My brother, his best friend and me

So the next few days after the gang band that ended with my own brother fucking me, things changed a lot. Mom said she heard from the neighbors that they saw us together with his arm around me and we seemed to be getting along at long last. 

“I have to admit I was really surprised when Nate called and said you were staying at his apartment but when Helen called, I got curious. What’s up with y’all?”

I sat there eating my breakfast and trying to come up with something fast. We hadn’t had a fight in a long time, we just stayed away from each other so I’m sure she had questions. 

“I ran into him at Luckies, we had a bite to eat and started talking. It was a lot to unload and we ended up talking all night. That’s why he called you”

“So are y’all gonna try and be nice to each other now?”

“We got something we wanna talk to y’all about. Nates coming over later. He has an idea”

Later that afternoon he came over and gave his pitch about me staying with him for the summer to repair our relationship. They were overjoyed and mom even cried. We had no idea how us being at odds had tormented her. 

The following week I packed up some stuff and moved in with Nate. As soon as we were together he was all over me. The fact we had this elicit relationship we couldn’t talk about really turned him on. He loved fucking me all the time. The idea of breeding his little brothers ass was just too hot to pass up. That first week we were fucking all the time and then it just stopped. I loved his big cock up my boy cunt so I was missing it when it went away. Eddy had trained me well to take a fuck but that was the only good thing about his sorry ass. 

Nate was so fucking mad at him, he couldn’t see straight. The fraternity officers for the coming year held a special meeting about him. I was asked to attend. They were so glad I didn’t want to press charges that they were bending over backwards to make me happy. The decision to punish him was almost given to me to decide how it was going to happen. They talked about kicking him out all together and getting him blackballed. Making him the resident house slave, what ever I wanted. Nate got so mad he couldn’t stand it so they kicked him out, blackballed him all over campus and somehow a video of him getting gang banged mysteriously got out and was soon all over campus. He didn’t come back that fall. It was probably best to keep Nate from stomping his sorry ass. The summer ended and Nate and I were  practically inseparable. He became very protective of me and was on guard all the time. I could tell he still had some guilty feelings about what happed and did anything he could think of to make it up to me. He almost got in a fight when some guy made a crack about me. 

“Nate, we need to talk”

He looked at me like he was in trouble. 

“Come sit with down” I patted the seat beside me. 

“What’s wrong, what happened?”

He was so alarmed. I could see the worry on his face. 

“Just listen to me a minute. We have a little problem. First of all, you need to know that I love you and appreciate you so much”

“I hear a but coming”

“Ok, let’s put it this way.... the butt is you”

“What are you talking about?”

“You gotta let what happens with Eddy go. It’s making you an angry bitter man. He’s out of our life and I don’t need to be protected. I’m not mad at you or any of the guys and you don’t need my forgiveness”

“I’m not angry!”

“You may not think you are but you are. I think you’re still punishing yourself over what happened and it’s eating you up”

He looked down at his hands and picked at them. I put my hand on his arm and squeezed it. He looked up at me with tears in his eyes. 

“I’m so sorry” he cried and collapsed in my arms. 

“I love being with you and making love and everything but in the back of my head I blame myself for what happened. If I hadn’t been such sorry brother and had looked out for you this never would’ve happened  I’m just so sorry”

“Stop it, I told you that night it wasn’t your fault. How could it be? Eddy pulled that on both of us and as nasty as it was he gave us a wonderful gift. Looks at us. We were nearly enemies. Damn near hated each other even. But that one night everything changed. You defended me, protected me and the animosity all disappeared. We are never apart for any more than we have to. I have my brother and I not only like you, I love you”

I pulled him to me and we scooted down on the couch and I held him close. He let me comfort him this time. He was so vulnerable and mentally exhausted from holding all this in for so long. He just kind of collapsed in my arms and I held him tight. When we first came together, we couldn’t keep our hands off each other but his turmoil and guilt made that stop but he tended to hold onto me a lot. He was still very affectionate to me but the sex was gone.

