It Happened One Night: Jace

by Kevgenesys

5 May 2018 3633 readers Score 8.8 (45 votes) PDF Mobi ePub Txt


I didn't intend to write a second part to "It Happened One Night: Jace" but with some requests and some imagining what would happen next in the story, I thought a next part might work. There will be at least one other part to this story, of course, since it ends on a cliffhanger. There is no nudity or sex in this part, but more about each of the characters is explored.

I'm always curious to know reader thoughts, and if you feel you relate to one of the characters in the story. Email me at [email protected]


"Hey, we still on for Friday?" I read from Benny's text.

It had been nearly a week since that one night with Jace. That is, Benny with Jace. As much as I tried, I found myself thinking about what I saw, what I heard, what I smelled, what I felt. I wonder what came over me - and why I came all over me - when I dashed out of the apartment.

Benny's only apartment mate was Jace, a stunning blonde, blue-eyed hunk who spent many hours at the gym each week. He did some modeling back in college, but focused primarily on baseball. He could easily go back to walking runways now, but instead, he's working at some firm now - marketing or sales or something of that nature. I was at the same party where Benny and Jace met about a year ago. Jace lived a couple towns away and was planning to move to the city to begin his career path. Benny suggested they could live in a place together - separate rooms, save money. A few months later, they began living together in high rise apartment. It's not a bad place and has a nice balcony view. It's much better than my place so it's usually me who's going over to Benny's.

Benny never hinted to me that he lusted after Jace - not that I can remember. I could recall times when I came over and Benny mentioned that Jace had a girl over in his room. Their rooms were on separate parts of the house. Jace's room on the left side and Benny's all the way at the right end. The living room and kitchen were in the middle. One time, Benny and I were watching an action movie, but during the scenes where the characters were quiet, deep in thought, we could hear the faint moaning of a girl coming from Jace's room. Benny and I looked at each other and laughed, and that was it.

Jace was always OK with Benny being gay - it didn't seem to bother him at all. When Benny and I would be chatting at the couch, Jace would come out of his room in just basketball shorts, grab something from the kitchen, and head back to his room. Sometimes my eyes went to him, but only because I was admiring the work he had been putting in the gym on his chest.

Benny himself got around as well. He had an athletic, slender build because his exercise of choice was running for miles. There's been a few nights when Benny and I would go out to a bar and he ends up leaving me with his arm around a good-looking guy. I couldn't fault him because there had been some times where I likewise blew him off for a girl. It was like this unspoken mutual agreement and it worked well for us. We even caught Jace at the bar once. We didn't go up to him as he was busy with two girls already. Benny told me later that Jace didn't come home that night.

"Friday. Yes, I'll come over," I texted back to Benny.

Since that night, I didn't know what to think anymore. But I knew what I WAS thinking, and it was....confusing. Something about Benny binding Jace, with his panicked look on his handsome face.....it gave me a rush. A rush that was....enjoyable? Something I wanted to feel again? When Benny kissed Jace down his neck and at his chest, I didn't really want him to stop either - what am I thinking, that's nuts! I never cared when I saw two guys kissing, so why would I care about this at all? I could still hear the sounds as Benny thrust into him. When Jace moaned, I wanted to hear him louder. I had imagined I was in Benny's spot...........sticking my own..........my own........WHAT? NO! Why would I want to do that?? It was just a coincidence that my mouth was watering when I saw Jace leak precum as Benny slobbered over his hard cock. I just happened to be in sync with Benny's thrusting and my stroking as I touched myself in silence, hidden at the shadowy doorway.

I thought about confronting Benny about all this - but how? And why? Should I report Benny to the police? That would cause a mess and what would I get out of ratting out my friend - a friend who drove me to the hospital when I got sick and lent me money when I couldn't afford my rent in between jobs. Should I tell Jace? Maybe he would thank me and let me have his ass. Wait, what?? NO.

Friday came. I stood in front of their apartment door. What if Jace answers? His room IS closer to the front door than Benny's, and he often ends up getting to the door first anyways. Maybe he would be shirtless again like the time-

"Oh!"

"Oh, hey Tyler!" Benny answered with a trash bag in his hand. "Perfect timing because I was just about to dump this into the chute." He looked like his "normal" cheerful self - not the haunting figure from last week.

"Hey..." I muttered, never too good at hiding my emotions. I walked into the entry way area of their apartment and stood there for a second as Benny let go of the trash bag.

"What's wrong...?" Benny said, closing the front door. He could always read me like a book.

"Uh, nothing.....just looking forward to tonight. Hey, is Jace in?" Ugh, way to be subtle!

"No, he's not in. Um....did you need to talk to him?"

"Oh, no, I don't. I don't even know why I asked. Forget I asked. Let's talk about something else."

"Tyler, what's the matter? Something is obviously bugging you. Does this have anything to do with Joelle?" We walked to the living room and sat at separate couches.

"Joelle? No, I haven't talked to her in a few weeks since the last time actually. It....doesn't seem likely we'll see each other again."

"Oh that's too bad. I thought you two really hit it off and were still interested. How do you feel about it?" Benny was also so sympathetic. At least, the Benny that I used to think I knew.

"It's fine......really."

