Returning The Favor

As always, leave a comment below or email me if you liked the story, or have any feedback! Follow me on twitter @QuesadillaNFrys for previews and depictions of my stories! If you have a story idea you'd like me to write, check my profile for instructions and email me at [email protected]!

Thank you, and enjoy!

---

"What did you think?" I asked nervously. I'd just fucked Dominic's virgin asshole for the first time and he hadn't said anything yet.

"I think that was the best fucking sex I've ever had!" Dominic replied enthusiastically. Still looking down on me, he reached down and pulled my semi-hard dick out of his ass, rolling it around in his hand and letting out a moan as it popped out of his hole.

"Thanks," I smiled. I knew my fears were unfounded, but I was still relieved that he said he liked it.

"Jesus, your cum feels so good inside me. Mmmm, so warm," he laughed, and then suddenly rolled off me onto the bed and then stood on the floor, landing gracefully beside me. He stood up and stretched, momentarily losing his balance from the wilding fucking I gave him, and still not used to having a load of jizz inside him. It was leaking out of his well-fucked hole. "I never imagined it would feel so fucking good to get rammed up the ass by a big-dicked nerd," he chuckled. "God, my asshole is still vibrating and I shot more jizz than ever!" He was practically giddy. I considered myself a bottom but he seemed to enjoy it even more than I do!

I laughed at that as I sat up, Dominic's cum dripping down my chest. Dominic reached behind him and stuck his finger in his ass, letting out a moan and making his cock jump. "Fuck, it's so wet back there. I love having your load inside me! Shit, it's making me get hard again!" He pulled his finger out and licked my jizz off of it. Goddamit, he looked so hot covered in cum from head-to-toe, wearing nothing but a backwards baseball cap and cum-soaked jockstrap. The sweat and semen glistened off his muscles, almost making him glow. His massive pecs bounced as he moved, his abs cut into his stomach like marble.

"So I guess this was the last time we're gonna do this," I said. "What a way to go out though, huh? With a literal bang!" I chuckled. Now that Dominic didn't need tutoring anymore, I had to wonder where we went from here. Would he still want to hang around me, even be seen with me? Would he still want to hook up? As amazing as the sex was, he still had a hot girlfriend who he could get some from (even if it wasn't a dick in the ass). I doubted he'd really want to be associated with me now that he didn't have to.

His face turned to a frown. "Why do you say that? Is something wrong?"

"I just figured you don't wanna hang out with me anymore."

"Of course I do! Why wouldn't I want to hang out with you, Leo?"

"Now that you don't need tutoring, you don't need to be seen with me. It's not like I'm very cool, we've been over that already."

Dominic walked over to me and sat on the bed. "Leo Mason, you're one of the most interesting people I know," he said. He leaned down and kissed me. "You're awesome, funny, sexy...and you just gave me the best goddamn fuck I've ever had. Any guy who would ignore you, especially after that, would have to be completely insane, and I regret all the times I did. You're most definitely cool, certainly to me." He kissed me again. "Besides, Coach and Ms. Edwards said I don't need tutoring anymore, but that doesn't mean it wouldn't help. I could probably use it for some of my other classes too, and trust me, I plan on studying a lot with you...and under you, and on top of you."

"I thought this was just supposed to be exploring, anyway?"

Dominic let out a laugh. "You still believe that? I stopped believing it the moment I first kissed you. Hell, I'm not sure if I ever really believed it myself."

I nearly passed out. Now I know what they meant by "swooning", because Dominic practically had me there.

"So where do we go from here?" I asked, when my moment of daze passed and I could finally think again. "Are we just friends? Friends who fuck? Or are we something more?" In truth, I wasn't really seeking to label it, but I wanted to be on the same page with him. What if I wanted more than him? Hell, what if he wanted more than I was willing to give?

The question seemed to stump him a little; I don't blame him, I didn't really have an answer myself. "I don't really know what we are right now. If it's cool with you, I'd like to figure it out along the way," he said. "I'd just it if we could enjoy each other, be around each other. We can find a name for it later."

I respected that. Hell, it was basically where I'm at too. There was one more pressing thing on my head. "So what about Sophie?" I asked. "How are we gonna keep it from her? She'd be pissed if she—"

"—Do you want me to break up with her?" Dominic asked.

