Casual Wanderer © 2025 All rights reserved. No parts of this publication may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including photocopying, recording, or electronic or mechanical methods, without the prior written permission of the publisher, except in brief quotations embodied in critical reviews and specific other non-commercial uses permitted by copyright law.
"Atonement (Part One)"
The courthouse had the Sunday smell, wax and old paper, but the room was all weekday spine.
Benches in two neat ranks, an aisle like a river running between two versions of the same town. On the right, suits black as a promise, haircuts you could set a watch by, Governor Whitlow himself, anointed in quiet with his signet ring flashing every time he adjusted a cuff.
On the left, Willow Creek proper.
Daisy's volunteers with hydrangea pins clipped to thrifted dresses, Mr. Peabody's guitar case set tenderly under the pew, Marla and Becky pressed shoulder to shoulder like choir ladies about to sing something that would sting and then soothe. The ceiling fans did what they could with air that knew secrets already.
Weston sat at the front, not at the State's table but close enough. Levi occupied the chair to his left, knee gently leaning against his, an anchor disguised as a habit. The new cane stood at Weston's right leg, hickory catching the light, brass collar winking. Under his thumb, along the inside curve, the shallow cut he knew by heart read what he needed: Still. Here. He traced it once as if to sign in.
Across the aisle, defense counsel shone like counter-arguments. Langford Price, hired out of Jackson by the Whitlow money, wore a thin, deadly suit that seemed oiled. He had a jaw made for saying "ladies and gentlemen" as if it were a dare. Boyd McKinnon, the Sheriff's lawyer, a local with a reputation for making bad men sound misunderstood, rolled a Montblanc between his fingers like the pen could talk for him when his mouth got tired.
At the far end, the bench rose in good wood and quiet authority. Judge Estelle Merriweather, with severe silver hair, a crisp robe, and a mouth both soft and merciless, adjusted her glasses, glanced over the two rivers of faces, and rapped the gavel once. The sound landed in the room like a stone in water and spread out in rings.
"We'll come to order," she'd said a minute ago, and everyone had, because there are still places in Mississippi where a woman on a bench can make a room remember itself.
Daisy Bell sat front row aisle-seat, a place she had earned. The ladle was not with her, court frowned on cookware, but her spine wore its authority just the same. To her right, Cassidy had a small notebook, a pen she clicked when she meant to behave and unclicked when she didn't, and a jaw that ignored the idea that fear should shut you up. Carla's hands were folded over a canvas bag that probably hid sandwiches and a packet of tissues. She looked like a woman prepared to mother half a county. The Willow House people had come in their best, which meant clean and pressed and serious, and a stubborn belief that sitting in daylight together changed things even when it didn't look like it yet.
The jury filed in, a dozen faces that looked like Willow Creek scrambled in a hat and laid out in a line: a teacher who had once taught half the room to read. A mechanic with grease permanently in the grooves of his knuckles. A farm wife with wrists strong from buckets and prayer. A boy just old enough to vote who was learning how to keep his face from telling you every thought he had. They wouldn't decide guilt in a few days, this was the long beginning, but they were the room's conscience, and everybody felt it.
The State stood. Assistant District Attorney Lila Dunbar, with a sleek bun, flats instead of heels in a nod to the work, a yellow legal pad with careful, patient handwriting, buttoned her jacket, and faced the box.
"Good mornin'," she began, voice warm and unsentimental. "On a summer night right here in Willow Creek, three men who should have known better took it upon themselves to put their hands and their boots on a citizen of this county. They did not act in fear. They did not act in haste. You will see that they acted together."
She paused long enough for the words to sink in. She didn't look at Weston when she said his name. She looked at the jury like grown people deserve to be looked at.
"You will hear from Mr. Weston Poole about what was said to him and what was done to him," she went on. "You will hear from the medical professionals who treated his injuries. You will hear from law enforcement officers who did their duty when others neglected theirs. And you will see a video that came into our possession anonymously, as sometimes happens when truth finds its courage another way. That video does not do all our work for us. It does, however, show you exactly what the defendants do not want you to see: the Sheriff of this county, Calvin Harlan, and Mr. Cade Whitlow, son of former Governor Ellis Whitlow, harassing, raping, and beating Mr. Poole while a third man recorded."
A ripple passed along the Whitlow side like wind over wheat. Ellis Whitlow's ring turned again.
"You will be asked to consider context," Dunbar said, letting the word breathe. "We ask you to consider conscience. The State will show motive, opportunity, identity, and intent, not because this is a story anyone takes pleasure in telling, but because daylight is owed."
She nodded once toward the table beside her, where another woman sat, a presence as precise as a plumb line. Amelia Raines had made partner in a Baton Rouge firm by thirty and legend by forty. Daisy had pried her out of a calendar crowded as a Christmas table and set her at Weston's elbow with a word, a casserole, and a call to an old boyfriend who owed her twice. Raines wasn't State. Mississippi didn't need her to prosecute. She was something rarer here: counsel for the victim, a voice to stand between a man's body and the machine that would now run in its name. She watched the jury with a stillness bred from years of making rooms decide to listen.
Dunbar finished clean. "We will not ask you to believe this because it is hard. We will ask you to believe it because it is true."
She sat. The murmur that followed wasn't disrespect so much as release. Judge Merriweather lifted her chin. "Mr. Price," she said. "Your opening."
Langford Price stood with a flare of navy and restraint and set his knuckles lightly on the defense table like a casual claim. He smiled the way you do when your watches cost more than most folks' trucks.