We ended up seeing a family therapist who, thankfully, was gay. We told him most of what happened and after a while and many sessions together, he was able to help Nate understand that what happened wasn’t in any way his fault. I was thankful for the help, he was in such a bad way, I was afraid he might do something crazy. Things evened out and by the time a year had passed be were in such a better place. 

We were still sharing his one bedroom apartment and the one bed. I’d started my freshman year and was doing well and had gotten into some of the activities on campus. I loved campus life and was finding my way really well and making a lot of new friends. An instructor in the fine arts building approached me in the student center about being a model for her department. He said he was looking for all kinds of body types and that I would be used in several different mediums. So the photography, sculpture and painting/drawing students would use me as well as other boys and girls both together and in couples or groups as subjects. The pay wasn’t  bad and the work for the most part was easy so I jumped at the chance. Soon I was being worked in both day and evening classes when I was free. Some things were as simple as them doing work on just a single body part like my hand or foot some was full body and it wasn’t long before I was doing it in the nude too. One of the other guys I worked with a lot was Jamie. He was everything I wasn’t. Nate always called me a twink, I was short and slim and not muscled up but kinda softer built. I had red hair and freckles scattered over my milky white skin. Jamie on the other hand was a powerlifter and he was pretty huge. He was damn near a foot taller than I was, his chest was twice as wide as mine too and my full ass wasn’t as big as just one of his ass cheeks. He was so powerful looking and he kinda unnerved me. We had been paired together on several settings and it wasn’t long before it dawned on me he was interested in more than posing with me. He asked me out and by the end of the evening I was in his bed with my feet over my head with his cock up my ass. When I finally made it home the next morning, Nate was sitting on the couch waiting for me.

“Where the hell have you been all night?” He asked sternly

“Back up brother dear. You don’t get to question what I do or where I’m doing it so ya wanna try that again?”

“I was worried something happened to you. I freaked out. You didn’t answer your phone”

“Ok, I told you I was going out with a friend, remember? It got late and I ended up staying at his place and I didn’t realize I’d dropped my phone in his car until I spotted it in the floorboard this morning”

“I’m sorry, you scared me a little bit”

He came over and hugged me. 

“You smell like sex!” He grabbed my shoulders and held me at arms length. “I thought this was just a friend? What the hell?”

“Damnit, Nate!” I yelled at him and pulled away. I stormed off to the bedroom and started pulling my shit out of the drawers and closet.

“What are you doing? What are you doing with your stuff?”
“Nate I love you and I thought we’d moved past all this but I can’t take it anymore. I’m gonna move back in with mom and dad. You’re not ready for this yet. I can’t go back to fighting with you again”

“Stop, just stop. Don’t go, I need you. Don’t leave me” 

He looked like a wild animal, pleading with me. I dropped down on the bed and just sat there looking at the floor.

“Look, I kinda like Jamie and I wanna see more of him. I thought when we moved in together we were going to be more than just brothers. That’s what you lead me to believe. Now you only hold me or lay beside me in this fucking bed. I was stupid to think we could be more than just brothers. I love you and I’m glad you’re a part of my life but I need more. I’m so happy we have got what we have but we are just brothers and I see that now. It was stupid to think anything more”

“That’s just it Nicki, I still want you that way. I want to be with you but my mind keeps saying it’s wrong. Ever since that night in that fucking hotel. I’ve wanted you. I didn’t even know who you were and I watched those guys fucking you and breeding you. I thought you were so fucking hot and sexy. Even since we were young I thought you were sexy I just put it out of my mind and thought something was wrong with me for ever looking at you that way. That night when I was fucking you the first time and that mother fucker pulled the mask off, every fantasy about fucking you just came rushing back to me like a tone of bricks. I got what I really always wanted, I was fucking my baby brother. The that next day it was even hotter because you wanted me to do it and the following week you were all I could think about. But the reality of it all hit me and then I was just angry. I thought I was dealing with all that and I was doing better but when I couldn’t find you I freaked and then I smelled sex on you it all came flooding back. Please don’t leave me. I’ll do better”

“So you’re telling me you’ve wanted me since we were kids?”

