At Tyler's Whim

"Fuck, I hope he's not here today. I cant do it again..." the brown haired boy thought as he took a deep breath before walking into the ominous looking building in front of him. He didn't know how today would go after yesterday, but his cock thickened in anticipation of what could come next.

Bennett Faulkner's eyes shifted back and fourth around the hallways of his high school hoping to god that Tyler wasn't here today. Yesterday was a nightmare for him, his secret got out. He doesn't know how Tyler found out about his lust for him, but he took full advantage of it between periods in the bathroom.

"Suck my dick, Benny... Yeah, that's a good lil faggot..."

The words were burned in his mind as he relived it. He was there, on his knees pleasuring the man he lusted over for years. He never would have expected his best friend to do that to him. He also however never expected to feel the way he did on the floor of the bathroom with Tyler above him using his mouth the way he did. Who could blame Bennett though? Tyler was every girl's desire, and every guy's envy. He was tall, decently muscled enough to compliment his frame, a charming smile and piercing green eyes that infatuated some. He dressed well, and filled out the clothes he wore better than everyone else in Bennett's eyes. His confidence was palpable, and oozed from every fiber of Tyler's being. Bennett was one of those people, and he couldn't escape it. He hated himself for not being more careful, he kicked  himself over and over for looking at him. He knew he wasn't worthy of Tyler's attention anymore, but he couldn't help but crave it. The two boys had a deep and entwined history, and their constant back and forth Frenemy-ship continued on in silence until Yesterday when it all changed. 

Again.

Bennett and Tyler's parents were longtime friends from college, Bennett's mother Jenny and Tyler's father Bill were in the same political science class, and kept in touch while pursuing their respective degrees. Being good friends throughout their college careers, they tried dating but found their friendship was stronger, both had friend-zoned each other long before they even considered dating each other, so both decided to keep in touch, but pursue other people.

Jenny met her now husband Edward during an internship at her local state representative's office where she was trying to gain experience in public office. After moving in together in their first home outside the city, Jenny got a notification from her social media profile, an old friend wanted to connect with her, and it was none other than Bill White himself, her old friend from college. After re-connecting, Jenny learned that Bill along with his new wife Charlotte were moving in next door into the just vacant house to the Faulkner's left. The two old friends were ecstatic; Edward was less so in the beginning, but quickly warmed up to the White family who just had their first son Riley, Tyler's older brother of 3 years. This got the Faulkners thinking about having a baby of their own, and less than a year later, Bennett; their only child was born.

As Bennett and Tyler grew up, they played outside with each other frequently, horsing around in Tyler's pool, playing video games and building crazy forts with Tyler's pillows and sheets in his room. The two were inseparable during those years like any "Dynamic duo" as Bennett's mother would put it-- could be. Later on as the boys grew up, Tyler took a liking to sports, specifically Baseball, and tried to get Bennett into it as well, although it later proved to be for nought. Bennett took a liking to art and science, specifically engineering and the boys started to drift apart. Being over each other's houses all the time, the two families practically had 3 children as both boys were seen as part of each family, with the exception of Bennett's father.

Edward took a liking to Tyler, his love of sport and athletics formed a connection with each other, and Bennett often felt that his dad liked Tyler more than him. Tyler would go fishing with him, play catch, touch football on thanksgivings, and skiing in the winter -- all things Bennett had no interest in. HE couldn't help but feel that tiny twinge of jealousy. He tried different sports of course, but didn't take a liking to them like Tyler had, and this created a bit of a resentment in Edward. The man often thinking that Bennett was being "ungrateful" for including him in these often expensive skiing trips to the mountains and signing him up for Baseball in the summers. This left Bennett longing for his father's attention. He tried to get him to notice his science projects in middle school, or how he aced specific tests in math and science, but the man remained distant from the boy, allowing a festering resentment to grow inside him.

