Unmasked
Alex Pov
The room was completely different from when I left. Everyone was either naked or half-naked, lots of kissing and groping going on, the 2 other strippers were sucking off Ben’s friends. In the middle of the room was a table with the last guy I saw coming down the stairs on it, minus the shorts.
It looked like he had been having an awesome time; his body glistened with loads of cum and was currently being fucked by Ben’s brothers, Liam and Chris. Liam was pounding the guy’s ass while Chris was going town fucking the guy’s mouth. I was surprised when they leaned into each other and started making out. It was hot to see these two stepbrothers going at it.
Ben came up to me and was clearly out of it. He put his arms around me and whispered that he loved me before sticking his tongue in my mouth. We kissed like that for what seemed like ages, but was only a moment, Ben naked and casually stroking himself while I tried to process the scene before me.
“It’s our turn to fuck this guy next,” Ben said, his words slightly slurred from the alcohol and drugs.
I wasn’t sure if I was ready for another round so soon after being with the stripper upstairs, but my body was responding to the energy in the room. I hesitated, watching the leather-masked man on the table as Liam and Chris were both ready to drop their loads.
“What do you think of Chris and Liam swapping spit?” Ben asked, nodding toward his stepbrothers.
“I thought it was fucking hot,” I admitted, surprising myself with my honesty.
Ben’s mouth curled into a smirk. Yeah, I think so too. I have two hot stepbrothers, that’s for sure.
Liam burst his load inside the guy in the middle of the room, and Chris sprayed his cum over the guy’s body, adding to the mess already there. Ben grabbed my hand and pulled me into the middle of the room. He asked which end I wanted, and I told him it was his birthday, so he should pick. Ben went straight for the guy’s ass.
There was something familiar about this guy. I slipped my cock into his waiting mouth, and he just moaned. Again, something very familiar about his moan and the way he sucked my cock.
I looked out across the room. I hadn’t seen Jeff in what seemed like hours, and still didn’t see him anywhere. This guy was getting his ass pounded hard by Ben; he slipped his cock out of his mouth for a bit and started moaning, “harder, harder,” this guy was out of control…
My stomach dropped. I knew that voice. It couldn’t be. That was ridiculous. Jeff was a total top. Well, mostly.
Ben said he was getting close and then said something that didn’t make sense. “Thanks for making my birthday so epic, Alex.”
I thought I’d misheard, but then just as Ben was exploding in the guy’s ass, he ripped off the guy’s mask.
“Oh, my fucking god.”
I couldn’t believe what I was seeing. It was him. It was Jeff, my boyfriend, getting fucked by my best friend. I was shocked. Jeff hardly ever bottomed for me; I was always the one Jeff was pounding.
A flurry of emotions hit me all at once – anger, humiliation, betrayal – but most of all, a surge of arousal that shocked me. My cock throbbed painfully in his mouth as I stared down at Jeff’s face. He looked up to realise who was fucking his throat, his eyes were wide with surprise.
Jeff’s eyes filled with a mix of shock, guilt, and something else – arousal? – as he looked up at me. His lips still wrapped around my cock, he seemed caught between continuing and pulling away.
He pulled off my cock, “I’m so sorry,” he managed to say. “You weren’t meant to find out.”
I couldn’t form words. My boyfriend was on a table, covered in cum, Ben, my best friend, was still buried deep inside him. The room seemed to spin slightly from the alcohol and drugs, but this moment – this revelation – cut through the haze with perfect clarity.
Ben pulled out slowly, his own expression a complex mix of defiance and concern. “Don’t be mad, Alex. It wasn’t planned, it just sort of happened.”
Just happened? I wanted to laugh at the absurdity. My best friend had my boyfriend bent over a table, everyone at the party had either fucked my boyfriend or dropped a load down his throat, including Ben’s dad, and it “just happened”? The anger and humiliation should have been overwhelming, but I was feeling something else as well.
I watched as Jeff lowered his eyes, unable to meet my gaze. My cock was still hard, jutting out between us like an accusation. The party continued around us, but it felt like we were in our own bubble of tension. Jeff looked up at me, eyes glassy, face flushed with exertion and shame.
