Gay For Pay

Gay man pays his straight friend $10,000 for one night together

  • Score 8.3 (6 votes)
  • 341 Readers
  • 2778 Words
  • 12 Min Read

The living room was dim, the only light coming from the flickering television set to mute. Dallin, a stocky 35-year-old with the beginnings of a greying beard, sat hunched on the couch. His wife, Maria, was upstairs putting their six kids to bed. The weight of his recent layoff pressed down on him like a physical force.

"I know it's a shock, Dall," Sebastian said, his voice quiet but steadfast. He sat across from him, his hands clasped in his lap. "And I know how this sounds. But I've been holding this in for years. Years, Dall."

Dallin shook his head, slowly, as if trying to dislodge the words he'd just heard. "Sebastian, man... I don't... I'm not gay. I've got a wife. Six kids. How can you even ask me this?"

"Because I'm desperate," Sebastian replied, his voice crackling. "And because I think you're desperate too. $10,000. It's not just about the sex, Dall. It's about finally being close to you. Just once."

Dallin looked at his friend--his college friend, his buddy for over a decade--and saw someone he didn't recognize. The money loomed in his mind, a lifeline thrown into a stormy sea. He thought of the mortgage, the pile of bills on the kitchen counter, his kids' faces.

"I'm flattered," Dallin said finally, his voice a hoarse whisper. "I really am. But no. I can't. I'm straight. I'm married. It's.... It'd be too weird."

Sebastian nodded, a look of defeat crossing his features. He stood up, putting his wallet back in his pocket. "I understand. I'm sorry, Dall. I shouldn't have..."

"Yeah," Dallin interrupted, not wanting to hear the apology. "You should go."

Sebastian walked to the door, pausing with his hand on the knob. He turned back, his eyes glistening. "If you change your mind... the offer stands."

The door clicked shut behind him, leaving Dallin alone in the dim light. He put his head in his hands, the silence of the house broken only by the faint, rhythmic creaking of the upstairs floorboards as Maria tucked their children in. The $10,000 hung in the air between them, a question he didn't want to answer.

----

Dallin found Maria in the kitchen, staring at a notepad filled with columns of numbers. The dinner dishes sat unwashed in the sink. He told her everything, the words tumbling out in a low, jargon-filled stream. 

"So... he's gay, Maria. And he says he's in love with me. That he's been in love with me for years. He offered me ten thousand dollars to..." he trailed off, unable to finish the sentence. 

Maria set down her pen. She looked at him, her face unreadable. For a long moment, the only sound was the drip of water from the faucet.

"Ten thousand dollars," she finally said, her voice flat. "That pays the mortgage for four months."

"I know how much it is," Dallin snapped, frustration building. "But it's not just... I can't do that. It would be cheating on you. It would be wrong. And..." He shuddered. "It would be disgusting. I can't have sex with a man."

Maria stood up, her chair scraping against the linoleum. She walked to him, her arms crossed. "Disgusting? You think I find it any less disgusting? You think I want my husband to go fuck some gay guy? But this isn't about what we want anymore, Dallin. It's about what we need.""

"We can find another way--" Dallin started.

"What other way?" Maria demanded, her voice rising. "You've been looked for work for weeks. Nothing. The kids need new winter coats. Sam needs braces. We're one bill away from disaster, and you're telling me you're too good to lay down with a dude for 15 minutes?"

"It's not about being 'too good'!" Dallin shouted, then caught himself, lowering his voice so the kids wouldn't hear. "It's about who I am. I'm your husband. I'm their father. I'm supposed to be a man."

"A man who can't feed his family isn't much of a man at all," Maria shot back. "I'm asking you to think about... to think about doing something hard, something terrible, so that the family can have a better life. That's what people do. They sacrifice for their family."

Dallin looked at her, the woman he'd loved for over a decade. He saw the fear in her eyes, the fear of losing everything. He saw the mother of his children, who was now asking him to do the unthinkable. 

"I can't believe you're asking me to do this," he whispered.

"I can't believe I have to," she replied. "Now go to bed. We can talk about it in the morning."

She walked past him and up the stairs, leaving him alone in the kitchen with the dirty dishes and the weight of her words.

----

Dallin's hand trembled as he pulled out his phone. He had to dial the number twice before he could get it right. Sebastian answered on the first ring, his voice a mix of hope and shame.

"Dall? Is that you?"

"Yeah," Dallin said, his voice hoarse. "We need to talk. In person. Now."

They met at a 24-hour diner on the edge of town, a place where they were unlikely to run into anyone they knew. The sticky formica top glistened under the fluorescent lights. A lone figure in a corner nursed a coffee.

Sebastian sat across from him, his hands wrapped around a mug of hot chocolate. He couldn't meet Dallin's eyes.

"I need to know," Dallin said, his voice a low, flat monotone. "Exactly. What do you want?"