Getting back to the boys however, as puberty reached them, Tyler started hanging out with girls more often. Sometimes ditching Bennett to hang out with his girlfriend Tara left him feeling very alone at times. Inside however, Bennett started to feel unwanted by both his father and his best and only friend. The cycle only grew, Bennett would reach out to hang with Tyler and he'd always be with "that girl" as Bennett would call her; refusing to actually say her name and as time continued to pass by Bennett's loneliness continued to grow and manifest itself as an insecurity he'd never be able to get rid of, until one day when his heart was smashed to bits.

Bennett and Tyler were staring intently at the TV screen as each of their characters fought, Tara looked on at the game but found it boring as fuck. She couldn't wait until the little nerd to Tyler's right would fucking leave so she could finally get some action with the boy. And as the clock reached 4pm, and then 5, she grew impatient. She crawled up and whispered something into Tyler's ear, causing him to pause the game immediately.

His eyes grew wide with arousal as his cock came to life at the words of his girlfriend, and he looked over at Bennett and told him he had to leave.  Bennett's eyes filled with dejection. 

"Wha-- but we were gonna swim later--"

"Yeah, but I just remembered I gotta do something with Tara, so you gotta jet, bro." He said turning off the console and getting up. Bennett noticed the lump in his friend's pants and didn't understand why he was looking at it still. He stood up as well.

"Come on, man cant we just go swimming? We never hang out anymore--"

Tyler grew frustrated, "Dude I don't want to go fucking swimming so just get out will ya?" he said pushing Bennett towards the door of his room. "Hey don't push me!" Bennett said swiping at Tyler's arms. Tyler stepped toward the smaller boy and roughly pushed him right out of his door. "Its my fucking house, now get the fuck out!" He said slamming the door behind him as Bennett fell onto his rear. He stared at the door in disbelief and started to get angry. He stood up and heard mumbling from Tyler's room.

"Ugh I thought the little twerp would never fucking leave." He heard Tara say, then following that was the unmistakable sound of making out. Bennett was crushed, his best friend threw him out so he could make out with his girl. A tear fell from his eye, his fists clenched and sadness swelled in his chest. He stormed away, vowing he'd never talk to Tyler again.

Until Tyler hung out with him a week later.

Now however, Things were very different, he had given Tyler a blowjob in the bathroom yesterday, and Tyler called him all sorts of names that turned the 18 year old on like nobody's business, and now his whole relationship with Tyler will be very different from now on.

"Hey-Hey!! There you are, Benny!" He heard from behind him. The voice pierced his soul, and his eyes shut tightly as he froze. His cock sprung to life immediately. He hated that he loved it that he called him "Benny" only his mother called him Benny, ever since he was a little boy. Unbeknownst to Tyler, his little next door neighbor was desperate for his attention even after all these years of constant bickering, making up for a bit, mutually pissing each other off again, rinse and repeat.

Bennett felt a big, warm arm slap itself across the back of his neck, and he was pulled into the crook of his armpit as the larger boy draped a heavy arm over his right shoulder. Tyler's scent seeped into his nostrils, filling them up and sending poor Bennett back to that place he hated to love so much. He couldn't help but look up at him. "H-Hi Ty..." He said shyly casting his eyes downward. Tyler pulled at Bennett toward the bathroom near them as kids walked past them getting to their first period classes. 

"C'mon little dude, lets talk a bit..." he said roughly guiding Bennett toward the bathroom, Bennett struggled a bit, he didn't want to go in there again. "B-But--"

"No buts, lets go Bennett..." Tyler said a bit more sternly. Bennett complied immediately and relaxed his struggle. He walked into the bathroom with his head down, and Tyler's arm securely across his shoulder. Tyler locked the door behind him so they were alone, he turned Bennett around so they were facing each other, and Tyler began to speak. 

"Look bro, things are gonna be different between you and me now, and I think I should clear the air. I know you've liked me since forever, you know you've like me since forever, so from now on, you're going to be mine. you're gonna do what I tell you and not think twice about it, but I think that's what you want isn't it?" He said stepping closer to his friend.

Bennett was red faced, he knew. Tyler knew everything about him, but how? How did he know so much? thoughts raced through Bennett's mind, and Tyler placed his hand on his chin, lifting his head up to lock eyes with his new boy. "Focus Benny. Sort out your feelings..." he said softly. Bennett wanted to lurch forward and kiss him, but he knew he couldn't ever do that... unless Tyler ordered him to. Bennett began to cry.

