Contradictions

The Party

“My sophomore year,” began Rick, “I was third-string quarterback. We had a really good season that year, so Debbie Henderson invited all the players, cheerleaders, and their dates over to her house to celebrate. Debbie was the head cheerleader, and the word around town was that her mother had given some head to get Debbie the position. Debbie was easily the hottest girl on campus, and every guy in school wanted to get into her panties, but the only one who was getting any from her was Johnny Madison, the first-string quarterback. Like Debbie, Johnny was a senior, but he got to be first string strictly on merit. He was not only all-conference, but all-state, and that’s why we had a good season.

“Debbie’s parents were really cool and pretty much let us do whatever we wanted as long as we didn’t cause the neighbors to call the cops. Some of the guys took their dates into Debbie’s bedroom or the laundry room for ‘private’ parties. Carlos Fuentes and Lisa Chang fucked in the swimming pool, and they didn’t care who watched. Not to be outdone, Andy Simpson and Eddie Hoffman started banging their dates on the living room floor. All the guys took bets on who would cum first.

On Monday, in the locker room, Vinnie DiFazzio said that he went looking for a bathroom, and Mr. and Mrs. Henderson invited him to use the one in their bedroom suite. When he came out, Mrs. Henderson was spread naked on the bed, and he ended up banging her while Mr. Henderson watched. Vinnie had a reputation for stretching the truth, so none of the guys believed him until Mark Baldwin said that something similar had happened to his older brother Bryce when he had gone over to the Henderson’s one day to deliver a package. Vinnie laughed, ‘But everybody knows that Bryce is gay!’ (It was no secret; Bryce Baldwin had been out of the closet for at least two years.) Mark shot back, ‘I said something similar had happened to him. I never said it was MRS. Henderson that he fucked!’ That drew a round of ooohs and aaahs from all the guys.

“Anyway, I had asked Linda Gillespie to the party, but she called me that afternoon to say that something had come up, and she couldn’t make it. I called Debbie to say that I wouldn’t be going to the party since I didn’t have a date, but she insisted that I come anyway. She said that she would hook me up with another one of the cheerleaders, Trisha Carpenter, so I agreed. Unfortunately, when I got to the party, Debbie told me that Trisha had cancelled too, but she insisted that I stay anyway. Of course, I felt like a fifth wheel, but I decided to stick it out. By the way, the next spring, Linda took Trisha to the prom, so I guess that explains why they both missed the party.

“Shortly before midnight, Johnny Madison, the quarterback and Debbie’s date, passed out on the floor from too much beer and vodka, and a couple of the guys had to take him home. The party pretty much started to break up at that point. I started to follow the parade out the door, but Debbie stopped me.

’Don’t go,’ she said. ‘We were just about to play Truth or Dare, and we need one more person.’

“’We,’ it turns out, were Joe Collier and Pete Gautier and their dates, Toni Spencer and Lynn Walker, all seniors. I was still feeling out of place, but Debbie said, ‘You can be my partner.’ Now, how could I resist that?

“We played several rounds with all kinds of silly dares. Then, on Debbie’s last turn, she said, ‘I dare Rick to suck off Joe and Pete.’”

“No shit!” exclaimed Jay, shifting the way he sat on the bed. “She actually said that?”

“Yeah, but we figured she had to be kidding, right? So, we just laughed, but when we saw that she was serious, the three of us started objecting.

‘Ain’t no fuckin’ way I’m gonna let a guy suck my dick,’ said Joe.

‘Me neither,’ said Pete.

‘Aw, c’mon Joe,’ said Toni. ‘Just look at those thick, sexy lips. If I had a dick like yours,’ she said, rubbing Joe’s crotch, ‘I’d let him blow me.’ Joe started to object, but Toni quickly stuck her tongue in his mouth and kept rubbing his crotch until his dick started to twitch.

‘Well, he ain’t sexy to me,’ said Pete, ‘and he ain’t gettin’ anywhere near my dick.’

‘Oh, sweetie, you love it when I suck you off, don’t you?’

‘Of course, but that ain’t the same thing.’

“Lynn stuck one hand up Pete’s shirt and rubbed his chest, nibbling on his ear and licking his face.

‘Oh, all right,’ he finally agreed, ‘but this better not leave this room!’

‘Well, I guess if Pete’s willing to do it, I can too,’ said Joe.

‘Well, I don’t give a shit whether you’re willing or not!’ I shouted. ‘It’s my fuckin’ mouth, and ain’t nobody pokin’ his fuckin’ dick in it!’