"Ladies and gentlemen," he said, voice silk over iron, "no one in this room disputes that an incident occurred near a river on a hot night in July. Hot nights in July do not produce saints."
A noise from the left bench, Marla's scoff, small and sharp, was swallowed by the fan.
"You will be told a story of monsters and martyrs," Price continued. "We ask you to recall that life rarely indulges such simple casting. Mr. Poole is a man with friends. He is also a man who, on the night in question, was, by his own admission, intoxicated, agitated, and involved in a confrontation whose beginnings are not captured on the video you will see."
"Objection to argument outside the evidence," Dunbar said, not loud.
"Sustained," Judge Merriweather replied without looking at Price. "Keep to your road."
Price dipped his head like he'd meant to step over the line just to see where it was. "As the Court pleases. The video in question, of uncertain chain of custody, edited at least once by an unknown party, will be paraded before you as if it were a gospel. We will ask the Court, at the appropriate time, to exclude it. We will ask you, if it is admitted, to look at it with adult eyes. To ask not only what it shows, but what it conveniently omits. You will hear from Mr. Harlan, a lawman with decades of service, about what he believed he was breaking up: a situation involving a man known to be provocative in his public advocacy."
He smiled again, thinner. "Passions run high these days. Grievances are litigated on the internet and in the street. Families are targeted for their names. We caution you against becoming instruments of that fashion."
On the left, Daisy's fingers whitened on the edge of the pew, then loosened. Raines laid two fingertips lightly on the table in front of Weston, a touch not for him so much as for the room, a dot on the i of patience.
Boyd McKinnon rose next, slower, his accent thicker, a man who'd built his career persuading juries that bad judgment was just good-old-boy mischief. "Sheriff Harlan will tell you he responded to a scene," he said, nodding at the men in the box as if they were kin on a porch. "He will tell you he tried to separate parties. You will hear words like 'harass' and 'assault'. We trust you to hold the State to its burden."
He sat in a creak of leather. The two tables looked suddenly, for a heartbeat, like they were braced for a storm in the same small boat.
Judge Merriweather's gaze swung to Raines. "Ms. Raines," she said.
Amelia Raines stood without fuss. She did not walk. She placed herself. "Your Honor," she said, voice low as a cello, "for the record, I appear on behalf of Mr. Poole to ensure his rights and dignity are protected during these proceedings, to coordinate with the State, and to be heard on matters that affect his participation as a victim under our statutes." She turned to the jury. "You will not hear me present evidence. But you will see me stand when the line between fair trial and fair target gets thin."
She sat, which somehow felt like a vow taken.
The Judge leaned a fraction forward. "Change of venue remains under advisement," she said, anticipating the next tug before it was thrown. "We will begin here, with this jury, unless and until it becomes impossible. The motion to exclude the video on grounds of authenticity will be heard outside the presence of the jury this afternoon. For now, we move forward."
A stir went through the right benches, quiet outrage dressed like decorum. On the left, a breath Daisy hadn't known she was holding left her like a gentle slap on the back.
Lila Dunbar stood again, a file in her hand. "The State calls..."
"Your Honor," Price interrupted, rising, "we renew our motion to sequester and to admonish the gallery against displays."
"Renewed and denied for the moment," Judge Merriweather said. "There will be no displays from anyone. That includes sighs the size of Buick engines." Her eyes found Marla and Becky and, to their credit, both women smiled and folded their hands. The Judge's mouth softened half a degree. "Call your witness, Ms. Dunbar."
"Levi Benton," Dunbar said.
Weston's hand slid along the curve of his cane and found Levi's, where it had been waiting. They squeezed once, businesslike and private. He felt Daisy's gaze from the front pew like a palm between his shoulder blades, holding him up without anyone noticing. Cassidy's pen clicked and unclicked and then stilled.
Levi walked to the stand with the gait of a man whose job was to coax frightened bodies to trust themselves again. He swore in with his voice even and his eyes steady. He sat. He glanced once at Weston, not lingering, and then looked at the jury as if they were patients who had come to him for the truth about their own insides.
On the defense side, Ellis Whitlow's ring turned. On the State's, Amelia Raines uncapped a pen as if that, too, were a form of readiness. The bailiff shifted his weight. Outside, a siren passed and went small.
"Mr. Benton," Dunbar began, "will you tell the jury where you were the night of July fourteenth, and what you saw when Mr. Poole was brought into the emergency department?"
It had begun, and the divided, braced, stubborn room leaned forward to listen.
*
(Two days later)
The ruling fell like a pane of glass set wrong and let go.
"Motion to exclude is granted," Judge Merriweather said, and the gavel kissed wood. The air left the room all at once, on the right in a pleased little hiss behind tailored sleeves, on the left in a low animal sound that was mostly somebody's breath catching. Ellis Whitlow's signet ring turned once, satisfied. Langford Price kept his face polite and let triumph live in the corners.
On the State's table, Lila Dunbar did not flinch. She drew a line on her yellow pad that meant adjust your case. Beside her, Amelia Raines capped her pen like a woman setting a pot to simmer, eyes on the jury as if to say: we are far from done.
"They'll rest," Price had told the Judge a moment earlier, smooth as a salesman. "Our clients will not be taking the stand." Boyd McKinnon nodded along, earning his retainer by not letting Calvin hang himself with his own mouth.
It all slid to a stop, then to recess.
The benches scraped.
The aisle split.
The two halves of the same town poured out the doors like hot and cold meeting in a storm.