"I-I'm a freak... I'm sorry Tyler but I--I don't know why I feel this way..." He said softly, casting his eyes downward, away from his friend.

"But you do, and I don't care. I showed you that yesterday, I showed you your new place. Now its up to you, you can either accept what you are, and accept your new place, or you can not, and we can go back to how things were, but you will never ever get the chance to do what you really want to do. I gave you a taste yesterday, and I can see you want more, don't you?" He explained softly as his friend sobbed like a baby under him.
Bennett couldn't fight his urges anymore, he couldn't deny what he felt for Tyler, pure admiration, pure subservience, pure need. 

He nodded his head.

"I thought so, but I will tell you now Benny that if you choose this, Things will be very different from now on. Do you understand? this is your last chance to back out, and we'll forget this happened." Tyler bargained. He of course knew what Benny would choose, the poor kid had been so neglected in terms of a strong male presence in his life. His own father won't even talk to him, he needs this, and fuck, Tyler needed it too.

Bennett thought hard on it, He knew Tyler was giving exactly what he wanted, a chance to belong completely to him, to serve him, to please the very boy he's been so desperate for attention from since pretty much when they were kids. The fear of losing Tyler again overwhelmed him, the day he shoved him out of his room to have sex with Tara burned itself in his mind, and right then he decided that from now on he would be Tyler's.

"Ok..." he mumbled.

Tyler's cock stirred.

"Ok what? Don't fucking mumble." he barked.

"I-I'll... do it..." He said a bit louder. His own cock was thickening too.

"On your knees, dipshit." Tyler mused as Benny lowered himself down onto the dirty tiled floor of the bathroom.

"Say what you'll do, Benny..." He ordered, cupping his friend's soft cheek, staring into his deep blue eyes.

"I'll... I'll be yours, Tyler..." he said weekly as his voice cracked under the strain of the situation, Tyler smiled, and Bennett beamed inside. He loved seeing Tyler smile.

"Why do you want to be mine, Benny?" He teased as he cupped his friend's cheeks. He couldn't believe how soft they actually were. He noticed that they were even smoother than some of the chicks he banged too. This was new territory for Tyler, being the Alpha came naturally, but not to this extent.

Bennett shifted his weight on his knees, his cock started to stiffen more. He stammered, he wanted to tell Tyler everything about how he was feeling but he knew Tyler didn't care about the details, he wanted a straightforward answer. Now.

"I... I... I've always wanted to...to be yours...  All those times we played in the pool at your house, or when we were alone in your room, I just wanted to make you happy... I couldn't bear the thought of making you mad..." He revealed as he shakes under Tyler's soft yet commanding touch. Tyler smiled. He knew Bennett was gay for him, he's always known. Every time he'd get out of his pool for example, there were lil Benny's eyes. When he came out of the shower, there they were again.

Tyler knew how infatuated Bennett was about him. He didn't blame Bennett. His own father barely paid attention to the little fuck. No older siblings to play with or confide in or to look up to, no wonder the poor boy was so deeply in love with Tyler. He almost felt bad for the boy. 

Almost.

Of course, Tyler wasn't gay, but he didn't deny that Bennett was unbelievably cute. He had little freckles under his eyes and across his nose, his brown hair was so soft, and his eyes were big saucers of brown, so rich and deep like chocolate. If the boy had more confidence, and wasn't a fag of course, he'd definitely be one the girls would swoon over. Besides, Tyler always liked being in charge; even with Tara. She'd try to take control but would ultimately submit to Tyler's will--Just like Bennett is doing right at this minute. It came naturally to him, he was "a born leader" as Bennett's own father would often tell him.

He knew Bennett needed this, to feel useful and needed. There was no doubt that Tyler loved the idea of 24/7 access to a surprisingly nice and eager mouth when Tara was being a bitch, so it was a win-win for both of them.

"Good." He said as he smiled down at his new boy. After that confirmation, he unzipped let his cock free as it expanded rapidly in front of Bennett's sparkling brown eyes.