The confession spilled out like warm honey — how he'd lost his virginity to his best friend's older brother in a toolshed during a thunderstorm, the scent of motor oil and rain-soaked earth clinging to them. How he'd lied about it for years, pretending his first time was with some faceless girl. Ethan listened, his thumb stroking the hollow of Alex's throat as the sun bled orange across his shoulders.
"And the wrestling?" Ethan asked when he finished, his voice rough. He already knew the answer — they'd recognized it in each other's bodies from the start — but the question hung between them anyway.
Alex flexed beneath him, tendons shifting under Ethan's palms. "I tried football first. Too many rules." His grin was sharp. "Wrestling let me get away with putting my hands on guys. Longer."
Ethan exhaled a laugh against his collarbone. His tongue followed the path of an old scar — a souvenir from a steel chair — before murmuring, "Show me."
They rolled together, limbs tangling, moss cool against their backs as they grappled without urgency. Ethan's knee slotted between Alex's thighs, his forearm braced against his throat just shy of pressure. Alex countered by arching his hips, grinding their hardening cocks together with a slow, filthy roll that drew twin groans. Their movements weren't combat now but conversation — each shift of muscle, each yielding press speaking louder than words.
Ethan pinned him eventually, their sweat-slick chests heaving, his mouth hovering inches above Alex's. "Still got it," he taunted, breath hot.
Alex surged up to capture his lips, biting just hard enough to make Ethan gasp. "Never lost it."
Their laughter melted into another kiss, slower this time, tongues sliding together with new familiarity. Ethan's fingers traced the shell of Alex's ear before threading through his hair.
"Tell me something else," Alex murmured against his lips.
Ethan shifted, rolling onto his back and pulling Alex flush against his side. The sun had dipped lower, casting golden streaks across their tangled legs. One thick arm curled behind his head while the other draped heavily over Alex's ribs, fingers absently tracing the ridges of his abdomen. "Like what?" The words rumbled through his chest where Alex's ear pressed.
Alex hooked a leg over Ethan's, toes brushing the wiry hair of his calf. "Something real. Before the island."
Ethan exhaled through his nose. His thumb found Alex's nipple, circling it lazily as he spoke. "I used to jerk off in the gym showers after practice." A smirk tugged at his mouth when Alex snorted. "What? You asked for real." His fingers trailed lower, following the trail of dark hair leading down. "Thought about the guys dripping sweat next to me, how they'd groan when they stretched. Sometimes —"
"Christ," Alex breathed.
Ethan squeezed him tighter, his voice dropping. "Sometimes I'd come so hard my knees buckled."
Alex's cock twitched against Ethan's thigh. The admission hung between them, raw and not pretty — exactly like the calluses on Ethan's palm skimming his hipbone.
Above them, palm fronds whispered. The tide crawled up the beach, close enough now that the occasional wavelet licked at their ankles, cool and startling. Neither moved. Ethan's fingers stilled, his breath warm on Alex's forehead. "Your turn."
Alex closed his eyes, swallowing against the sudden tightness in his throat. "The first time I got fucked," he began, "the guy pinned me facedown on his bed. Said I was built for it." His laugh tasted bitter. "I hadn't even taken my shirt off."
Ethan's arm tensed around him. Alex felt the exact moment his jaw clenched — a subtle flex against his temple.
"Asshole," Ethan muttered.
Alex shrugged, though the motion was swallowed by Ethan's embrace. "Got the job done."
Salt spray misted their skin. Somewhere down the shore, a hermit crab scuttled over wet stone. Ethan's hand slid up Alex's spine, blunt nails scraping lightly. "That's not how it should be."
Alex turned his face into Ethan's pec, inhaling musk and seawater. "Show me then."
Ethan's chuckle vibrated through him. "With pleasure."
The waves kept coming. Alex counted them, waiting. When Ethan finally rolled atop him, his hips settled heavy between Alex's thighs, their bodies slotting together like tide-worn rock.
Ethan paused, studying Alex's face — really studying it — before pressing their foreheads together. His hands traced the sides of Alex's torso, thumbs brushing the underside of his pecs, slow as sunrise. "Say it," he murmured.
Alex swallowed. "I want you."
Ethan kissed him — soft, unhurried — then pulled back just far enough to let their breath mingle. His cock dragged wet and hot along Alex's as he rocked forward, a tease of friction that drew a shudder from them both. "Like this?"