Daisy staked out a patch by the water fountain like you would claim a patch of shade, first in, last out, and her people gathered without needing to be told.
Cassidy's hydrangea pin flashed stubborn on her thrifted dress as she clicked her pen too fast for sense. Marla and Becky flanked her like a pair of cast-iron bookends, whispering hurts they would deny if confronted. Carla stood with her canvas bag tucked under one arm, calm on purpose, eyes on Weston the way a nurse watches a pain scale.
Levi stayed at Weston's shoulder, close enough to intercept anything thrown and far enough to let him breathe. He passed Weston the paper cup after rinsing it twice as if he could wash the ruling off the water.
"They tossed it," Marla hissed. "Like a hair in the sink."
"They would," Becky said, pearls glinting like teeth. "Devil's tailor made that man a suit." She jerked her chin toward Price, who ghosted past with a nod that smelled like cologne and contempt.
Raines joined them, cool as a kitchen kept on low. "Without the video," she said softly, "we lean on testimony. Chain of custody can be cured with a mouth that will tell the truth." Her gaze was needles and thread. "Colton."
Cassidy blew air through her cheeks. "That boy? He'll fold like card table legs. He'll run before they say 'Raise your right hand,' or he'll get up there and lie pretty to save his skinny hide."
"Mm," Carla said in a tone that meant she remembered boys who lied out of fear and then told the truth because somebody stood steady beside them.
Across the hall, the Whitlow contingent did not bother to keep their voices down. "No video," someone said, savoring it. "No case." Price's shoulders never broke posture. McKinnon laughed without opening his lips.
Cassidy bristled. "He'll buckle," she said, meaning Colton and everyone like him. "Or he'll get up there and try on that old smirk and I swear to God..."
"Cassidy." Daisy's voice wasn't loud. It didn't have to be. It slid under the panic and lifted it, set it back on its feet. "Hush a minute."
They all did.
She straightened a stack of pamphlets no one wanted and looked each of them in the face like she was counting heads at a table. "Look," she said. "We knew we weren't gettin' through this like a parade. We knew they were gon' throw every dollar and college word at the parts that scare 'em. They got their win this morning. Fine. Now hear the rest."
She tapped the fountain button with one finger and watched water arc and fall, thin and faithful. "Video didn't make what happened true," she said. "It just made it easier for folks who don't like lookin' at hard things. Truth stands up in a room on its own legs, shaky, ugly, but it stands." She let that settle. "Sometimes it borrows a boy's mouth to do it."
Cassidy rolled her eyes, softening. "You're talkin' 'bout Colton."
"Yes," Daisy said. "I've known a hundred like him. Boys who learned mean so they could pass for safe. Boys who kept receipts 'cause they didn't know any other way to matter. Does that excuse a thing? No, ma'am, and don't you misquote me. But it tells me there is good in him yet. I seen it."
"They'll chew him up," Becky murmured, half horrified, half eager for the spectacle.
"They'll try," Raines said, voice like the back edge of a knife. "But you'd be surprised what a human being can do with a bench full of eyes on them and a decent question." She looked at Daisy, an accord passing between women who had taught rooms to behave. "And with someone in the second row who won't let them drown."
Cassidy's mouth twisted. "He'll lie," she said again, less certain this time. "He'll save himself."
Daisy tucked a stray curl behind Cassidy's ear the way she did when the girl was seven and determined to punch a boy for cutting ahead in the lunch line. "Maybe," she allowed. "Maybe he'll buckle and we'll have to find another way. But I'm gon' spend this next breath hopin' better. Because hope is a choice and I am old enough to know it's my job."
There was a beat of silence.
Then, Daisy added, softer, mostly to herself. "We gon' leave a door open for that boy to walk through under his own power. And if he walks, we gon' make room for the truth he carries, even if it cuts us comin' in."
Marla sniffed, half a laugh, half a tear. "You and that kitchen gospel."
"It's kept us fed," Daisy said, and her smile made a little space in the crowded hall. "It'll keep us standing."
Across the aisle, a bailiff called five minutes. The Whitlow ring turned. Lila Dunbar flipped to a fresh page. Amelia Raines adjusted her jacket as if it were armor she'd earned.
Cassidy sucked in a breath to argue one more time, then let it out as a sigh that surrendered only to Daisy. "Fine," she said. "We'll hope."
"We will," Daisy said.
They moved as a small body toward the doors, the heat visible beyond the glass, the town waiting to choose its next version of itself.
Then they stepped outside, and the hive cracked open.
Heat poured into the hallway and dragged everybody with it, suits, Sunday dresses, Whitlow boys with their mouths full of entitlement, Willow House volunteers with hydrangea pins whose stems shook when they breathed. Out on the steps, voices bit and swarmed. Somebody on Cade's side, friend with a neck like a stump and sunglasses too proud for the sun, started throwing words like rocks. The kind you don't print. The kind that bruise on the way in.
A knot of self-appointed saints swelled behind him, and signs and Scripture were held high as shields. "This town's gone to the devil!" one woman cried, hair sprayed into conviction. "A haven for deviants! For sin!"
Levi stepped off the top stair like a man walking into a cold river and drew back his fist at the stump-necked friend, ready to put punctuation where a period belonged.
"Levi," someone hollered.
The courthouse doors swung again. Daisy walked out into the noon with the look she saved for stoves that thought about scorching. She didn't have her ladle, but her voice had its weight. She put one palm flat to Levi's chest without drama, like setting a hot pan back on the eye, and slid her body between him and the man who deserved nothing.