I hadn't expected that question; I figured he'd be fine sneaking around instead, and I hadn't really given much thought to that possibility.

"No," I said.

"Are you sure?" Dominic asked. He seemed surprised, even taken aback. "Because I'll—"

"—No, I'd rather you didn't. You're the most popular guy in school, and I don't want you ruining your reputation over me, over something that's so new and untested. I'm happy with what we have, and I don't need you to do that for me." After everything he'd done, it was my turn to reassure him. I was comfortable with what we had, and I had no intention of putting him through the social wringer just for me. I had no idea where this would lead, but there was no reason for him to destroy himself just for a horny gay high schooler like myself. "Besides," I snickered, "I kind of like the sneaking around. It makes it hotter."

Dominic leaned forward and kissed me. "Oh yeah?" he said, with his classic grin. "You like it when nobody knows you're sticking your big fucking nerd-dick inside the popular jock and making him moan like a fucking schoolgirl until you fill his hole with cum?"

"Mmm, yeah," I answered. "I like when I stretch his hole so good he shoots the biggest load of his life with the stupidest grin on his face."

"Fuck," he moaned, rubbing up against my cum-covered cock as he continued making out with me. This went on for a few minutes until I heard a chime go off; I got a text.

"Shit. Hang on one minute, Dominic." He pulled away and whimpered as I pushed the big lug aside to get to my pants across the room, and he collapsed back onto the bed. The text was from Emily.

"Waiting outside," it said. I'd texted Emily in the car that I'd been invited to a party at Dominic's house, his way of saying thank you to me for tutoring him.

"Fuck. Sorry man, I've gotta go. My sister is here." I started getting dressed.

"Aww man, really?" Dominic said.

"Yes, really," I teased back.

"Come on nerd, just a little longer? I'll miss that big dick of yours."

"Sorry," I said, leaning over kissing him on the lips. "I promise you'll see it again!" I teased.

***

I walked out to Emily's car, sitting in the large driveway.

"There you are!" she said. "How was it?"

"The party was surprisingly fun," I said. "It was a lot better than I expected."

"Really? You're still going with that line?" she said. I was taken aback, but held firm.

"What do you mean?"

"Oh please, little brother. Don't play dumb, because I'm not. It's obvious you were hooking up in there." She was grinning wildly. "You said it was a party, but there are no other cars, I don't see anyone else through the windows, you're all sweaty, and you smell like sex." Damn, she really had me dead to rights, 4 different ways. "This is the Morenos' house. So who's the lucky guy?" she asked, as she pulled out of the driveway. I'd forgotten that she dated Dominic's older brother for a few weeks when she was in middle school, but it wasn't very long, so I guess she'd either forgotten about Dominic or hadn't met him.

"Dominic," I said. There was no point trying to keep it from her, and I knew she wouldn't tell anyone.

"Really?! Isn't he the captain of the football team?!" she asked. "And dating some super-rich, crazy girl?" I guess she knew more than I thought. It was my turn to look at her surprise. "What?" she said. "I've still got some connections, they tell me things."

"Yeah, that's him."

"So what's going on? Is he—"

"—I don't know. I don't think he knows."

Emily turned to look at me. "Well be careful, Leo. I've dated jocks, and I don't want him hurting you, especially if he gets conflicted about his feelings. Don't get yourself mixed up in all that."

"Don't worry, sis. I've got it handled, and he's a lot sweeter than most of those guys. Hell, he's a lot sweeter than most of the guys I've dated."

Well if you say so," she replied. "If anything happens, he'll get an earful from me."

***

The next day, I got a text from Dominic.

"Hey nerd! Wanna hang out today?"

"Sure!" I texted back. "I'm busy this afternoon, but what about tonight?"

"Tonight's great! I'll come pick you up around 6?"

"Perfect!"

Dominic arrived at my house that evening at six p.m. sharp. He was dressed surprisingly nicely, wearing a polo shirt and slacks. He certainly had the look of a prep school boy now (which, technically, we were).

"Hey there, nerd!" he greeted me. "Ready to go?"

