After that morning blowjob in the basement, I couldn’t stop thinking about how Tyler had taken every inch like it was nothing. His mouth felt better than anything Mia had ever done and the way he called me ‘sir’ made my balls tighten in a way I had never felt before. The guilt sat there in my gut but the ego rush kept pushing it down. I had just let my girlfriend's little brother drain me dry while she slept upstairs and part of me already wanted more.
We all sat at the breakfast table like nothing had happened. Tyler sat directly opposite me spooning cereal into his mouth with that same coy little smile. Mia was between us flipping more pancakes onto plates.
“How was the workout babe?” Mia asked as she slid a fresh plate in front of me.
“It was good,” I said awkwardly. “I was just helping Tyler with some form tips.”
Tyler took a slow bite and looked straight at me. “Yeah your boyfriend really showed me how to go deep on those squats this morning. I felt it all the way down.”
Mia laughed. “You two are so into this workout thing.”
Tyler grinned. “What can I say? Jake knows exactly how to hit the right muscles. He kept telling me to open up more and take it deeper until I really felt the burn.”
I nearly choked on my orange juice. Before I could respond Tyler “accidentally” dropped his fork. It clattered loudly on the floor under the table.
“Oops,” he said casually. “I’ll get it.”
He ducked down under the table while Mia continued talking about her plans for the pool later. She was completely distracted facing the other way as she reached for the juice carton.
Under the table Tyler didn’t go for the fork right away. Instead I felt his warm hand wrap around my bare foot. My heart jumped. Then his soft wet mouth closed around my big toe. He sucked on it slowly and filthy, swirling his tongue around it like it was the head of my cock. I went rigid in my chair. My cock instantly surged to full hardness inside the shorts that Tyler had given me earlier. My cock was throbbing painfully against the fabric of Tyler’s shorts. He sucked harder, taking more of my toe into his warm mouth, his tongue sliding underneath it in long strokes. The sensation shot straight up my leg to my groin. I gripped the edge of the table tight trying to keep my face neutral.
Mia kept chatting away totally unaware. “You guys should do another session later. Tyler could really use the extra work.”
Tyler finally released my toe with a quiet wet pop and came back up with the fork in his hand like nothing happened. His lips were slightly shiny. He looked me dead in the eyes and smiled.
“Yeah I definitely need more work,” he said smoothly. “Jake really knows how to hit those deep spots. I was sore in places I did not even know could get sore.”
Mia rolled her eyes. “You are such a drama queen.”
I sat there rock hard heart hammering trying not to shift in my seat. Tyler had just sucked on my toe under the table while my girlfriend sat two feet away and now he was casually talking about getting stretched and filled like it was normal workout talk. My cock was leaking steadily into his shorts. The ego rush mixed with the danger made me dizzy.
I forced a laugh. “Tyler is a quick learner. He doesn’t hesitate to push past his boundaries.”
Tyler licked his lips slowly. “Yeah man. I think I can handle even more next time.”
Mia stood up to grab more juice from the fridge completely oblivious.
Tyler kept the jokes coming every chance he got. Each one hit me like a punch to the gut mixed with a rush straight to my groin. I had been straight my whole life. I loved Mia. She was hot and tight and she moaned so pretty when I pounded her. But sitting there across from her brother who had just swallowed my entire load, I couldn’t stop comparing. Tyler's mouth had been so eager, so hungry. He had taken me rough and deep and loved every second. Mia never let me face fuck her like that. She would tap out after a minute. Tyler had looked up at me with tears in his eyes and still pulled me deeper. The thought made my balls tighten again right there at the table. I could feel myself starting to leak a little into his shorts.
“You okay babe?” Mia asked when she sat back down. “You look a little flushed.”
“I am fine,” I said quickly. “Just thinking about relaxing by the pool after this.”
Tyler smirked and leaned back in his chair. “No nasty business sis. I don’t want to see you both naked by the pool.”
Mia groaned and threw a napkin at him. “You are being so gross right now," she said laughing. “I am going to pretend I didn’t hear any of this.”
We kept eating and Tyler kept dropping those little comments every few minutes. He would say things like I cannot wait to have some more protein again. Mia would roll her eyes and change the subject to plans for the pool later but I was rock hard under the table by the time we finished. My ego loved every second of it. Here I was the big muscled boyfriend and her own gay brother could not get enough of me. It felt powerful in a way that made my dick throb visibly. I had to adjust my legs twice to hide it.