Sebastian took a shaky breath. "I want you to make love to me, Dall. Like I'm the only one. Like you mean it." His words started to gain momentum, a strange urgency filling them. "I want you to kiss me. Hold me. Tell me you love me. I want you to... penetrate me. And I want you to ejaculate inside of me. So I can feel like I'm yours, even if it's just for one night."

Dallin felt a surge of nausea. He pictured it, his mind supplying images he fought to suppress. But he also pictured his wife's face, her words echoing in his mind. Sacrifice.

"Fine," Dallin said, the word tasting like ash in his mouth. "But we do it my way. I'm not... I'm not going to be the one on the receiving end. I penetrate you. You don't touch me there. Never."

Sebastian nodded, his eyes finally meeting Dallin's. There was something in them--gratitude, yes, but also a hint of the same disgust Dallin felt. "Deal. I'll be the bottom. You'll be the top. Just like you said."

"And we never talk about it again," Dallin added. "After it's done, it's done. We go back to being friends. Just friends."

"Agreed," Sebastian said quietly.

They sat in silence for a moment, the terms of their deal hanging between them like a thing unspoken. Finally, Dallin stood up.

"I'll call you tomorrow. We'll set a date." He walked away without looking back, the bell on the diner door jingling his exit.

----

The hotel was the kind Dallin had only ever seen from the outside. Marble floors, a concierge who never questioned, and an elevator that required a key card. The penthouse suite was on the top floor. When Sebastian opened the door, Dallin stepped into what looked like a magazine spread. Panoramic windows showed the city lights sprawling below. A king-sized bed, adorned with white linens, dominated the room. A bottle of wine chilled in a silver bucket.

"You went all out," Dallin said, his voice small in the lavish space.

"You deserve it," Sebastian replied, taking his coat. "Or, we deserve it. For this one night."

He gestured to the wine. "I got this for you. It's a good Bordeaux. And..." he pulled a small pill bottle from his pocket. "I got these too. Just in case you, you know, have trouble. Nerves and all."

Dallin stared at the pills. Viagra. He took one, washing it down with a long gulp of wine. The warmth spread through his chest, but it did little to ease the dread twisting in his gut.

They sat in awkward silence for what felt like an eternity, sipping their wine. Dallin focused on the view, trying to lose himself in the twinkling lights below, to imagine he was anywhere else.

"I think it's been twenty minutes," Sebastian said softly. He set down his glass and moved to stand in front of Dallin. "Can I...?"

Dallin gave a small, stiff nod.

Sebastian's hands were gentle as he began to unbutton Dallin's shirt. He moved slowly, deliberately, as if unwrapping a precious gift. Dallin sat rigid, his jaw clenched, his eyes fixed on a point on the wall. He could feel the Viagra working, a physical response his mind screamed against. It was a betrayal by his own body.

Sebastian slid the shirt off Dallin's shoulders, his fingertips lightly tracing the muscles there. He knelt down before him to remove his shoes and socks, then unbuckled his belt. Each article of clothing was folded and set aside with care.

When Dallin sat there in only his boxers, Sebastian paused. He looked at him, his eyes filled with a complex emotion--love, guilt, and a hunger that had been denied for years.

"You can lay down on the bed if you want," Sebastian said gently. "We can take this as slow as you need."

Dallin nodded, still not trusting himself to speak. He stood and walked to the bed, his movements stiff, robotic. He laid down on his back, staring at the ceiling, his body tense as a wire.

Sebastian slowly removed his own clothes, revealing a body that was completely smooth, every trace of hair meticulously removed. He joined Dallin on the bed, propping himself up on one elbow, his hand resting lightly on Dallin's chest.

"It's okay," Sebastian whispered. "Just focus on me. For tonight, just focus on me."

Dallin closed his eyes, a single tear escaping from the corner to trace a path down his temple. He lay there, waiting for what came next.

----

The initial thrust was guilt-ridden, a violent contradiction to everything Dallin believed about himself. He expected discomfort, disgust, a violent rejection from his own body. Instead, there was only warmth, and a strange, unexpected pleasure.

Sebastian gasped beneath him, his body accommodating Dallin's rhythm with an ease that surprised him. There was no resistance, no shyness--just a willing, eager receptivity. It was nothing like the sex he had with Maria, which often involved her tensing up, asking him to be gentle, to slow down.

Here, with Sebastian, there was none of that. Sebastian took him deeply, eagerly, his body moving in a perfect, syncopated dance with Dallin's. Soon, Dallin found himself picking up the pace, his thrusts becoming more deliberate, more controlling. A low growl escaped his throat--a sound he'd never heard himself make before. He was reverting to something primal, a version of masculinity he'd never known he possessed.

Sebastian was in his own world, his eyes rolled back, his mouth open in a silent scream of pleasure. Without ever touching himself, he arched his back, crying out as he rode out wave after wave of orgasm, his prostate gland pumping in unison with the pleasure emanating from within.