"Yep! I just need to grab my jacket."

Dominic followed me into the kitchen, where my jacket was hanging on a chair between my mom and Emily.

"Hello there!" my mom said. "Leo, honey, are you going to introduce us?" I paused and turned towards my mom.

"This is my friend Dominic." Emily's eyes shot wide open, as if to express surprise. "I've been tutoring him, and we're gonna go hang out for a bit."

"Okay, honey! Have fun," she said to me. "Hi Dominic! I'm Leo's mom. It's very nice to meet one of my son's friends, he doesn't really bring many around!"

"Mom!" I sniped at her in embarrassment. God, kill me now.

She ignored me. "And these are his sisters, Emily and Madison," she said, gesturing at them. Madison ignored everyone with an eyeroll, as was typical of her, while Emily lightly waved.

"Oh my God!" Emily mouthed at me when my mom wasn't looking. I'd told her that Dominic was hot, but I guess her expectations were much lower.

"I know!" I mouthed back.

"It's very nice to meet you, Mrs. Mason!" Dominic said.

While Emily, thankfully, knew the true nature of our relationship and had enough self-control, unfortunately, my mother did not. "Well aren't you just the most handsome young man!" She said. "I didn't know they made them like this anymore!"

"MOM!" I shouted. Dominic chuckled, blushing. She shot me a glare, but her facial expressions suggested she'd behave anyway. "I'm your mother, but I'm not blind," she said.

"I appreciate the compliment," Dominic said. "I guess I'll have to tell my girlfriend she's got some competition," he quipped. Oh, how right he was, but not for the reasons she or my mom would think!

I'd finally put on my jacket and said goodbye to my mom and sisters, quickly ending the conversation before my mom could ogle Dominic any more.

"I'm sorry about them," I said as we got into Dominic's car.

"What're you sorry for, man? They're great!" he said in earnest.

"Thanks, but I don't want you dealing with my mom eye-humping you. That's my job!" I said. Dominic laughed again, and kissed me.

"You've got nothing to worry about," he said. "But I totally wanted to kiss you in there. Now that we're alone..." he leaned in and kissed me again, deeply this time. I kissed back for a few seconds before pulling back for air.

"So where are we going?" I asked.

"It's a surprise," Dominic said. "But I thought we could go grab dinner. Consider it the third and final part of my 'thank you', for both the tutoring and the awesome sex."

I couldn't believe he felt the need to thank me, when I most assuredly was a more than eager participant, but I accepted nonetheless. We chatted a bit until we arrived at the restaurant, a surprisingly fancy Italian place that was far nicer than I'd expected, and a much longer drive, all the way out of town to a nearby city.

"We have a reservation, Moreno," he said."

"Right this way," the hostess replied, leading us to our table, a small, relatively isolated corner booth, just fitting two people, with the seats in such a way that you'd sit perpendicular next to each other, rather than across from each other. "Your server will be right with you!" she said, leaving us some menus. We chatted until our waitress arrived, and placed our drink orders.

"I'll be right back with those," she said. "Have a nice date!"

"Oh, this isn't—" I began.

"Thank you," Dominic said over me. Our waitress left to go get our drinks.

"She thinks this is a date," I chuckled.

"Well what else would you call it?" he asked me, chuckling himself.

"Wait, you asked me here on a date?"

"Guilty," he smirked. "I might've had some ulterior motives beyond a thank you-dinner." His face turned more serious. "I hope that's okay, but if you—" I leaned forward and kissed him.

"No," I said. "I'm thrilled to be out on a date with you. But it would've been nice to get a heads-up," I chuckled.

"Sorry, I wasn't sure you'd say yes," Dominic blushed. "You seemed so adamant about trying to keep this a secret. I even took us to a place further out of town so you'd be more comfortable."

I was staring at this beautiful Italian boy, muscles curving all over his body, asking myself if he could be any more amazing. I was about to lean over and kiss him again, when the waitress returned with our drinks. We chatted for a while until our waitress came back with our food, and ate while we continued our conversation. We talked about everything, from college to school, our hobbies, and everything in between.

Dominic giggled as I slurped some noodles into my mouth. "Dude, you've got a little sauce on your face," he said.