"Hands behind you, baby," she said. Levi's jaw worked, then he obeyed, fingers lacing at the small of his back like prayer.
Daisy looked at the stump-necked man the way a carpenter looks at a crooked line. Then she turned and let the whole staircase have her.
"Now you listen," she said, and the words reached the street, the lawn, the men in sunglasses, the women with verses, and the boys on the edges who were learning what grown felt like. "I cook for half of y'all, and I have buried some of the rest, and there ain't a one of you don't know I say what I mean and I mean it soft until soft don't work."
A murmur rolled. The stump-necked friend smirked, readying another slur. Daisy cut him off without touching him.
"You call this the devil's town?" she said. "No, sir. This is a tired little place tryin' like all of us to become better than our worst day. You know what we worship? We worship a God who sat down at tables with drunks and lepers and women folk you wouldn't look in the eye, and He called them friends. If your Jesus fits in your fist, you done shrunk Him to the size of your anger."
Someone in the back, a church lady with a sign, shouted, "Scripture says..."
"Scripture says love your neighbor," Daisy shot back, quick as a switch. "Scripture says the greatest commandment, honey. Not 'til it's comfortable. Not 'til he thinks like you. Not 'til she passes your little tests. If you need a loophole, you came to the wrong gospel."
A boy near the Whitlow row snorted. "What about sin?" he called. "Y'all celebratin' it now? Turnin' boys...like that Jackson of yours...into a..."
He didn't finish.
He didn't have to.
The ugliness of it rippled anyway.
Daisy didn't blink. "My boy is exactly who God made him," she said, voice steady. "Jackson Bell came into this world golden-headed and tender-hearted with a laugh that could bless a pot roast, and if you think my ways 'turned' him, bless your heart...you give me too much power and the Lord too little. I didn't make him. God did. And I'll tell you what I taught him, since you brought him into our conversation without invitin' him: I taught him to feed, not scorch. I taught him to tell the truth and hold a hand in a hospital when the room's divided. If that offends your religion, maybe what you practice ain't faith. Maybe it's fear in a choir robe."
The stump-necked man took a half step like he might puff himself bigger. Daisy didn't cede him an inch.
"You want to talk about sin?" she said. "Let's look square at it. Sin is layin' your hate on top of somebody else and callin' it holy. Sin is puttin' on righteousness like a costume while men you elected bruise boys in the dark. Sin is usin' Scripture like a hammer to nail shut the very doors the Lord told us to open. If your heart's a locked box, that ain't piety...that's a padlock on grace."
The evangelicals' chant stuttered and lost its rhythm. Folks on the stairs shifted, like a human animal checking its footing when the ground changed.
Daisy pressed her palm out, not to hush them so much as to invite them to be better than what they'd brought. "You talk about Willow Creek like it's fallen," she said, softer now, and the softness was the part that found throats. "This town holds funerals and potlucks and new babies and bad days. We pass casseroles down the pew same as we pass judgment if we ain't careful. We are learning. You hear me? Learning. It is slow work. It is tired work. It is God's work. And we will do it without your slurs. We will do it without your spit. You got a prayer? Say it. You got a verse? Live it. But don't you stand on these steps and blaspheme the name of love because you are scared of boys who won't fit your picture frames."
A man in a sports coat sneered, last try. "You think you're a preacher, Miss Bell? You think your kitchen gospel counts in court?"
Daisy's smile didn't reach her eyes. "Baby, my kitchen gospel kept half of y'all alive when your mamas were too tired to try. My ladle has done more pastoring than your Facebook page ever will. And I promise you this: we will feed you, even now. We will feed you when you come to your senses and lay your rocks down. But we will not join you in throwin' them."
Silence fell like a summer storm does: hard, thorough, and clearing. The stump-necked friend's mouth worked and found he had misplaced his bravery. The sign woman lowered her placard a few inches and stared at her own hands like they might tell her something truer than her talking points. Even the Whitlow row went still, calculating, heat-cool air moving over their collars.
Somewhere behind them, the courthouse door banged open again and feet scrambled the marble. Cassidy barreled out, hair a halo of motion, eyes sparking like she'd swallowed a headline.
"Daisy!" she said, breathless, loud enough to carry to both banks of the divided river. "He did it. Colton...he's decided to testify."
The word landed like gospel sung on the correct pitch.
The mob's heat bled off a degree, then two. Somewhere close, the willow's hush reached the steps, and, for a blink, Willow Creek listened.
*
(The next day)
The oath left Colton's mouth dry.
He said "I do" like a boy trying on a man's suit, swallowed, and sat. From the gallery, the room came into focus in bands, the Whitlow side, polished and predatory. Willow Creek, tight-jawed and breathing together. Weston at the State's table kept his eyes on his hands, thumb resting along the shallow cut on the hickory cane that read Still. Here. Daisy sat second row aisle, purse on her lap like a gavel no one could take.
On direct, the questions were gentle scaffolding.
Assistant DA Dunbar walked him through the small, unarguable things: his name, his relation to the parties, his phone number as it appeared in the records, the fact that he had possessed a video "of an altercation" and that it had left his possession. He nodded, said "Yes, ma'am," found words like "I was there" and "I filmed," and his voice didn't crack until he said Weston's name. Amelia Raines did not speak. She watched the jury.
Then Langford Price stood, and the temperature in the room changed.
"Good afternoon, Mr. Bishop," Price began, syrup over a razor. "You've had an eventful week."
Colton forced his hands together so the tremor didn't show. "Yes, sir."