"Well, we'll just have to find you another girl then! What are you feeling tonight? Blonde? Brunette? Redhead?"

"Blonde. I mean, none of those. I mean, I don't care about the hair color."

"Aha, of course, of course. As long as they have a nice booty, right? You've always been such an ass man. ANYWAYS, the Spark Tavern starts getting busy at around 9 tonight. So that would give us about 30 minutes to-"

"Benny, do you like Jace?" I blurted out, surprising myself.

Benny shot a confused look at me. "Well, Jace IS very attractive of course.......but why does that matter?"

I looked back down at my hands. "I don't know. Just wanted to know I guess. I just thought.............I mean, I guess I was just curious or something...."

Benny started to smile. "I mean a girl a week can't be wrong, Tyler. Have you finally noticed how hot he is? Don't tell mean YOU fancy Jace?" He laughed.

That comment totally threw me off guard in my already confuzzled mind. "What??"

Benny giggled. "I mean, I wouldn't hold it against you. Jace has been known to make even the straightest guys question themselves."

"H-hey I don't! I really don't! ......it's...it's you who likes Jace!"

Was I yelling? I was yelling.

Benny could only laugh at my surprisingly erratic behavior. He continued to be the jokester, "Tyler, what is WRONG with you? It's OK if Jace makes you confused-"

Benny didn't realize how it was more than a joke to me, and I had enough. I quickly jumped up from the couch.

"No, YOU want Jace and you HAD Jace. I saw you. I was there. I saw you last Friday. You.....and your rope......and that bottle.......and you.....and you....with his jockstrap.........."

In the midst of whatever I was yelling, Benny stopped smiling. He didn't look like his normal cheerful self. He looked.....more like the Benny from the other night....I don't know how to describe it.

"You were there and you didn't say anything?" Benny finally spoke up.

"....And you were...........you started.........you took off his underwear and...........started touching him........everywhere..........:"

"Why didn't you say something that night?" Benny said in the same calm tone as before.

"Huh?" I didn't even know half the words I just said.

"Why didn't you say something to stop me? What were you doing?" Benny was now scarily calm.

"I.....I, uh......." And now I was scared and not calm.

"You just decided to.......watch it all play out.....?"

"...................no...........I................well, I......"

"You were enjoying it, weren't you?" My body language was giving up everything to Benny.

"I......I wasn't. I was................I just..............."

"What did you like about it, Tyler? You liked seeing Jace all vulnerable? You liked seeing his jock body getting used?" It was like hearing dark Benny again and I began to get a rush again as Benny's words reminded me of Jace's moans.

"No! ...........I.....no, why would I....? .........I'm not into that......"

"Tyler, just ask." Benny smiled. "I know what you want."

"What.....?!" Did I even know what I wanted?

"Just ask," Benny's words hypnotized me.

"I, uh...........I want..............."

"You want........................."

"I......................."

"You want.........................."

"I want Jace."

Benny made a devilish grin. "You want him, you got him." Benny got up and sat back down next to me. I was frozen. What did I just say? He put his hand on my shoulder. "You want it like that night, huh? You wish you were me that night. You've been thinking about it all week it looks like. Look, you're even thinking about it now."

What was Benny talking about?? He was looking down at my crotch and when I looked down, I was in horror, as I had a visible hard-on in my pants.

Did I really want Jace? No, of course not......I was just being tempted or something.......but how does that explain me getting turned on? Oh it could be anything! I'm a guy after all! Maybe I'm just into kinky stuff...? This didn't make any sense. I better call it off.

"Benny!" I yelled. Sometime, when I was lost in my own thoughts, Benny had gotten up and left.

He popped out of his room. He held a used jockstrap - the same one from the night - the one that belonged to Jace. "You want this, Tyler?" Benny taunted.

I was like a moth to a flame. I got up and followed Benny into his room and he closed the door. I don't know what Benny said, but the next thing I know I was lying down on his bed with the jockstrap in my face, with the thoughts of Jace's thick cock and big balls swirling through my mind.

"Oh Tyler, you like that, don't you?"

I don't know what I answered, or if I even answered. I was remembering the time Jace came out his room once when Benny and I were eating in the kitchen. He was just wearing a towel, still wet from a shower. When he turned the corner, he almost dropped his towel, but ended up just showing a side of his well-toned ass. Was he teasing me that time? Maybe he wanted me to see him like that. Maybe he wanted me to have his toned, tan ass.

"Jace is always teasing you, don't you see?" Benny whispered.

That explains why he answers the door all the time, wearing a tight t-shirt and sweatpants. He's teasing me those times too. And when he stretches his arms over his head and tells us he's heading to bed............he's just asking to be taken down..........right? His biceps always looked so big when he did that. But Jace is straight.............he must need someone to........to put him in a position so that he wouldn't be able to protest, where he would be out of control, where he would not be able to remember anything the next day. Things were getting clearer to me.............I think..............at least, whatever Benny kept whispering to me was making sense, whatever he was saying. Yes, Jace wanted to show me everything his hot bod had to offer that other night, and he wanted me to have him tonight.

"Jace....................wants you...................to fuck him......................"

The sound of the front door. Jace was home.

by Kevgenesys

Email: [email protected]

Copyright 2024