"Where?!" I asked, looking for my napkin, which was on my lap.

"I've got it," he said, before I could grab my napkin. Dominic leaned forward and licked me, before pulling me into a saucy kiss. I moaned into his mouth as his tongue entered. He kissed me deeply for a few seconds before pulling away. "There you go, nerd," he said. Now he had sauce on his face too, but he didn't seem to mind as he wiped it off with his napkin.

Our conversation continued, even as he'd pulled his foot out of his shoe and began moving it up my leg. I moaned and he giggled as it began massaging my crotch, thankful for the half-wall that blocked the view under the table from most of the restaurant.

"That's not fair," I groaned, as his foot pressed deeper into my growing shaft.

"What's not fair?" He teased.

"That!"

"I don't know what you're talking about, I'm just sitting here trying to eat my dinner, while you're moaning like a horndog," Dominic smirked. I was starting to leak serious precum now.

"Two can play at that game," I smiled.

I took it a step further, and grabbed his groin in my hand. I could feel the growing mass in my hand, and he moaned when I squeezed it. "MMffffpphhh...fuck, Leo." I kept massaging his pelvic area, and it was becoming increasingly difficult for either of us to focus on our meals when the waitress returned.

"How is everything," she asked with a smile.

"Very...very good," Dominic said. "Can we get this wrapped up to go and have the check, please?" he asked, with a twinge of desperation in his voice.

"Absolutely, I'll be right back!" she said, taking our plates, and seemingly oblivious to what was going on beneath the table, before walking away.

"Alright nerd, let's call it a draw so we can get home and finish this," he growled.

***

The car ride back to my house was pleasant, if incredibly sexually charged. I was almost worried Dominic was in such a hurry, he'd get into a crash. Thankfully, we made it back to my house in one piece, while my sisters and parents were already sound asleep. I pulled Dominic up to my room, where we started making out and stripping down the moment the door was closed. We crashed onto my bed together, kissing passionately. The passion soon changed into lust though, as our clothes flew off, revealing bodies covered by only their underwear. Both of us were rock hard; I could feel Dominic's rubbing against me through our underwear.

He moved behind me and slid my briefs down my legs, exposing my cock. My hand immediately went to his erection, sliding into his underwear and stroking him slowly. Eventually, he pulled it free and threw his underwear aside. "I'm ready whenever you are," he whispered lustily.

"Me too," I panted back. Soon after, he rolled on top of me. Our naked cocks grinded against each other, hard and leaking precum, until Dominic slid down and started sucking me off. He slapped the head against his tongue, then sucked harder as he bobbed his lips up and down rapidly. After several minutes, I reached forward and pushed his hair back slightly.

"Dominic," I moaned softly. "Fuck yeah..."

He stared up at me with those big, beautiful brown eyes, smiling widely. "You suck it so good," I groaned, thrusting upward into his mouth as he bobbed his head on me. It felt like he was sucking me up forcefully, as if his mouth was strong enough to pull me into him like it had gravity.

"God, I want you to fuck me," I moaned. "I need your big dick in me!" Up until now, he'd still never fucked me, but I knew I'd wanted it from day one, and I wasn't gonna wait any longer.

"Yeah nerd? You want me to fuck you?" he grinned.

"God yes! Do it, man!"

Dominic lifted off my penis and sat on my chest, putting his big Italian schlong right in front of my face. "Suck It. Now," he commanded. I immediately obeyed, grabbing hold of his meaty pole and engulfing every inch of it within moments. My nose was buried deep inside Dominic's pubes, my tongue running along his length, tasting the salty preload dripping from the tip of his dick. When Dominic saw me devour his massive tool, he roughly shoved my face upward and held my jaw open wide. Then, without warning, he stuffed all eight inches straight into my throat.

My eyes watered and tears ran down my cheeks, while my throat burned as Dominic fucked my face mercilessly. I loved every second of it!

"Suck my cock, nerd!" he grunted. "Kiss it, lick it, make it all nice and wet for your tight hole!" He thrusted forward rhythmically, making me slobber all over the hefty pole.