‘Oh, please, Rick,’ said Debbie. She started rubbing my crotch like Toni had done with Joe and kissing me like I had never been kissed before. This was Debbie Henderson, head cheerleader and the hottest girl in school, making the moves on me! I couldn’t believe what was happening. When she finally pulled her tongue out of my mouth and looked at me with those dreamy brown eyes, I started to repeat that I would not suck anybody’s cock, but she quickly placed one finger across my lips to silence me.

‘Please, Rick. I really want to see this, and if you’ll do this for me, I promise you I’ll make it worth your while.’ With that, she took my hands and rubbed one against her crotch and stuffed the other inside her blouse. She wasn’t wearing a bra! Oh, my God. At that point, she could have asked me to jump off the Golden Gate Bridge, and I would have done it.”

Jay rubbed his crotch with one hand and his chest with the other.

“‘Like Pete said, nobody can ever know about this but us. This does NOT leave this room!’ I looked around the circle, and everybody nodded in agreement.

“I knelt down in front of Pete and took a deep breath. Pete still seemed hesitant, so Lynn unbuttoned his jeans, reached inside his boxer briefs and pulled out his cock. I took it between my fingers, handling it like it was a squishy worm or somethin’, squeezed my eyes shut, opened my mouth, and placed it against my tongue. The feel of it on my tongue shocked me so much that I immediately withdrew, but Debbie came up behind me and placed one hand on the back of my head and slowly guided Pete’s dick back into my mouth. I gave it several more licks before I finally took the whole thing in my mouth and started sucking. Pete wasn’t getting hard, so Lynn kept deep-kissing him and whispering nasty things in his ear until he finally stiffened. Meanwhile, Joe had no such problem. He shot up the second I put Pete’s dick on my tongue.

“The whole time that I was sucking Pete’s dick, two thoughts kept running through my mind: one, God, I wish he would hurry up and cum so we can get this whole thing over with, and two, Debbie had better damn well make this worth it. Finally, Pete began to moan and pant, and I could feel his dick pulsate, so I knew he was close to cumming. I pulled back and started pumping his shaft with my hand.

‘Hey, dude, what the hell are you doing? Don’t stop now!’

‘You ain’t cummin’ in my mouth, dude!’

‘That was the deal, Rick. You’re supposed to suck us off, and that means the whole shebang. And besides, it’s just gettin’ good.’

“When Debbie saw that I wasn’t ready to give in, she knelt down beside me and gave me another deep, wet kiss. Then she said, ‘Here, Rick, let’s do it together.’ And she leaned over and took Pete’s cock in her mouth and started sucking. Seeing her suck his cock like that right in front of my face blew me away. 

"After a few seconds, she again deep kissed me and alternated kissing and sucking several times until she finally placed her hand behind my head again and moved it toward Pete’s cock. We licked on it from opposite sides and kissed with Pete’s cock between our lips. After a couple of minutes of this, Debbie placed Pete’s cock back in my mouth while she crawled underneath and licked his balls. I dunno, but I’m pretty sure that Pete had never had his cock sucked and his balls licked at the same time.”

Jay licked his lips.

“‘Oh, God!’ screamed Pete. ‘Goddam. Oh, shit. Fuck. Fuck. Fuck. Ah, aahh, aaahhh, AAAHHH! He exploded in my mouth, and I gagged. I wanted to spit it out, but Debbie quickly grabbed me and wrapped her lips around mine. She swirled the cum around in my mouth with her tongue and scooped some of it into hers. When cum started to drool out of my mouth, she licked it up and scooped it back in. She kept up this routine until I had no choice but to swallow. Of course, she swallowed some of it too, but I got most of it. I wasn’t crazy about having cum in my mouth, but Debbie made it incredibly sensual. It was unlike anything I had ever experienced before.”

Jay gulped.

“With one down, I didn’t have to move over to Joe. He was already standing in front of me with his cock stiff as a board. Having sucked one cock, I had no trouble with another, especially when I thought about Debbie joining me in the finale.

“Joe was ready to cum in half the time that it took Pete, and sure enough, just before he did, Debbie knelt down, and we kissed with Joe’s dick between us. I couldn’t believe how much cream he unloaded. I’m sure it was twice as much as I had ever shot, but then again, he was two years older than I was.