“Yeah. I guess since I hit puberty. When you were little, you drove me crazy just being a pesky little kid but that changed and I was attracted to you and I knew it was wrong so I guess that’s why I was such a bastard to you. It’s kept you away from me. I would never have touched you, I’d a killed someone that hurt you but I didn’t trust myself around you so I pushed you away. Then that fucker Eddy’s telling me about this little twink he’s fucking, I wanted to fuck him too. My brain nearly exploded when I found myself balls deep in my own brother. I think that’s a big part of why I was so mad at him. The thought that he was the one fucking you all that time and it could have been me. He told me so many times about fucking you but I didn’t know it was you”

“Wow, that’s a lot to take in. I had no idea you felt like that. All those years I thought you hated me and I couldn’t figure out why”

“Nicki, that first week you were here and we were going at it like dogs in heat, I was over the moon, I finally had you but I overthought it all and stopped everything”

I pushed all my stuff over to the side of the bed and pulled him down to me and kissed him.

“I want you, make love to me Nate”

He leaned up on his side and started opening the buttons on my shirt. He pulls it open and starts stroking my smooth body. I open my jeans and pull them off as I lay beside me. I look into his eyes and tell him.

“Fuck me”

Together we get him naked and he reached down between my wide open legs and slipped his fingers in my ass. He looks back up at me and said

“So does your new boyfriend know what a little pig bottom you are? I feel his load still in you. That from last night or this morning?”

“Both” I look up at him and smile. “Wanna fuck me with his load for lube?”

“Fuck yeah. Just like the first time” He got between my legs and pulled them up then just rammed in me hard and fast.

“I think it’s hot my baby brother is such a fucking slut. We should ask him to play with us”

Nate’s hammering away at my ass like crazy. It had been so long since we had last fucked I’d almost forgotten how hot he is in bed. His line of hot nasty commentary and him working my nipples had me blowing a load before I knew it and shortly I had his cum deep in my ass mixing with Jamie’s two loads. 

Life got better between us and we were soon having a wonderful time together. I continued dating Jamie but was reluctant to do a threesome with him. Nate wanted to share me but I wasn’t ready. Although one time Jamie called me on FaceTime and I was sitting on Nate’s cock. He made me take the call and Jamie never new I was getting fucked as we talked. Jamie started hanging out at our place a lot. I guess he thought we shared a one bedroom just to save money, I didn’t think he had a clue Nate was fucking me. I doubted he knew Nate was into guys but it all came out in the open one Saturday afternoon at my parents house. 

They invited us over for a cook out. They liked Jamie a lot and had us over quite a bit. This time Nate was with us and we got caught. Dad, Nate and Jamie were drinking beer and talking on the patio and mom was working on something in the kitchen. I was digging stuff out in my bedroom to take back to the apartment when Nate walked in. I was digging in some boxes in my walk in closet and he talked me into a quick fuck. He pulled the door closed and I’m on all fours with my pants down in my closet with his cock up my ass just hammering away and the door opens. Jamie is standing there, slack jawed, watching his boyfriend getting fucked by his own brother. 

“Oh My God!”

That’s when Nate started shooting his load up my ass. It’s also when I noticed Jamie had a raging hard on too. I reached forward and grabbed him and pulled his shorts down and started sucking his big cock before he could react. Nate told him to keep it quiet so we wouldn’t get caught by our parents and with in minutes he was blowing his load down my throat. We got it together and I told him we would talk about it on the way home. He didn’t seem upset or even that surprised. We just went back down to dinner and had a nice evening. 

We had all road together so the conversation on the home was pretty interesting. 