Suddenly, Dominic pulled out, throwing me off balance momentarily, before slamming back in. "Yes dude, take that fat dick!" he groaned loudly. This time, instead of forcing my mouth around his entire shaft, he kept three quarters of his penis in my oral cavity, while letting me use my hands to stroke the remaining quarter of his member. As he pounded me, Dominic alternated between fingering my hole and holding my hair. Finally, he pulled back and I caught my breath.

Dominic climbed on top of me, lining our erections up perfectly and groping them in his thick hand, then sliding them both together. I was moaning so much, thankfully we didn't have thin walls. He used his other hand to cover my mouth anyway.

"Don't tease me. Fuck me!" I begged.

"Only if you promise to be quiet," Dominic laughed.

I nodded eagerly. "Please Dominic," I whimpered excitedly, knowing full well I probably couldn't keep it.

His dick glistened with the precum and saliva we'd coated ourselves in, and I squirmed as Dominic slid backwards and guided the tip towards my hole, pushing inside without hesitation or preamble. Once there, he hilted himself in an instant, pushing all eight inches of pure muscle deep inside me. Dominic barely gave me chance to adjust to the new size, before jerking forward and grinding his hips against mine. He fucked deep, thrusting in and out roughly while smacking my ass cheeks with every inward motion.

"Ugh..you're so tight," Dominic growled. "That nerd hole is squeezing my cock off!" It occurred to me that he was probably more used to giving vaginal sex than anal, and there was a good chance he'd never fucked an ass before. He kept thrusting inside me, and I howled in pleasure. His heavy balls bounced against my pelvis repeatedly, hitting me with every downward thrust. His large fingers dug into my flesh, digging into my own backside. I was practically delirious with pleasure as his big shaft pounded me with a passion I don't think I'd ever felt before.

"Ahhhg-ahhgnnnn...oh shit..." Dominic cursed loudly. "You're fucking gorgeous Leo, I wanna watch you cum." I was definitely close, and he stroked my cock as he drilled deep into me.

I let loose a loud moan as my jizz started spraying out of me. "Oh godddd!! Mmmmghhhhh!!" I wailed. At first, I thought it wouldn't stop coming, and it hit me in the face and chest. A few more thrusts of Dominic's cock drilled more out of me before I finally stopped shooting. "Fuucckkk!!! Oh yeeeessss!" Dominic exclaimed in victory. And with that, he clenched his teeth tightly shut and let loose, shooting rope after stringy strand of semen into my depths. Every spurt sent a jolt directly up my spine and caused another orgasm to wrack my frame.

"Fuck man, take my load!" he shouted, filling me with more cum than I could fit. I watched as his muscular body spasmed and jerked in time with each spurt against my prostate. Our orgasms finally subsided, and he collapsed next to me. Afterward, we lay side by side for a long minute, catching our breaths, slowly recovering from the intense orgasm. Dominic moved next to me, snuggling me up underneath his arm and breathing heavily.

"That was fuckin' great," he breathed. "even if I didn't get your big nerd cock in my hole this time." I laughed, which hurt a bit because I was exhausted and still panting, but I powered through it.

"There's always next time," I chuckled.

"I hope I didn't hurt you too much, nerd. I was kinda on autopilot back there, but I tried my best to keep from hurting you."

"Are you kidding?" I replied with a giggle. "That was amazing! I've never been fucked so good in my life!" I leaned over to kiss him with my cum-covered mouth. "I hate to make this a fuck-and-duck," I continued, "but in the morning I'd rather my parents don't find out I got laid by finding someone in my bed or sneaking out of my room." The last time Emily had a guy over, she didn't hear the end of it for a week. I was in no mood to be on the receiving end of that. While they probably suspected I was sexually active at this point, there was an unspoken rule that they didn't want to know what we did, and frankly, Emily and I felt the same. They'd given us the talk about safety and protection (emphasizing the risk of pregnancy to her, and HIV to me), but that was about it.

"Of course," he said. "I understand. My parents might freak too if they see I'm not home in the morning." Dominic gathered his things and got dressed, finding his clothes scattered across the room and mixed in with mine, but managing to get it all. He gave me a quick cum-covered kiss, and headed out the door while I went to the bathroom door to take a shower.