Alex arched, chasing the heat. "Jesus, yes."
Ethan laughed low in his throat and caught his mouth again, swallowing his whine. Their hips found a rhythm, lazy and deep, skin sticking where sweat pooled in the hollow of Alex's collarbones. Ethan's fingers tangled with his, pinning them above his head as he sucked a mark into Alex's throat — not rough, just present, just proof.
"Look at me," Ethan breathed. Alex did, blinking salt from his lashes. Ethan's pupils were blown, his hair damp with ocean spray. He moved with the same deliberate control as when he'd wrestled him into the sand—every shift calculated, every press intentional.
Alex gasped when Ethan's thumb found his nipple again, rolling it tight between callused fingers. His hips stuttered. "Close —"
Ethan groaned, his rhythm faltering. "Me too." His grip tightened on Alex's wrists as he thrust harder, once, twice, then stilled with a choked-off sound. Alex came with a sob, his vision whiting out as Ethan spilled his sperm between them, hot and slick.
They shuddered through it together, Ethan collapsing onto his forearms to kiss him through the aftershocks — messy, open-mouthed things that tasted of salt and satisfaction.
When Ethan finally rolled them onto their sides, Alex curled into him like driftwood seeking shore. Ethan's palm smoothed down his flank, coming to rest low on his back.
"Better?" he asked, voice rough.
Alex nosed along his jaw, humming. The tide reached their toes again, cool and insistent. Neither moved.
"Where do you call home?" Alex asked against his pulse.
Ethan exhaled, fingers drifting through the damp hair at Alex's nape. "Pinecrest, New York. A little shit town by the reservoir."
Alex's breath hitched — not from the aftershocks this time, but surprise. He tipped his head back to stare. "You're joking."
"Swear to god." Ethan swiped a thumb over Alex's bottom lip, grinning at his stunned expression. "Why?"
"Because," Alex said, laughter bubbling up, "I bartend at The Rusty Anchor. Literally across the town line."
Ethan barked a laugh, loud enough to startle a seabird into flight. "Fuck. That dive with the taxidermy moose?"
"The very same." Alex folded his arms behind his head, grinning. "Bet I served you."
Ethan's brow furrowed as his gaze dropped to Alex's mouth. "Nah. I'd remember you."
The truth settled between them like the damp sand clinging to their calves — years of orbiting the same roads, the same neon-lit bars, the same sticky summer nights. Alex traced the scar on Ethan's bicep, sun-warmed under his fingertips. "Ever go to Ridgewood's Fourth of July fair?"
"Every year." Ethan caught his wrist, pressing his lips to Alex's palm. "Do you work the beer tent?"
"Christ." Alex shoved him, laughing. "Were you the asshole who tried to pay in dimes?"
Ethan rolled atop him again, pinning him with his weight and a wicked grin. His thighs bracketed Alex's hips, still sticky between them. "Guilty."
The admission sent something hot and reckless curling through Alex's gut. He bucked up, knocking Ethan off-balance just enough to flip them, sand gritting beneath their shoulders. Ethan's laughter punched out as Alex straddled him, hands planted on his chest.
"Small fucking world," Alex muttered, leaning down to suck his collarbone.
Ethan's hands slid up his thighs, gripping hard. "Smaller now."
The next wave crashed close enough to splash their legs. Alex barely noticed, too busy mapping the places their hometowns overlapped — the diner Ethan mentioned with cracked vinyl booths, the trailhead where Alex used to run before dawn — each shared landmark another tether between them.
Ethan arched beneath him when Alex's teeth found his nipple. "Next time," he rasped, "we do this on my couch."
Alex lifted his head, seawater dripping from his hair onto Ethan's chest. "Deal."
And wasn't that a thought — bodies tangled on familiar furniture, morning light through blinds they'd both cursed trying to fix. Ethan's fingers tightened on his hips like he was thinking it too.
"Tell me about your place," Alex murmured against his shoulder. The words tasted unexpectedly vulnerable.
Ethan's fingers stilled where they'd been combing through Alex's hair. "Two-bedroom ranch. Crack in the ceiling from when I tried installing a pull-up bar drunk." His chuckle vibrated beneath Alex's cheek. "The kitchen's all avocado green. I haven't gotten around to ripping it out since the divorce."
Alex exhaled through his nose, tracing the scar on Ethan's ribs. "Mine's a studio the size of a shoebox. Could piss in the sink from bed if I wanted." He felt more than heard Ethan's snort. "My ex-wife took the house and most of my pension. Left me with a futon and three plates."
