Straight Fraternity
straightfraternity.com 29 Oct 2025
Straight Fraternity offers a mix of college jocks, rough straight guys & skaters experiencing their first guy-on-guy sexual experiences. They jerk off in solos or with other guys, there are handjobs & blowjobs (sometimes at glory holes) & occasionally they fuck. The Gay Chicken scenes are a lot of fun. This is very much a gay-for-pay site. 200 videos to download, stream & watch on your mobile. Lots of new faces but many guys return.
Overall Score: 63 / 100
In This Review
Straight Fraternity Review
Straight Fraternity was a gay porn mainstay that featured college-aged straight guys doing their first jack-off videos and exploring sex with guys, including wanking together, blowjobs, and sometimes fucking. The site stopped producing new content over eight years ago, although they promised that they were remastering older scenes and adding them back into the inventory with larger and better quality versions. We haven't visited the site for six years, and while there were 203 videos the last time we were here, there are now only 200, so we need to check back and see what's new.
This is one of the original gay-for-pay sites, so almost all of the guys are straight and they're getting their first taste of guy-on-guy sex. While you'll find some guys with ripped and gym-fit bodies, many have regular or slim physiques, some with some nice definition. Most of the guys are White, but there's a decent number of Black guys and Latin studs. The majority of guys are smooth, but there are some hairy ones here and there, as well as others who are still growing into their body hair with patches in the middle of their chests. Many of the guys have tattoos, and a few are wearing various kinds of facial hair like trimmed beards or goatees, a bit of chin scruff, or maybe they're gone a couple of days without shaving.
Leon is a handsome, collegiate hunk with bulging biceps and he looks sexy in a muscle t-shirt. While many of the guys debut at Straight Fraternity jerking their cocks in solos, Leon started off playing a game of Gay Chicken with a sexy guy named Dax; they kiss, stroke and suck each other's dicks, and Leon wanks Dax till he cums. Leon returned for a second video where he got his butt hole licked and fingered by the site owner. Then, before retiring from the site, he got his dick sucked at a glory hole, another common feature here.
For me, the biggest draw at Straight Fraternity is that the guys aren't all gorgeous and perfectly-built porn hunks. It's not that they're dogs either, they're just average guys, the kind you'd see walking down the street or at the store, guys in their early to late twenties, a few are older. Whether you like rough straight guys or clean-cut college guys, you'll find a good mix here as well as the odd porn stud. Are they really straight? Most appear to be, although some are definitely gay or bisexual, and a few have gone on to become bigger gay porn performers.
The guys often start off with an audition where they talk with Franco Dax (the producer), then they strip and stroke their dicks. After that, pretty much anything can happen - it depends on the guy. There's a lot of side-by-side jerking, blowjob action, and cock measuring; the guys often strip each other, there's rimming, and there's fucking both with and without condoms. There's some kinky stuff, too, like spanking and piss play. And Franco is always pushing the guys to go past their limits and try new things including kissing, eating cum, or getting facials, and these sessions often use the Gay Chicken game. Franco himself appears in 55 of the videos and gets into the action; he regularly gives handjobs, blowjobs, or fucks ass (he bottoms, too); and he's usually the one manning the gloryhole, although not always. And by the way, he's more of a hairy daddy who is heavily inked and usually bearded.
Straight Fraternity currently offers 200 exclusive videos that mostly run between 10 and 20 minutes, although there are some as short as five minutes. The vids are offered in MP4 format in from two to four sizes with the largest coming in at 480p to 540p and the smallest sized at 240p and 360p. The smaller are compatible with mobiles and the larger ones generally play well on desktops as long as the player isn't sized too large; the quality is average. The streaming versions are offered at the same resolutions and play at 998x540, and if you have a large monitor, you'll want to reduce the size of the player so the videos look better. Also, the video player defaults at the lowest speed, but you can easily adjust the speeds in a drop down menu.
Each episode has a page with a write-up about the guys and what happens. And each has a picture set, most with between 14 and 28 screencaps that you can view in galleries. Some of the episodes feature digital stills, and the odd one may not have any photos, but this is rare. Most of the pics are sized at 960x540, but I did find some smaller sizes, too. You can view each set as a hands-free slideshow. And while you can download each set in zip file, you can't save the pictures individually.
