Cheater's Punishment

This story will be a little different from what I've previously done, but I hope you enjoy it anyway!

As always, leave a comment below or email me if you liked the story, or have any feedback! Follow me on twitter @QuesadillaNFrys for previews and depictions of my stories! If you have a story idea you'd like me to write, check my profile for instructions and email me at [email protected]!

Thank you, and enjoy!

---

The contact was listed on his phone as "FB", and it was in an encrypted chat app with no number attached. But it was clear what it was: She'd sent him flirty messages. There weren't too many from him, but there was a text right at the bottom: "I'm serious, my girlfriend can't find out we fucked."

It was incontrovertible evidence that Marco was cheating on her. He'd left his phone on the table, and Angie saw him get a notification in the app. She was absolutely livid. How could he do this to her? She stormed off to work before Marco got out of the shower. Riding the subway on her way to the office, Angie took some time to process. She calmed down somewhat, and decided she didn't want to break up with him. No, she wanted to get even.

In the breakroom, Angie ate her lunch in silent contemplation when her friend and co-worker, Will, walked in. Will was a handsome, muscular dude, with a well-known penchant for bedding anyone he could get his hands on. It helped that he was bisexual and practically attracted to anything that moved, of course. He'd made several attempts on Angie of course, but she was faithfully committed. Unlike her partner, apparently.

"Hey Ang, what's wrong?" Will sat down across from her.

"Oh, I just found out Marco's been cheating on me. I saw his texts. Lying bastard." Angie scowled, taking a vicious bite out of her sandwich.

"Wow, really? Well, that's too bad." Will shook his head. "Do you know who it was?"

"No, but when I find out who the bitch is, you might need to hold me back from killing her," Angie fumed.

Will smiled. "You're a feisty one. I like that about you,"

Angie rolled her eyes, but said nothing.

"But why don't you just break up with him and let cut your losses?" Will suggested.

"No. Crazy as it is, I still love the bastard. But I'm not letting him off the hook for this," Angie declared.

"Maybe I can help. I have an idea..." Angie perked up. "What if you teach him a lesson by making him watch another guy fucking you?"

"Hmm..." Angie gave that some thought. "I don't know. I think I have a better idea..."

---

Angie's plan had come together perfectly. Everything she needed was in place. The strap-on and dildoes had arrived on schedule, and she even managed to persuade Marco to try them.

"Please, baby?" she cooed. "I do so much for you, and all I'm asking is that you give it a try. If you don't like it, we can stop."

"I don't know, Ang. What if it hurts?" Marco asked.

"You've fucked me in the ass before, right?" Angie countered. "Does it look like I'm in terrible pain? And you're the one with the prostate, that's supposed to make it feel even better."

"Fine, I'll give it a shot. For you, babe." Angie smiled, and kissed him on the cheek. "Trust me, you'll love it! I know I will!"

Now, Angie was tying Marco up and blindfolding him. "Just relax, Babe. You're perfectly safe, and I promise I'll make you feel really good." Marco's muscular chest heaved up and down with his breathing, but he followed Angie's instructions and tried to relax. She started sucking his dick, and almost immediately, it sprang up to it's full length. "Fuuuuuck yeah, babe," he moaned.

"I'm just getting started," she cooed. "Ready for more?" Marco nodded nervously, as she began inserting a finger into his tight hole.

"Uggghhh, shiiiittt..." Marco grunted as he felt her finger penetrate him.

"Just relax, baby...relax," she said calmly. Angie poked around in there, eventually finding his prostate. She put a little pressure on it.

"OOhhhhh fuck!" Marco bucked up, still held down by the restraints.

"You feel that, Babe?" she asked. "That's your prostate! Did it feel good?"

"Ye-yeaah..." he stammered. "Fuuuuck, keep going..." Angie smiled and pulled her finger out. She grabbed the first dildo, lubed it up, and pressed it against his tight hole. Marco moaned, and she gently pushed until the head popped inside.

"JESUS! Nnnngghhh!" he groaned. "Fuck, I feel so full, babe..." Angie pushed the dildo further, and slowly began moving it in and out, rubbing it against his prostate. "Oooohh fuck, yes...fuck, Ang, that feels amazing," Marco whimpered.

"Just wait till you see the next one, Babe. This'll blow your mind." Angie reached for the other dildo and lubed it up. Then, she slowly began inserting the second toy.

"Ngggghhhh...shit, fuck, that's big, Ang!" he gasped.