“I tried to hold it in my mouth, but it started running all over the place, and that’s when I got another surprise. Toni knelt down on the other side of me and started kissing me and licking my face along with Debbie. Sometimes they kissed each other, passing Joe’s juice between them. As much as I had objected to sucking another guy’s cock, I had to admit that this was the hottest damn thing I had ever seen.

“In no time at all, Joe was down on the floor too, sucking his own jizz from Toni’s mouth. It was a round-robin with four of us passing the cream from one to another. My own dick was hard as a rock and straining to break out of my jeans.

“Suddenly, I felt a pair of hands unbuttoning my fly and reaching into my briefs to free my aching cock. I figured it must be Debbie, but when I looked down, I saw that there was hair on the back of the hands. They were Joe’s!”

Jay reached inside his briefs and pulled out his cock.

“‘Are you ready for your reward?’ asked Debbie. That would have been reward enough had it not been for the fact that my balls were aching for relief. Debbie pulled off my shirt, grabbed some cushions off the sofa, and laid me down on them. Then, while Toni and Lynn came around and pulled off my shoes, socks, jeans, and underwear, Debbie also stripped naked. God, she was beautiful! What an awesome fuckin’ body!

“She straddled me across my waist, kissed me, and then licked my body all the way down from my lips to my cock. She teased me mercilessly, licking underneath my balls and around my cock, but not taking it completely in her mouth.

“Suddenly, I had the strangest sensation. Toni and Lynn were sucking my toes. I couldn’t believe how sensual that was. Debbie went down on my cock, but in short, staccato strokes, which drove me even more crazy. Then, she scooted up until she was positioned directly over my face. She squatted down, pressing her pussy against my mouth. I opened wide and licked and sucked like there was no tomorrow. Toni and Lynn moved up and began sucking my tits. My God, they were torturing me with delight.

“Lynn whispered something to Pete, who ran out of the room and quickly returned with a wet wash cloth, which Lynn used to wipe my armpits. Then, she and Toni licked there. I never realized before just how sensitive that part of my body was. They alternated licking and sucking between my tits and my armpits. I’m not sure which excited me more.”

Jay rubbed his hands over his own tits and under his arms.

“I continued to eat Debbie’s cunt when all of a sudden I felt a warm mouth engulfing my cock, which had been begging for attention. It took a moment for it to dawn on me: Debbie was sitting on my face, Toni and Lynn were licking my tits and armpits, so who was sucking my cock? It was Joe! I thought about yelling at him, but then I figured, hey, I had sucked him off, so why shouldn’t he suck my dick? Besides, it all felt way too good. Why the hell should I complain?

“After about five minutes of this treatment, Debbie slid down to my cock and sat on it. As she pumped up and down, her voluptuous boobs bounced in rhythm. What a glorious sight! Toni and Lynn went back to work on my nips, and then I was hit with another shocker. Joe came around and stuck his newly hardened cock back in my mouth. My instinctive reaction was, hell no, I agreed to suck you off once, and that was all, but the rest of my body was so totally absorbed in what was going on that it seemed only natural to have something in my mouth at the same time.

“Pete must have felt left out because he stood over Joe and stuck his cock in Joe’s mouth. After a couple of minutes of this action, Joe and Pete moved over to the side and got into a 69 position, sucking each other’s dicks. When they came, each one took the other’s cream in his mouth, and then they swapped cum, much as the girls and I had done earlier. Debbie grunted and squealed until she finally exploded.

“This was all more than I could handle. I fired off load after load up Debbie’s cunt. I thought I would never stop shaking. When Debbie rolled off of me, Toni and Lynn took turns licking my cum out of her cunt. I thought I had died and gone to heaven. I couldn’t imagine getting up off the floor. When I finally did, though, I caught a glimpse of Mr. Henderson, Debbie’s father, ducking back around the corner with his stiff prick in his hand.

“After we all got dressed and headed for the door, Debbie asked, ‘Well, are you glad you took the dare?’

‘Well, I dunno if I ever wanna suck another cock again, but the reward sure as hell was worth it.’

‘Good. Because that was only the first part of your reward.’

‘What?’

‘Yeah, why don’t you come over next Saturday night, and I’ll give you the rest of it.’

‘Wh…wh…?’

‘No, no. Not now. You don’t want to spoil the surprise. You just be here around 8:00 Saturday night, and I’ll make it worth your while.’

“Well, as you might expect, my imagination ran wild with anticipation. I got so horny just thinking about it, I must have jacked off four times a day for the next week.”

Author's note: In Chapter 7, Rick describes his shocking reward, leading to more gay sex.