“You’ve been fucking my boyfriend behind my back?” I finally managed to say, my voice cracking slightly.
Ben ran his hand through his hair, cum still glistening on his softening cock. “It wasn’t like that, Alex. Well, not exactly.”
Jeff tried to sit up, but his body was slick with the evidence of what had happened. “Alex, please. I can explain.” His voice was hoarse from the throat-fucking he’d received.
Something primal stirred in my gut. The sight of Jeff like this—used, claimed by others, marked with their cum—it should have disgusted me. Instead, my cock twitched, and I had to do something.
I grabbed Jeff by the hair and pulled him close, his face inches from mine. “Is this what you’ve been doing when I thought you were working late?” The words came out raw, almost a growl.
Jeff swallowed hard. “No, I—”
“Don’t fucking lie to me.” I yanked his head back, exposing his throat.
Ben stood nearby, his hand resting on Jeff’s shoulder in a gesture that seemed both protective and possessive.
“I wanted to tell you,” Jeff whispered, his eyes locked on mine. “But I didn’t know how.”
“How long?” I demanded, my grip on his hair tightening. “How long has this been going on?”
Jeff winced. “A few months. Those words hit me like a punch to the stomach, fuck, my boyfriend and best friend had been fucking for months. For some reason, my cock was still throbbing. I started fisting my cock and unleashed the biggest load of my life onto Jeff’s face, fuck, I moaned.
The party started to die down after that, and I told Ben and Jeff I needed to get some sleep.
Later that night, when everyone had gone to bed, I asked Jeff what had happened and why he ended up as the guy getting his ass fucked all afternoon. He told me Ben’s dad and brothers were talking to him earlier about the strippers coming and that the one that was going to be everyone’s cumdump had cancelled as he had covid.
“They really wanted the party to be epic,” Jeff continued, “and asked if I knew anyone who would want to be a cumdump for the afternoon.”
I stared at him, still processing everything. The idea of my boyfriend being the centre of all that attention—of being used by multiple men—kept replaying in my mind.
“I was pretty drunk and high,” Jeff said, his voice softer now. “And I told them that it was one of my biggest fantasies to be bred by multiple men one after the other, but I didn’t think you would agree to it.”
My breath caught in my throat. I’d never known Jeff to have any such fantasies. We’d been together for years, and this was the first I was hearing of it.
“That’s when Ben’s dad came up with the idea of using a mask,” Jeff explained. “He said you didn’t have to know about it.” He paused. I don’t know what happened at the end. I’m not sure why the mask came off. I had my own ideas about that, Ben, I think, wanted everything out in the open.
I drifted off to an uncomfortable sleep. The strange bed didn’t help, but the images replaying in my mind made rest nearly impossible. Sometime during the night, I woke to find Jeff missing from beside me. The empty space was still warm. I rubbed my eyes, figuring he’d probably gone to the kitchen for water or to use the bathroom.
After about twenty minutes, Jeff still hadn’t returned. My throat felt dry, and I needed water myself. I slipped out of bed and headed downstairs, the wooden floor cool against my bare feet.
As I approached the living room, I heard muffled sounds – soft moans and the rhythmic creaking of furniture. My heart rate quickened. I should have turned around, gone back to bed, pretended I hadn’t heard anything. But something pulled me forward.
The sight that greeted me knocked the air from my lungs. I was shocked by the sight in front of me.
Jeff was sitting on Ben’s dad’s lap, who had the biggest cock I’ve seen; it had to be at least 10 inches and thick. Jeff was moaning, fucking himself, rocking back and forward, saying how good this fucking cock was, so much bigger than Alex’s.
I couldn’t believe what I was hearing. My cock was average at best, but I’d never thought Jeff had been unsatisfied. My stomach twisted with a mix of jealousy and arousal as I watched them, frozen in place. I hadn’t even realised I was watching them and wanking my cock.
Jeff leaned into Ben’s dad, their mouths meeting in a hungry kiss that made my chest tighten. They were oblivious to my presence, lost in their own world of pleasure. Ben’s dad’s hands gripped Jeff’s hips, guiding him up and down on that massive cock.
I almost jumped out of my skin when Ben came up behind me and put his arms around my shoulder, and asked if I was enjoying the show. I looked down, and my cock was giving me away; it was rock hard. Ben looked at me and smirked.