“Ok y’all. I gotta be honest. When I met Nicki and figured out who he possibly was I wanted to go out with him”

“What are you talking about?”

“A friend of mine told me about this guy that got tricked into fucking his brother and I had a strong suspicion that you guys were them. I couldn’t figure out how to ask without coming off like a fucking perv if I was wrong”

“You gotta be shitting me! I’ve been trying to get Nicki to bring me in on a three way with you guys since the first time you fucked him. I asked him that first morning after as I was hammering my load in with yours. To fucking hot”

“I’ve always wanted to fuck with brothers. This is such a fantasy come true for me. You guys are fo fucking hot”

We were in Nates car, he’s behind the wheel and Jamie is in the backseat. He’s leaning over the seat between us, his arm over my shoulder gently flicking my right nipple. He’s already figured out that makes me crazy. 

“When we get back to the apartment, I wanna eat your brothers cum from your little boy pussy and and then I’m gonna breed you again”

“Dude, I’m so all over this. I’ve been begging Nicki to at least let me watch y’all fuck. He told me that first day you had a big cock and shoot huge loads”

We couldn’t get back home fast enough. I ran up the stairs with Jamie behind me, and unlocked the door and was naked before Nate could get the front door shut and locked. He looked over at Jamie as he stripping off his clothes and said.

“So I guess you’ve already figured out my baby brother is a little freak, he’s a total cum pig. He was a trained bottom boy half way into high school”

“Fuck! You started fucking him early!”

“No, it wasn’t me. I didn’t start fucking him until last year after he graduated high school. It was a former friend who trained him” He did air quotes when he said friend.

“What do you mean by that?”

Almost in unison Nate and I said, “Not talking about that”

Thankfully, Jamie dropped it and pulled me down on the living room floor. He was flat on his back and wanted me squatting over his face eating Nates load out of me. Nate’s standing astraddle Jamie and I’m sucking his cock. After getting all slicked up with my throat slime, he pulls out and drops behind me and slides his slick cock up my ass right over Jamies face. He never stopped licking my hole. Nate pushes me forward so I could suck Jamies long fat cock. I’m in bottom boy heaven. Two big raw cocks using me as a fuck toy. Jamie asked Nate if we should breed me this way but he had other ideas and wasn’t ready to get off yet. He pulls his big cock from my sloppy hole and he tells Jamie he wants to talk to him in the kitchen. I’m laying in the floor like a fucking rag doll and Nate tells me to go turn back the bed and get some towels. I jump up and run to take care of everything.

Meanwhile in the kitchen… my men are talking.

“You’re up to something dude, talk”

Nate reached in the freezer and rammed a fresh bottle of poppers. He got us some bottles of water and said…

“I wanna share his cunt with you”

“Yeah, I know…”

“No man, I want us to fuck his little pussy together at the same time. Both our cocks in him at the same time”

As they discuss this, Nate is stroking Jamies hard cock.

“Dude, that would be fucking wild but I don’t know. We’re both really hung and I’m pretty thick. What if we hurt him or worse, damage him. I’d never forgive myself”

“I would never do anything to hurt my little brother. I think he can take it, hell I think he’s going to love it. He was gang banged by nearly 10 guys last year and loved it. I sure he can do it. That’s why I got the poppers out, it will set him free and open that pussy wide for us. What do ya say”
“Let’s do it”

“Ok, follow my lead”

They grab the water and poppers and head back to find me in bed. Jamie pushed me back on my back and pulled my legs up and was soon pounding away at me and Nate was down my throat with Jamie eating his ass. I wish we had pictures of this, it had to look hot as hell.

They traded places and turned me every which way but loose. This was so fantastic, I was loving all the attention taking everything they dished out to me. Finally Nate sits on the edge of the bed and has me sit on his cock facing him, I’m working my ass on him big time. Jamie comes up behind me and is stroking my body and my perky little nips then he slips the poppers to my nostril and puts his thumb on the other one and tells me to inhale deep. It’s kinda burns a sec and then my brain kinda starts shooting off fireworks in my head. He did it again on the other side and said to take a deeper snort. Seconds later as it’s taking affect and I’m seeing stars before my eyes, he starts pushing his big cock inside me next to my brothers hard cock. 

