was the part that was hard to process. His body responding to something that wasn't Duncan's hands or Duncan's voice or Duncan's weight. Just current. Just electricity. Just Duncan turning a dial.
Duncan increased the intensity, the buzz becoming a sharp pulsing current that had Jake's hips jerking involuntarily. He picked up a riding crop and began to tap it lightly against Jake's ass, each tap coinciding with a pulse from the unit. The dual sensations were overwhelming, a confusing mix of sharp sting and deep internal jolt that Jake had no language for yet and didn't need — his body was doing the understanding for him.
Jake was lost in it, a mess of sensation, when Duncan suddenly stopped everything. He unfastened the spreader bar and helped Jake to his feet. He led him to the pillory, which had been assembled in the center of the room. He bent Jake over, latching his head and hands in place.
Then Duncan knelt in front of him. "You've been a good boy taking all that," he said, his voice softening slightly. "Now, open up."
He unzipped his jeans and fed his hard cock into Jake's waiting mouth. Jake moaned around him, the taste and feel of him a grounding force after the disorienting sensations. Duncan fucked his throat slowly, deeply, his hands gripping the pillory. When he was satisfied, he pulled away.
Jake felt the butt plug being removed, replaced by the slick, blunt head of a large, steel dildo. Duncan drove it in, fucking him with a slow, merciless rhythm while his hand stroked Jake's aching cock. He brought Jake to the edge again and again, each time pulling back just before Jake could fall over. The frustration was agonizing, his entire body trembling with need.
"Please," Jake begged, his voice hoarse and muffled. "Sir, please..."
Duncan finally took pity on him. He set the dildo aside and wrapped his hand firmly around Jake's cock.
"Come for me," he ordered.
The permission was a tidal wave. Jake cried out as the orgasm tore through him, violent and all-consuming. His body convulsed in the pillory, his release painting the floor beneath him.
When it was over, he slumped, boneless. Duncan unlatched the pillory and guided him to the thick rug in front of the fire. He removed the harness and the cuffs, his touch gentle now. He cleaned Jake with a warm cloth and pulled a heavy blanket over them both as he lay down beside him, pulling Jake into his arms.
Jake nuzzled into his chest, his body spent and buzzing with contentment. The fine chain at his throat felt warm now, a part of him.
"Happy Thanksgiving," Jake slurred sleepily.
Duncan kissed the top of his head, a deep satisfied rumble in his chest. "It is now.”
Wednesday Jake was in the kitchen by nine with Bobby's cookie recipe open on his phone, the butter already softening on the counter. He'd texted Bobby Tuesday night for the recipe — Bobby had sent it with three pages of notes and the instruction do not skip the chilling step, I mean it underlined twice.
He made the cookies first. Then he started the yeast rolls, the dough coming together the way dough came together when you paid attention to it, the caretaker's cottage filling slowly with the particular warmth of something baking that had no shortcuts in it.
Duncan appeared in the kitchen doorway at ten in clean jeans and a sweater, his hair still damp, drawn downstairs by the smell the way Jake had suspected he would be.
He looked at the cooling rack. Looked at Jake.
"Bobby's recipe?" Duncan said.
"Three pages of notes," Jake said. "Don't touch them until they're cool."
Duncan looked at the cookies. Looked at Jake. Looked back at the cookies.
"I wasn't going to," Duncan said, and poured himself a coffee.
Zach arrived at noon for the rematch, came through the door, stopped in the kitchen doorway and looked at the cookies and the rolls proving on the counter and the general atmosphere of a cottage that smelled like a bakery.
"Is this what it's always like here?" Zach said.
"No," Jake said. "Sometimes it smells like construction."
Zach took a cookie. Looked at Duncan. "Ready to lose again?"
"Ready to finally win," Duncan said, already moving toward the front room.
Jake put the rolls in the oven and followed them.