He gave my cock a smack and then proceeded to move over to Jeff and his dad and rubbed his cock along Jeff’s ass crack. He looked back at me and told me to come here.
I was mesmerised by the sight in front of me and just moved over to where Jeff was fucking himself. Ben told me to kneel and to suck his cock, smirking down at me. I started sucking on Ben’s cock, licking it all over, lost in the moment.
Ben grabbed me by my hair and told me to look at your boyfriend’s face. Jeff looked at me, but I could tell he was lost in the moment; his eyes were out of focus, Ben’s dad’s cock was his only thought at the moment.
He loves being fucked, Alex, you haven’t been looking after your boyfriend, Ben said. He moved my face to Jeff’s ass and Ben’s dad’s cock.
“Lick,” he said.
I did what I was told and slobbered over where Ben’s dad was fucking Jeff. Ben said, “OK, enough, cuck, just sit there.”
I should have been jealous or angry, but all I could think of was how fucking hot this was.
Ben’s eyes met mine as he began to push his cock into Jeff’s hole alongside his dad’s cock. Jeff moaned, “Yes fuck me, Ben, stick that big fucking cock in me.” I didn’t know how he could fit two large cocks in his ass, especially the size of Ben’s and Ben’s dad's.
Still looking at me, he says, your boyfriend’s ass is so tight. They both started giving Jeff the fucking of his life. Jeff looked down at me, not really believing I was kneeling there watching them. He was moaning, saying fuck Alex, this feels so good. I’ve never felt so full.
Ben’s dad asked Jeff how he was going to go back to Alex’s small cock after this. Jeff said, your cock is so much better than his, Max. You can fuck me anytime you want.
That’s right, Ben’s dad said, I own this ass now, you are my boy to fuck whenever I feel like it. Jeff just moaned and was lost fucking himself on these 2 huge dicks.
I didn’t even realise I was wanking myself just watching the scene unfold in front of me. I was so turned on, I didn’t need to be involved, just watching my boyfriend being owned by these two guys with cocks larger than mine was so hot, I was so turned on and excited that I lost it and dropped my load.
After I had cum, I felt sleepy, so I went back to the kitchen and grabbed some water and went back up to bed.
I woke with Jeff sleeping in front of me, my cock hard and resting between his ass cheeks. The worst hangover pounded in my skull, and blurry memories of the night before floated through my mind. Had I really watched Jeff getting fucked by Ben and his dad? That seemed too wild to be real, but the soreness in my knees and the taste in my mouth told me otherwise.
I slipped out of bed, desperate for water to soothe my parched throat. The wooden floor creaked beneath my feet as I made my way downstairs, my head throbbing with each step.
Ben’s dad was already in the kitchen, wearing a skimpy pair of underwear that did nothing to hide his semi-hard cock. My eyes lingered on the bulge before meeting his gaze. His face showed concern, or maybe it was guilt.
“Good morning, Alex,” he said, Great party last night. You look like you may need these, and handed me some Panadol and water.
I thanked him and told him yeah was a great party, but I was surprised that Jeff had agreed to be everyone’s cumdump.
Ben’s dad put his arms around me and told me Jeff was a great guy for agreeing to do that, and that I really lucked out having him as my boyfriend. He was rubbing my back and said you seemed to enjoy what was going on after the party as well with Jeff and Ben, from what I saw.
Well, I guess that confirmed it wasn’t a dream, lol, I told him I was going to go back to bed for a bit. He said it might be best if I got some food into my stomach, as it would probably make me feel better. I agreed, and he brought over some bacon and eggs and hash browns, definitely what I needed.
After finishing my breakfast, I sat there trying to process everything that had happened last night. Ben came downstairs and sat next to me, draping an arm around my shoulders.
“I’m sorry if things got a bit out of control last night,” Ben said.
“Which part?” I retorted, the words coming out harsher than I intended. The part where Jeff was a party favourite for you and all of your guests, or the part where “You and your dad were both fucking my boyfriend at the same time behind my back? Why would I be upset with that?”
Ben’s dad looked up with a guilty expression and mumbled something about needing a shower before quickly exiting the kitchen.