“OOOOOOOOOH! MYYYYY GOOOOOOD!!!” I moan “FUUUCK MEEEEEE!!!!”

“When we get through breeding you, baby boy, your little pussy is never going to be the same again” Jamie whispered in my ear as he’s fucking me from behind. Then Nate slipped his tongue in my mouth and is making out with me. He stops and pulls my face to his and said.

“We’re going to be sharing you a lot more baby brother. Our very own personal cum pig. Is that what my little Nicki want’s?”

I can hardly think, let alone speak, I’m so turned on. Jamie leaned forward and kissed Nate and Nate pulled me into the kiss too. We never break the kiss, only sounds in the room are the wet sloppy sounds of cocks in my boy cunt and us breathing and kissing. It was so incredible, I could have just floated away on a cloud I was so happy. Jamie started picking up the pace and slamming up into my hole and working my brothers cock in the process. Five minutes later he finally breaks the kiss and yells he fixing to cum and then almost immediately Nate pulls all three of into a bear hug and starts humming and then Jamie is too. They are grunting and groaning as they mash me between them and then I finally start to blow too. I shot so hard it hit Nicki in the chin. We are a heaving pulsing mass of man flesh and sweat. Jamie pushes us back on the bed and he falls over to the side. Nate pulls me up into the bed and the three of us just lay snuggled up together. We woke up the next day about 1:00 that afternoon. 

“Damn guys. My ass hurts!”

Needless to say, that got a big laugh.

I’m laying in bed between them, watching as they laugh and start talking. We all agreed that was the hottest experience any of us had ever had and that we would be sharing a bed and me a lot more in the future. I tried to get up but my legs were about as weak as water. Jamie scooped me up and carried me to the bathroom and we showered and cleaned up. By then I was feeling more myself and after Nate got it together, they took me out for some food. It had been a long time since dinner and we were hungry. Over the next several months, Jamie was staying at our place more and more. All of us had grown very close and very affectionate with each other. Jamie and Nate were just as likely to be making out as he and I were and I never stopped making out with Nate. We just fit together somehow. By the time the school year was over, Nate thought Jamie should move in with us. I loved the idea but our one bedroom apartment was too small for three men and with both Jamie and Nate being bigger guys, it was a bit tight so we all alerted looking. We found an older house in area not to far from campus and with three of us splitting the rent it was very affordable. Our parents as well as everyone that knew us thought my boyfriend and I were sharing the place with brother. We didn’t correct them we just smelled and kept our mouths shut. Even though Nate’s my brother, it felt more like he was my boyfriend along with Jamie and they felt the same way. It was a great three way relationship and we did really well with it. The only person that ever found out  was another one of the art class models, Clayton. 

Every once in a while we would fire up Grindr and invite some guy over to play. We never put our face out on it because we wanted this as our thing and didn’t want to risk too much with other students. Clayton’s profile had his picture but nether Jamie or myself recognize him and he came over. When he knocked on the door that night, it was really late and we knew he was coming so Jamie just yelled for him to come in. He knew us both and had met my brother a number of times on campus and what he walked in on was  me on my back with my brother up my ass and Jamie down my throat. He was out of his clothes and up in the middle of us in a heart beat. Turned out he didn’t have a problem with brothers fucking and had always wanted to hook up with us. Clayton became a frequent visitor to our house after that. Things progressed and after Nate graduated he took a great job here in Dallas and by the time Jamie and I finished and landed jobs, we bought a nice house and stayed together. Life is good in a loving household when you have two beautiful men loving and taking care of you. By the way, I take care of my men and anything they need. They funny thing is, I’m the smallest and the youngest and I’m also the biggest bread winner so yes, I take great care of my men.