Mrs. Samuels' apartment was exactly the right size for the family it had been built around and exactly the wrong size for the family it had become. The big folding table had been set up in the living room the way it was set up every year — taking up most of the available floor space, chairs pulled from every room, the kitchen table brought in to serve as the buffet, Mrs. Samuels moving through the narrow channels between furniture with the practiced efficiency of someone who had been making this work in small spaces her entire life.
Jake and Duncan arrived at two with the cookies in a tin, a basket of yeast rolls still warm from the caretaker's cottage oven, and a bottle of wine that Duncan had selected with the focused consideration he brought to everything and which Jake had not asked about and did not intend to.
Ryan and Astrid were already there. Astrid on the sofa with Kelly, two weeks old, wrapped and sleeping with the complete unconsciousness of someone who had no opinions about Thanksgiving yet. Molly was on the floor with a collection of plastic animals arranged in a configuration that made sense to her and to nobody else. She looked up when Jake came in, assessed the situation, and went back to her animals.
Then she saw Duncan.
She stood up. Walked to him with the particular purposeful toddle of a year and a half year old who had decided something. Stopped in front of him. Looked up.
Duncan looked down at her. The particular expression of a man encountering a situation he had not prepared for and was going to handle with complete composure anyway.
"Hello," Duncan said.
Molly reached up and took his finger.
Duncan looked at Jake. Jake looked at the ceiling.
Molly led Duncan to her animals and sat him down on the floor beside them with the absolute authority of someone who owned this space and was extending an invitation that was not optional.
Duncan sat. Looked at the plastic animals. Looked at Jake one more time.
Jake went to find his mother.
Sean arrived twenty minutes later with Linc, who had to turn slightly sideways to come through the doorway and whose tattoos went from his wrists to his collar and whose handshake when Ryan extended his was the particular handshake of two big men taking each other's measure and finding it satisfactory.
"Lincoln," Mrs. Samuels said, taking his hands in both of hers. "You're very welcome here."
"Stink," Sean said.
"Lincoln," Mrs. Samuels said again, pleasantly but with the particular finality of a woman who had decided.
Linc looked at Sean. Sean shrugged. Linc looked back at Mrs. Samuels.
"Thank you ma'am," Linc said.
Zach appeared from the kitchen with a handful of crackers. Looked at Linc. Looked at the tattoos. Looked at Linc's face.
"Are those real?" Zach said.
"Zach," Jake said.
"I'm just asking," Zach said.
"Yes," Linc said, with the patient tone of a man who had been answering this question since he was nineteen.
"All of them?" Zach said.
"All of them," Linc said.
Zach nodded. Filed it. Went back to the kitchen.
The table was loud and warm and slightly too crowded, which was exactly right. Mrs. Samuels had made turkey and stuffing and green beans and gravy and the box potatoes which were a Samuels Thanksgiving institution that nobody had ever successfully argued against and nobody intended to try. Jake's yeast rolls went in the basket at the center of the table.
The yeast rolls disappeared faster than anything else on the table. Mrs. Samuels looked at the empty basket. Looked at Jake.
"Those were yours," she said.
"Yes," Jake said.
She nodded once. The verdict delivered.
Duncan ate the box potatoes with the focused attention of a man forming an opinion he was going to keep entirely to himself.
Jake watched him from across the table. Duncan looked up. Their eyes met. Duncan's expression was completely neutral.
Jake looked at his plate.
Kelly slept through the entire meal in the portable bassinet Mrs. Samuels had set up in the bedroom doorway. Molly ate sweet potato off Ryan's plate and ignored her own. Linc ate two full plates with the focused efficiency of a large man who performed physically and needed the fuel. Sean talked about the band, about the Toph photos, about the January show at the Meridian Gallery — the particular pride of someone who had seen their work rendered at a professional level for the first time and was still processing it.
"He came to see us play," Sean said. "At the Anchor. Showed up with Jake."
"Toph?" Mrs. Samuels said.