Ben’s hand moved to my thigh, resting there with familiar ease. “Well, you did seem to get excited when I was slipping my cock into Jeff’s ass. And he did sort of love it.” His fingers inched closer to my crotch. “And you are sort of hard right now with us just talking about it.” His hand had shifted to my covered cock and just held it there, to my annoyance, my cock gave me away again and was rock hard again.
Chris and Liam came downstairs and grabbed some food, and started eating. They were saying how yesterday’s party was awesome, and they didn’t believe how hot my boyfriend was taking everyone’s cock.
Liam asked if I was upset that my boyfriend was such a huge cumdump for Ben and his friends. I told him that this was a once-off, and it was one of his fantasies, so who was I to spoil his fun? Chris said that’s very nice of you. If he were my boyfriend, I would be jealous as hell.
Ben smirked. “I think Alex secretly gets off on other guys fucking his boyfriend. I could feel my face burning up at his words.
“Well, if you ever need any help in that department, just come over,” Chris replied. “I’m pretty sure we can arrange another night when Mom isn’t here, and we can all give you and Jeff a good time.
Especially Dad—I think he might have a bit of a crush on your boyfriend.” He laughed, but something was knowing in his tone that made my stomach flip. “Dad’s actually with Jeff at the moment. He was saying something about putting a soothing cream on Jeff’s ass, as it looked pretty red after yesterday’s use.”
My heart jumped in my chest. I stood up abruptly, nearly knocking over my chair. “I should check on Jeff,” I mumbled, avoiding Ben’s amused gaze as he headed for the guest room.
As I made my way up the stairs, my mind raced with the images from last night—Jeff’s face contorted with pleasure, Ben’s father’s massive cock sliding in and out of my boyfriend, the sound of their moans filling the living room. My own reaction to it all confused me. I should be furious, devastated even, but instead, I found myself turned on by it.
I paused outside the bedroom door, hearing muffled sounds from within. Taking a deep breath, I pushed it open.
The sight that greeted me made my mouth go dry. Jeff was naked on his back, legs in the air, and Ben’s dad—also completely naked—had his face buried between Jeff’s thighs, his tongue working deep inside Jeff’s ass.
“Hi, baby,” Jeff moaned, looking over at me with glazed eyes. “Max was just taking care of my hole, making sure it all feels better, after all the pounding it took yesterday”.
I was just looking at Ben’s dad lapping at Jeff’s hole, my cock was starting to bone up again, watching the action in front of me. Ben’s dad looked at me and my hard cock with a smirk and said have a seat, Alex, enjoy yourself while I take care of your boyfriend.
It was like I was hypnotised; I sat on the chair in the corner and started stroking my cock, Jeff and Ben’s dad were moaning. Jeff was saying yes, fuck, yes, make my hole feel better, get that fat tongue all the way in my hole.
Ben’s dad looked at me and said I know how to make your boyfriend feel good. After a bit, Ben’s dad moved up onto Jeff’s chest and told him it was his turn to make me feel good. Jeff started sucking Max’s cock, moaning how big and how thick it was and that he’d never had a cock this big.
I was getting turned on seeing Jeff being used by Ben’s dad again. I couldn’t stop myself from cumming all over myself. Ben’s dad looked at me and smirked. He started pounding Jeff’s mouth. Jeff was slobbering, and his face was a mess.
You love me playing with your boyfriend, don’t you? It’s ok, you can tell me. I had to admit to him that, yes, I did. Ben’s dad told me that he would be happy to come over to our place and make Jeff feel good whenever I liked. About 15 mins later of Ben’s dad fucking my boyfriend’s mouth, Ben’s dad finally came, with Jeff moaning how great Max’s cock was.
Ben’s dad said we had better get ready to go as his wife was due back in an hour. We all pitched in and cleaned up the house from the night before, getting rid of any evidence that there was practically an orgy happening in the lounge room the previous night.
As Jeff and I were leaving, Ben and his dad kissed Jeff on the mouth goodbye, hope to see you soon, son, Ben’s dad said, I hope so too, Max, Jeff replied.
To be continued…..
If you enjoyed this story, consider supporting the author on Substack.
To get in touch with the author, send them an email.