"You understand you're under oath."
"Yes, sir."
"Wonderful." Price paced a slow, educated step closer. "Let's talk about that video. You recorded it on your phone?"
"Yes, sir."
"And then you…misplaced it? Surrendered it? Which story are we getting today?"
"I...someone took it. Then it got sent."
"Someone. A mysterious Samaritan." Price smiled at the jury. "And you expect us to trust a recording the Court has already found too unreliable even to be shown?" He let the rhetorical hang a beat, then sharpened. "You hate Mr. Poole, don't you."
"No, sir," Colton said, too fast.
"Let's be honest with one another." Price lifted a page. "You sent Mr. Poole dozens of messages in the weeks before the so-called 'incident,' yes? Friendly at times. Then angry when he didn't respond. You threatened to 'make him talk'...your words. Read them?"
Dunbar rose. "Objection..."
"Overruled," Judge Merriweather said. "He may answer."
Colton stared at the printout, the ugliness of his own typing too neat in black and white. "I wrote that," he whispered. "I was mad. I..."
"Because he wouldn't give you what you wanted." Price's voice sweetened by half. "Attention. Admission. Love?"
Colton stared at his lap. "I...wanted him to see me," he said, small.
Price pounced. "You invited him to meet you at the lake that night, didn't you?"
Colton blinked. "What?"
"We have call records. Texts. You initiated the conversation." Price lifted a brow. "You lured him."
"No, sir, I..."
"Mr. Bishop, did the State promise you anything for your testimony? A reduction? A recommendation? Did the victim's friends' coach' you? The ladies from Willow House?" He let his eyes flick, surgically, to Daisy.
Colton's gaze followed and stuck. Daisy met him full on, neither pleading nor scolding, just present. Baby, tell it and don't shake, her eyes said without moving.
Price drove on. "You're a self-confessed liar. You admit to filming men who were 'helping', Sheriff Harlan, a lawman, break up a scuffle. You admit to spreading that film. And now, to save your skin, you come here ready to say anything..."
"Objection, argumentative," Dunbar said.
"Sustained," Judge Merriweather warned. "Mr. Price."
He recalibrated, his smile thinner. "One more question. You describe yourself," he tapped his folder. "In your own words, 'always a nobody to everybody.' Isn't this your moment to be somebody, Mr. Bishop? To trade on the suffering of others for your minute on the courthouse stage?"
A rustle crawled along the benches. Colton's mouth opened and shut. He felt the old reflex surge, the mean grin, the shrug, the retreat back into snickering safety. He saw Weston's profile, still as a photo. He saw Levi's knuckles white on his own knee, holding still by will alone. He saw Ellis Whitlow's ring turning like a lazy planet.
And then, he saw Daisy.
She didn't nod.
She didn't blink.
She just held him in her sights like a door she wanted him to walk through.
And that's when something flipped. Colton sat up a fraction. And when he finally spoke again, his voice had edges, but they were his, not Price's. "No, sir," Colton said. "I ain't here for a minute. I'm here 'cause I been wrong, and I can't carry it no more."
Price's mouth tightened. "Nothing further at this time."
"Redirect?" Judge Merriweather asked.
Dunbar rose, then paused. She looked at Colton and sat back down, as if she'd decided the room didn't need a lawyer just then.
Colton inhaled, shaky. He looked at the jury, teacher, grease-knuckled mechanic, farm wife, boy trying not to show his thoughts. He swallowed once. Then he turned his face to the microphone and told the truth.
"It was at Miss Daisy's barbecue," he said, voice thin but steadying. "Town was eatin' and dancin' and pretendin' we ain't all watchin' ever'body. Cade Whitlow..." He flinched saying the name and kept going. "He come up to me all friendly, 'like we boys,' he said. Said Weston was a no-good faggot. Said I could help bring him down a peg. He told me to text Weston and tell him I wanted to talk private, just by the lake for ten minutes. Said Weston would come for me 'cause he's soft-hearted."
He stared at his hands and made them still. "And...I did. I wrote Weston to meet me. He said okay. We went out. It was dark 'nough the water looked like oil. Calvin Harlan was already there." The word tasted bad. "He was leanin' on his cruiser."
"Mr. Bishop," Judge Merriweather said, softer, as if she'd felt the tremor move through the room, "you are telling this court that the Sheriff of this county was present at the lake before Mr. Poole arrived."
"Yes, ma'am," Colton said, and now the tears came, hot and humbling. "He knew. He told me, 'You're doin' the Lord's work, son,' and I heard that lie and believed it 'cause I wanted to be on the side that don't get hit."
A sharp intake on the Whitlow benches. Someone muttered something that could have been a prayer or a curse. Price half-rose, checked himself. McKinnon coughed into his fist and looked at the ceiling fan like it might write him a new script.
"When Weston came up," Colton continued, "he smiled at me first. 'You okay?' he asked. That's what he said. He asked me. Before anyone else did. And I..." His face twisted, and he let the ugliness of it show. "I raised my phone. I raised it 'cause Cade told me, 'Get it, get it all'. I told myself I was makin' proof in case it got bad. I told myself I could stop it if I had it. Truth is, I wanted to hold somethin' of his. Even the worst thing. So I could make him look at me later. I'd been a nobody to ever'body my whole life, and I thought bein' near mean might make me matter."
The farm wife had her fingers pressed to her mouth now, eyes bright with a complicated mercy. The boy on the end of the jury blinked hard. On the left bench, Cassidy's pen had gone still. Carla's hands had found each other and stayed linked. Levi's jaw worked, but his fists stayed open on his thighs.