"Take a deep breath, baby," she soothed. "Breathe out." Marco did, and as he did, the second dildo slid inside.

"Fuuuuccckkk, that's deep..." Marco moaned. "Holy shit, Ang, this is so hot."

"Yeah, you're such a good boy, baby. Just take a moment and relax, okay?" Marco's dick was leaking pre-cum profusely.

"You ready to go faster, babe?"

"Y-yeah...please..." he moaned. Angie began moving the toy faster, and Marco squirmed and bucked.

"Fuuuck, Ang, this is so fucking deep," he moaned. "I love it, babe, please don't stop." Angie grinned, and began moving the toy faster. "Aaaaahhhh...fuck, baby, that feels amazing," he panted.

"Mmm, that's right, babe. Just relax and let me do the work," Angie replied. She continued fucking him with the dildo, and Marco writhed in pleasure.

"Fuuuck, babe, I'm gonna cum soon," he moaned. Just like that, Angie pulled the dildo out. Marco whimpered as it left his ass, still bucking in his restraints. Angie grabbed the largest one, and attached it to the strap-on she was wearing. She lubed it up and pressed the tip to his hole.

"This one's gonna be bigger, Babe. It's a strap on, so it'll be like I'm fucking you myself. Are you ready?" Marco was still panting and writhing in pleasure. "Just fuck me, Ang, please..."

"Of course, Babe." Angie pushed the dildo into Marco, who groaned.

"Ngggghhh! Shit, baby, that's so big!"

"Are you alright, Babe?" Angie asked, concerned.

"Yes, please just keep fucking me, Ang," Marco replied. He sounded like he was struggling, but she kept going. Angie began moving the strap-on, pushing it in and out. She watched his face contort as he felt the fullness. "Holy shit, this is so fucking deep."

"That's a good boy, Babe. You're taking this so well. Do you think you can handle a little more?"

"Fuuuck, please, yes. Keep fucking me, baby." Angie began to speed up, and Marco bucked and squirmed in his restraints. "Fuuuuuck, babe, that's so big. Holy shit, that feels good."

"Are you close, Babe?" Angie purred.

"Yes, Ang, please don't stop."

"Cum for me, Babe. Show me how much you love it." Angie kept thrusting, and soon, Marco cried out in pleasure.

"Aaaaaggggghhhh, fuck! Yes, babe, I'm cumming!"

He spasmed as he came, his load shooting all over his stomach, without touching himself. "Fuuuucking shiiiit! Oh god, I'm fucking cumming," he cried. Angie could feel his ass tightening and loosening, and she could feel his warm cum hitting her skin. The spasms subsided, but she kept going, having no intention of stopping. Marco kept moaning and groaning as she pounded him. If his still-hard cock was any indication, he was still enjoying it.

It was time. She pulled the dildo out of his ass, and quietly motioned to the corner of the room. There, stroking his hard dick, was Will, who had quietly slipped into the room while she was fucking Marco. He came up behind Marco, and lined his throbbing cock up with the straight stud's hole.

"Nnnngghhh...baby, what's that?" Marco asked. "What are you using now?"

"Don't worry, it's just the biggest one. This'll really make you feel good, Babe. Ready?"

"Yeah, babe, fuck me with that huge cock," he moaned. Will pushed it in slowly, and Marco let out a long groan. "Fuuuuck yesss," he panted.

"Feel good, baby?" Angie asked, as Will began to move his massive cock in and out.

"Y-yes, it's so deep. Keep fucking me, babe, please," he begged. Angie motioned for Will to pick up the pace, and he did. Soon, he was pounding the bound stud, and Marco was moaning in pleasure. "Nggghh, fuck, that's so big," he moaned. "So deep...fuck, you're so fucking good, baby." Angie smiled. She'd had no idea Marco would take so much pleasure from having a big fat cock in his ass. He was moaning and writhing, and his dick was rock hard.

"Mmm, you're loving this, aren't you, Babe?" Angie teased.

"Fuck yeah, I am," he gasped. "It feels like your dildo is so far in my guts, babe. Fuck, you're gonna make me cum again."

"Yeah, baby, cum for me," she purred. Will continued pounding him, and soon, Marco's muscles tightened and his body went rigid.

"Nnngghhh, shit, I'm gonna cum again, babe. Fuck, I'm gonna fucking explode," he cried.

"Do it, Babe. Cum for me. Show me how much you love it," Angie urged. Marco grinded against the cock he didn't realize was in his ass.