Now let's talk about updates. When we reviewed the site a few years ago, around 400 videos had been removed. The site had gone through a major reset and redesign, and had also stopped producing new videos. Instead, it started remastering the older scenes and re-releasing them in larger sizes with improved quality. The site is currently updating three times a week with recycled scenes, but we're not seeing an increase in the actual number of videos. At the time of our last review, there were 203 videos, this time four years later, there are 200 videos. If you haven't been a member of the site before, you'll enjoy watching the guys getting their first taste of guy-on-guy sex.
One last thing about updates, the site had promised they were removing videos and remastering them before re-introducing them as updates. However, this isn't always the case. Of last week's three updates, two had been remastered with a bigger size, the third has the original three smaller sizes. The previous three updates only had one remastered scene and the three before that were all remastered. What is disappointing is that 400 videos had been removed, but the video counts have never returned to that level.
Are there any other downsides? Well, the biggest issue here is, of course, that the site is not producing new content and recycles scenes. While I'd have liked to see model profiles or at least more info than is given in the scene descriptions, the scene descriptions do include a little info about the guys. And I found it frustrating that the site defaults to showing you the lowest quality streaming videos, and since these are quite fuzzy in a larger player, you'll want to select the highest quality size right away. The Live Men link leads offsite to a third-party live cam site where you may have to spend more money for full nudity and action.
I enjoyed Straight Fraternity and all those hot straight guys. It delivers the kind of guys and action I expect from the tour. And while we can't always guarantee these guys are 100% straight, they mostly seem to be. There are 200 exclusive videos to download, stream, and watch on your mobile, and while the site is smaller than it was in its heyday, there's still lots to enjoy. The producer engages the guys with getting-to-know-you sessions before the action, and he gets them doing all kinds of things and pushes their straight boundaries. Straight Fraternity is a horny good time with lots of fun thrown in, and I'd say it's still worth checking out.
Pros
- Exclusive content
- College-aged guys and rough straight amateurs
- Creative scenes with a variety of action
- Videos are downloadable
Cons
- Recycled updates; site doesn't produce new content
- Only some updates are remastered & larger
- No model profiles
- Live Men link leads to third-party cam site
Changes Since Last Review
- Score lowered to 63 from 65
- Site is still only recycling updates
- 3 fewer videos
Videos
Videos are available for download and streaming.
200 exclusive videos in MP4 format that play 10 to 20 minutes, some are shorter. Downloads: two to four sizes at 240p to 480p, plus some at 540p; average quality or better, smaller sizes compatible with most mobiles. Streaming also available.
Pictures
200 or so picture sets. Most pics are good amateur quality screecaps sized at 960x540 or 600x400; some sets have pics that are digital stills at 800x600. Slideshows and downloadable zip files available, pics cannot be saved individually. Most sets have 14 or 28 photos.
Site Issues
This site is no longer being updated!
Site is recycling updates; they're no longer shooting new content, so if you were a member over two years ago, you may be familiar with the recent updates.
Membership Prices
- Monthly: $19.95 (recurring)
- Monthly: $24.95 (non-recurring)
- Quarterly: $49.95 (non-recurring)
- Year: $99.95 (non-recurring)
Why You Can Trust Our Review
Online since 1999, GayDemon is your trusted, expert guide to membership sites. Our team of seasoned editors has decades of combined experience in the gay porn industry, providing objective & critical reviews with your interests in mind. We pride ourselves on being thorough, honest, & transparent in every review we publish. The review of Straight Fraternity details what you can expect as a member if you choose to subscribe, providing an accurate overview as of 29 Oct 2025. Please note that websites evolve, and we cannot guarantee that the content, prices, or features will be exactly the same when you visit https://www.straightfraternity.com.
At GayDemon, we maintain full editorial independence, and while we may earn a commission if you purchase through links on our site, this has no impact on our opinions or review quality. Our goal is to always provide honest, unbiased assessments to help you make informed decisions about StraightFraternity & other membership sites. If you have any questions, feel free to contact us or leave a comment.