"The photographer," Sean said. "He's good. What he did with the band shots—" he paused, searching for it. "He found the thing. You know when someone just finds the thing."
Linc nodded. The particular nod of someone who had been in the photographs and understood what Sean meant.
Astrid asked Zach about his college applications with the genuine interest of someone who had decided to know her brothers in law properly. Zach answered. Then looked at Duncan.
"You go to Alderton," Zach said.
"I do," Duncan said.
"Architecture," Zach said.
"Second year," Duncan said.
Zach nodded slowly. Something moving in his expression that he caught and filed before it became anything more. Jake watched him do it. The effort of sitting on significant information in a room full of people who didn't have it yet.
Not now, Jake thought. He's going to hold it.
Zach picked up his fork and went back to his turkey.
Dessert was Mrs. Samuels' pie — apple, from scratch, the way it was every year — and the tin of cookies Jake had brought.
He set the tin on the table and opened it.
Mrs. Samuels looked at the cookies. Two varieties, arranged carefully. She picked one up and looked at it.
"What are these?" she said.
"Cranberry and black pepper," Jake said. "And rosemary lemon butter."
Mrs. Samuels looked at the cookies with the particular skepticism of a woman who had been making chocolate chip from the Toll House bag for thirty years and had opinions about innovation.
"Rosemary," she said. "In a cookie."
"Try one," Jake said.
She looked at it for another moment. Then she took a bite.
The table watched her.
She chewed. Set the cookie down. Picked it up again. Finished it. Reached for a cranberry black pepper.
The table was very quiet.
She finished the second one. Looked at Jake.
"Where did you get this recipe?" she said.
"A friend," Jake said.
"Which friend," she said.
"Bobby," Jake said. "He bakes."
Mrs. Samuels looked at the remaining cookies in the tin. Looked at Jake.
"I need that recipe," she said.
"I'll get it for you," Jake said.
Sean had already taken three. Linc had taken four with the complete lack of self-consciousness of a man who had decided these were good and saw no reason to pretend otherwise.
Zach looked at the cranberry black pepper cookie in his hand. Looked at Jake.
"Bobby made these?" Zach said.
"His recipe," Jake said. "I made them."
Zach took a bite. Said nothing for a moment.
"Tell Bobby he's good," Zach said.
"I will," Jake said.
After the dishes were cleared and Kelly had woken up and been passed around the table and Molly had fallen asleep on Ryan's shoulder and Linc had helped Sean carry the folding table back to the closet with the ease of two people who moved equipment for a living — the apartment settled into the particular warmth of a Thanksgiving evening that had done everything it was supposed to do.
Duncan found Jake in the kitchen helping his mother with the last of the dishes.
Mrs. Samuels looked at Duncan. At the dish towel in his hand.
"You dry," she said.
Duncan dried. Jake washed. Mrs. Samuels put things away and talked about nothing important and the kitchen was warm and small and exactly right.
In the car on the way home Jake told Duncan about the clipboard. All five pages. Bobby's handwriting organized in sections. The community. The workshop. The twenty witnesses. The collar section left blank with Duncan's decision written in Bobby's careful hand.
Duncan listened without interrupting. The Grenadier moving through the November night, the particular quality of the drive home after a significant day.
When Jake finished Duncan was quiet for a moment.
"He'll have thought of everything," Duncan said.
"He has," Jake said. "There's a fifth page."
Duncan glanced at him. "What's on the fifth page?"
"I don't know," Jake said. "He wouldn't show me."
Duncan looked at the road. Something moving through his expression that Jake couldn't quite read in the dark of the car.
"I'll call him tomorrow," Duncan said.
They drove home through the November night. The caretaker's cottage warm and waiting at the end of the drive.
Duncan pulled in. Killed the engine. Sat for a moment.
"Happy Thanksgiving," he said.
"You already said that," Jake said.
"I meant it then too," Duncan said.
To get in touch with the author, send them an email.