Weston did not move.
He listened.
"They started with words," Colton said, voice hoarse. "Cade said nasty. Calvin, too. They circled him. Weston tried to step around. I laughed..." He winced like the memory shocked him. "I laughed, 'cause I didn't know what else to do and I wanted them to keep likin' me. Then Cade shoved him. Sheriff tripped him. I filmed 'cause I was scared if I didn't, they'd turn on me and drown me in that black water. I told myself I'd stop 'em when it got bad. I didn't. I kept that camera up like a coward and a thief. I heard them say 'blessings' while they hit him. While they...raped him." Colton muttered, head dropping slightly in shame. The room gasped. "I heard myself laughin'...that's the part I can't out-run. And when it was over, I went home with hell in my pocket. I typed 'I'm sorry' to Weston a hundred times and didn't send it."
He swallowed.
The words had taken their own weight.
He let them.
"Then, the Whitlow boys called me rat. The Sheriff's friends told me they'd drown me if I opened my mouth. So...I hid. I went to Willow House, 'cause I didn't know where else to go." He glanced at Daisy, then away, then back and kept his eyes there. "Miss Daisy found me. She didn't let me off. She told me love ain't a hall pass and consequence don't mean you ain't loved. She said tell it plain."
Price rose again, sputtering. "Your Honor..."
"Sit down, Mr. Price," Judge Merriweather said. The gavel tapped once, not hard.
Colton took a shaking breath. "I'm gay," he said, and it didn't echo. It landed. "I wanted Weston to want me. I wanted to hurt him for bein' what I couldn't be brave enough to be. I wanted to be on the side that don't get hit. I was wrong. I was wrong about all of it. I set the meetin'. I filmed. I laughed. I did not stop it. That's my part. I...ain't a hero. I ain't even a good witness most days. But I ain't gon' be a liar today."
Silence took the room and held it. On the Whitlow benches, Ellis's ring stopped turning. A cousin's jaw clenched. A friend's smirk dissolved like sugar in coffee. Price's pen hovered and found no note to write. McKinnon stared at his Montblanc like it might unsay what had been said.
On the left, a sound like a pew creaking was just Daisy letting out the breath her people had been holding for her. Cassidy's chin trembled and then set. She wiped one eye like she was brushing hair from her cheek and glared at anyone who noticed. Carla bowed her head just long enough to say thank you without making a scene. Levi shut his eyes and opened them again, steadier.
Weston didn't cry.
He pressed his thumb into the shallow cut of Still. Here. and nodded once, so small it could have been a tremor. Amelia Raines wrote a single word on her pad, admitted, then underlined it slowly, as if scoring a hymn.
Judge Merriweather leaned forward. "Mr. Bishop," she said, voice even, "you understand what you have placed on this record."
"Yes, ma'am," Colton said, and now he was crying without hiding it. "I know I got to pay for what I did. I know they do, too."
"Ladies and gentlemen," the Judge said to the jury, "you will disregard counsel's commentary about heroism and stagecraft. You will remember only what has been properly placed before you." She looked back at Colton. "You may step down."
He stood on wobbly legs. As he turned, his eyes found Daisy once more. She didn't smile. She didn't nod. She just set her jaw around grace and consequence and let him see that she would be there when the door he had just opened swung heavy. He managed the smallest grateful tilt of his head and took his seat behind the State with hands empty and, for the first time, clean.
The room exhaled.
And in the ledger none of them could see, names had shifted columns: Calvin Harlan, Cade Whitlow, and a third, unnamed no longer, sliding from impunity toward sentence, Colton Wayne Bishop from shadow toward the hard light he had finally chosen.
*
(Two days later)
The room had been holding its breath, waiting.
The bailiff's voice found the rafters. "All rise."
Judge Merriweather took the bench, her robe carrying the hush with it. Weston rose with the room. Levi rose with him, knee against his under the table, the way you tie two boats together. The new cane waited at Weston's right hand like a word you don't need to say to believe.
The jury filed in with faces that had learned not to give anything away. The foreperson, a woman whose hands smelled faintly of bleach and choir folders, held a paper thick as a verdict. She would not look at anyone in particular. She looked instead at the place on the wall where the county seal hung, as if truth lived there when it needed to.
"Madam Foreperson," Judge Merriweather said, even and merciless. "Has the jury reached a verdict?"
"We have, Your Honor."
"On the charge of aggravated assault and sexual assault against Weston Poole, how do you find the defendant, Calvin Harlan?"
"Guilty."
The word landed in the wood and went down into the pilings. A sound rolled through the benches, not a cheer yet, not allowed, but something that wanted to be. On the Whitlow side, Ellis's signet ring stopped its lazy orbit. Calvin's jaw did not move. His eyes went flat, as if he'd just remembered what a night with no stars looks like.
"And on the charge of violation of civil rights under color of law?" the Judge asked.
"Guilty."
"On the charge of aggravated assault and sexual assault against Weston Poole, how do you find the defendant Cade Whitlow?"
"Guilty."
A bullpen of suits shifted their weight. Cade's mouth twisted into the shape it wore when someone told him no at a country club and he'd mistaken it for flirting. You could see the first honest surprise of his adult life touch his face and find it didn't fit.
"And on the charge of conspiracy?" the Judge asked.
"Guilty," said the foreperson, and it was like a pin set clean in a hinge.