"Dallin," he whispered, his voice breaking. "I love you, Dallin. Please. Finish inside me. I want to feel it."

The words, gasped in such a moment of vulnerability, triggered something deep in Dallin. He bent forward, capturing Sebastian's mouth in a deep, French kiss, their tongues twining as he pumped himself into his friend one last time. He came with a groan, the sensation intensified by the intimacy of the kiss, the feeling of Sebastian's body quivering beneath him.

For a long moment, there was only the sound of their ragged breathing. Then, Sebastian began to weep. Tears streaked down his face, but he was smiling--a radiant, joyful smile that seemed out of place in the dim light.

"Thank you," he whispered, his hand cupping Dallin's jaw. "It was everything. Everything I ever dreamed of."

Dallin said nothing. He rolled off, laying on his back on the luxurious sheets, staring at the ceiling. The guilt was already creeping in, cold and insidious, wrapping around his heart. He thought of Maria, of his kids, of the life he had just so thoroughly betrayed. Disgust, thick and clammy, settled over him like a shroud.

"We should never talk about this again," Dallin said finally, his voice flat and devoid of emotion.

Sebastian, still blissed out, nodded. "Of course. Whatever you want."

But as he lay there, staring at the man who had just given him everything he'd ever wanted, Sebastian knew, with a certainty that transcended logic, that this was not the end. It was only the beginning.

----

The money was on the night stand, a thick wad of cash that seemed to radiate a cold, accusing light. Dallin pulled his clothes back on without a word, his movements stiff, robotic. Sebastian still lay on the bed, his eyes red-rimmed but serene, watching him.

"I'll call an Uber," Sebastian said softly.

"Don't bother," Dallin replied, his back turned. "I'll walk."

He snatched the cash from the nightstand without counting it and stuffed it into his jacket pocket. The walk home was a blur. Traffic lights, sidewalks, other people--none of it registered. Only the weight in his pocket and the weight in his chest.

Maria was waiting in the kitchen, a cup of now-cold coffee in front of her. She looked up as he entered, her face a mask of anxiety.

"Well?" she asked. "How was it?"

Dallin opened his mouth, but no words came out. The images flashed before his eyes--Sebastian's face contorted in pleasure, the feel of the kiss, the warmth closing around him. A violent heaving rose in his throat.

He clapped a hand over his mouth and sprinted to the bathroom, making it just in time. He hunched over the toilet, his body heaving as he vomited. Maria knelt beside him, her hand on his back.

"Shh," she murmured. "It's okay. It's over."

When the dry heaving finally stopped, Dallin sat back against the cold bathroom wall, his face white as sheets. He grabbed Maria's wrist, his grip too tight.

"Promise me," he gasped. "Promise me you'll never mention this ever again. Never."

Tears welled in Maria's eyes. "I promise," she whispered.

----

That night, Dallin dreamed. In the dream, he was back in the penthouse, above the city lights. Sebastian was beneath him, their bodies moving in that same primal rhythm. But in the dream, there was no guilt, only the raw, overwhelming pleasure. He woke with a gasp, his body betraying him with an erection that pulsed in the darkness.

"Fuck," he whispered into the silence, hatred for himself a thick, bile-like taste in his mouth. He lay motionless, staring at the ceiling, until the sun finally began to creep through the curtains.

----

A year later, they met for breakfast. It was Sebastian's idea--a quiet diner away from the parts of town where they might be seen. Dallin had texted back a single word: "OK."

They sat across from each other in a vinyl booth. Sebastian looked the same, maybe a little more rested, a little more at peace. Dallin had lost weight, his face more angular, his eyes harboring shadows that hadn't been there before.

"So," Sebastian said, forcing a smile. "How've you been?"

"Fine," Dallin said, his voice too loud. "Got a new job. Nothing great, but it pays the bills."

"That's good," Sebastian replied. "And the family?"

"Good. Everyone's good."

Their order came. They ate in silence, the only sound the clink of utensils against plates. But the silence wasn't empty. It was filled with something that crackled in the air between them-- a tension, an electric awareness of the other's body. Every time their eyes met, it held a beat too long. When Sebastian licked a drop of coffee from his lip, Dallin's grip on his fork tightened.

Neither of them acknowledged it. They played their roles, acting like the friends they had been before that night. But the performance was thin, transparent, and beneath it, the unspoken truth pulsed like a second heartbeat. 

When the meal was finished, they paid their separate bills and stood outside on the sidewalk.

"We should do this again sometime," Sebastian said, his voice carefully neutral.

"Yeah," Dallin agreed, jamming his hands into his pockets. "Sure."

They walked in opposite directions. Neither of them looked back.


To get in touch with the author, send them an email.


Report
What did you think of this story?
Share Story

In This Story