Ethan's arm tightened around him. The silence stretched, filled only by the hiss of retreating waves. When he spoke again, his voice had gone rough. "She take the dog too?"
Alex's throat closed. He nodded against Ethan's skin.
"Fuck." Ethan rolled them abruptly, pinning Alex beneath him with sudden intensity. His breath came hot and unsteady. "We're stealing him back."
Alex blinked up at him, startled into laughter. "What?"
"That golden retriever in your wallet photo." Ethan's thumb brushed Alex's lower lip. "I'll distract her. You grab the dog."
The sheer ridiculousness of it — this mountain of a man plotting a canine heist — punched through the last of Alex's defenses. He dragged Ethan down into a kiss that tasted like salt and something dangerously close to hope. "His name's Buster," he admitted when they broke apart.
Ethan grinned, wild and bright. "Buster's coming home." He kissed him again, deeper this time, hands mapping Alex's shoulders like he was memorizing the territory. When he pulled back, his eyes were dark with promise. "Then we're burning her fucking hydrangeas."
Alex's laughter startled another seabird into flight. The sound carried over the water, lighter than either of them had been in years. Ethan's weight settled more firmly against him, his erection pressing insistently against Alex's thigh.
"Thought you were spent," Alex teased, arching into him.
Ethan nipped at his jaw. "Takes more than one round to put me down." His hand slid between them, calloused fingers wrapping around them both. Alex gasped at the contact, the heat of Ethan's palm almost too much after the first time.
Above them, the first stars pricked through the indigo sky. Somewhere beyond the reef, a fish broke the surface with a quiet splash. Ethan's thumb swiped over the head of Alex's cock, smearing precum down the length.
"Tell me about your couch," Alex murmured. "The one we're fucking on when we get home to Pinecrest."
Ethan's hips jerked. "Red plaid. Sags in the middle." Alex groaned as Ethan tightened his grip. "Your turn."
"Single mattress on the floor," Alex gasped. "Pillows still smell like— oh fuck— like Buster’s fur."
Ethan’s laugh was breathless. He kissed him, tongue pushing past Alex’s teeth as his strokes turned demanding. The scent of their earlier release still clung to their stomachs, salty and primal. Alex’s toes dug into the sand when Ethan twisted his wrist just so.
"Tell me," Ethan gritted out, "where you want me."
Alex shuddered. "The kitchen counter." His nails raked down Ethan’s back. "Against that ugly green tile."
Ethan’s groan vibrated against his throat. Their cocks slid together in his slick fist, the rhythm turning frantic. Sand gritted beneath Alex’s shoulders, the tide licking at their ankles as Ethan panted against his mouth —
Something cracked in the underbrush.
They froze.
Alex’s pulse hammered in his throat. Ethan’s grip went still but didn’t loosen. The jungle exhaled around them, leaves rustling. Then —
A coconut thudded onto the sand.
Ethan burst into laughter, collapsing against Alex’s chest. The tension shattered. Alex wheezed, clutching Ethan’s shoulders as their laughter tangled with the waves.
"Fucking nature," Ethan muttered, nosing along Alex’s collarbone.
Alex carded fingers through his sweat-damp hair. Their hips rolled together again, slower now, savoring the drag of skin on skin. The stars multiplied overhead, the Southern Cross shimmering through the palms.
Ethan’s mouth found his ear. "When we get back," he murmured, "first thing I’m doing is bending you over that moose at The Rusty Anchor."
Alex bucked beneath him with a punched-out moan. Ethan’s hand sped up, his other arm bracketing Alex’s head as their bodies locked together. The orgasm hit like a riptide — Ethan came with a bitten-off curse, hot stripes painting Alex’s abs as his own release spilled over Ethan’s knuckles.
Panting, they lay tangled in the wreckage. The tide reached their hips now, cool but not unwelcome.
Ethan lifted his sticky hand, examining it in the moonlight. "We’re disgusting."
Alex caught his wrist, licking a stripe across his palm. Ethan’s breath hitched.
"Speak for yourself," Alex said.
Ethan’s grin was wolfish. He kissed him slow, deep, tasting himself on Alex’s tongue. Somewhere in the jungle, a nightbird called. Neither listened. They slept.
If you enjoyed this story, consider supporting the author on Wattpad.
To get in touch with the author, send them an email.