Colton stared at his folded hands, lips moving around a prayer he didn't know how to finish. Daisy was a line of calm at the end of the aisle, pocketbook resting on her lap like a small, polite anchor. Cassidy's pen didn't click. Carla had both hands around a tissue she hadn't used yet. Marla's mouth flew to her pearls. Becky held her elbow so the old habits wouldn't turn into a commentary.
"Very well," Judge Merriweather said. "We will proceed to sentencing."
All the air tightened. This is where fiction usually cuts; life does not. The Judge's voice took on that cadence reserved for the math of consequence.
"Calvin Harlan," she said, looking at the man who had made uniform a mask for harm. "For aggravated assault and sexual assault, twenty years. For violation of civil rights under color of law, twelve. To run consecutively. Thirty-two years. You abused your oath. You will not have occasion to again for some time."
Calvin did not blink. Somewhere, a woman in the third row let a breath escape that had been waiting in her ribs since July.
"Cade Whitlow," Judge Merriweather continued, "for aggravated assault and sexual assault, fifteen years. For conspiracy, eight. Twenty-three years. Privilege is not a sacrament. Consider this a proper education."
Cade's mouth tightened. Ellis's ring turned once. His jaw made a little quiver and then remembered itself.
"Colton Bishop," the Judge said, and the room's current changed temperature by a few degrees. "You stand before this court not as an accessory of convenience, but as a man who invited harm and then preserved it when you should have stopped it. You also stand here as a witness who told the truth when it was time and in doing so exposed the rot that would have smothered it. Mercy is not forgetfulness. Justice is not appetite."
She looked down at him, not through him. "For conspiracy, six years in the custody of the Department of Corrections, with credit for time served and recommendation for placement in a facility with counseling services. You will make restitution. You will comply with all programming ordered. You will carry this, Mr. Bishop, and you will come out better or you will waste the gift you have been handed."
The clink of cuffs on a chain has a way of making a room forget its opinions. It's a small sound that fills a head. Colton's breath hitched. He nodded to show he'd heard, and then he shook his head because being twenty-two and being brave don't always happen on the same day.
When the bailiff touched his elbow, something in him broke the way a fever does.
"Miss Daisy!" he called, voice high, not caring who saw. "Miss Daisy..."
Daisy was up before anybody could tell her not to be. The bailiff saw her coming and didn't put his arm out all the way because some laws are written in the bone. Daisy got to Colton at the aisle. She didn't make a scene of it. She gathered him into her like he was nobody's business and everybody's boy. The cuffs knocked her wrist and she did not care.
"Did I..." Colton gulped air, tears cutting tracks he couldn't hide. "Did I do good?"
"You did good," Daisy said into his hair, voice a steady creek. "It's gon' be alright. You hear me? It's gon' be alright."
"I'm scared," he confessed, the confession tearing on the way out.
"I know," she answered. "I'll be there the day those gates open. I'll be the first face you see. You walk to me, you hear? Not to shame. To me."
He nodded into her shoulder like a child, like a penitent, like a person. The bailiff touched her elbow gentler now. "Ma'am..."
"One more breath," she said without looking. He gave it to her.
"Ma!" Colton shouted as they turned him, and for a second he was only that, a boy calling home. A woman had slipped into the back, cheap dress, a storm of guilt and hope around her like a weather system. She put a trembling hand to her mouth, his mama, the one who'd run out of excuses, and she cried without pretty, hand forward as if to bless him from a distance she had made. "I'm sorry!" he shouted, voice gone raw. "I'm sorry, Mama! I'm sorry!"
She nodded like a drowning woman deciding toward the surface. Daisy lifted a hand to the woman and tipped her chin once, Come see me, we can start there, without speaking. The deputies moved. The cuffs flashed once in the fluorescent and vanished through the side door.
Behind Weston, the held-in noise finally found a mouth.
It came first like a wind through leaves, shivering and murmuring, and then like summer rain across tin when the Judge's gavel blessed it by not pounding too soon. A cheer rose, stitched with sobs, laughter, and a few honest shouts that didn't ask permission.
"Justice!"
"Thank you, Jesus!"
Someone started clapping, realized where they were, and stopped. Someone else didn't.
Weston did not move. He stood in that choir of sound and kept his thumb on the inside of the cane and stared at the grain like it contained scripture. His chest rose and fell. The back of his throat held salt at bay the way a man does when he's got a whole life to live and not enough napkins in his pocket to mark this minute properly.
Levi's hand found the small of his back and stayed there, nothing showy.
Amelia Raines let herself close her eyes for the space of one breath, then opened them and resumed being the woman you wanted on the right side of your case.
Cassidy finally let her pen fall and whooped once, then covered her mouth and cried into the hand that'd been pointing at the future all week. Carla put her forehead to her fingers and whispered something that was not a bargain but a thank you. Marla and Becky cried ugly and didn't apologize, then straightened their collars like decency could be returned to its shelf afterwards.
On the other side of the room, suits gathered their disappointment, folded it small, and tucked it away between billable hours. Ellis Whitlow's ring spun and spun and did not find purchase on anything it could change as he watched his only son get dragged away.
Judge Merriweather rapped the gavel once, twice, the sound of authority calling the room back to itself. "This court thanks the jury for its service. Sentences as stated. We are adjourned."
Benches scraped.
Bodies moved.
A town got up different than it had sat down, which is all anyone can ask of a day.
Daisy stood where she was as the aisle made itself around her, her face fixed toward the door where a boy had disappeared, and a promise had gone with him. In the middle of the noise, Weston finally turned and found her.