"Do you want it harder, Babe?" Angie asked.

"Yes, fuck, please, fuck me harder," he pleaded. Will complied.

"Good, because I have a surprise for you."

"Huh?"

Angie moved closer to Marco, and took the blindfold off. As his eyes adjusted, he realized that the person fucking him was not his girlfriend. He also saw that the dick currently pumping in and out of his ass was not a dildo, but a real man's dick, and had an owner who was enjoying himself very much.

"What the FUCK, Angie?" Marco grunted out, the cock still pummeling his ass. Marco struggled, but it was no use; the restraints were too tight. Will continued pounding him, with a vicious smirk.

"I know you've been cheating on me, babe," Angie said. "I saw your texts with her. Consider this your punishment. You've been very naughty, and I want to make sure your behavior changes."

"FUCK!" he grunted. Will was thrusting as hard as he could now. "I'm sorry..." Marco grunted out between thrusts, attempting to catch his breath. "I promise I won't see her ever again. It was a mistake, a one-time thing. I know I don't deserve forgiveness, but — FUCK — I'll do whatever I can to make it up to you, every day of our lives!"

"Oh, thank you baby!" Angie cooed. "And don't worry, You've already started." She grabbed Marco's dick, as Will fucked him as hard as he could. "Cum for us, Babe," she coaxed.

"Argghhhhh...oh god..." Marco's cock throbbed, and then burst, cumming hard, the thick, white liquid spattering his chest and stomach. "Agghhhhhh fucking hellll!" Marco's load covered him, and Angie was thrilled to see how much her straight man loved being fucked. She looked up at Will, and gave him a thumbs-up. He grinned, and began pumping even harder. "Yes, Babe. Keep cumming," Angie encouraged. She stroked him through the rest of his orgasm.

"Mmm, look how much you love this," Angie said. "How much did you love cheating on me, Babe? I bet it was a lot."

"No, I didn't. I swear. I was just drunk, it was sloppy." Will was pounding him with everything he had.

"Tell us, Babe."

"The only thing I can say...It can't possibly compare to this moment right now! Fuck! I fucking love you babe, I'm so sorry!" Marco grunted with each thrust of Will's dick in his ass.

Will was getting close too, and soon, his cock pulsed and throbbed inside Marco’s hole. "Fuuuuuuck, I'm gonna cum," Will announced, a few moments later.

"Yes, fill him up!" Angie encouraged. Will gave a final thrust and exploded, releasing his load into the muscular straight jock's ass. "Fuuuckkk," Marco groaned. "That's so deep, ughhhh…”

"Fuck, YES!" Will moaned. His thick cum coated Marco's rectum, filling him up. "Take that jizz up your hole, slut! You fucking like that?"

"Yes, I fucking love it. Fuck, it's so hot," Marco admitted. "Fucking fill me up, I want it." Will's jizz flooded the straight boy's ass, and some began to seep out. "Shit, there's so much," he panted.

Will pulled his cock out of Marco, letting jizz ooze out of his used hole, and walked around the bed, his dick swinging as he moved. He was a large guy, and had a huge, thick, veiny cock. Now that it was no longer buried inside him, Marco's ass gaped wide open.

"Mmm, did you like it, babe?" Angie purred, rubbing her fingers along Marco's toned abs.

"Yes, babe, thank you. I'm so sorry," Marco apologized. "Fuuuck," he groaned. "Oh god, oh shit, that was fucking intense."

"Well, I think we can call it even," Angie responded, a smug smile creeping across her face. "But don't you EVER cheat on me with another woman again, or you won't enjoy it the next time." Angie walked out of the room.

---

"You took it a lot better than last time," Will grinned.

"Fuck you, asshole," Marco said, but tried to hide a smirk. "But I will admit, it's a lot better when I'm not drunk. And 'FB'? I saw that in my phone. What's that supposed to mean?"

"Come on! It means I'm your 'Fuck Buddy'!", Will said with a devilish grin, as he began untying Marco.

"Yeah, well just be glad she didn't know it was you, or you might've gotten a lot worse than just a dildo in your ass from her," Marco replied. "Shit, my ass is gonna be fucking sore for a week. What the fuck did you do to me?"

"Oh, don't act like you didn't enjoy it," Will said, and leaned down to kiss Marco, who still had one hand tied to the bedframe. He resisted at first, but gradually relented. "You know, I don't think she'd mind if we went for round two..." Will growled.