Breakfast finally ended and we all cleared the table. Mia gave me a quick kiss on the cheek and said she was going to change into her bikini. Tyler hung back a second while she walked upstairs. He stepped close enough that I could smell the faint scent of my own cum still on his breath from earlier.
“You know, I do want more of that cock later today,” he whispered low enough that only I could hear. “I am still thinking about how good you tasted.”
I did not answer. I just nodded and headed outside with Mia. My heart was pounding and my cock was still half hard.
The afternoon sun beat down hot in the backyard. Mia and I lounged by the pool on matching chairs. She had her sunglasses on and a tiny bikini that showed off her curves. I lay there shirtless in nothing but the gray shorts Tyler had lent me. The fabric clung to my thighs from the heat and the way my body glistened with sweat. My six foot four frame looked even bigger under the bright light. Broad shoulders thick chest abs cut deep from years of gym and sports. Water polo and basketball had carved me into this and I knew it showed. Mia reached over and ran her hand along my arm.
“You look so hot right now,” she said, smiling. “I love when you get all shiny like this.”
I smiled and pulled her in for a kiss. Her lips were soft and familiar. It felt good. Normal. The kind of thing a boyfriend should want. We talked about random stuff for a while. She told me about her classes next semester and how she wanted to go on a trip soon. I nodded and laughed at her stories but my mind kept drifting. The sun warmed my skin and made my muscles relax yet every time I closed my eyes, I saw Tyler on his knees in the basement. The way his throat had bulged around my cock. The spit dripping down his chin. The way he had moaned when I called him a hungry cocksucker. My dick started to swell again. It pushed against the thin material of the shorts growing thicker and heavier.
“Come on Jakey,” I told myself inside my head. Your hot girlfriend is right next to you. Take her back upstairs and fuck her like you usually would have done. She loves it when you pound her deep. Why the fuck are you thinking about her slutty brother’s mouth working your cock instead.
The guilt hit hard but the thrill won out. I glanced over at Mia. She had dozed off on her lounge chair. Her chest rose and fell slow and even. The sun made her skin glow. She looked peaceful and beautiful. I should have woken her up and carried her inside. Instead I felt my cock throb harder at the thought of Tyler waiting somewhere in the house.
‘Fuck it,’ I muttered under my breath. I stood up slowly and was careful not to wake her. My bare feet padded across the warm deck and I slipped back inside through the sliding door. The air conditioning hit my sweaty chest and made my nipples tighten. I was still shirtless and the shorts rode low on my hips showing the deep v lines that pointed straight to my growing bulge. My heart pounded as I walked down the hallway toward Tyler's room. The house was quiet except for the faint sound of video game gunfire coming from behind his door.
I pushed the door open and stepped inside then closed it softly behind me. Tyler sat at his desk with headphones on eyes glued to the screen. He must have heard the click because he pulled the headphones off and turned around. His face lit up with that smirk I was starting to crave. He stood up slowly and stretched like he had all the time in the world.
“I have been waiting for you,” he said, voice low and teasing.
I hesitated for a beat, my hand still on the doorknob.
“I… uh… I was just bored,” I muttered trying to sound casual. It came out rougher than I meant.
Tyler smirked wider and stepped closer. “Sure big boy," he said. “I know a way or two to get rid of that boredom.”
I walked toward him until my legs hit the edge of his bed. He did not stop. He closed the distance and placed both hands on my chest pushing me down onto the mattress. I landed with a soft bounce, my muscular frame sprawled out shirtless and already breathing heavier. Tyler dropped straight to his knees between my spread legs. His eyes locked on the obvious tent in the shorts. He ran his palms up my thighs and hooked his fingers into the waistband.
“I like my shorts on you,” he said “but you look better naked.”
He pulled the fabric down slowly and teasingly. The elastic dragged over my hips and the thick base of my shaft appeared first. Then more and more until the whole ten inches sprang free. It slapped heavy against my lower abs and bobbed there rock hard and leaking. The fat head glistened with precum. Veins stood out thick along the length. My heavy balls hung low and full again even after the morning load. Tyler stared at it like it was the only thing in the room. His breath came warm against my skin. He licked his lips once, slowly and deliberately. My cock throbbed so hard it jumped visibly right in front of his slutty face. He had milked me dry hours ago in the basement yet here he was on his knees again looking like he needed it more than ever. The sight sent a fresh rush of ego straight through me mixed with that sharp edge of guilt about Mia napping just outside. I knew I should stop but my dick was already making the decision for me.
If you enjoyed this story, consider supporting the author on Patreon.