She didn't smile.
She didn't cry.
She lifted her chin the tiniest bit, and he knew she was saying.
*
(A few weeks later)
They brought Weston through the buzz and clatter to a row of booths that smelled like tired air. Plexiglass rose between the plastic chairs, cloudy with fingerprints and years of breath. Weston set his cane against the lip of the booth. The brass collar knocked, a small, sure sound. He touched the inside curve with his thumb and sat.
Colton came in a minute later, cuffs neat as punctuation, orange too bright for his skin. He looked narrower than the courtroom, like the space itself pressed a man thinner. When he saw Weston, something in his ribs tried to run and something else held.
They didn't reach for the phones right off. They were close enough to read each other's faces without talking through static.
Weston lifted the receiver first, lifted his chin toward the other one. Colton picked up like it might bite.
"Hey," Weston said. The word was plain. "Thank you for tellin' it."
Colton's mouth twitched, a laugh that hadn't learned how. "I kinda set it on fire, then showed y'all the match," he answered, voice rough in the handset. "Ain't sure 'thank you' fits."
"Two things can be true," Weston said. "You hurt me. And you helped me. I came to tell you both, so we can leave this room right."
Colton swallowed.
His eyes were wet and stubborn. "I..." He shook his head as if to dislodge his own throat. "I'm sorry. Sounds like I'm tryin' to bargain, but I ain't. I'm...Weston, I'm sorry." He darted his gaze down, then up again, making himself take the weight. "Will you...can you..." The word came out small as a seed.
Weston looked at him for a moment. He didn't make poetry out of it.
"I don't know that my forgiveness is the fix you want," he said. "But I ain't carryin' hate for you. I can say that clean." He eased his thumb along the cane's carving and let the quiet mean something. "I forgive you enough to pray you'll forgive yourself. That part's yours."
Colton flinched, as if mercy hurt on contact. "I don't know how," he whispered. "All I hear is me laughin' on that video. I hear it in my sleep."
"It fades," Weston said. "Not all at once. Not clean. Pain is loud as a brass band at first. Then...it turns into lessons you can stand. I wish it didn't have to come that way, but sometimes it's the only teacher folks listen to." He tipped his head toward the glass, toward the world that wasn't this room. "What happened...changed me. Changed this whole place. Made men stand up who'd been sittin' quiet. Made me let folks hold me without thinkin' that made me smaller. Made me know exactly where I'm still tender and what I'll do with that tenderness now."
Colton blinked like he was memorizing a map. "What're you gon' do with it?"
"Make rooms where other boys don't have to learn the hard way," Weston said. "Hold Levi's hand in the grocery store like it's just a hand. Let Miss Daisy boss me into livin' long enough to be old and loud. Help Cash hang a door or two that catches true." A smile eased his mouth. "Take this cane places and tap it twice' fore I walk in so people know I'm still here."
Colton's breath hiccupped into a laugh, brief and honest. He scrubbed at his eye with the back of his cuffed wrist. "You happy?" he blurted, almost childlike, as if the answer were a rope he could grab.
Weston didn't have to think long. He turned half in his chair, the cane's ferrule nudging the floor like a yes. "I am," he said. "Not every minute. But in the way that counts. It didn't come the way I wanted, and it took more than it had any right to, but it brought things I didn't know I was allowed to ask for."
Colton nodded too fast, like agreement could be a loaner. The fear came back then, honest and raw. "Six years is a long time," he said. "I don't know what I'm gon' be on the other side."
"You get to pick," Weston said. "Start now. Read somethin'. Write somethin'. Work if they let you. Listen to the good voices when they show up. Let the bad ones pass like weather."
"Folks ain't gon' want me," Colton said. It wasn't a complaint. It sounded like a measurement he trusted too much.
"Some won't," Weston allowed. "But you're part of Willow Creek whether it's convenient or not. That town's got a long memory for harm and a longer one for mending. Miss Daisy'll be the first face you see when the gate opens, you heard her." He leaned in, let the smallest grin show. "And if you behave yourself, I'll let you sign my cane when you get out. Back side under the brass, where only folks who need to know can find it. No heart dot over your i. I got limits."
Colton's laugh came out cracked and new. "Yes, sir," he said without thinking, a joke turned reverent by accident. He straightened. "I'll…I'll try. I don't want to be the person I was."
"You won't be," Weston said. "You ain't, already."
A guard tapped the glass once with a knuckle. Time's up. Weston stood, the chair legs scraping the floor with a sound that made everyone in the row twitch. He picked up the cane. For a second he placed his palm flat on the glass over Colton's, a reflection of touch the room allowed.
Weston turned, took three steps, turned back at the door because the boy had given him a question he'd tried to carry alone. "Hey," he added, voice lighter than the room. "When they hand you a mop, don't make it a martyrdom. Make the floor shine. That's how this starts."
Colton's mouth made a shape it hadn't remembered: a smile that didn't ask permission or forgiveness, just existed for itself. It was small and looked good on him, like a thing that could be taught to stay.
The door buzzed.
Weston went through, the cane's tip ticking the rhythm he'd chosen. The guard touched Colton's shoulder and steered him toward the corridor. Alone for a breath, with no one to see, Colton let the smile spread just enough to feel strange and right.
On the glass, five fingers' worth of prints blurred with light until they didn't look like smudges anymore.
Just proof that two people had been there, talking plain through a hard thing, and that maybe, just maybe, the door had started to swing the other way.
(To be continued...)
To get in touch with the author, send them an email.
